Chandigarh: Dealer fined ₹25k for not steering exchanged car's transfer
For failing to transfer the ownership of a city resident's old car, exchanged for a new one, which led to a speeding challan landing at his address, a car dealership will be coughing up ₹25,000 as compensation.
Terming them guilty of deficiency in service, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-DF 1 has directed the dealership, Lally Motors, to pay the complainant ₹15,000 for mental agony and ₹10,000 as costs of litigation.
Further, the dealership has also been told to clear the pending challan and transfer the exchanged car's ownership to either themselves or the new owner to whom they have sold the vehicle.
In 2019, the complainant, Dr Swaran Singh, a resident of Sector 18, had walked into Lally Motors in Industrial Area to purchase a Volkswagen Vento car.
Under a scheme, he agreed to exchange his old vehicle, valued around ₹2 lakh, which was adjusted against the price of the new vehicle.
After the deal, the dealership had issued a delivery letter-cum-undertaking, dated October 23, 2019, promising that they will be responsible for all future taxes, challans and accidents related to the old car.
But three years later, Dr Singh received a challan from the Chandigarh Traffic Police in December 2022, much to his surprise.
The photograph attached to the challan showed his old car, which had supposedly been sold to someone else by the dealership. On inspecting further, to his shock, Dr Singh learned that the dealership had failed to transfer the car's ownership to its new owner after the exchange.
Approaching the consumer commission, the complainant alleged that the car dealership sold his old car further without transferring its ownership, a violation of the Motor Vehicles Act.
The dealership was summoned by the commission but they didn't turn up and were proceeded against ex parte on October 21 2024.
Skoda Auto Volkswagen India contested the complaint, taking preliminary objections of maintainability, cause of action, jurisdiction and non-joinder of the necessary party. They alleged that so far as selling of the car went, they had nothing to do with it, and it was a matter between the dealership and the complainant.
The commission accepted that the company had no role in the dispute and dismissed the complaint against them.
However, it observed that the complainant had submitted documentary proof against the dealership, which was not rebutted in any way. Disposing of the complaint, the commission slapped a ₹25,000 penalty on the dealership, including the compensation and litigation costs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
Over ₹17k challans pending against Hyd police vehicles
At a time when citizens are turning traffic vigilantes, law keepers are found breaching regulations. As per a RTI filed by city-based traffic educator Lokendra Singh, a fleet of vehicles registered under the Director General of Police Telangana have accumulated 17,391 challans - some pending since 2017. Though the total challan amount stands at around Rs 68 lakh, the department might have to cough up a penalty of Rs 1.36 crore. This, as Section 210B of the MV Act, 2019, states that if an authority empowered to enforce the Motor Vehicles Act commits an offence, they are liable to a penalty twice the amount corresponding to that offence. These challans, issued to police vehicles with registration series TS 09 PA XXXX and TS 09 PC XXXX, are in use by senior police officials. Most of the violations are related to over-speeding. When TOI checked for details on the portal, it found that a majority of these police vehicles (Innova) had 10 to 15 challans each. City police issued more than 50 lakh challans in '24, collected over 46L Surprisingly, some vehicles had unpaid challans pending since 2018. For instance, one police vehicle TS 09 PA XX88 had 11 challans starting from Oct 2018 to April 2023. The total outstanding amount: 11,385 'Fines auto generated' "The majority of traffic fines against police vehicles are automatically generated by speed detection cameras that monitor vehicles exceeding speed limits. We will forward these fines to the respective officers and ask them to provide evidence justifying their speed violations," said Rahul Hegde BK, deputy commissioner of police (traffic), Hyderabad commissionerate and public information officer, traffic branch. He added: "The fines will be withdrawn if we find that the vehicles were responding to emergency situations, conducting patrol duties, or were involved in VIP escorts." Lokendra Singh, a volunteer with Hyderabad City Security Council said such traffic violations set a bad example for the public. "When they see police personnel flouting regulations, it diminishes their trust in the system and leads them to question the necessity of following rules. I have also noticed that many police vehicle drivers often do not use seat belts while driving," said Singh. Over 50 lakh challans Hyderabad city police issued as many as 56.3 lakh challans in 2024, with most violations involving riding without helmets and driving on the wrong side. The authorities collected 46.6 lakh against these challans - 82% of the total amount.
Time of India
17 hours ago
- Time of India
Of 102 hit-&-run compensation claims filed in Gurgaon, only 2 settled in 3 years
Gurgaon: In three years, 102 claims have been filed by families or victims of hit-and-run accidents, of which compensation has been disbursed for only two of them. Two cases are in the final stages of processing, and the remaining – 98 – are still being investigated by police. This slow pace of resolution has left families of accident victims in the lurch, with some waiting for years after they applied for aid under the 2022 Hit-and-Run Motor Accident Compensation scheme. The scheme, which falls under Section 161 of the Motor Vehicles Act , came into effect from April 1, 2022. It offers Rs 2 lakh as compensation in cases of fatalities, and Rs 50,000 for serious injuries. The scheme is only applicable for hit-and-run accidents, in which police have not been able to identify the errant driver or vehicle. Sunita, a city resident whose husband died in a hit-and-run accident on the Delhi-Gurgaon Expressway this year, told TOI she has been waiting for compensation for months. Her husband was the only earning member of the family. "My husband was returning home after work on a cycle when he was hit by an unknown vehicle. After his death, I started working as domestic help to support my family," she said, adding that compensation will help her pay for her kids' education. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với mức chênh lệch giá thấp nhất IC Markets Đăng ký Undo The issue of delayed resolutions also came up at a district road safety committee meeting, chaired by Gurgaon deputy commissioner Ajay Kumar, earlier this week. "The regional transport authority (RTA) secretary has been directed to expedite the data collection process, ensuring that claims are processed swiftly and efficiently. The goal is to provide timely financial assistance to victims, alleviating some of the burdens they face in the wake of these tragic incidents," the DC had said, directing all involved agencies to expedite the process. According to the norms, a hit-and-run accident victim or a victim's family can apply for compensation under the scheme before the sub-divisional magistrate. They have to submit a death certificate, post-mortem report, or hospital treatment documents as proof. But the scheme does not specify any timeline for completion of police inquiry, which delays a decision on the claim. Accidents aren't uncommon on city roads, particularly the Delhi-Gurgaon Expressway, or NH-8. Last year, Gurgaon recorded 1,026 road accidents that led to 428 fatalities. Around 44% of the accidents were on national highways in the city, and the largest chunk of fatalities involved two-wheelers, traffic police data showed. In accident cases in which the errant driver/vehicle has been identified, victims and their families can approach the Motor Accident Claim Tribunal (MACT) and file a case to seek compensation. The tribunal, after hearing both sides, determines the amount of compensation that may be paid to accident victims or their families. In many cases, the company that insured the errant driver's vehicle is asked to provide compensation.
Time of India
18 hours ago
- Time of India
8 held for Semaglutide theft from Dr Reddy's lab; 2 cr drug seized
Srikakulam: The JR Puram police in Srikakulam district have arrested a gang of eight individuals, including four employees of Dr Reddy's Laboratories, in connection with the theft of about 460 grams of Semaglutide (GLP-1), a patented anti-diabetic drug worth over ₹2 crore. The drug was stolen from the company's warehouse at Pydibheemavaram for sale in the black market. Those arrested include Dr Reddy's chemists Dronadulu Suresh (31), N Appala Naidu (28), and Gollapalli Kantarao (35); warehouse staffer G V Raghavendra (33); and four others with pharma backgrounds in Hyderabad: G Suresh Reddy (40), A Tirupati (32), K Balakrishna (33), and B Naveen Kumar (33). The police said Semaglutide is an anti-diabetic medication used for the treatment of type 2 diabetes and an anti-obesity medication used for long-term weight management. It is a peptide similar to the hormone glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1), modified with a side can be administered by subcutaneous injection or taken orally. Basically it was the patent product of Dr Reddy's Laboratories and the product was meant for export to foreign countries. Srikakulam district police chief KV Maheswara Reddy said the GLP-1 drug was produced at Dr Reddy's Lab production unit and subsequently stored in the freezer room of the FG warehouse on February 17, 2025. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Perdagangkan CFD Emas dengan Broker Tepercaya IC Markets Mendaftar Undo Staff members later discovered that the medicine had been stolen from the freezer room on February 23, 2025. The drug can be sold by only patent persons. However, the drug has high value in the black market. Based on the complaint, the police formed three teams to solve the offences. The JR Puram police inspector M Avatharam along with his team sub-inspector S Chiranjeevi and G Laxman Rao investigated the case in multiple angles to identify the culprits. The investigation revealed that Raghavendra stole the drug from the warehouse. Later, he gave it to Appal Naidu, Suresh and Kantarao for sale of the drug in the black market. The trio gave the stolen drug to Tirupati and later it was handed over to Suresh Reddy in Hyderabad for sale. Suresh Reddy had previously worked with a pharma company and he has links with some persons involved in selling of drugs in the black market. However, he also failed to trade the stolen chemical that led to disputes among the gang. When Raghavendra asked Suresh Reddy to return the drug, he cheated them by giving fake Semaglutide powder. The police nabbed all the eight persons in connection with the case and recovered around 440 gram of stolen Semaglutide powder and 460 gms of fake Semaglutide powder from them. Police said during the audit, staff observed that 3.38 kg of Palladium Acetate, valued at over 60 lakh and stored at the warehouse within the production unit of Dr Reddy's Lab, had been stolen in May this year. Palladium acetate, or palladium(II) acetate, is a chemical is a red-brown solid and is widely used as a catalyst in various organic reactions, particularly cross coupling reactions like Suzuki and Heck reactions. The police said the same gang was involved in the case and the investigation is on to recover the stolen chemical from them.
