These scientists think alien life best explains what Webb just found
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience.
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience.
Yahoo is using AI to generate takeaways from this article. This means the info may not always match what's in the article. Reporting mistakes helps us improve the experience. Generate Key Takeaways
A team of scientists is doubling down on its claims that a world 124 light-years away in space is likely covered in oceans and full of aquatic life, with new data to support the findings.
The research, led by astronomers at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom, kicked off a fervent debate in 2023 when it suggested K2-18b, an exoplanet in the constellation Leo, gave a chemical signal for dimethyl sulfide gas . On Earth, that molecule is only known to be made by living things — primarily phytoplankton, a type of microscopic algae.
The initial report was based on observations from the powerful James Webb Space Telescope , a collaboration of NASA and its European and Canadian counterparts. But the results created a lot of hubbub among habitable world experts. Skeptics criticized the weakness of the signal and other aspects of the study, such as the belief that the planet, about nine times heavier than Earth and 2.5 times wider, is indeed a water world .
Other scientists continue to feel frustrated with the way the work is being described to the public, with news headlines that suggest the group is closer to discovering life beyond Earth than it really is.
Now the team has put forward a follow-up study, using a different instrument on Webb, that offers a fresh view of the planet and more evidence for either dimethyl sulfide or a similar life-related compound, dimethyl disulfide, in its atmosphere.
"The signal came through, strong and clear," said Nikku Madhusudhan, lead author of the new paper , published this week in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
SEE ALSO: Scientists haven't found a rocky exoplanet with air. But now they have a plan.
An artist's imagining of an exoplanet orbiting a red dwarf star
Further studies of exoplanet K2-18b, which orbits a cool dwarf star in its so-called "habitable zone," continue to incite controversy over whether it hosts life. Credit: NASA / ESA / CSA / Joseph Olmsted (STScI) illustration
K2-18b orbits a red dwarf star , cooler than the sun , in its so-called "habitable zone," the region around a host star where it's not too hot or cold for liquid water to exist on the surface of a planet. In our solar system, that sweet spot encompasses Venus, Earth, and Mars.
Based on the new analysis, the scientists seem more confident that K2-18b is a Hycean world, a type of planet predicted to exist in the galaxy, combining the words "hydrogen" and "ocean." These theorized exoplanets, a subset of worlds that can't be found in our own solar system, are called mini Neptunes : smaller than Neptune but larger than Earth.
Such planets could be covered in water and surrounded by thick atmospheres full of hydrogen gas, unlike Earth's nitrogen-based atmosphere. If they exist, Hycean worlds are expected to be easier to see and study with telescopes than Earth-like rocky worlds , because they're bigger and have puffier atmospheres.
"Given everything we know about this planet, a Hycean world with an ocean that is teeming with life is the scenario that best fits the data we have," Madhusudhan said in a statement . He did not respond to questions from Mashable earlier this week.
Meanwhile, other scientists are offering counter arguments to explain the planet, such as the possibility that K2-18b is a big rock wrapped in a magma ocean , with little likelihood of being habitable. Some also have attempted to apply different computer models to the 2023 data and could not pick out dimethyl sulfide, or DMS for short, from other signals.
The latest Webb data focused on mid-infrared light, a different part of the light spectrum, where DMS and dimethyl disulfide, or DMDS, leave stronger chemical fingerprints.
The way they analyzed the planet's atmosphere is called transmission spectroscopy . When planets cross in front of their host star, starlight shines through their atmospheres. Molecules within the atmosphere absorb certain light wavelengths, or colors, so by splitting the star's light into its basic parts — a rainbow — astronomers can look for which light segments are missing to figure out the makeup of an atmosphere.
While Earth has relatively tiny amounts of DMS and DMDS, K2-18b appears to have much more — perhaps thousands of times more, according to the paper, fitting with theories for Hycean planets. The observations reached "three-sigma" significance, the team said, meaning there's only a 0.3 percent chance the results happened by accident. Their findings could qualify as a formal scientific discovery with just 16 to 24 more hours of Webb telescope observations, they said.
Regardless of the way the Cambridge team has talked about its next steps, there doesn't appear to be consensus among scientists on the right time to claim a detection of extraterrestrial life. That may be one reason why their work is raising hackles, said Michaela Leung, a planetary scientist at the University of California in Riverside.
James Webb Space Telescope against a starry background
Despite the James Webb Space Telescope's power, scientists question whether it's capable of definitively identifying specific life-produced gases in exoplanet atmospheres. Credit: NASA GSFC / CIL / Adriana Manrique Gutierrez illustration
She recently wrote a paper on other molecules researchers could look for with Webb that are linked to biology on Earth.
"Look for another gas," Leung told Mashable. "A strong claim of life detection here is going to report more than one potential biosignature. Even if what is in that atmosphere is DMS, which I think is not clear at this time, I think we would also have to robustly eliminate all abiotic possibilities."
The Cambridge team considered how the two gases might form without organisms, such as through starlight or from comets , giant snowballs hurtling through space. Still, they believe a biological explanation is the more likely scenario.
No matter how much more time they spend measuring the chemical composition of K2-18b's atmosphere, that data alone won't be enough to convince some scientists, said Sarah Hörst, a professor at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, who specializes in planetary atmospheres.
"We have many examples in our own solar system of molecules that could be considered to be signs of life but have eventually been shown to have other explanations," Hörst told Mashable. "The search for life is quite challenging and will require extraordinary evidence."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
13 minutes ago
Summer solstice 2025: When is the 1st day of summer?
Get ready for sun-soaked days and warmer weather, as the summer solstice 2025 is just around the corner. The astronomical event marks the official start of summer and the beginning of an extended period of daylight in the northern hemisphere as we transition out of the darker, colder months. The solstice occurs twice a year when one of Earth's poles reaches its maximum tilt toward the sun, according to NASA. The word "solstice" comes from the Latin solstitium, meaning "sun stands still," referring to the moment when the sun's apparent path pauses before reversing direction, according to Royal Museums Greenwich. Across the globe, cultures have long celebrated the summer solstice with unique traditions from watching the sunrise align with Stonehenge in England to dancing around maypoles in Sweden and lighting bonfires in Norway. Here's everything you need to know about the 2025 summer solstice. When is the 2025 summer solstice? The 2025 summer solstice falls on Friday, June 20, at 10:42 p.m. ET, according to NASA and the Old Farmer's Almanac. This marks the longest day of the year in the northern hemisphere, when the Earth's tilt positions it closest to the Sun. "The situation is reversed for the southern hemisphere, where it's the shortest day of the year," NASA states. What is the summer solstice? The summer solstice occurs at the point in Earth's orbit when the sun shines most directly on the northern hemisphere, according to NASA. "Astronomers consider this the beginning of the Summer in the northern hemisphere," NASA states. While it marks the start of summer in the north, the event marks the winter solstice in the southern hemisphere, where sunlight is at its lowest angle. When is the longest day of the year in 2025? The longest day of the year in 2025 will occur on Friday, June 20, for those in the northern hemisphere. On this day, the sun reaches its highest point in the sky, resulting in the most daylight hours of the year. NASA notes this happens when "the sun is directly over the Tropic of Cancer," located at 23.5 degrees north latitude. Is the summer solstice the first day of summer? Yes, astronomers recognize the summer solstice as the official first day of summer in the northern hemisphere, according to NASA. The National Centers for Environmental Information explains that solstices and equinoxes mark the start of the astronomical seasons. These events occur when the sun reaches its most extreme position relative to the equator, either directly overhead or crossing it. Meteorological seasons split the year into three-month groups based on temperature cycles and "are more closely tied to our monthly civil calendar than the astronomical seasons are," according to the agency. Does the summer solstice always fall on the same day? According to the Old Farmer's Almanac, the summer solstice doesn't always occur on the same date. It can fall on June 20, 21, or 22, depending on the year. This is because the timing of the solstice isn't tied to a fixed calendar date. Instead, it's determined by the exact moment the sun reaches its northernmost point from the celestial equator during Earth's orbit. What happens on the summer solstice? On the day of the summer solstice, the sun reaches its highest point in the sky at noon, and its position changes very little for several days before and after, according to the National Weather Service. This results in the longest day of the year and the shortest night. While the term "longest day" doesn't refer to the number of hours in the day, it does mean the day with the most sunlight.
Los Angeles Times
an hour ago
- Los Angeles Times
How two satellites are mimicking total solar eclipses in space
CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — A pair of European satellites have created the first artificial solar eclipses by flying in precise and fancy formation, providing hours of on-demand totality for scientists. The European Space Agency released the eclipse pictures at the Paris Air Show on Monday. Launched late last year, the orbiting duo have churned out simulated solar eclipses since March while zooming tens of thousands of miles above Earth. Flying 492 feet apart, one satellite blocks the sun like the moon does during a natural total solar eclipse as the other aims its telescope at the corona, the sun's outer atmosphere that forms a crown or halo of light. It's an intricate, prolonged dance requiring extreme precision by the cube-shaped spacecraft, less than 5 feet in size. Their flying accuracy needs to be within a mere millimeter, the thickness of a fingernail. This meticulous positioning is achieved autonomously through GPS navigation, star trackers, lasers and radio links. Dubbed Proba-3, the $210-million mission has generated 10 successful solar eclipses so far during the ongoing checkout phase. The longest eclipse lasted five hours, said the Royal Observatory of Belgium's Andrei Zhukov, the lead scientist for the orbiting corona-observing telescope. He and his team are aiming for a wondrous six hours of totality per eclipse once scientific observations begin in July. Scientists already are thrilled by the preliminary results that show the corona without the need for any special image processing, said Zhukov. 'We almost couldn't believe our eyes,' Zhukov said in an email. 'This was the first try, and it worked. It was so incredible.' Zhukov anticipates an average of two solar eclipses per week being produced for a total of nearly 200 during the two-year mission, yielding more than 1,000 hours of totality. That will be a scientific bonanza since full solar eclipses produce just a few minutes of totality when the moon lines up perfectly between Earth and the sun — on average just once every 18 months. The sun continues to mystify scientists, especially its corona, which is hotter than the solar surface. Coronal mass ejections result in billions of tons of plasma and magnetic fields being hurled out into space. Geomagnetic storms can result, disrupting power and communication while lighting up the night sky with auroras in unexpected locales. While previous satellites have generated imitation solar eclipses — including the European Space Agency and NASA's Solar Orbiter and Soho observatory — the sun-blocking disk was always on the same spacecraft as the corona-observing telescope. What makes this mission unique, Zhukov said, is that the sun-shrouding disk and telescope are on two different satellites and therefore far apart. The distance between these two satellites will give scientists a better look at the part of the corona closest to the limb of the sun. 'We are extremely satisfied by the quality of these images, and again this is really thanks to formation flying' with unprecedented accuracy, ESA's mission manager Damien Galano said from the Paris Air Show. Dunn writes for the Associated Press. AP journalist John Leicester contributed to this report from Paris. The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Gizmodo
an hour ago
- Gizmodo
NASA Moves Ahead With Private ISS Mission After Air Leak Repairs
NASA is looking to launch Axiom Space's fourth private mission to the International Space Station (ISS) this week, after recent attempts to repair air leaks in the Russian module appear to have been successful. Last week, the space agency abruptly postponed the launch of Axiom Mission 4, which was set to launch on June 11. NASA cited a new pressure signal in a segment of the Zvezda service module that's been leaking air, very slowly, for nearly six years. In a follow-up statement on Saturday, NASA explained that the pressure signal (a change in airflow or cabin pressure picked up by sensors) may be a sign that the leaks have been sealed. There's also a chance, however, that air began flowing to a different area in the aft segment of the Russian module, leading to the new pressure signal. 'Following the most-recent repair, pressure in the transfer tunnel has been stable. Previously, pressure in this area would have dropped,' NASA wrote in a statement. 'This could indicate the small leaks have been sealed. Teams are also considering the stable pressure could be the result of a small amount of air flowing into the transfer tunnel across the hatch seal from the main part of [the] space station.' NASA is monitoring the change in pressure over time, and evaluating the condition of the transfer tunnel and the hatch seal between the space station and the back of the Zvezda module. In the meantime, the agency decided to go ahead with the launch of AX-4 no earlier than Thursday, June 19. The mission will be led by spaceflight veteran Peggy Whitson, a former NASA astronaut who holds the national record for the most cumulative days spent in space. She will be joined by pilot Shubhanshu Shukla of India, mission specialist Sławosz Uznański-Wiśniewski of Poland, and mission specialist Tibor Kapu of Hungary. The decision to postpone the mission was to allow more time for NASA and the Russian space agency, Roscosmos, to evaluate the situation on board the ISS and decide if more troubleshooting is needed before adding more crew members to the space station. In its most recent statement, NASA said that 'teams are making progress evaluating the transfer tunnel configuration.' Roscosmos first reported the leak in August 2020, tracing it to the Zvezda life support module that Russia launched to low Earth orbit in July 2000. Since then, the rate at which air is leaking from the Zvezda service module has doubled from one pound a day to a little over two pounds a day, according to a report released in 2024. That led NASA to elevate the leak to the highest level of risk. At the time, it was reported that NASA and Roscosmos could not agree on the root cause of the leak or a way to fix it. Although it's taken years to address, the recent repair efforts show some progress in trying to fix the leaky space station. Whether or not the aging ISS is fit to host more astronauts right now remains to be seen.
