AUKUS is a disaster for Australia. Trump has given us an out – let's take it
The Australian national security establishment's worst nightmare has arrived. The Trump administration is putting AUKUS to a review. A review many fear will put the $368 billion submarine deal to the sword.
Led by Elbridge Colby, defence undersecretary and noted AUKUS sceptic, the Pentagon's review will assess whether the deal meets the president's 'America First' agenda.
It was always very unlikely that any presidential administration would be willing to hand over some of the crown jewels of the US Navy's fleet to Australia, which is what the first part of the deal involved – the United States giving Australia control of some Virginia class nuclear-powered submarines. We don't know much about the details of the deal, but we do know that the US always had a get out clause there. It's up to the president to decide whether to hand them over, and really, why would they?
Now, it's possible the Trump administration will tank the whole thing. And we can safely assume that won't mean handing back the $800 million Australia has already invested, no strings attached, in the US shipbuilding industry in the vain hope that would accelerate production rates.
AUKUS was always a disastrous deal for Australia. We were never likely to get any submarines, and all the deal does is tie us ever closer to an increasingly volatile and aggressive America. AUKUS would not have made Australia safer. It would have made us more vulnerable and compromised our ability to make independent decisions about our own security.
Trump has given us an opportunity to get out. We should take it.
Australians already knew that Trump is not to be trusted. Polling by The Australia Institute done back in March found that more Australians considered the US president a bigger threat to global peace than the leaders of the world's two most powerful authoritarian states in Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping.
Almost half (49 per cent) said they felt less secure since the election of Trump.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
28 minutes ago
- ABC News
Breakfast Wrap: What next for AUKUS?
The questions about Australia's deal to buy nuclear powered submarines aren't going away. We learnt this week the US Defence Department is reviewing the agreement. And while the Australian government is playing it cool and insisting there's nothing usual about that, not everyone is so sure. We'll bring you the latest reaction here from shadow Defence Minister Angus Taylor and get the view out of the other AUKUS partner, the UK. Also today bring you a panel of journalists to wrap the huge political week that was. And a flight travelling from India to the UK has crashed on take-off. We'll get an early view from one aerospace expert about what happened. Recap the morning's news, politics and global affairs with the Breakfast Wrap
West Australian
29 minutes ago
- West Australian
Israel, Iran, Middle East travel warning: Smartraveller tells Australians to ‘shelter' as war erupts
Smartraveller has issued an urgent warning to Australians in the Middle East, telling them to shelter as military strikes hit Iran and Israel declares a state of emergency over possible retaliation. 'Following military strikes in Iran, Australians in Iran should shelter in place and take the advice of local authorities in affected areas. See our general advice on protecting your safety during an armed conflict,' Smartraveller said in a statement online. 'Airlines may cancel or reduce their operations to and from Iran at short notice and your options to leave may be limited. Check the latest flight status with your airline or travel provider. The Australian Government may not be able to assist with your departure.' Iran has a 'do not travel' level warning according to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade website. Australians in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories have been warned about the 'increased threat of military and terrorist attacks'. 'Following military strikes in Iran, there's an increased threat of military and terrorist attacks against Israel. In an attack or other armed conflict, you should take shelter (and) follow the advice of local authorities,' a statement from Smartraveller said. 'Monitor local media and public safety information updates through the National Emergency Portal (accessible in Israel only).' Smartraveller said the security situation in the Middle East could continue to deteriorate without notice. 'There may also be airspace closures, flight and other travel disruptions.' As the first Israeli strike on Tehran hit, the FlightRadar24 website tracked several commercial passenger planes turning around just outside Tel Aviv. Over Iran, flights quickly scattered — some even becoming untrackable — before later reappearing on the map in another location. The airspace over Iraq has also emptied. In Tel Aviv, flight boards have filled with 'cancelled' messages for both arrivals and departures. The usually bustling city is now under a state of emergency, coming at a time when tens of thousands of travellers are headed to the city to celebrate Tel Aviv Pride as part of Pride month. Smartraveller is warning Australians to stay away of possible additional attacks and armed conflict. If armed conflict breaks out, the travel safety group urges Australians to: They encourage Australians to stay in contact with friends or family where possible, follow instructions and to make plans to leave. The Australian Government warns it will not make the decision to leave or stay for Aussies caught up in war. 'If you want to leave, go early. Don't wait for help from the Government or evacuation flights. Conflict may escalate to a point where it's no longer safe to leave,' Smartraveller says. Australians should also contact their airline or travel agent. 'Airlines often cancel flights to locations affected by armed conflict, especially if it threatens the airport. Local authorities may shut the airport down or declare a no-fly zone. Opposing forces may take over the airport,' Smartraveller warns. When flights become sparse, costs for tickets can become astronomical. To contact the Australian Government in an emergency:
Perth Now
30 minutes ago
- Perth Now
‘Shelter': Urgent warning for Aussies in Middle East
Smartraveller has issued an urgent warning to Australians in the Middle East, telling them to shelter as military strikes hit Iran and Israel declares a state of emergency over possible retaliation. 'Following military strikes in Iran, Australians in Iran should shelter in place and take the advice of local authorities in affected areas. See our general advice on protecting your safety during an armed conflict,' Smartraveller said in a statement online. 'Airlines may cancel or reduce their operations to and from Iran at short notice and your options to leave may be limited. Check the latest flight status with your airline or travel provider. The Australian Government may not be able to assist with your departure.' Iran has a 'do not travel' level warning according to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade website. Australians in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories have been warned about the 'increased threat of military and terrorist attacks'. 'Following military strikes in Iran, there's an increased threat of military and terrorist attacks against Israel. In an attack or other armed conflict, you should take shelter (and) follow the advice of local authorities,' a statement from Smartraveller said. 'Monitor local media and public safety information updates through the National Emergency Portal (accessible in Israel only).' Smartraveller said the security situation in the Middle East could continue to deteriorate without notice. 'There may also be airspace closures, flight and other travel disruptions.' As the first Israeli strike on Tehran hit, the FlightRadar24 website tracked several commercial passenger planes turning around just outside Tel Aviv. Over Iran, flights quickly scattered — some even becoming untrackable — before later reappearing on the map in another location. The airspace over Iraq has also emptied. A screengrab from Flightradar24 shows airlines takling a wide berth around Iran. Credit: Supplied In Tel Aviv, flight boards have filled with 'cancelled' messages for both arrivals and departures. The usually bustling city is now under a state of emergency, coming at a time when tens of thousands of travellers are headed to the city to celebrate Tel Aviv Pride as part of Pride month. Smartraveller is warning Australians to stay away of possible additional attacks and armed conflict. If armed conflict breaks out, the travel safety group urges Australians to: Stay in safe places Limit movement Be alert, especially in large crowds Keep a low profile Keep hard copy lists of emergency contacts with you They encourage Australians to stay in contact with friends or family where possible, follow instructions and to make plans to leave. The Australian Government warns it will not make the decision to leave or stay for Aussies caught up in war. 'If you want to leave, go early. Don't wait for help from the Government or evacuation flights. Conflict may escalate to a point where it's no longer safe to leave,' Smartraveller says. Australians should also contact their airline or travel agent. 'Airlines often cancel flights to locations affected by armed conflict, especially if it threatens the airport. Local authorities may shut the airport down or declare a no-fly zone. Opposing forces may take over the airport,' Smartraveller warns. When flights become sparse, costs for tickets can become astronomical. To contact the Australian Government in an emergency: Call the nearest Australian embassy, high commission or consulate Call the 24-hour Consular Emergency Centre on +61 2 6261 3305'
