
Crew of New Zealand navy ship that sank off Samoa lacked training and experience, inquiry finds
A lack of training, qualifications and experience among the crew on board a New Zealand navy ship that ran aground, caught fire and sank off the coast of Samoa have been identified by a military Court of Inquiry in a final report released Friday as contributing to the disaster.
The deficiencies were among a dozen failings of the crew, ship and New Zealand's Navy that contributed to the loss of the HMNZS Manawanui in October 2024, the 120-page report said. An interim report last November had already divulged that the ship's crew didn't realize the vessel was on autopilot and believed something else had gone wrong as it plowed toward a reef.
All 75 people on board evacuated to safety as the boat foundered about 1.6 kilometers (a mile) off the coast of Upolu, Samoa's second largest island. The ship was one of only nine in New Zealand's navy and was the first the country lost at sea since World War II.
What went wrong?
Officials did not immediately know the cause of the sinking and the Court of Inquiry was ordered to find out. Insufficient training, lack of qualified personnel on board and inadequate risk management, were among a raft of problems uncovered in its findings released Friday.
The report also underlined the so-called hollowness of New Zealand's navy — which prompted the organization to 'take risks' to meet demands 'with a lean and inexperienced workforce,' its authors wrote.
'It's an indictment on the fact that our navy was left in quite a perilous state,' Defense Minister Judith Collins told reporters in Auckland Friday. The whole of the country's military needed a 'serious uplift,' she added.
The state of New Zealand's aging military hardware has prompted several warnings from the defense agency, which in a March 2024 report described the navy as 'extremely fragile,' with ships idle due to problems retaining the staff needed to service and maintain them.
What will happen next?
The Court of Inquiry could not make findings of guilt, it said, and suggested a separate disciplinary investigation for individual members of the crew who were not named in the report. Their suggested offenses were redacted.
The report included a dramatic transcript of what unfolded on the bridge, with one crew member saying to another that the ship was 'not really doing what I want it to do" as they tried to change the vessel's course.
'It's a bad day for the navy,' said Rear Admiral Garin Golding, the leader of the navy. 'Our reputation has taken a hit.'
The navy would 'learn from' the episode and ensure it wasn't repeated, he added. Friday's findings, however, also urged recognition for those involved in the decision to abandon ship, who the report found saved lives during the evacuation.
What happened to the ship?
The specialist dive and hydrographic vessel had been in service for New Zealand since 2019 and was surveying the reef that it ran aground on. Its sinking provoked alarm, demands for compensation and fear of environmental catastrophe for Samoan villagers living on the coast where it capsized, who say they fear permanent damage to the fragile reef ecosystem.
A no-fishing zone around the vessel was lifted by Samoa's government in February.
New Zealand's military said this month that it had completed months of work to remove diesel fuel and other pollutants from the ship, which remains where it sank. Salvage work to retrieve equipment and weapons continues.
Seawater and marine life in the area are 'uncontaminated', the military said, citing Samoa's scientific research agency. A decision about whether the ship will eventually be removed has not been made.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Record
9 hours ago
- Daily Record
Raploch war memorial plans take next step as long-running project moves closer
The group behind the memorial plans have found more than 120 men and women who served in World War Two from the area - with hopes to commemorate their sacrifice with a permanent monument. Raploch is stepping closer to achieving its goal of creating a lasting monument to its war dead. Rev Barry Hughes and Raploch Community Council have now lodged a planning application with Stirling Council planners to install the memorial at the north west corner of Raploch Community Campus on Drip Road. A fundraising campaign was launched last year in a bid to raise £30,000 for the war memorial to honour the community's fallen. In 2019, two local residents discovered not only the names of over 60 local men who served their country and were among the fallen of World War II, but also where they had lived in Raploch. This discovery gave the impetus for a project to build a war memorial in the Village Square outside the Raploch Community Campus, to commemorate all those from Raploch who have lost their lives in conflict. The Raploch War Memorial Group formed and then discovered over 120 men and women who also served during World War II and were injured, prisoners of war or awarded and recognised for their actions during service. They also aim to honour these men and women with a history book that has some of the stories they have discovered. The group said last year: 'We are pleased to announce that we are now in a position to begin our fundraising for the war memorial. 'It has taken us longer than we expected but we didn't want to start this process until we had everything in place to begin the official application for planning permission. 'We are hoping to raise £30,000 to fund the construction of the war memorial.' A public consultation in the area in 2022 asked people to vote on a number of options for the memorial. Asked what they would prefer to see on the memorial, 55 per cent said a list of the names of the fallen in all conflicts of the 20th/21st centuries; 30 per cent said a tribute quote to all the fallen in all conflicts; 7.5 per cent opted for only a list of the names of the fallen in World War II; and 7.5 per cent went for 'other'. A second question asking people whether the top two winning designs and quote from a local children's war memorial design competition should be included saw 94.59 per cent of respondents say yes, with 5.41 per cent saying no and 2.7 per cent unsure. The proposals for the permanent memorial to the fallen were dreamt up by local pensioner Mick Lowe and partnerships with local groups including Raploch Community Partnership, St Mark's and St Margaret's, Stirling Council and the Salvation Army have been formed for the project. The project came about after pensioner Mick began researching soldiers to find out more about his dad John, who died in 1948 after being a prisoner of war during World War Two. Mick discovered a total of 68 soldiers who died during the Second World War from Raploch. But the proposals would see a war memorial erected to pay tribute to the casualties from several conflicts who originally hailed from Raploch. Six streets in a new housing development being built in Raploch are also being named after men from the area who died in World War Two. Brewster Crescent, Fairley Crescent, Hulston Road, Turner Street, Spencer Place and McDonald Court, will become lasting legacies of six of those who lost their lives in the conflict, and their fellow fallen comrades from the community. Private Robert Brewster of 21 Hawthorn Crescent, Pte John Fairley of 43D Raploch Road, Pte William Hulston of 8 Hawthorn Crescent, Pte James Turner of 23 Hawthorn Crescent, Pte Ian Spencer of 4 Haig Avenue, and Pte James McDonald of 64 Drip Road are amongst a list of 48 names compiled by Raploch man Mr Lowe. The formal planning application lodged last week states: 'Raploch Community Council wishes to erect a war memorial adjacent to the Raploch community campus building. 'The war memorial will be 2000mm x 1500m wide, will be set on a raised foundation, and then be 2860mm high; it will be made out of sandstone.'


BBC News
12 hours ago
- BBC News
HMS Bristol: Last Falklands warship given send-off by veterans
Veterans and members of the public have turned out to give a final farewell to a former Royal Navy flagship that played a "vital role" in the Falklands Bristol was towed out of Portsmouth Harbour on Wednesday, almost five years after it was warship, which was the last ship serving from the Falklands War, is being taken to a Turkish Howe, from the South Atlantic Medal Association 1982, said the vessel had a "remarkable and unique legacy". The Type 82 destroyer was commissioned in March 1973 but having been designed to defend a class of aircraft carriers which was never built, it was the only warship of its class to enter service. The vessel led a group of two destroyers, five frigates and an RFA supply ship providing reinforcements in the Falklands, and later joined the carrier battle task group as an air defence 1987 it became a training ship before an explosion in its boiler led to it being used as a harbour training vessel - until it was decommissioned in October 2020, after almost 48 years of of the public and veterans congregated on Old Portsmouth's Round Tower to wave off HMS Bristol, which was visually rust-stained, as it left the Hampshire naval base. "As HMS Bristol embarks on its final voyage to the scrapyard in Turkey, we pause to reflect on its remarkable and unique legacy," Mr Howe said."For many veterans, Bristol was more than a vessel - it was a home, a place of camaraderie, and a symbol of resilience."Its departure marks the end of an era, but its contributions to our history and the memories of those who served aboard will endure.""We honour all who sailed in her and bid HMS Bristol a respectful farewell." You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.


The Independent
13 hours ago
- The Independent
Last Falklands era warship given ‘respectful farewell' as it heads to scrapyard
Veterans and members of the public have turned out to give a 'respectful farewell' to a former Royal Navy flagship that played a 'vital role' in the Falklands conflict. HMS Bristol was towed out of Portsmouth Harbour on Wednesday, almost five years after it was decommissioned. The warship, which was the last ship serving from the Falklands war, is being taken to a Turkish scrapyard. The Type 82 destroyer was commissioned in March 1973 but having been designed to defend a class of aircraft carriers which was never built, it was the only warship of its class to enter service. Bristol led a group of two destroyers, five frigates and an RFA supply ship providing reinforcements in the Falklands war and later joined the carrier battle task group as an air defence destroyer. In 1987 it became a training ship as part of the Dartmouth Training Squadron before an explosion in its boiler led to it being used as a harbour training vessel at HMS Excellent, Portsmouth, until it was decommissioned in October 2020 after nearly 48 years of service. Members of the public and veterans congregated on Old Portsmouth's Round Tower to wave off Bristol, which was visually rust-stained, as it left the Hampshire naval base. Chris Howe, of the South Atlantic Medal Association 1982, said: 'As HMS Bristol embarks on its final voyage to the scrapyard in Turkey, we pause to reflect on its remarkable and unique legacy. 'This ship played a vital role in the 1982 Falklands conflict, serving as a headquarters and providing steadfast support to British forces. 'For many veterans, Bristol was more than a vessel – it was a home, a place of camaraderie, and a symbol of resilience. 'Its departure marks the end of an era, but its contributions to our history and the memories of those who served aboard will endure. 'We honour all who sailed in her and bid HMS Bristol a respectful farewell.' HMS Bristol was sold for recycling by ship recycling experts from the Defence Equipment & Support (DE&S) Defence Recycling & Disposals Team (DRDT), on behalf of the Royal Navy. A DE&S spokesman said it would be taken to a specialist recycling facility within an EU-approved yard in Turkey, with all reusable equipment having been removed for sale. Alistair Hughes, head of DRDT, said: 'Recycling of ships at the end of their hull life is routine business for the Royal Navy and our aim is to achieve maximum value for money for defence in an environmentally compliant manner – HMS Bristol is a fitting example of this after her many dedicated years of service.'