I could lose home because I won't go to chapel, says Hull atheist
A woman living at an historic almshouse says she is being threatened with eviction for not attending its chapel.Sandy Smith, a 69-year-old atheist, has lived at the Charterhouse, in Hull, for almost five years, but said she had now been placed under investigation by the charity's trustees.A residents' handbook states that everyone must attend the on-site chapel on Sundays unless excused by the "master" of the organisation, who is appointed by Hull City Council.The Charterhouse, which was founded in 1384, declined to comment. The council said the Charterhouse operated "in accordance" with a scheme approved by the Charity Commissioners.
Ms Smith, who has a chronic lung disease, fears she could lose her flat. She said a governance document lodged with the Charity Commission stated that any resident who was not a member of the Church of England and who applied to be excused "shall be excused from attendance"."I did go to chapel for about a year, but some of the sermons I found offensive," she said.
"I took this up with the former master, who would not give me permission not to attend, so I didn't return, and ever since then I have had a sequence of letters and warnings saying that it is part of my agreement to stay here that I go to chapel every week."I am just not prepared to do that."An almshouse is a form of charitable housing.The Charterhouse provides supported independent living for up to 40 residents over the age of 60. The residents' handbook describes the Charterhouse as "a religious foundation" and states that "all residents are required by the scheme to attend divine service in the chapel on Sundays... unless excused from attendance by the master". "There is also a service every Wednesday which residents are requested to attend."The handbook goes on to state that "chapel absences may invalidate your license to occupy".
'Lovely view'
Ms Smith, who moved to the Charterhouse during the Covid-19 pandemic, said the worry of losing her home was taking its toll on her mental wellbeing."I just think it is unreasonable and I am going to fight it," she said. "This flat is probably one of the best flats I've ever lived in. I've got a lovely view, I'm central and I can afford the rent."The historical part of the building is fantastic, but this is the housing project that they are getting rents for and the two should not be conflated in my opinion."The story was initially reported by The Hull Story website.Ms Smith has been asked to attend a panel with the trustees of the charity later. A letter from the Charterhouse dated February 10 said the panel would report its conclusions to the full board of trustees, who would decide whether to take no further action, issue a verbal warning, issue a written warning or "set aside the appointment".The BBC put all Ms Smith's points to the Charterhouse, which declined to comment.Hull City Council, which is responsible for appointing the master and some of the trustees, said the Charterhouse operated "in accordance with a scheme that has been approved by the Charity Commissioners and was most recently revised in December 2015". "The trustees that are appointed by the council exercise their personal responsibility as trustees to manage the properties in accordance with the requirements of the approved scheme," the council added.
Listen to highlights from Hull and East Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
4 hours ago
- Wales Online
Frustrated residents have four years for new flats and now they are nearly ready
Frustrated residents have four years for new flats and now they are nearly ready Councillors and council officials celebrated the topping out of a block of flats in Grangetown that residents have been waiting years to move into The leader of Cardiff Council, Cllr Huw Thomas, said he understood the frustration of residents (Image: Ted Peskett ) Key decision makers at Cardiff Council said they understand the frustrations of tenants in a council housing estate who have been waiting years for their new flats to be built. Cardiff Council's cabinet member for housing and communities, Cllr Lynda Thorne, and the leader of the council, Cllr Huw Thomas, made their comments at the topping out ceremony of a block of independent living flats at Channel View. The flats are part of the first phase of a wider scheme to completely redevelop the Grangetown estate. Residents living in the 13-storey block opposite were first told in 2016 that their flats would be demolished and that they would be rehoused, with many claiming they have been living in poor conditions since then. Never miss a Cardiff story and sign up to our newsletter here. Cllr Thorne, who is also a ward councillor for Grangetown, said: "I was doing monthly surgeries and I felt as frustrated as they did. "I guess we forget that we had Covid in between which delayed it all and then unfortunately we had issues with the... regulations, particularly to do with fire safety which delayed it further. "Yes, I understand their frustration and I felt [it] too because I want to see it [the new building] coming out of the ground as well." Article continues below Residents living in the old block claimed they experienced issues with mould, damp and leaks as they waited to see progress on the new flats. It was reported in March 2024 that some residents had experienced plumbing issues that saw sewage appear in their toilets and baths. Cardiff Council's cabinet member for housing, Cllr Lynda Thorne (Image: Cardiff Council ) Cllr Thorne said she was "over the moon" to see the new building, block B, at its highest point in the construction process. She added: "This is actually a replacement for the high rise and of course, since we took the cladding off they have been a bit colder and sometimes [there has been] a little bit of condensation in the flats which means they are all keen to move into their new flats. "Although it doesn't address the housing crisis, it does address getting... particularly older people, in really good accommodation." Cardiff Council has partnered with Wates Residential on the Channel View project. Residents living in the 13-storey building opposite the new structure have been waiting years for progress on the Channel View project (Image: Ted Peskett ) Block B will deliver 24 new energy efficient council homes for older people and the apartments in the six storey building are expected to be ready for residents next year. The leader of Cardiff Council, Cllr Huw Thomas, was also present at the topping out ceremony. The leader of Cardiff Council, Cllr Huw Thomas (left) at the topping out ceremony with regional managing director of Wates Residential, Edwards Rees (Image: Ted Peskett ) When asked about delays to the project, he said: "Rome wasn't built in a day and I am really concious of how long it's taken to make a reality of this project. "We first started talking about it and the need for it shortly after I became leader eight years ago, so it's a frustrating thing for everyone how long these things take to come to fruition. "You've obviously in that period had issues like Covid, you had the disastrous mini budget that in turn affected interest rates and that has had a knock on impact on costs as well. Block b of the Channel View redevelopment scheme is nearing completion (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne ) "There are good reasons why it has taken so long, but I absolutely understand the frustration from residents. "The council has tried to do what it can to support them... during that period and obviously for the residents living across there will be payments in terms of a relocation payment as well and disruption. "We all acknowledge that it has not happened as quick as we would like, but it has also delivered some really good learning of how we take these processes through quicker and the irony is, and this is a UK challenge, the actual building bit doesn't take as long as the financial assembly and the planning process." A second block of flats that's also part of the first phase of development at Channel View is scheduled for completion in 2027. This building, called block A, will consist of 102 community living apartments, community facilities, a rooftop terrace and a cafe. The whole Channel View scheme will eventually see the 180 existing properties there, originally built in the 1970s, replaced with 400 new homes. Article continues below It will also seek to deliver improved connectivity for the estate, improvements to the public open space at The Marl, and the creation of a new public realm using green infrastructure and sustainable drainage systems (SUDS).
The National
2 days ago
- The National
Scottish grandmother volunteers to help displaced Gazans
'You can't justify that – a three-year-old child is a three-year-old child,' said Smith, from Berwickshire. 'It does not matter where on the planet they are from, they do not deserve to be targeted, maimed and murdered.' Equally harrowing was hearing about a young mum who lost her baby and one arm when an Israeli explosive hit as she was breastfeeding. It's only now, a month since Smith returned to Scotland from Cairo in Egypt, that she is able to talk about her experience because the trauma she witnessed was so overwhelming. READ MORE: Freedom Flotilla urges UK Government to 'protect' ship from Israel as it nears Gaza However, she is determined other Scots should hear about the thousands of Palestinians who have escaped the bombardment of Gaza but whose current living hell has been largely overlooked. Most were allowed to cross the border into Egypt because they needed urgent medical treatment for injuries cause by Israeli explosives but are now trying to survive in some of the worst slum areas of Cairo without status, jobs or welfare. 'What I saw and heard in Cairo was catastrophic – not just the aftermath of war but the bureaucracy of abandonment, the quiet violence of being rendered invisible,' Smith (below) told the Sunday National. There are more than 100,000 Gazans now living in Cairo with no legal status. 'They are not refugees. They are not asylum seekers. Nor do they want to be. They want to go home. In the meantime, they are people with no rights, no support and no safety net — invisible in a sprawling, chaotic city of over 10 million. Their kids can't go to Egyptian schools and none of them are allowed to work. It's the most impossible situation for them as if they haven't been through enough,' she said. Smith spent a month volunteering mostly with Network for Palestine, a charity set up by Palestinians to help the evacuees. Her trip was entirely self-funded as she felt she could no longer see the carnage on the TV news without trying to help. A long-time supporter of Medical Aid for Palestine, she had previously worked with Palestinians in the West Bank under the auspices of the British Council in 2010. 'Of all the countries in the world, Palestine is the most like Scotland,' said Smith, right. 'They have some of the best of us – gallows humour, hospitality, national and civic pride, warmth and openness, innovation, resourcefulness and they love a hoolie.' One of the hardest aspects of her visit was seeing the effects of war on the children. Before the current Israeli onslaught and even under occupation, the children were bright and full of energy. The Gazan children in Cairo, by contrast, had completely shut down. READ MORE: 'Joy, celebration and warmth' of Palestinian art to be showcased at Edinburgh Fringe On her first day Smith met a three-year-old who had not spoken for months. A day or two later, she was invited to an Eid party at a hospital in a slum area known as Garbage City. There are more than 150 Gazans living in the grounds of the hospital, mostly injured children. 'The party was organised and paid for by a couple of ordinary young lads from North London and there were bouncy castles and music,' Smith said. During the event, a minibus drew up full of injured kids recently arrived from Gaza. As the children got off the bus, Smith saw they were missing limbs and had other life-changing, visible injuries. They were thin, grey, silent and just stood on the sidelines watching. When Smith met parents, she was struck by how they immediately wanted to show her pictures of their former homes, family, friends, parties they had held for their children and barbecues in their Gazan gardens. At first she found it strange but then she realised they wanted her to know that their current circumstances did not define them. 'It was to say 'I had a life there, I worked as a computer technician, my husband was a paralegal, we had this car, my kids went to this school',' explained Smith. 'Although they have lived under military occupation in a huge compound, they have obviously striven to be educated, happy, free spirited, creative and resourceful. 'Even in their temporary homes in Cairo, even in pain and limbo, they show strangers photos of their lives before to say – this is who I really am. They are not their current situation.' On her trip to Cairo, Smith took £5000 she had raised plus four reconditioned laptops and an iPad. 'I wish I had been able to take much more as many of the children are trying to keep up their education but can't go to school so are trying their best on their mums' phones,' she said. 'Palestinians have one of the highest literacy rates in the world at 99.25%. That's higher than the European average, much higher than the US and even higher than Israel. Education is not just a value – it's a form of resistance.' A ray of light is two Montessori schools that have been set up for the children, while Network for Palestine is working hard to cater for all the families' other needs. 'Network for Palestine in Cairo are absolute heroes and have helped more than 25,000 women, children and families,' said Smith. 'On the days I spent at their HQ, the phones never stopped, the human traffic over the door was relentless and the staff and volunteers were clearly pressed at every turn.' Operating in not much more than a single room only one year ago, the network's HQ has grown so much it is now like Glasgow's Refuweegee charity 'on steroids', according to Smith. 'It is an absolutely huge donation centre with clothes for women, children and men, food, furniture, offices and meeting rooms for all the social work as well as counselling rooms where children, young people and their families get expert support from clinical psychologists trained to support the kind of trauma they have and continue to live with,' she said. However, even those delivering help, who are mostly volunteers, are buckling under the pressure. One said: 'It's emotionally, psychologically and physically exhausting just to keep going, especially when you haven't processed your own trauma and you're faced with the trauma of others that seems never-ending. You are desperate for every piece of news from Gaza, but you're also scared to know what's happening.' Now back in Berwickshire, Smith is doing all she can to raise awareness. Smith said: 'One thing people said to me time and time again is that they just want to be seen. They want it acknowledged that they deserve to live and deserve to be.'
ITV News
2 days ago
- ITV News
Why rescue centres in the South West are still struggling to cope with a rise in abandoned kittens
Cat rescue centres across the South West say they are struggling to cope with 'huge' numbers of kittens being abandoned. It's thought an overhang from the pandemic five years ago is partly responsible, with fewer cats being neutered or spayed at the time. The Moggery Cat and Kitten Rehoming Centre in Bishopston received more than double their normal intake of abandoned kittens in 2024. They say volunteers rescued an additional 220 cats to what they'd expect during kitten season. Founder Christine Bayka told ITV West Country huge numbers of people adopted cats during the 2020 lockdown but later changed their mind about owning pets. She added that fewer cats were neutered or spayed too. 'During the Covid lockdown, the PDSA and RSPCA stopped doing neuters as normal because they could only have one vet in the operating theatre at a time,' said Bayka. 'We continued to neuter cats, but we were only able to do about a quarter of the amount we usually would,' she added. A lot of rescue centres and animal shelters are now facing a backlog of cases on neutering operations. This year At the beginning of this year, the Moggery Rehoming Centre rescued 50 cats and kittens from one flat in Weston-super-Mare. The cats and kittens filled the centre's capacity for the first three months of 2025, limiting their ability to help other cats. The issue is being felt in Gloucestershire too. At Cheltenham Animal Shelter, the team has received 34 kittens since the start of this year, while usually at this point they would have usually taken in two to four. At Bristol and Wales Cat Rescue, a campaign has allowed staff to neuter 50 cats, at no cost to their owners. A spokesperson for the organisation said the campaign has stopped them from receiving an excessive amount of kittens, reducing pressure on their service. Best practice - advice from Cats Protection Cats Protection says it's best to neuter cats at around four months old- the age female cats can get pregnant- to prevent them from having unwanted litters. It adds that neutering/spaying cats also has multiple health benefits for them. Neutering male cats prevents them from wandering far from home in search of a mate, which lowers the chance of them getting injured while roaming. It also reduces the chance of them contracting diseases like Feline AIDS (FIV) and prevents them from getting testicular cancer. Similarly, spaying female cats can also reduce the chances of them contracting FIV. It also eliminates risk of ovarian and uterine cancer.
