King's invite to Canada sends a message to Trump
A decade ago, a portrait of the British monarch caused a row in Canadian politics. Now, the King is being invited to deliver the Speech from the Throne. What's changed?
In 2011, shortly after forming a majority Conservative government, Prime Minister Stephen Harper caused a national uproar when he sought to emphasise Canada's ties to the British monarchy. In one example, he replaced two artworks by a Quebec painter with a portrait of the Queen.
Some rebuked the gesture as being out of touch with modern times. Canada has, throughout its 157-year-old history, sought increasing independence from the British monarchy, while still remaining a part of the Commonwealth.
When Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau succeeded Harper four years later, the Queen's portrait went down, the Quebec paintings, back up.
Fast forward to 2025, and a paradoxical shift has occurred in Canada's relationship with the Crown. In a transparent show of Canada's sovereignty and independence against threats from US President Donald Trump, Prime Minister Mark Carney - a Liberal - has invited King Charles the III to open the 45th Canadian parliament.
King Charles uses symbols to show support for Canada
The strategy behind Carney's invite to the King
The move is "a huge affirmation and statement about the uniqueness of Canada and its traditions," Justin Vovk, a Canadian royal historian, told the BBC - "a theatrical display that is meant to show what makes Canadians separate from Americans" and not, as Trump has often repeated, a "51st state".
Both countries are former British colonies, but America's founding fathers took a different path and severed all formal connections to the Crown nearly 250 years ago.
Canada's separation from the monarchy has been more gradual, and its ties have never been completely broken. Canada's parliamentary system is modelled after Britain's Westminster system. The British monarch is still formally the head of state, but their duties are often carried out by their Canadian representative, called the governor general.
Loyalty to the Crown was seen as important to Canada's politicians in the 19th Century who wanted to maintain separation from the US, said Canadian royal historian and commentator Carolyn Harris.
That later changed in the 1960s, as Quebec - Canada's majority French-speaking province - began to assert its own distinct identity and threatened separation. This led to an era of politicians like Lester B Pearson and Pierre Elliott Trudeau who worked to untangle Canada from its British colonial past.
In 1982, Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau repatriated Canada's constitution, giving full legislative power to the federal government and the provinces, and removing it from British parliament.
Ms Harris noted that Canada remained a constitutional monarchy throughout these periods. What fluctuated, however, was how much the prime minister of the day chooses to embrace that connection.
Carney's invite to King Charles III signals that his government will be one that is much more supportive of the Crown, Mr Vovk said, marking "a very different tone" from previous Liberals.
A British monarch has not delivered Canada's throne speech since 1977, and has not opened a brand new session of parliament since 1957, making the King's upcoming visit a truly rare occasion.
It comes at a consequential time for Canada.
Carney heavily campaigned on standing up to Trump, after the US president spent months undermining Canada's sovereignty by saying it would be better off as a US state.
Trump also imposed a series of tariffs that have threatened Canada's economic stability, given that the US is its largest trade partner by far.
When announcing the visit last month, Carney called it "a historic honour that matches the weight of our times".
He added that the King's visit "clearly underscores the sovereignty of our country".
Both historians, Mr Vovk and Ms Harris, noted that the bulk of Canada's modern population is indifferent to the British monarchy. Some are even critical of it.
The coronation of King Charles III in 2023 made way for fresh scrutiny of the Crown's historic mistreatment of indigenous people in Canada, and questions on whether the new monarch will move towards reconciliation.
Quebec politicians are also still calling for Canada to cut ties with the monarchy. On Friday, the separatist Bloc Québécois party said it will again seek to scrap the need for elected officials to swear allegiance to the King.
Some Canadians will be intrigued by the pomp and pageantry of the King's visit, Mr Vovk said, but its chief purpose is to send a political message from Canada to the world.
It is also a way for Prime Minister Carney to improve the relationship with Trump, who is famously a fan of the British monarchy and its history.
"Strengthening the relationship with the monarchy puts a stamp on legitimacy that transcends individual parties and the current political climate," Mr Vovk said. "Politicians come and go, but the monarchy has always remained."
It also works to tie Canada closer to Europe - a key objective of Prime Minister Carney, a former governor of the Bank of England, who has spoken about the need for Canada to find new allies as it navigates its changing relationship with the US.
The visit is notable for the Crown, too.
It will be the King's first to Canada as reigning monarch. He and the Queen had intended to visit last year, but cancelled their plans due to his cancer diagnosis.
The palace has promised a throne speech that will "mark a significant moment between the Head of State and the Canadian people".
And while it will be a short trip - the King and Queen will arrive Monday morning and depart Tuesday evening - the palace said they hope the trip will be "an impactful one".
King meets Carney in symbolic support for Canada
Mark Carney says Canadians are not 'impressed' by UK's invite to Trump
Provocative Trump statements about Canada loom large as Trudeau meets King
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'Until the wheels fall off': Manny Pacquiao and the trouble with growing old in a young man's game
When they say that the last thing to go is a boxer's punch, it gives hope to just about any boxer who can still form a fist. It is therefore not only an adage but cruel, for it suggests that where there is a punch there is always a way. It suggests that punching power will come to a boxer's rescue in their time of need and that it will be there long after their speed, timing, reflexes and resistance have all gone. The problem is, a boxer's ability to punch — hard, soft or otherwise — is often dependent on those very things, and seldom is throwing a punch ever just a case of throwing a punch. To do it right, and generate power, the punch must, A) be thrown correctly, and, B) land. Ideally, when we talk of power being the last thing to go, we should be more honest. We should emphasize that it is star power, not punch power, we are talking about. For it is that, more than anything else, a promoter will aim to exploit when offering an aging boxer a route back, and it is that an aging boxer can usually rely upon, more so than their punch, when in need of either money or attention. Unlike a punch, you see, it always works and never lets them down. It may fade or become tarnished over time, but there is still no longevity like that of a big name. Mike Tyson's, for example, has outlasted even his ability to punch hard. We saw evidence of this last year when Tyson, at the age of 58, attracted 60 million eyeballs to Netflix on the power of his name yet struggled to then throw six power punches during a fight against Jake Paul. You also have Manny Pacquiao's name. His name continues to open doors and secure rankings at the age of 46, with a WBC welterweight title shot against Mario Barrios recently announced for July 19 in Las Vegas. Not only will that be Pacquiao's first fight in four years, but it follows a defeat against Yordenis Ugas and indicates that what is fair and right is immaterial when your name has value. If, like Pacquiao's, it carries significant value, a retired fighter is welcomed back with open arms. They are ranked. They are fast-tracked. They are indulged. They can then delay the drift toward civilian life all retired fighters fear and conclude that the risk of one day forgetting their name is worth the perks of today exploiting it. It is for that reason some fighters need the decision taken out of their hands. They need to be told they cannot box rather than have someone mutter to them that perhaps their time is up. After all, for most boxers, their time is never up. Until the day they die, they will still be able to punch, and that is all that matters. The punch, remember, is the last thing to go. 'Man, it's hard,' said Shane Mosley, a former lightweight, welterweight and super welterweight world champion of retirement. 'If I hadn't hurt my arm, and if I hadn't had surgery and the doctor messed up my arm, I would probably have gone on boxing a lot longer. Since my arm got hurt, I had to retire at 45. I can't be like Bernard [Hopkins, who was still active in his 50s]. That could have been a goal of mine had it not been for the injury.' That Mosley somehow considered retirement at 45 to be premature tells you everything about the mentality of the world champion boxer afraid of irrelevance. For Mosley was no fool, nor was he deluded enough to think he was as good at 45 as he was at 35, much less 25. In fact, he knew, having lost his final fight against David Avanesyan, that he could no longer do most of the things he once took for granted and made look so easy. 'I felt good but I was frustrated the whole damn fight,' Mosley said of his swan song. 'I was almost knocking him out a couple of times but I couldn't knock him out. 'How come I'm hitting him with these shots but I can't knock him out?' I was frustrated. Also, 'How come he's hitting me with these stupid shots and I know he's getting ready to do it, and I know they're coming, but I'm still getting hit? Why?' Those thoughts shouldn't be going through your head when you're fighting. But they were that night. He would turn southpaw and throw a stupid right hook and catch me with it. I knew exactly what he was going to do but couldn't do nothing about it.' Anthony Mundine lands a left on Shane Mosley during the WBA International super welterweight title bout on November 27, 2013 in Sydney, Australia. (Mark Metcalfe via Getty Images) The date of Mosley's realization was May 28, 2016, and the result of the fight was a unanimous decision loss. Five years prior to that, he had boxed Manny Pacquiao and was knocked down in Round 3 and been unable to win a single round or seemingly pull the trigger. It led to one of four defeats Mosley suffered in a three-year period, which included a draw against Sergio Mora and a stoppage loss against Anthony Mundine, two men well below the normal level at which Mosley flourished. Yet still, despite the signs, Mosley carried on. He kept punching, he kept hurting, and he kept taking the opportunities promoters were willing to give him in exchange for his name and his brain. 'I couldn't believe it was going to go the way it did, or for as long as it did, but I have always been obsessed with boxing,' Mosley said. 'I started doing it at 8 and eventually I was like, 'You know what? I'm going to box until the wheels fall off and I can't do it no more.' I just loved boxing. I was in love with it.' Like any toxic relationship, what starts as infatuation can later sour, and the very thing you once loved can in the end be the same thing that destroys you. This is true of the relationship most boxers have with boxing, a sport designed to cause damage, and no amount of distance or clarity prevents them being drawn back together when the time comes. Even though they accept that most reunions will end in tears, the outcome itself is never the point. All a tempted fighter needs to know is whether it can be done or not. They have no interest in whether it can be done well, or indeed whether it should be done. They just want to know if it is possible. That's why even injuries — bad ones — are no longer a deterrent in the eyes of some retired fighters. They can be healed with time, like any trauma, and after a while a retired fighter will either compartmentalize or simply forget the pain of old. 'How come I'm hitting him with these shots but I can't knock him out?' Also, 'How come he's hitting me with these stupid shots and I know he's getting ready to do it, and I know they're coming, but I'm still getting hit? Why?' Shane Mosley Take Sergio Martinez, for instance. He was forced to retire in 2014 due to a series of knee surgeries and was before that seen wearing a knee brace and struggling to stand, let alone move, as Miguel Cotto put him out of his misery in Round 10 of a WBC middleweight title fight. If ever a fighter looked done, it was Martinez that night. Patched up and stitched together, his body had already bailed on him and all he required from Cotto was some help out the door. By the time he then got it, there was not only a look of resignation on the Argentine's face, but on Cotto's a look of sadness, for he knew the fight had ceased to be a fight and was now closer to an intervention. Martinez, that night, was 39 years of age; a good age to call it quits, irrespective of all the injuries. However, because he started boxing late, at 20, the two-weight world champion refused to see age as an accurate gauge. Nor did he see injuries, no matter their severity, as the thing that would ultimately stop him doing what he loved to do. And so, at the age of 45, Martinez inevitably returned to the ring. Tentative at first, he elected to have four routine fights in Spain, the last of which involved England's Macaulay McGowan, a boxer who had lost his two previous fights. 'He's actually my mum's age,' McGowan, 19 years Martinez's junior, said at the time. 'I'm in two minds about it. When I see old fighters come back, I sometimes think, 'Screw them, what the hell are they doing? It's a joke.' Then other times I think, 'Fair play to them. Why the hell not?' 'I used to have a little crappy dongle [USB stick] stuffed into the side of my computer and all weekend I'd be watching different boxers. One day it would [Marco Antonio] Barrera and the next it would be [Erik] Morales or [Arturo] Gatti. Martinez was also one of my favorites to watch, and after watching him, I'd go to the gym on the Monday as a southpaw with my hands down, jumping around, throwing big one-twos.' Former two-weight world champion Sergio Martinez competed well into his 40s. (NurPhoto via Getty Images) Whether it's fans or opponents, there remains a market and a captive audience for the retired, big-name fighter, and therefore an incentive for them to return. 'He's not the man he was by any stretch, Martinez, but I want that Martinez win on my record,' said McGowan, knowing the power of names. 'All these great British fighters have lost to Martinez over the years, but soon you'll see on Boxrec: Macaulay McGowan beat Sergio Martinez.' The fact that this result cannot be found on has less to do with Sergio Martinez's form as a man in his mid-40s and more to do with his ability to pick the right fights and opponents to mitigate the things he was unable to do as a man in his mid-40s. Indeed, after comfortably beating McGowan in 2022, Martinez continued to box at the same sort of level, winning twice more, and few took exception to him operating this way, with the danger effectively minimized. Often it's about knowing your place and your limitations. Just as a 45-year-old man will, or should, feel less inclined to prowl nightclubs on a Saturday night, so too should a 45-year-old pro boxer know better than to think he can still mix it with young world champions on a Saturday night. In other words, grow old gracefully, or at least safely, and nobody appears to have a problem. Why else, for example, would someone like Oliver McCall still be allowed to box in 2025? He is, after all, now 60 years of age, yet he fights for the 78th time on June 3, this Tuesday, in Nashville. His first pro fight was all the way back in 1985 and his recent ones, all of which have taken place in Nashville, have been of a similar ilk: Soft touches to protect McCall. In a sense, the career of McCall has started to mirror the aging process. He is as vulnerable at the end as he was at the beginning and is now being treated with due care. He is going out the way he came in. Przemyslaw Saleta lands a punch against Oliver McCall on August 13, 2005 in Chicago, Illinois. Twenty years later, McCall is still fighting. (Jonathan Daniel via Getty Images) At the age of 47, Italy's Emiliano Marsili was still winning fights, still competing for European titles, and still, rather miraculously, unbeaten as a pro. His record, at 47, was 42-0-1, and he had managed to avoid defeat for a total of 20 years. He had done so not because he was the world's best lightweight, but instead because he was the smartest. He knew when to fight, who to fight, and how to fight as a man in his 40s. That he never boxed for a world title was a regret of Marsili's, yet it could also be argued that it contributed to him staying unbeaten for so long. 'I turned professional quite late at 27, and at the time my goal was to become Italian champion and nothing more,' he explained. 'The difference between me and other boxers is that I spent a long time training and sparring on the same team as Sandro Casamonica, Gianluca Branco and Stefano Zoff when they were fighting for either European titles or world titles. I would do lots of sparring with them and learn a lot. 'I also live very well. If you don't, you will not be fighting for the European title at 47. Most days I go to bed at nine o'clock and then wake up early. Thanks to my family, I have been able to keep straight and lead this kind of life.' Marsili's first and only loss came against Gavin Gwynne, a fighter from Wales, in December 2023. The enduring image from that night is one of Marsili sitting on his stool between rounds eight and nine, unable to continue on account of a shoulder injury. He was, through eight rounds, winning the fight on two of the three scorecards, yet was eventually defeated by his own body. Not his brain. Not his technique. Just his body. 'Mentally I am better now [at 47],' Marsili said. 'I am more experienced and calmer; I take time to make decisions and I am clever. But physically you lose the resistance you had before when you were young.' Emiliano Marsili, 47, reacts to defeat after suffering an injury against Gavin Gwynne on December 01, 2023 in London, England. (James Chance via Getty Images) The same year that Emiliano Marsili's body quit on him, Scotland's Willie Limond experienced something similar when he was pulled out after eight rounds in the company of former three-weight world champion Ricky Burns. It was the second fight of Limond's comeback and only then, at 45, did he acknowledge that there was a limit to what his body could do and achieve. In his first fight back, a scheduled six-rounder against CJ Wood, there were no such revelations. In fact, when stopping Wood inside three rounds, Limond felt like a man reborn. He had by that point forgotten the pain of training for the fight. 'I was out running the other day and was three miles into a seven-mile run when I thought to myself, 'What the f**k am I doing this for?'' he said back then. 'I called my manager and said, 'I think I'm going to have to call this off.' It was just one of those days.' He had even forgotten the reason for doing the fight in the first place. He had forgotten how, rather than trigger a comeback, that six-rounder against Wood in 2023 was supposed to just offer Willie the chance to box on the same bill as his son, Jake. He had forgotten the initial promise: One more and that's it. 'It's more than likely this will be the last one,' Limond said beforehand. 'I last fought three years ago and haven't done a lot of training since. 'If something good gets offered to me after this fight, that could change my mind. But, right now, this is my last fight.' Then he won that 'last fight' and was reminded how it felt to win. After three years without it, now it was back. Now he understood the difference between watching his boys win fights — one as a pro, the other as an amateur — and experiencing the same feeling for himself. Now he understood the real reason why he had wanted to return. 'I'll struggle,' he said of retirement, 'because I've always been about it. I've got a job with Boxing Scotland [the national organization for boxing in Scotland] and train four pros, including my boy, but participating and watching are two different things. Willie Limond (R) and son Jake Limond (L) during a press conference ahead of the Willie Limond vs. Joe Laws fight at the Emirates Arena, on February 1, 2024, in Glasgow, Scotland. (Ross MacDonald - SNS Group via Getty Images) 'I know when it's over I'll be sad. But I also know how old I am and know it doesn't get any better. Anything I haven't achieved in boxing is not going to be achieved now in my 40s. I have to be realistic about that.' Yet it was never a specific achievement Limond still chased in his 40s. It was something else; something he couldn't find or feel elsewhere. He got it against Wood, he got it against Burns, and he was in pursuit of it again in a third comeback fight against Joe Laws — scheduled for May 3, 2024 — when he suffered a seizure in his car driving home from the gym on April 6. He was found unresponsive inside his vehicle that Saturday morning and was immediately taken to Monklands Hospital in Airdrie, Scotland, where he died nine days later. He was just 45 years of age. 'I know a lot of people have said it's because of brain damage from the boxing, but it hasn't got anything to do with it,' said Jake Limond, Willie's son. 'If I was looking at a 45-year-old guy who had 50 fights, and a lot of them had been wars, I would probably think it was the boxing, too. But that's why we were all shocked. It wasn't the boxing that done this. It was literally just a pure random occurrence. If he stopped boxing 10 years ago, or if he had never taken the Joe Laws fight [in May], it wouldn't have mattered. The same thing would have happened.' In Scotland the Limond name lives on, proof once more that a boxer's name is the last thing to go. It lives on in this instance through Jake and Drew, Jake's brother, who turned pro just four months after their father tragically passed away. For two years both Limond boys had watched their father try to claw back time as an old man in a young man's game and saw him defy the odds and perform, in training, like a much younger man. They were also with him on the day that he died, one of them 20, the other 18. It was then that Willie Limond, their hero, was again considered young — too young to die — and they, his boys, suddenly felt old.
CNN
38 minutes ago
- CNN
Key Trump adviser pushes back on Musk's criticism of ‘big, beautiful' bill
CNN's Dana Bash sits down with White House Budget Director Russ Vought to break down President Trump's tax and spending cut bill, as well as his broader push to slash spending and upend the federal government.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Idaho woman's death was a suspected suicide. Then police noticed her toenails
In our Reality Check stories, Idaho Statesman journalists seek to hold the powerful accountable and find answers to critical questions in our community. Read more. Story idea? Tips@ Reyna Quintero was getting dressed for a girls' night out that she had planned for days. Earlier in the day, the 34-year-old had called her sister several times to talk about what they'd wear and had just gotten off the phone with her teenage daughter, her family testified in court. Quintero had asked to use her eyelash curler. By all accounts from her family, she was excited to go out and celebrate. So when her daughter came home and found her choking on her own blood, with a gun resting in her mother's hand, she told police she knew it wasn't suicide, according to a probable cause affidavit. The daughter had been out grabbing McDonald's with her grandfather when she received a distressed call from her father, who had sent them out for the food, at their house about an 'accident.' Quintero's body was lying in her daughter's room underneath the vanity. The Caldwell Police Department was called to the subdivision off of South Florida Avenue in Caldwell and found Quintero with a gunshot wound to the left side of her head. But detectives weren't convinced it was a suicide. Months after the shooting, the Canyon County Coroner's Office wasn't able to rule the shooting a suicide, leaving the manner of death undetermined, according to the probable cause affidavit. Michelle-Rene Kilgore Marmolejo, a criminologist from the Canyon County Sheriff's Office, testified in court that it's 'rare' for someone to kill themselves with their non-dominant hand, according to court records. Though the gun was found in Quintero's right hand, the bullet wound entered on the left side of her head. Dozens of court filings obtained by the Idaho Statesman showed how a nearly yearlong investigation by law enforcement focused in on Quintero's husband, Gerardo Francisco Torres-Rodriguez, whom she had been planning to divorce him after he had an affair with a 17-year-old in Mexico, according to interviews with family and phone records. Caldwell Detective Oscar Martinez reviewed the crime scene and autopsy photos again and again, until an open bottle of nail polish on the vanity table made him look at Quintero's toenails, according to the affidavit. Her toes were only partially painted. It was that detail, the unscrewed bottle of nail polish on her daughter's vanity table, that prompted Martinez to believe Quintero was in the middle of painting her toenails when she was shot — and that the crime scene had been altered before law enforcement arrived. Caldwell police publicized Quintero's death for the first time this week, because of the sensitive nature of the investigation, spokesperson Char Jackson told the Statesman. Police were concerned that the investigation could have been compromised by releasing case information, she said. Law enforcement agencies typically release information to the public when a homicide occurs or when someone is charged with a severe crime, such as first-degree murder. Torres-Rodriguez was arrested and charged with the first-degree murder of his wife in June 2024, 10 months after the homicide. Third Judicial District Magistrate Judge Gregory Frates allowed Torres-Rodriguez's case to move forward to trial after the prosecution presented half a dozen witnesses, including law enforcement, during a preliminary hearing at the Canyon County Courthouse last year. Frates concluded, based on the evidence, that there was probable cause that Torres-Rodriguez killed his wife. He said like many homicides, the evidence was 'circumstantial,' but Torres-Rodriguez was the only one at the house, the blood splatter was 'certainly conspicuous,' and the scene was altered. The location of Quintero's body, along with the trajectory of the bullet, also made it clear she was kneeling over when she was killed, he said. 'It was effectively an execution,' Fates added. Torres-Rodriguez faced more than a weeklong trial where witnesses testified about his 'odd demeanor' after the killing. Canyon County Deputy Prosecutor Stephanie Morse urged the 12-person jury to find the 41-year-old guilty, the Canyon County Prosecuting Attorney's Office said in a news release. 'He earned the verdict you are about to deliver when he decided Reyna's life was expendable,' she told the jurors. 'He earned it when he jammed the gun into her head. He earned it with his utter disregard for life.' Jurors agreed that Torres-Rodriguez staged his wife's murder as a suicide after shooting her in the head, and convicted him of first-degree murder, the Prosecuting Attorney's Office said in a news release. Witnesses in their testimony said Torres-Rodriguez manipulated his daughter into finding her mother's body and noted his nonchalant demeanor on a surveillance video camera outside the house, which showed him smoking a cigarette as he waited for his daughter to arrive. The girl's aunt also testified about the way her niece and nephew had been manipulated by their father. 'She is very fearful for herself, for her brother's safety,' Quintero's sister, Dulce Madera-Madriz, said in court last year. Torres-Rodriguez sentencing is scheduled for 9 a.m. Aug. 8, court records showed. Under state law, he could face up to a life sentence, but he will have to spend at least 10 years in prison. Quintero's daughter was likely one of the last people to speak to her mother. The prosecution asked her daughter in court if she remembered what her mother said to her before hanging up the phone after calling to ask to borrow her eyelash curler. 'That she loved me,' her daughter said.
