Smart motorways have higher rate of recorded breakdowns
National Highways statistics show 56% of breakdowns logged on England's motorways last year happened on smart motorways.
That is despite the roads only making up 20% of the total motorway network.
The 141,149 smart motorway breakdown incidents recorded in 2024 was an average of 387 per day.
The AA described the statistics, released in response to a Freedom of Information request, as 'a major concern'.
National Highways said the technology installed on smart motorways means breakdowns on those roads are more likely to be detected.
Smart motorways are designed to increase capacity at a lower cost than widening roads.
That can be done by converting the hard shoulder into a live running lane.
There have been long-standing safety concerns after fatal incidents in which vehicles stopped in live lanes were hit from behind.
Then-prime minister Rishi Sunak cancelled all future planned smart motorway projects in April 2023, citing financial pressures and a lack of public confidence in the roads.
Future investment in smart motorways was cancelled by former PM Rishi Sunak (Jonathan Brady/PA)
Some smart motorway stretches are controlled schemes, which use variable speed limits but retain a hard shoulder.
AA president Edmund King told the PA news agency: 'For many drivers, fear of a collision on a smart motorway would be reinforced by witnessing a breakdown in a live lane, or frequently seeing vehicles in refuge areas.
'These new figures suggest that the chance of that happening is increasing – approaching 400 a day along 396 miles of smart motorway, even when including controlled stretches.
'Equivalent to one a mile each day, that inspires more motorists to stay out of lane one, thus increasing the chance of congestion.'
For the first time, figures published by National Highways show 251,448 breakdowns on England's motorways were logged last year.
That is a rise of 3% from the previous year and 47% compared with 2014.
Parts of the M4 are a smart motorway system (Steve Parsons/PA)
The AA said free breakdown recovery in roadwork areas and monitoring of smart motorways have increased the number of incidents recorded by National Highways.
It believe the length of the motorway network can be ruled out as a major factor as it has only increased by 65 miles in the past decade.
Mr King said: 'It is a major concern that we are witnessing more than a quarter of a million breakdowns a year on the motorway network – and those are just the officially recorded ones.
'The situation does not appear to be getting any better.'
He added that drivers can reduce the likelihood of breaking down by taking measures such as having their vehicle regularly serviced, checking tyre conditions and pressure, and ensuring they have adequate fuel or charge.
A National Highways spokesperson said: 'Our latest analysis continues to show that overall, smart motorways remain our safest roads.
'We have upgraded the technology to detect stopped vehicles, improved response times to live lane breakdowns and installed more than 150 additional emergency areas giving people a place to pull over if they break down.
'Unlike other roads, smart motorways have technology in place to identify stopped vehicles, including breakdowns.
'This means more breakdowns are identified on smart motorways compared to other road types, and as a result these stats are not a reliable indicator of actual safety.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
20 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Drivers warned to ‘plan ahead' as major UK tunnel under £25million refurbishment to spark holiday hotspot delays
TUNNEL VISION Drivers warned to 'plan ahead' as major UK tunnel under £25million refurbishment to spark holiday hotspot delays Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A CRUCIAL tunnel used by 38,000 drivers a day is set to undergo further disruption, with drivers urged to "plan ahead" to avoid delays. The road, used by many as a route to summer holiday destinations in Cornwall, has had fixed lanes implemented as new technology is installed as part of a year-long refurbishment. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 The Saltash Tunnel in Cornwall will see further disruption as part of works that began in late 2024 Credit: Alamy The Saltash tunnel in Cornwall has had its usual tidal traffic system switched off and replaced with fixed lanes, in a change expected to impact journey times for travellers. The works comes as part of a £25 million refurbishment which began in late November 2024 and is set to continue until late 2025. Drivers have been warned to plan their route and allow extra time for their journeys, especially when going eastbound into Devon. Tunnel manager Julian Mitchell said the new traffic management system is in place for "safety reasons". He said: "We appreciate the tidal flow switch-off will have an impact on people's journey times, although our current monitoring, including the May bank holidays, suggests only slight delays. "In the meantime, we advise people to plan ahead and allow extra time for their journeys, especially those from Cornwall into Devon." National Highways said that the work was being done to address repeated technology faults with the traffic control system. The overhaul of this system was due to begin later in the summer, however, these faults have meant that the processes has been started early. These new fixed lanes are set to be in place for the duration of the tunnel's refurbishment. Moment fuming motorist loses the plot in GTA road rage smash National Highways said: "The tunnel has functioning safety systems and CCTV in place, and daytime traffic is now using two lanes westbound through the tunnel and on the Tamar Bridge and one eastbound lane through the tunnel and over the bridge with the cantilever link for local traffic and Tamar Tag holders." "As an additional safety measure, traffic signals have been installed at Tamar Bridge, the eastbound approach to the tunnel and the tunnel entrances. "These lights are not in day-to-day use but will enable National Highways to close lanes in the event of a breakdown or incident." It said during the overnight tunnel closures, traffic would continue to follow the standard B3271 and North Road diversion routes.
Top Gear
21 hours ago
- Top Gear
Rapid response: can the Maserati MC20 make a good roadside recovery car?
Ever had a long wait for a recovery van? Top Gear to the rescue... with a slightly reduced toolkit Of course it's a Disco. It's always a Disco. First call out of the day and I'm first on the scene. That was the plan of course, and it's worked a treat. Now, what had Dominic told me it was likely to be? Ah, that's right, it's a Land Rover, therefore... almost anything: blown turbo, glitchy electrics, belts, water pump, front diff, front wheel hubs, air suspension, cracked engine block... I open up the MC20's toolkit. It contains a towing eye. Nothing else. Hmm. Hang about, Dominic shoved a chunky battery starter pack in the Maserati's footwell earlier, seeing as battery issues account for about 20 per cent of callouts. I connect it up. Much clicking, no life. And that's me done, out of ideas. All I'm good for right now is tea and sympathy. My shoulders sink as I realise I left my flask at the hotel this morning. I smile wanly at the beleaguered Disco driver, 'At least the sun's out...' We've all heard the horror stories, people waiting for hours for the recovery services to turn up, stranded on the hard shoulder of the M40 for two hours (that'll be me), broken down in roadworks on the M4 after a piston went through the block (also me). How to solve this? Get to people faster, duh. Where some would suggest more patrol vans, Top Gear suggests speed. We've built the AA a rapid response vehicle. Photography: Olgun Kordal Well, I say built, but what we've actually done is livery up Maserati's 620bhp mid-engined supercar, sucker some lights on top and headed off to help one of the UK's most remote patrols cover his Highland patch. My thinking was that he must have a huge area to cover and on these corking roads I could get from one end of the Highlands to the other a mite faster than a 113bhp Ford Transit. True though that may be, it's not how it works. Instead a 62-mile radius is drawn around the patrol's front door and that, literally, is their sphere of influence. Dominic Carroll has been an AA patrol for eight years. Like most others he was a mechanic first, a Gold level Vauxhall tech who fancied a change. After a month's training and two weeks working alongside a mentor, he was ready to discover a whole new world of vehicle repairs beyond Vectras and Corsas. This is his turf and today we've been brought together to form the AA's Highland Patrol, which means we can put an addendum on the AA's frankly pretty weak slogan. 'Always ahead. Thanks to 620bhp.' Actually, the AA used to have a bespoke Highland Patrol. Mounted in Land Rovers they'd cruise around looking for members they could assist. In pre-mobile times away from motorway emergency phones, that was how it was done. It's all much more high tech today. And reliable presumably, seeing as the Land Rovers have long since been retired. A few patrols up here are mounted in four wheel drive Volkswagen Transporter 4Motions to combat remote winter callouts. Dom arrives at the stranded Disco 15 minutes later, an interval in which I've learned that the Maserati's main role is to be a distraction until the cavalry arrives. The most valuable tool on board the Transit is the knowledge management system, a built in computer that's a bit like Wikipedia for patrols. Not only is it chock full of information on typical issues for any given car, it allows each patrol to edit entries to say how they fixed them. A wifi booster means it still works in remote areas. Mostly. We are very remote today. An alternator issue is quickly diagnosed, and 10 minutes later the Disco is on its way. Dom gives me a tour of his van, pointing out the immediate areas where the Maserati falls flat. 'We have to have cross cab access plus a sliding door on the safe side.' I look at the MC20 and picture clambering across the transmission tunnel and out through the upwards opening door on my hands and knees – not an image of competence and capability. 'I tend to leave the van out a bit so it protects me working around the car in front. On motorways we have to leave 18 metres of clearance between van and customer car – that's called the crush zone for obvious reasons.' Dom's Transit is brand new – he's happy because the AA fast-tracked it to him specially for today. The sliding door opens to reveal... everything. Not just big ticket items like batteries and spacesaver wheels, or generic items such as pumping airbags to get into locked cars, clutch cables, amalgamating tape, reflective card to replace mirrors, cable ties and lens tape ('Haven't used that for about a year'), but even car specific repairs. 'See this? This is really good,' Dom shows me a little metal sleeve. 'It's a gear selector repair kit for a Fiat 500 and Ford Ka – we do this repair pretty much all the time. People think they've got a clutch issue on their 500, but it's actually the gear selector's ball connector. It's plastic and wears over time. Before we got these, we used to use a disposable glove and clamp that in place. But this is pretty much permanent.' Around 80 per cent of issues can be fixed at the roadside, reckons Dom. Those that can't require recovery. The back of every Transit is filled with a compact recovery trailer (CRT) that swings out hydraulically and clamps on the towbar. 'If we hadn't been able to get that Discovery going then we'd have had to call a flatbed, because this has a tow limit of around 2,000kg.' How fitting that the AA's new spearhead has a trident badge This is akin to an issue I've run into with recovery services before – no matter how much you tell the call centre to just send recovery because every tyre is punctured or there's a hole in the engine block, for a variety of reasons around insurance and health and safety they have to send a patrol to assess the issue first. Meaning more delays and frustration. But then sometimes punters don't know what they're talking about or are, er, economical with the truth. 'I once had a callout where a customer had told us his car was suffering a fuel cutoff issue and when I got there, there was fire, police, ambulance and the car was upside down in the middle of a field. The fuel cutoff wasn't the only issue there, was it?' I'm hoping for similar drama today, but the next call sounds fairly prosaic – a Mercedes with a flat tyre. That and batteries are the most common callouts. Having failed to slot the spacesaver spare in the Maserati's boot, I hotfoot to despatch tea and sympathy... well sympathy, to the afflicted party. The trouble is that on single track Highland roads the Maserati isn't actually that fast. Even by supercar standards ground clearance is hopeless. It scuffs and scrapes its belly everywhere, so I slow down and the Transit catches up. There's a nose lift, but it drops back down above 25mph. But it does have things in its favour. Speed, when you can deploy it, comes as effortlessly as breathing, the twin turbo V6 barely having to work. It's comfortable too, with fine seats and a calm, placid ride, plus it sups fuel sparingly (even though the fuel gauge is a terrible fibber, screaming at you to fill up when there's still 20 litres in there). Spend a day in here? No issue at all. But mainly the MC20 looks flipping fantastic as an AA early warning vehicle. When the sun's on it the Giallo Genio paintwork proves a near exact match for the AA's Ford M8 yellow. Bit more costly though – thick, rich and heavily pearlescent, it's a £9,650 option at Maserati, but comes free with every AA van. Special order obviously, seeing as the vans are built in batches by Ford and VW (the only two AA suppliers). The last order was 740 new shape Transits. They join a nationwide fleet of 2,800 vans, 250 trucks and one (temporary) Maserati. Personally, I'm looking past Maserati's troubled relationship with reliability and focusing on how fitting it is that the AA's new spearhead has a trident badge. And winter tyres. And a V6 that doubles as a boot warmer. Not sure that's intentional. Or desirable, as when I pull up at the Mercedes and open the boot I rediscover the teacakes I bought on the way up yesterday to dispense to those in need. Chocolate is seeping out of the foil cases. The Merc CLS is a breeze. The owner wasn't confident using the jack, so Dom and I look like high-vis heroes, wielding trolley jack and wheel gun and switching it to the spacesaver in F1 pitstop time. One thing though – to absolve itself of complete responsibility the AA tells customers they need to check the wheelnut torque in 30 miles. Bet none do. And yes, there is an algorithm that prioritises cases based on location, gender, age, weather conditions, danger and so on. It doesn't chide you for choosing an unreliable car though, so that's something if you have a Fiat, McLaren (yes, Dom has seen a few – 'Always electrics in those') or Jaguar Land Rover product.
Scottish Sun
2 days ago
- Scottish Sun
England stars enjoy day at F1 Spanish Grand Prix as Thomas Tuchel takes squad on team-bonding trip
Stars will remain in Spain for a special reason following the race Wheelie good England stars enjoy day at F1 Spanish Grand Prix as Thomas Tuchel takes squad on team-bonding trip Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THOMAS TUCHEL has taken his England stars to a team bonding session at the Formula One Spanish Grand Prix The Three Lions manager, the players and backroom staff arrived in Barcelona on Sunday morning before heading straight to the F1. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 7 Thomas Tuchel took the England team for a day out at the Spanish F1 GP Credit: Getty 7 The team posed for a photo alongside F1 CEO Stefano Domenicali, middle Credit: Getty 7 The likes of Harry Kane were seen touring the Red Bull garage Credit: Getty 7 Stars were given special access to be in the paddock for the trip Credit: PA 7 Cole Palmer still seemed too cold as he wore a jumper in the Spanish sun Credit: PA 7 England will remain in a training camp in Spain after the race Credit: Getty 7 Arsenal duo Bukayo Saka and Myles Lewis-Skelly were also seen on the gridwalk Credit: PA The vast majority of the 26-man squad have not been to the F1 before, and after the race, they will go to nearby Girona for a training camp. As they arrived many of the stars were seen posing for pictures with fans. Most stars wore shades and loose-fitting shirts for the occasion, although Chelsea talisman Cole Palmer seemed to still be too cold in the Spanish sun as he took the paddock wearing a jumper. Arsenal pair Bukayo Saka and Myles Lewis-Skelly joined their team-mate with zipper jackets, though the teenager later removed it. READ MORE IN F1 HAND BREAK F1 star OUT of Spanish Grand Prix and will undergo surgery after serious injury Meanwhile, Tuchel was all-smiles seen as he was pictured at the track wearing a cap. The squad posed for a picture alongside F1 CEO Stefano Domenicali as he welcomed the footballers into the mad world of motorsport. Many of them were also invited into team garage's before the race. Skipper Harry Kane was among the stars seen being given a tour of Red Bull's garage as he posed for snaps alongside team mechanics, while the likes of Morgan Gibbs-White, Dan Burn and Ollie Watkins posed for a picture next to the car. BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK Chelsea's Conference League winning trio Reece James, Noni Madueke and Trevoh Chalobah were seen at the Mercedes garage, while James was also part of a group including Jude Bellingham and Eberechi Eze who took in some hospitality with McLaren. The Papaya constructor later shared a post of Kane taking a selfie with their car, which they no doubt hope will give them some more good luck after drivers Oscar Piastri and Lando Norris scored P1 and P2 in Saturday qualifying. Fernando Alonso overheard taking sarcastic swipe at old rival Lewis Hamilton after blunder ahead of Spanish Grand Prix England will remain in Girona until next Saturday when they return to Espanyol's ground in Barcelona for a World Cup qualifier against Andorra. Tuchel, who has handed a first senior call-up to Chelsea's Trevoh Chalobah, decided to avoid St George Park's next week and instead, spend the whole time in Spain. This is to get used to the heat ahead of next year's World Cup in the United States, Canada and Mexico. The temperature in Barcelona and Girona is expected to be around 26C, although that is still not as warm as many of the World Cup host cities at this time of year. Next weekend's game was supposed to be in Andorra but the tiny nation's new stadium is not yet ready. After the match, new boss Tuchel and the squad will fly to the midlands to prepare for a friendly with Senegal at Villa Park in Birmingham on June 10. Under Tuchel, England won their first two qualifiers against Albania and Latvia.
