Joe McCarthy makes a big impression on his Lions debut
IT WAS THE 11th minute in Perth and the Lions were under the pump.
They had made a flying start to score through captain Dan Sheehan but the Force quickly hit back through Nic White – who else? – after the first of what proved to be several restart receipt botches by Scott Cummings and co.
With the game tied at 7-7, the Lions' discipline began to slip. Tadhg Beirne was among those to give up penalties, as was Joe McCarthy when he swung up the side of a maul.
So the Lions found themselves defending another maul just five metres from their line. A big moment early in the game. Give the hosts a lead and there might be trouble.
But it was 24-year-old McCarthy who splintered through the Force maul and took hold of the ball, reefing it clear of Australian hands so the Lions could kick clear.
Just two minutes later, McCarthy had another turnover. This one came at the breakdown after excellent work by Beirne, who fought hard in a choke tackle, listened to the warning to release the ball-carrier, and left the door open for McCarthy to pounce for a clean poach.
With the siege lifted, the Lions found their rhythm again and soon grabbed their second try of the night as Henry Pollock and Josh van der Flier combined beautifully to tee up Tomos Williams.
Scott Cummings and Joe McCarthy. Billy Sitckland / INPHO Billy Sitckland / INPHO / INPHO
There was another McCarthy pilfer in the first half, again off the back of Beirne's good work. On this 34th-minute occasion, Beirne barged through a Force ruck to leave the ball exposed. McCarthy didn't need to be asked twice, scooping it up and launching a counter-attack.
Advertisement
The Irish lock simply never let up in a powerful, busy performance for the Lions as they hammered the Force 52-7 to get their tour of Australia rolling.
His ball-carrying was prominent, with 15 carries leaving him second on the Lions' list behind Sione Tuipulotu.
On the other side of the ball, McCarthy's 17 tackles left him short of only Josh van der Flier's 22.
It wasn't all about grunt work, either. When the Force spilled the ball in the Lions' 22 early in the second half, McCarthy showed good alertness to step in at scrum-half and fire a long pass from left to right, sparking the classy breakout try finished by Williams.
Sure, Beirne and Finn Russell were screaming for the ball but McCarthy calmly adapted to make sure it got there. He had a few other nice passes in this game.
The Leinster second row also finished one of the Lions' eight tries, cantering into the left corner after Pollock's brilliant chip and regather left the Force reeling. That relatively handy finish was justified reward for McCarthy's work rate.
Of course, Andy Farrell knows all about what McCarthy brings. He has seen him make a big impact against better opposition than the Western Force. But momentum and form during a Lions tour are important. This was a great start for McCarthy on his debut in the red jersey.
The Dublin man was always going to be an intriguing figure on this tour. He's the least experienced of the second rows but he offers something different to the others.
At 124kg, McCarthy is the biggest and heaviest of the second row crop. He's probably the purest tighthead lock, the most obvious physical enforcer. His power and weight are useful when it comes to intense physical battles like the maul and scrum.
McCarthy with Dan Sheehan. Dan Sheridan / INPHO Dan Sheridan / INPHO / INPHO
McCarthy has also been working hard on his lineout skills and looks a more fluid mover and jumper than ever. He had five wins in the Lions' lineout in Perth.
His biggest area for improvement in recent years has been cutting out momentary lapses of concentration or indiscipline. While his yellow card against France earlier this year showed that it remains a work in progress, there is no 24-year-old professional player who is the complete package.
We know that Farrell is a big fan of 'Big Joe,' so it will be interesting to see how the rest of this tour pans out for him.
Captain Maro Itoje will be starting the Tests in the second row barring injury, with McCarthy, Beirne, Ollie Chessum, James Ryan, and Scott Cummings also in the mix.
The Force game was a bad night for Cummings as he and his lifters struggled to deal with restarts.
Beirne played in the second row against Argentina before switching to blindside flanker today, which underlines that Farrell is considering this for the Tests. It could be that Itoje, McCarthy, and Beirne all fit into the same pack.
Chessum came on in the second row for Cummings against the Force and he is a dynamic player who can also play at blindside.
Ryan will have something to say about this selection debate as he gets set to finally make his first Lions appearance against the Reds on Wednesday. The Leinster man has been in fine form, so he will look to match McCarthy's impact by impressing in Brisbane.
The back five of the Lions scrum was always going to be difficult to pick and McCarthy's big performance in Perth has probably made it even trickier.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
17 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Ireland in promotion hunt after strong day one at European Team Championships
Ireland are in fifth place after day one of the Division 2 events at the European Athletics Team Championships in Slovenia. It was great day for Jack Raftery and the men's 4x100m relay team, as they set another new national record. Raftery put in one of the performances of the day to clock a PB of 44.98 in the 400m, which was good enough to see him finish fourth. In doing so, the Dubliner became just the second Irish man to break the 45-second mark. "I don't know if I have words for it," Raftery said afterwards. "That's the best field I've ever been part of; it's a Diamond League quality field. If I had ran a PB and came last, I would've been happy. I can't believe that. I felt great coming down that home straight. "Oh my god I'm delighted." Sharlene Mawdsley, meanwhile, ran an SB of 50.93 as she came home third in the women's 400m, a result that she was satisfied with. "I don't even know how I made it around," was her assessment post-race. "A season's best is great, it's a shame I didn't come first, I would've loved to win the top points, but it would've taken a PB to do that today. "It was about getting out there and doing my family proud." But there was delight for the men's 4x100m team as they set a new national record for the second weekend in a row. The team of Michael Farrelly (Raheny Shamrock AC), Sean Aigboboh (Tallaght AC), Marcus Lawler (Clonliffe Harriers AC) and Israel Olatunde (Tallaght AC) came home in 38.88, four tenths of a second faster than what they had managed last weekend. "There's a lot of effort that has gone into this over the years," said team captain Lawler. "We're all delighted to break the national record." It was good enough for second place overall. The action is set to resume this afternoon at 1.30pm with promotion on offer for the teams which finish in the top three. Team Ireland - Day One results Sean Mockler – Men's Hammer Throw – 12th (64.00m) Shane Howard – Men's Long Jump – 11th (7.20m) Arlene Crossan – Women's 400m Hurdles – 14th (59.14 PB) Clodagh Walsh – Women's Pole Vault – 10th (3.40m) Fintan Dewhirst – Men's 400m Hurdles – 15th (79.01) Niamh Fogarty – Women's Discus Throw – 5th (52.20m) Bori Akinola – Men's 100m – 8th (10.62, -2.2m/s) Eric Favors – Men's Shot Put – 5th (19.42m) Lucy-May Sleeman – Women's 100m – 9th (11.84, -1.1m/s) Sophie O'Sullivan – Women's 800m – 16th (2:12.87) Shane Bracken – Men's 1500m – 3rd (3:42.92) David Cussen – Men's High Jump – 5th (2.16m) Sharlene Mawdsley – Women's 400m – 3rd (50.93) Elizabeth Ndudi – Women's Long Jump – 4th (6.26m) Jack Raftery – Men's 400m – 4th (44.98) Grace Casey – Women's Javelin Throw – 14th (42.33m) Brian Fay – Men's 5000m – 2nd (13:56.07) Ava O'Connor – Women's 3000m Steeplechase – 3rd (9:45.09) Women's 4x100m Relay (Sarah Leahy, Ciara Neville, Lauren Roy, Sarah Lavin) – 3rd (43.97)
RTÉ News
17 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Sione Tuipulotu shrugs off Australian tannoy announcer 'gag' over overseas-born Lions players
Sione Tuipulotu insists the British and Irish Lions must continue to shrug off any provocation during their tour of Australia after their overseas-born contingent were attacked by the tannoy announcer at Optus Stadium. Tuipulotu, one of eight players in Andy Farrell's squad who were born, raised and educated in the southern hemisphere, was among those caught in the crosshairs before Saturday's 54-7 rout of Western Force. "Another Aussie at number 12, Sione Tuipulotu," was how the Scotland centre was introduced when the team was read out for the Lions' opening match on Australian soil. Mack Hansen, James Lowe and Pierre Schoeman were also referenced by the nation of their birth rather than their adopted country, for whom they have qualified either through residency or family heritage. It continued a theme from the hosts that began when Wallabies and former Ireland head coach Joe Schmidt described Tuipulotu and New Zealand-born Ireland international Bundee Aki as a "southern-hemisphere centre partnership" in the build-up to the defeat by Argentina in Dublin. Tuipulotu emphasised the words "good humour" when brushing aside the jibes that he expected on his return Down Under. "I knew there would be some 'good humour' coming back home to Australia. These are all things we've got to take in our stride," he said. "To not announce the elephant in the room, I am from Australia. I was born here. I don't know how funny that gag is to everyone! "I'm loving my rugby playing for the Lions and I'm really passionate about it. Andy's brought the group together so well." The victory in Perth exposed several shortcomings such as a high penalty count and creaking set-piece, but there was also much to admire in the attacking exuberance that produced eight classy tries. Tougher tests than the Force await on tour but combined with the evidence gathered from the Aviva Stadium eight days earlier, Farrell's Lions are clearly keen to keep the ball alive - and on this occasion the passes stuck. Finn Russell was at the heart of onslaught in his first outing of the tour and the Scot's instinctive play drew approval from Farrell, who declared: "He's ready to go. And that's good." Tuipulotu, who expects to be firing by the Test series as he continues his comeback from a significant ankle injury, said: "We're taking ideas from all the nations. "Obviously, the coaching style is very Ireland dominant and there are a lot of ideas that we're getting from the Irish coaches, but then those ideas are being sprinkled on. "When Finn comes in, he plays his style. He plays to the structure of the team, but he's a very instinctive player and he wants to play what's directly in front of his face. "There's a mixture there and that's what's going to make it hard to defend for opposition teams. "They're not necessarily defending a structure of play, they're defending a structure of play with really supreme individuals conducting it like Finn. "Finn's a world-class number 10 and he's been here, been there, done that. He's come off a really good season after winning the Premiership with Bath and I thought him and Tomos Williams controlled the game really well.
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Meath v Galway: The long and winding road back from 2001
The last time Meath played Galway in Croke Park they had just whipped Kerry in stunning fashion. The 2001 All-Ireland final was the first decider of the 'second chance' era. In other respects, it represented the end of an era, one generally beloved of Gaelic football fans from outside Dublin or the North. That period between Ulster's two patches of dominance in the early '90s and the early 2000s. When Dublin couldn't get out of Leinster. The early years of the Celtic Tiger. Bertie's first term as Taoiseach. Kildare super-fan Charlie McCreevy in Finance. Talk of shiny new stadiums going up all over west Dublin. Half of Croke Park still a building site, covered in Sisk signage. The Galway hurlers and footballers have rarely gone well at the same time (though they have occasionally been going badly at the same time). Like the Irish soccer and rugby teams, relative boom times for one have tended to coincide with lean patches for the other. The second year of the new millennium was one such time, however. It was the closest they've come to emulating Cork's feat in 1990. On the morning of the All-Ireland hurling final, a big yard sign around Enfield addressed the Dublin-bound traffic with the message 'Good luck today Galway but Sam is MINE!!' Unfortunately for the owner of the sign, it happened the other way around. Meath's blithe pre-match confidence was seemingly well-founded in the aftermath of their borderline garish hammering of Kerry in the semi-final. "Just in case you think there's something wrong with the caption in the top left corner of the screen, there isn't. That is the correct score. 2-13 to Kerry's five points," said Darragh Maloney with three minutes left in normal time. Most of the Kerry support were a long way down Jones's Road at that point. Boylan later claimed he felt a shiver of foreboding as the Meath crowd 'way-hayed' every five-metre fist pass in the closing minutes, as if he knew in his bones this was all bad karma. On the other side, Galway's progression to a third All-Ireland final in four years was considerably more laboured. The 1998 champions had lost the previous year's decider to Kerry after a replay and looked a jaded, clapped out team in their four-point defeat to Roscommon in Tuam in June. There was an undue air of finality in the assessments of Galway that evening. "They had gone to the well and found it dry," according to Pat Spillane on that evening's Sunday Game. As usual, the implications of the new format didn't occur to people until they started to play out in practice. Not unlike 2025, Galway made uneven progress out in the wilds of the backdoor, winning their first ever championship fixture against Armagh after almost tossing away a large lead. But, crucially, they made progress, nonetheless. Meath had gone the traditional route, beating Dublin in the Leinster final. Their sadistic habit of holding out the prospect of victory to underdogs in Leinster before snatching it away at the last minute was again in evidence a couple of times against Westmeath that summer. That was all mere prequel to their massacre of Kerry. It remains the heaviest championship defeat Kerry have suffered in the 21st century. The second heaviest was in Tullamore a fortnight ago. The Meath fans, as we've noted before, practically conga-danced their way into Croke Park for the decider. The final itself was a strangely drab one from a neutral perspective. The piéce de résistance semi-final performance being followed by a flat final performance is a story we've seen recur often across sports. England in the 2019 Rugby World Cup being a classic of the genre. In Gaelic football, Meath in 2001 is probably the starkest example of the phenomenon. Their final display was as abject as the semi-final was spectacular. 2001 remembered as @MeathGAA and @Galway_GAA lock horns again in the championship - watch on @RTE2 and @RTEplayer - listen on @RTERadio1 — The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame) June 28, 2025 It was only seven minutes into the second half, with just one point separating the teams, that Martin Carney put his finger on things - "Meath just seem tied to the ground. There's a malaise there today that we haven't seen throughout the summer." A couple of minutes later, Carney noted that "Galway were pulverising them everywhere but the scoreboard." Soon, they were doing so on the scoreboard. Galway's two most recent inter-county managers were central figures in the second half performance. Kevin Walsh devoured John McDermott on kickouts and then Pádraic Joyce began to get his eye in after an indifferent first half. The Meath defence continually showed Joyce onto his right foot, which might have been a sensible enough strategy on any other day. Joyce finished with 0-10, five with either foot. In his Man of the Match interview that night, he figured the county board chairman accidentally spilt holy water on his right boot before the game. Long before that, Meath were reduced to 14 men when the score was at 0-09 to 0-07. Trevor Giles, who endured surely his worst ever half of football in Croke Park, bizarrely shanked a free-kick into Joe Bergin's hands, who fed Paul Clancy. Nigel Nestor crudely dragged down Clancy from around the shoulder and was banished on a second yellow. Donal Curtis, veins bulging almost with fury at how the game was going, made strenuous efforts to join him though the referee Michael Collins evidently felt he couldn't send two of them off. They were thrown an undeserved lifeline late in the second half when John McDermott was absurdly awarded a penalty for a Golden Raspberry attempt at a dive. All it ended up doing was sapping their morale further as Giles dragged it low and wide of the left upright. Things petered out horribly for Meath after that and the rest of the game was a procession. 0-17 to 0-08 was the slightly jarring final scoreline. Meath were a no-show. And Galway, after surviving numerous scares en route, were champions for the second time in four years. The only county to vote against the backdoor format at Special Congress the previous winter had wound up winning the first ever All-Ireland title via the backdoor. We weren't to know it but it was the last we'd see of either team on that stage for two decades. The following year, a highly physical and well-conditioned Armagh overcame Kerry through force of will in the 2002 decider. A year after that, Tyrone swarmed Kerry in the 2003 semi-final in a spectacle which deeply offended the southern purists (namely, Pat Spillane) to tee up a first-ever all northern final. Ulster was over its late-90s slump and Kerry and Tyrone would carve up the remainder of the decade between them. The 2001 finalists had retreated almost to also-ran status by that stage. Meath's decline was the more precipitous. On the evening of the 2001 defeat, a couple of Meath fans were vox-popped and finished their contribution by announcing that "Sean Boylan is God", which Michael Lyster, back in studio, mis-heard as "Sean Boylan is gone" before chortling at the fickleness of supporters. Though, as it happened, this was Meath's last significant push for glory in Boylan's long reign. His last four seasons in charge were a forgettable post-script, akin to Micko's final three years as Kerry manager. Between 2002 and 2005, they failed to make a Leinster final and were beaten twice by Fermanagh and once by Cavan in early round qualifiers. Meath rallied under Boylan's successors, reaching All-Ireland semi-finals in 2007 and 2009. The late 2000s crop of players were not regarded as world-beaters in their own time, constantly being judged against their illustrious forebears. The succeeding generation, however, would place them in a far more flattering light. "When I look back on it, do I have frustrations? I think we were maybe over-achieving a little bit, to be honest with you," Anthony Moyles said on 'The Square Ball' podcast. "When I look at the next 10 years, Meath didn't get within an a***s roar of an All-Ireland semi-final." The manner of the 2010 Leinster final victory - we won't go there - appeared to do more psychological harm than good. Galway's drop-off was comparably gradual but began to pick up speed by the end of the decade. They still held the whip-hand in the province until the mid-2000s. There have been occasions when Galway have celebrated Connacht title wins with great gusto, usually after they've ended a bit of a drought or pipped Mayo in a classic. The few post-2001 Connacht championship wins were not among those times. The Connacht title wins of 2002, 2003 and 2005 were won almost on autopilot and quickly followed by quarter-final losses and they infamously wouldn't win again in Croke Park until the 2017 Division 2 final against Kildare. Joyce, still relied upon into the twilight of his long career, played his final match in 2012 qualifier loss to Antrim. This result was, at one level, shocking but was nonetheless typical of the era. Throughout that period, the persistent air of purist self-regard which was rife in Galway football was deemed an impediment to their development, in an era of swarmed defences. The televised humiliation of 2013 against Mayo is recalled as the nadir, though it may have had some benefits in the sense of shaking them out of their torpor. It wasn't until Walsh came in as manager, the arrival of Shane Walsh and Damien Comer from the underage ranks, and the shock win over Mayo in 2016 that Galway re-announced themselves as a player. Meath's situation was considerably more grim. Their struggles were the subject of much lamentation and even pity throughout the 2010s, their morale seemingly destroyed by the awesome and overbearing nature of Dublin's dominance throughout that era. Their football identity largely built on always being able to match the Dubs, they suffered a crisis of confidence when they were no longer able to do so. That situation prevailed right up until 27 April, 2025. Now, they look reborn. Despite their manager's misgivings, no team has benefitted more from the rules revolution than Meath, who boast the athletic profile which suits the new game perfectly. They've now beaten Dublin and Kerry in the one campaign, something they only managed once before - in 2001.
