Karnataka High Court adjourns pleas against state caste survey implementation to July 17
The Karnataka High Court on Monday posted to July 17 petitions filed against the Socioeconomic and Educational Survey and rejected a petitioner's oral plea to restrict the state government from taking action on the basis of the caste survey during the pendency of the petitions.
The bunch of six petitions dating from 2015 to 2024 have called into question the caste survey, which was completed in 2015 and unveiled by the Congress government on April 11 at a cabinet meeting.
Petitioners Shivraj Kanshetty and others have requested the high court to strike down a September 6, 2014, amendment to section 9 of the Karnataka State Backward Classes Commission Act 1995 that facilitated the caste survey and the 2014 order for the survey.
The petitions from 2015 have been pending in the high court on account of the Supreme Court hearing a plea related to the powers of states to decide on policies for the development of backward classes under sections 15(4) and 16 (4) of the Constitution of India.
During the arguments on Monday, the counsel for the petitioners said the petitions related to the caste survey sought to be conducted by the government of Karnataka in 2014.
A division bench of Chief Justice N V Anjaria and Justice K V Aravind said the matter was not urgent and could be taken up on July 17.
The counsel, however, sought a high court direction that no further action should be taken on the report on account of an undertaking given by Karnataka to the Supreme Court, where the matter is still pending. The high court directed the petitioner's counsel to apply for an interim order for the relief sought.
In March 2021, the high court adjourned the pleas challenging the caste survey by referring to a matter pending before a Constitution bench of the Supreme Court in civil appeal No.3123 of 2020, where the apex court has 'formulated six questions for consideration'.
One of these questions is whether the 102nd amendment to the Constitution 'deprives the state legislature of its power to enact a legislation determining the socially and economically backward classes and conferring the benefits on the said community under its enabling power?'
Another question is 'whether states' power to legislate in relation to 'any backward class' under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) is anyway abridged by Article 342(A) read with Article 366(26c) of the Constitution of India?'
A third question is 'whether Article 342A of the Constitution abrogates States' power to legislate or classify in respect of 'any backward class of citizens' and thereby affects the federal policy/structure of the Constitution of India?'
'Section 11 of the Backward Classes Act provides that the State Government shall, at the expiration of ten years on coming into force of the said Act and every succeeding period of ten years, undertake revision of the lists prepared by the state government for the purpose of excluding from such lists those classes who have ceased to be backward classes or for including in such lists, new backward classes under Articles 15(4) and 16 of the Constitution of India,' the high court said in its order on the petitions on March 17, 2021.
'Sub-section (1) of Section 11 of the Backward Classes Act contemplates exclusion of backward classes of Citizens and inclusion as well. The survey which is the subject matter of challenge in these petitions has been undertaken in aid of the exercise to be conducted under sub-section (1) of Section 11 of the Backward Classes Act,' the court had further observed. 'Now, the Constitution Bench is examining the very power of the State to legislate in relation to 'any backward class' under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) in the light of the provisions of Article 342(A) of the Constitution incorporated by 102nd Amendment with effect from 15th August, 2018. Thus, the questions which are being examined by the Constitutional Bench include questions regarding the very existence of the power of the state government to make classification in respect of any backward class of citizens.'
The high court had earlier adjourned the hearings on the petitions against the caste survey on account of the Supreme Court addressing the issue of state powers to legislate on the welfare of backward classes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Ambedkar row: State SC panel issues notice to Lalu
Patna: Bihar State Commission for Scheduled Castes has issued a notice to RJD chief Lalu Prasad , demanding a response within 15 days as to why a case under the SC/ST Atrocities Prevention Act should not be filed against him for allegedly disrespecting a photograph of Dr B R Ambedkar. The incident occurred during Lalu's birthday celebration on June 11. The letter, signed by commission vice-president Devendra Kumar on June 13, read, "You (Lalu) have insulted the photo of Constitution maker Baba Saheb Dr Bhimrao Ambedkar on your birthday, which is being continuously seen on social media. The insult of Baba Saheb has hurt the honour of not only one class but the entire country. Therefore, give an explanation within 15 days and tell why a case should not be registered against you under the Scheduled Castes, Tribes Atrocities Act. " The controversy arose from a viral video showing an RJD worker placing Ambedkar's picture as a gift on a table near Lalu's feet. Lalu neither acknowledged nor touched the photograph, nor made any comment. The BJP has strongly criticised the incident. In defence, Tejashwi Prasad Yadav, Lalu's son and former deputy chief minister, accused the BJP of levelling false accusations. "BJP has nothing to do with the principles and policies of Baba Saheb. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later [Video] getfittoday Undo Today, even at the age of 78, Laluji meets people for 10 hours. But those making allegations have no shame at all. BJP should learn that even at this age Laluji remains in touch with the public," he said. Deputy CM Samrat Choudhary wrote on X on Sunday, "It has been more than 36 hours since the video of Baba Saheb's insult came out. The whole of Bihar is hurt by that video, but not even two words of regret have come from RJD. Bihar has definitely seen the arrogance of Lalu's beloved son Tejashwi. Our question is that even after insulting Baba Saheb by keeping his photo near his feet, Lalu's son does not feel it is an insult, then after what other will RJD accept as an insult?" Jan Suraaj founder Prashant Kishor also criticised Lalu and took a swipe at the Congress. "Rahul Gandhi says don't be afraid. Lalu had his feet in front of Baba Saheb's photo. If you have the courage, then show it by giving a statement on it," he said in Muzaffarpur on Sunday. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .
The Print
an hour ago
- The Print
Priyanka targets Left in Nilambur, says lives at risk amid human-animal conflict
In an apparent response to Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan's earlier statement that a major hurdle in addressing the growing incidents of human-animal conflict was the wildlife laws enacted by the Congress government led by Indira Gandhi, Vadra said there was no point in blaming old laws. Vadra, who represents the Wayanad constituency in the Lok Sabha, referred to the loss of lives and livelihoods caused by human-animal conflict in her constituency– of which Nilambur is also an Assembly segment — and said it is the responsibility of the state government to ensure the protection of people's lives and livelihoods. Malappuram (Kerala), Jun 15 (PTI) Congress General Secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Sunday used incidents of human-animal conflict and the alleged politicisation of the welfare pension scheme to criticise the CPI(M)-led LDF government during a corner meeting held to seek votes for the party's candidate in the Nilambur Assembly by-election. 'There is no point in blaming old laws or saying that it is somebody else's fault. When we are in government, when it is a government, then it is the government's responsibility to place basic protection for lives and livelihoods,' said Vadra at the meeting organised at Moothedam village after a roadshow. In a recent press conference, CM Vijayan said that the state government was taking all possible steps to address the increasing instances of human-animal conflict, but central laws remained a major hurdle in effectively dealing with the issue. 'Everyone knows that these wildlife laws were introduced during the tenure of the Congress government at the Centre under Indira Gandhi in 1972,' the chief minister said, referring to the Wild Life (Protection) Act of 1972, which was enacted for the protection of plant and animal species across India. Vadra, who visited the home of a victim of human-animal conflict before attending the corner meeting, said it is very important to find concrete measures to protect lives. She also referred to the recent incident in which a teenage boy was electrocuted by an illegal wire trap intended for wild boar in the Nilambur Assembly constituency. Raising the issue of the Rs 1,600 welfare pension given to over 62 lakh people, the Congress General Secretary accused the Left government of politicising it. It must be given on time. It cannot be distributed at the convenience of the government — when it suits them, whether during elections or otherwise, she said. 'People depend on this pension,' Vadra added. Her statement on the welfare pension came as the ruling CPI(M) launched a strong campaign in bypoll-bound Nilambur against Congress leader K C Venugopal's remark likening welfare pensions to a 'bribe'. The CPI(M), which accused him of attacking a vital welfare scheme, seized on the comment made during a speech as part of the ongoing Nilambur bypoll campaign, framing it as an insult to pension beneficiaries. Venugopal later clarified that his remarks regarding the Left government's welfare pension disbursement were intended to highlight delays and the partial clearing of arrears close to elections. During the corner meeting, Vadra also referred to the ongoing protest by ASHA workers in Kerala, who are raising various demands, including an improved honorarium. The Lok Sabha MP said the role of ASHA workers had become a 24/7, seven-day-a-week job, and was no longer just voluntary work. 'So, if they are asking for a reasonable raise in their honorarium and Rs 5 lakh as a retirement amount, what is wrong with that? Is it not their right?' she asked. Congress leader Aryadan Shoukath is the UDF candidate, while the CPI(M) has fielded its state secretariat member M Swaraj as the LDF candidate for the 19 June bypoll, which is considered crucial for both fronts ahead of the Assembly elections next year. PTI TGB TGB KH This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
There is no question of change in leadership in State, says Mahadevappa
Ruling out any possibility of replacing the Chief Minister in the State, Social Welfare Minister H.C. Mahadevappa has said that there is no question of change in leadership. 'We do not know when the Congress high command discussed with MLC Vishwanath about a change in leadership in the State,' he quipped. Addressing presspersons in Kalaburagi on Sunday, Mr. Mahadevappa affirmed that Chief Minister Siddaramaiah will complete a full five-year term. The people of Karnataka have blessed the Congress for five years and also given an opportunity for Mr. Siddaramaiah to continue in office for five years, he added. Criticising the BJP leaders for their double standards while demanding the resignation of Mr. Siddaramaiah for the recent stampede during the RCB's victory celebrations in Bengaluru, Mr. Mahadevappa argued that a stampede claimed lives during Kumbh Mela, more than 250 people lost their lives in a plane crash in Ahmedabad and seven devotees flying from Kedarnath temple to Guptkashi in Uttarakhand were killed in a helicopter crash. Did anyone demand the Prime Minister's resignation, he asked. It is inappropriate to politicise such tragic and sorrowful events, he said. However, the State government has formed an inquiry commission to investigate the stampede and to look into procedural lapses. 'We shall wait for the commission's report,' the Minister added. Taking an oblique dig at the functioning of the Modi-led government at the Centre, Mr. Mahadevappa said that the glorification of a single individual can be a pathway towards dictatorship. When a leader is praised and his actions are portrayed as infallible, it can undermine democratic institutions and pave the way for authoritarian rule. To uphold democratic values and preserve them, a consortium of various progressive organizations organised in September last year a 2,500-km-long human chain across the State to spread awareness about the Constitution and democracy during the International Day of Democracy. One must remember that equality and harmony can be achieved only by following the teachings of the Buddha, Basava and Ambedkar, he reiterated. MLA Allamprabhu Patil, MLCs Thippannappa Kamaknoor and Jagdev Guttedar and Dalit leader D.G. Sagar were present.
