Pat Spillane: The stupidity of the GGA's biggest problem makes me channel the words of Margaret Thatcher
We are cutting off our nose to spite our face with too many matches
The French Open tennis finals were exceptional. Spain v France finished 5-4 in the Nations League. And that Munster hurling final – wow.
You might remember a couple of weeks ago I spoke about Rory McIroy's final round in the Masters as being my TV sporting highlight. Well, the Munster hurling final topped that, for sure.
That game in Limerick had everything: excitement, tension, drama, a rollercoaster ride of emotions. It had me glued to the TV from the first whistle to the last. I remember describing a football match on The Sunday Game as orgasmic. Well, that hurling game was orgasmic – no explanation required.
Neutrals who know nothing about Gaelic games were talking about the hurling final. The GAA is now hot and sexy, believe it or not. People talk about the new rules in Gaelic football and the exciting football championship. The magic of David Clifford. The Jim McGuinness factor. I should be happy. And yet I'm not.
Kerry's Paudie Clifford in action during their group game against Cork. Photo: David Fitzgerald/Sportsfile
This whole split season thing is bothering me, it is annoying me, it is angering me. The scheduling is wrong, wrong, wrong. For years, I railed against the state of football. Thankfully, enough important people came around to my way of thinking.
They got Jarlath Burns on board. He appointed Jim Gavin and his FRC colleagues. They rejigged, remodelled, and created a new game of Gaelic football.
And the rest is history. This championship has been the most exciting for many, many years. And, whisper it, despite that brilliant Munster hurling final, the football championship has been far better than its cousin. That is a first.
Thankfully, my crusade about the plague of Gaelic football has been, hopefully permanently, suspended. The crusade against the split season, however, will continue.
And a quick history lesson about the split season. Why did it come about? It was to give certainty to club players who went months without matches. And I have absolutely no problem with that.
But the reasons – and this is what people forget – that club players went months without games were down to two connected factors.
First was the incompetence of county boards who couldn't organise a piss-up in a brewery and couldn't put in place a proper fixtures structure for club players.
And secondly, subservient county board officers who bowed to the whims and demands of dictatorial inter-county managers, having an undue influence over when club matches should and should not be played.
There were many county boards, and Kerry was one, that had proper club fixtures in place. Where club players had a well-run schedule of games, played on the dates arranged.
I get the argument from Cork and Galway, they are against the split season being axed because they have so many competitions to run off. But here is the gas part. Cork's football championship started this week, involving the divisional and colleges sides. And guess what? Some of the divisional teams had to pull out because they couldn't field due to some players' club commitments.
Split season my arse.
Monaghan's Andrew Woods tries to get away from Miceál Rooney of Down. Photo: Philip Fitzpatrick/Sportsfile
Sadly, the GAA has taken a sledge-hammer to crack a nut with this split-season format. We had exclusive use of September to promote our games around our football and hurling finals. That is gone.
We have taken our two main products out of the shop window for six months – August to January – and given our rival sports, rugby and soccer, a free run. And they are making hay while the sun shines.
You can argue the pros and cons about club and inter-county competition, but the bottom line is that the inter-county competitions are those that generate the revenue for the GAA that can be ploughed back into games promotion and coaching. The inter-county senior football and hurling championships raise the profile of the GAA.
They provide the role models Irish youngsters aspire to emulate.
The split season in its present format is wrong in so many ways. We are cutting off our nose to spite our face with far too many matches, with too many competitions, too many games in too tight a time-frame.
The major competitions are not getting room to breathe and not getting the profile and publicity they deserve.
And let's not forget the club player now plays for 12 months of the year, so there is no split season in that sense.
Many club players start playing competitive games in February and some play All-Ireland club championships in January.
The inter-county players under this format are now training and playing all year round as well.
The only lads who are happy are the hundreds who fly to America for the summer to play football and hurling because they know their club championship won't start until August or September.
The final round of group games took place in the senior football championship on Saturday and Sunday. The second and third-placed teams will be into a preliminary quarter-final.
Those teams will have played four big matches in five weeks to reach the semi-finals. And if they want to play in the All-Ireland final, they must play five big matches in seven weeks. Now don't tell me that is fair.
All I can say is be careful what you wish for. I don't have a problem with the split season in theory, but it needs tweaking.
Here is a lesson from history and the greatest business blunder of all time. In 1985, after 99 years, Coca-Cola decided to change their formula for the most successful soft drink in the world.
The result was an avalanche of criticism and 79 days later they returned to the old formula. Lesson learned. Maybe the GAA will take that lesson on board as well and admit that there is a problem.
And don't get me started on having no replays. The last three Ulster football finals went to extra-time and two to penalties.
We saw an All-Ireland final last year going to extra-time and we had Munster hurling final going to penalties for the first time.
Christ, just think what replays would have done for the profile of those games in the provinces and nationally. And the money generated that could be spent by the provinces on coaching.
We should go back to replays for provincial finals and All-Ireland finals, with no extra-time the first day out.
But, of course, I know the GAA can turn to their usual sources, rugby, soccer, American football and concerts, to make up the shortfall in revenue. What a stupidly short-sighted approach.
Penalties to decide a football or hurling match are a joke. There may be plenty of drama, but it is a lottery and not a fair way to win or lose a game.
Can I just remind people that the FRC recommended last year that penalty shootouts should be replaced by an overtime showdown. A next score wins format. Or one where the conceding team has an opportunity to match their opponents' score and prolong the drama. That is a brilliant idea which the GAA has chosen, in its wisdom, not to go for.
I will not let up on this campaign. I will use the words of Margaret Thatcher – this lady is not for turning. Well, this man isn't either on the stupidity of the split season.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
21 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Conor McManus: Here's my ranking of the top 12 counties going into the knockouts
When we won our first provincial title in 2013, we were straight into an All-Ireland quarter-final against Tyrone – about the last county Monaghan would want to face given the local rivalry and how little there was between us. We lost narrowly and what we wouldn't have given for another rattle at somebody, anybody, let alone for a group stage. The problem for us was we lost the next game and it was season over. There are three provincial champions in next weekend's All-Ireland preliminary quarter-finals , who have all lost matches and are availing of the opportunity to get their season back on track. Hard not to be envious. It has been a brilliant championship so far. The new rules have helped with the quality of the football and played a part in some really exciting finales. The GAA is getting rid of the format next year but it has been great so far. READ MORE There was no dead rubber on the last day with nothing on the line, be it a home game in the preliminary quarter-final or just to stay in the championship. You can argue the jeopardy because so many home games have been lost but don't think for a minute Donegal wouldn't have wanted a week's break before the quarter-finals. Competition has been crazy and I think the final weekend has really complicated the job of picking out a likely winner, as the last unbeaten record went up in smoke after Kerry lost. Keeping in mind where we are and what we have seen, this is my ranking of the 12 counties still involved. 1. Armagh Rian O`Neill of Armagh in action. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho The All-Ireland champions getting beaten wasn't a huge surprise because they were already straight through to a quarter-final and potentially had one eye on that. They changed selection a little but there was no reason to believe they weren't going all out to win the game. It would have suited Armagh better to see Galway out of this championship than in it but the incredible rivalry between them was again on show – a fifth championship match in four years. They also have a panel that puts them in a better position than any county to make changes without undermining the team. They are bookies' favourites and deserve to be. 2. Donegal Michael Murphy of Donegal. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho I don't think they are firing on all cylinders despite being Ulster champions. They have a lot of mileage up between being in the provincial preliminary round and going to extra time against Armagh. Jim McGuinness would have loved to get that extra week. A huge amount of play is now going through Michael Murphy which seems like a fairly obvious thing to say when you have someone of that ability in such good form but to go ahead and win it all they will need to be getting more from Oisín Gallen, Ó Baoill, McBrearty et al. They will avoid Tyrone and Armagh if they reach the quarter-finals. They are also very hard to beat. 3. Galway Paul Conroy of Galway kicks a point. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho On Saturday they just looked like a team that were just maybe teetering on the edge of exit – eight points down – and it was hard to see where their response was going to come from but in the second half they decided, 'not today'. Despite missing penalties and despite the setbacks and the knock-backs in the game, they just kept coming and asking questions. They also started to get their hands on primary possession, which is something they had been struggling with in recent times for all the obvious strength of their middle third. Paul Conroy returned are looked a bit closer to his FOTY form and Shane Walsh was firing up front. I just thought their response with the season on the line was great and it looks like it could open up for them. 4. Tyrone Tyrone's Padraig Hampsey. Photograph: Ryan Byrne/inpho I don't necessarily think it's too early for them and they'll certainly not feel that themselves. Malachy O'Rourke has them motoring nicely. They were well superior to Cavan and as with their best performance, there was a nice spread of scorers, 11 and Darren McCurry in top form. They'll be quietly confident and happy with where they're at. I think being straight into the quarter-finals is a huge advantage over whoever the opposition will be. 5. Kerry Kerry's Gavin White. Photograph: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho Losing to Meath isn't the end of the world for Kerry. It will sharpen their teeth and the extra game will do them no harm even though they'll be expected to beat Cavan at home (talk to Mayo about that!). They were missing six players, including heavyweights like Paudie Clifford, Seán O'Shea and Diarmuid O'Connor, which is no reflection on Meath but gives Jack O'Connor room to improve. He's led them the long way around to All-Irelands in the past but improvement is required. 6. Dublin Dublin's John Small. Photograph: Evan Logan Dublin's win in Newry was impressive because Derry are no bad team. There is a difference when they're at full strength and Dessie Farrell will need everyone on board if they make inroads. Con O'Callaghan looks irreplaceable for them but they look like they're getting close to their best team on the pitch now at this stage. Consistency has been an issue but they should still have the beating of Cork in Croke Park and after the group, Armagh can't play them in the quarters. 7. Monaghan Micheal Bannigan of Monaghan. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho It looks a bit unfair on Monaghan listing them at seven but while they would give any of the top six a game – and did against Donegal in Ulster – they haven't the same consistent experience as those counties. They won Division Two and topped their group here. On Sunday they got into top gear in the final quarter and dominated the game a bit better and got control of kick-outs. They are scoring very heavily and will feel they're a match for anyone from here on in. 8. Meath Meath's Conor Duke. Photograph: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho Like Monaghan, they may feel hard done by to rank only eighth having won their group and with the scalps of Dublin and Kerry already on their belt but you have to take everything into account. They had a very poor second half in the Leinster final and while they're entitled to point to an unbeaten record in the group, have those games reached the highest intensity levels? Meath deserve plaudits. Getting Brian Menton back in has added a bit of steel and a bit of experience. Donal Keogan at the back has been a real rock over the years but the most impressive thing is just how they've hung in there despite missing two key forwards, James Conlon and Matthew Costello, and still scored freely. 9. Down Pat Havern of Down in action. Photograph: James Lawlor/Inpho Coming off a Tailteann Cup win last year Down have kicked on impressively despite relegation in the league. Their ability to carry the ball at pace and move it through hand and foot has been impressive. Odhran Murdock is an excellent footballer with everything in his locker, from winning primary possession in the middle of the field to carrying and shooting off either foot. It gets tougher from here, though. 10. Louth Louth's Sam Mulroy. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho Winning Leinster looks like it took something out of them and they struggled to put away Clare on Sunday. I'm sure they arrived in the All-Ireland series optimistic they could make an impact but it just hasn't worked out and they will be off to Ballybofey on Sunday. Big achievement already, though. 11. Cork Paul Walsh of Cork. Photograph: Leah Scholes/Inpho Cork's big test was the group match with Kerry and they were disappointing that day – all the more so when they see what a Meath team they competed with were able to do. The games where they've been written off are where you tend to see the best of them, like, last year, for example, when they beat Donegal. I just can't see them beating Dublin in Croke Park even though they could well raise a gallop. 12. Cavan Tyrone's Peter Harte and Oisin Brady of Cavan. Photograph: Ryan Byrne/Inpho The mood will hardly be great after two big defeats in the group. They're still in it because of a head-to-head with Mayo, who were really competitive with the teams that thrashed Cavan but they will lean into the display in Castlebar when heading down to Killarney to face a sore Kerry.
The 42
an hour ago
- The 42
McIlroy clearly isn't ready for his next Everest - but can he keep going without one forever?
SO IT TURNS out Sisyphus might have quite liked the rock all along? The rock, after all, gave him an identity and a purpose. Without it, he's just a guy walking up a hill. Where's the story in that? After Rory McIlroy finally rolled his pock-marked rock over the hill at Augusta National, the consensus was that he was now freed of all pressure and burden and would now go on a tear through the majors. This wasn't just the verdict of over-excited sportswriters like your correspondent here: McIlroy himself said he was playing with house money for the rest of his career. When McIlroy began his press conference on Masters Sunday by asking, 'What are we going to talk about next year?', he should have known that the answer would quickly be, 'Er, it'll still be you, Rory.' McIlroy cannot help but take the path of most interest, and so his post-Masters story has been more captivating than anyone might have expected. His form on the course has certainly slumped. A brilliant 67 at Oakmont yesterday sealed a tied-19th finish that looks a lot better than it felt, while he missed the cut at the Canadian Open with one of the worst rounds of his career and was a non-factor on favoured terrain at the PGA Championship. The vibes, meanwhile, have jackknifed. McIlroy has not always looked as agitated and dispirited on the course as he did at times at Oakmont – the course was so difficult that he was far from alone in tossing clubs – and he has remained as polite and decent with course volunteers and staff members as ever. McIlroy has, however, cut a jaded kind of melancholy with the media, declining all four post-round interview requests during the PGA Championship and maintaining his silence after his first two rounds at the US Open. This is not to say it's been a total blackout – McIlroy has given pre-tournament press conferences at each of his last three events and spoke after his two rounds in Canada – but that the game's biggest star won't speak after the biggest events is a needless failing of already put-upon fans. This has also provoked a disproportionate level of kickback among some in the American golf media, with some hitherto near-sycophantic journalists and podcasters caustic in their criticism of McIlroy's gradual public withdrawal. Given McIlroy occasionally fills his travel time with these podcasts, it would be unsurprising if he was stung by the reaction. All of this feels like part of a bigger split between McIlroy and America itself, as he plans a move to London while trimming his PGA Tour schedule and committing to play in India and Australia later this year. McIlroy, however, would have been better advised skipping media after his round on Saturday rather than deliver the dyspeptic, humourless four-odd minutes he did. He gave Stephen Watson of BBC Northern Ireland a two-word answer to his softball opening question, and went on to voice vague frustrations at the media in general, undermine his admirable grind in making Friday's cut by saying he didn't particularly want to play the weekend at all, and then rounded it all out by saying he felt he had earned the right to do whatever he wanted. Advertisement The media should not be the chiefly offended by these abject minutes, Rory McIlroy should. He has rarely delivered public comments less representative of himself. McIlroy was happily more like his old self on Sunday, giving a cheery pre-round interview to NBC before shooting the joint-lowest score of the day and giving a much wordier, thoughtful post-round interview. 'Look, I climbed my Everest in April, and I think after you do something like that, you've got to make your way back down, and you've got to look for another mountain to climb', said McIlroy, admitting his mental focus and motivation has been absent since the Masters. This was the first US Open in which he finished outside the top 10 since a missed cut in 2018, after which he sat down with himself and resolved to build his game and frame his mind around the year's biggest tests. This built the consistency that ultimately set himself back down the path to Masters glory. Having prepared himself to win, the second major part of the breakthrough was his decision to be willing to lose. The 2022 Open, the 2023 and 2024 US Opens and the 'nearly man' run in autumn last year provided enough heartbreak for anyone's career, but also showed that McIlroy had, in how own words, learned to be 'vulnerable.' After all, anybody who wins big must first be ready to lose big. A crucial part of this vulnerability was his openness with the media: asked to explain away the latest gut-wrench and near-miss or preview the next weighty major title, McIlroy was hopeless at batting away a question and muttering some bromide about 'the process.' Instead he engaged with an open heart and an open mind. Hence why it feels we all got the payoff at the Masters in April. But all of that is, frankly, exhausting, so who can blame him if he just wanted to rock up to a few majors and treat them just as golf tournaments for a while, rather than grand exhibits of his ambition, status and legacy? He has been doing his best to avoid stumbling onto another grand quest since the Masters, and his media withdrawal is potentially part of all of this, given we keep asking him about precisely that which he is trying to avoid. We asked him, for instance, ahead of the PGA Championship whether he has found another career North Star after completing the career Grand Slam, to which he replied he hadn't and nor was he seeking one. 'I think everyone saw how hard having a north star is and being able to get over the line', he said, adding he had 'burdened' himself with the Grand Slam chase. He's had to answer several of these media contrivances. But therein lies the rub. Can McIlroy continue to compete at the very elite end of a maddening and volatile sport without another north star? Is the necessary price of more ambition the weight of another burden? And does he have the appetite to carry another? Searching for that focus, McIlroy has trained his sights on the Open championship in Portrush next month. 'If I can't get motivated to get up for an Open Championship at home, then I don't know what can motivate me', asked McIlroy after yesterday's final round. That does not read as a rhetorical question, but an open one, and another question he must decide whether he wants to answer.
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Rory McIlroy first to qualify for Team Europe Ryder Cup team
Rory McIlroy is the first player to automatically qualify for Team Europe for the 2025 Ryder Cup and set to make his eighth consecutive appearance in the competition. The Masters Champions is the first member of captain Luke Donald's teams for this years edition of the Ryder Cup which will take place at Bethpage Black in New York from September 26-28. The Hollywood native has secured his spt with two months to spare in the qualificaiton period after his four victories to date since the European points list started in August. McIlroy, who has hit a slump since completing the career Grand Slam by winning the green jacket at the Masters, won the DP World Tour Championship in Dubai in November 2024, the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am and the Players Championship on the PGA Tour. He has also 10 top 10 finishes across the qualification period and his 19th place finish at the US Open at Oakmont secured his qualification. Speaking on his automatic qualification McIlroy said 'It's always a huge honour to represent Europe in the Ryder Cup, so it means a great deal to have qualified for my eighth in a row and to be part of Luke's team again at Bethpage. 'Rome was such an incredible week with the environment Luke created, and I can't wait to be back in the team room. 'Winning a Ryder Cup away from home is one of the biggest challenges there is in golf. We know it is going to be tough in New York, but we are all looking forward to that challenge in September and the opportunity to potentially do something special.' Make that EIGHT consecutive Ryder Cups 😏@McIlroyRory is the first #TeamEurope player confirmed for the 2025 Ryder Cup. — Ryder Cup Europe (@RyderCupEurope) June 16, 2025 McIlroy made his Ryder Cup debut in Europe's win in 2010 at The Celtic Manor Resort and was part of the most recent European team to win in the US in 2012 at Medinah. He has been on five winning teams having been part of the successful teams at Gleneagles in 2014, Le Golf National in 2018 and Marco Simone in 2023. He was Europe's top points scorer two years ago in Rome contributing four points as Team Europe defeated the United States 16 1/2 to 11 1/2 and has won a total of 18 points overall in his previous seven appearances. Captain Donald is delighted to have McIlroy back on board for the 2025 edition of the Ryder Cup. 'Rory has once again been in superb form this year and I'm really pleased to welcome him to Team Europe as our first automatic qualifier for Bethpage. 'Clearly it is great to have the reigning Masters Champion on your team, but Rory also has a wealth of Ryder Cup experience and that is going to be important for us as we know how tough the challenge is going to be in New York. 'I'm now looking forward to seeing how the other players perform over the next two months and seeing who joins Rory in the other automatic qualification spots.' The automatic qualification perioid ends for Team Europe on Sunday August 24 with the top six players in the European rankings at the conclusion of the British Master securing their spots with Donald set to select his Captain's Picks on Monday September 1. Currently in the automatic spots are Tyrrell Hatton, Shane Lowry, Robert MacIntyre, Sepp Straka and Rasmus Hojgaard.
