A community rallied to share flu shot experiences. Then the government stopped the study
Some Denver parents got texts during this winter's brutal flu season with videos sharing why people in their neighborhoods chose flu shots for their kids, an unusual study about trust and vaccines in a historically Black community.
But no one will know how it worked out: The Trump administration canceled the project before the data could be analyzed -- and researchers aren't the only ones upset.
'For someone like me, from the Black community who income-wise is on the lower end, we don't often have a voice,' said Denver mom Chantyl Busby, one of the study's community advisers. 'Having this funding taken away from this project sends a horrible, horrible message. It's almost like telling us all over again that our opinions don't matter.'
How to talk about vaccines with parents – or anyone – is taking on new urgency: At least 216 U.S. children died of flu this season, the worst pediatric toll in 15 years, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Unvaccinated children are fueling one of the country's largest measles outbreaks in decades, and another vaccine-preventable disease — whooping cough — is soaring, too.
At the same time Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. questions vaccines long proven to be safe and effective. Moves by the Trump administration are making it increasingly uncertain that COVID-19 vaccines will be available this fall. And the administration has slashed funding for public health and medical research, including abruptly stopping studies of vaccine hesitancy.
'We need to understand what it is that is creating this challenge to vaccines and why,' said Michael Osterholm, who directs the University of Minnesota's Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy and worries the country is entering 'scientific dark ages."
At Denver Health, Dr. Joshua Williams is a pediatrician who every day has vaccine conversations with confused or worried parents. Some even ask if they'll get kicked out of his practice for refusing immunizations.
Nope, Williams says: Building trust takes time.
'The most satisfying vaccine-related encounters I have are the ones in families who had significant concerns for a long time, came to trust me over the years as I cared for broken arms and ear infections – and ultimately vaccinated their child,' he said.
But in the TikTok age, Williams wondered if digital storytelling – seeing and hearing what led other families to choose vaccination – might help those decisions. He chose flu shots as the test case — just under half of U.S. children got one this season. And Black children are among those most at risk of getting seriously ill from influenza.
With a grant from the National Institutes of Health, Williams partnered with Denver's nonprofit Center for African American Health to host workshops bringing volunteers together to discuss how influenza and the flu vaccine had impacted their lives. Professionals helped those who wanted to go the extra step turn them into 2- to 3-minute polished videos.
After two years of community engagement, five of those videos were part of the pilot study sending text messages to 200 families who get care at two Denver Health clinics.
In one video, a mother described getting her first flu vaccination along with her young daughter, making her own health decisions after leaving a controlling relationship.
In another, a grandmother explained how she'll never again miss a vaccine appointment after her grandson spent his 4th birthday hospitalized with the flu.
Seeing 'people that they look like, that they sound like, who have experiences they've been through that can go, 'Hey, I felt like you felt but this changed my life,'' is powerful, said Busby, who OK'd her kids' flu vaccinations after questioning Williams during multiple family checkups.
The study's sudden cancellation means Williams can't assess if the texted videos influenced families' vaccine decisions – lost data from more than two years of work and already-spent NIH dollars. It also jeopardizes the researchers' careers. While considering next steps, Williams has asked permission of community members to use some of the videos in his own practice as he discusses vaccination.
Williams gets personal, too, telling families that his kids are vaccinated and how his 95-year-old grandmother reminisces about the terror of polio during her own childhood before those vaccinations were developed.
'We've lost the collective memory about what it's like to have these diseases in our community,' Williams said, ruefully noting the ongoing measles outbreak. 'I think it's going to take a collective voice from the community saying this is important, to remind those in power that we need to be allocating resources to infection prevention and vaccine hesitancy research.'
—-
—-
The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
27 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Charity rescues 72 ‘neglected and malnourished' rats from ‘disgusting' conditions in home
Dylan Beckett, head of the small animal team at Assisi, said he believed he was attending a regular callout when a woman rang to say she had 50 rats 'that were properly split into males and females'. 'She kept reassuring me that they were split because 50 rats can very quickly turn into 200 rats,' he added. 'I told her we would take a set and then get them rehomed and come back for the next set. So that's what I was expecting when I got there.' Once he arrived at the home, however, he was shocked to find the conditions the rats were living in. 'It was foul-smelling and disgusting. There was just this stench of death, faeces and neglect. 'The rats were covered in tumours, burst abscesses and injuries. Some are so inbred they are missing limbs and eyes. 'You could tell they were extremely malnourished and neglected. The only thing they had been fed was dry dog kibble. 'The owner had been picking them up by their tails, so some of them have broken tails. Every single one of them has a chest infection,' Dylan said. Despite the distressing scenes, Dylan said the rats' owner appeared to be unfazed. 'There was no remorse, whatsoever. When I was lifting the rats, they were screaming in fear. That scream is not a sound you could get used to,' he said. 'When an animal is screaming in fear or pain it's a horrible thing to listen to, but the owner was chuckling while hearing that. They were just showing zero compassion. In my eight years of doing this, I've never seen anything like it.' One of the rats taken away has since died and three others have had to be put to sleep since arriving at Assisi. However, Dylan is determined to take care of the rest to the best of his ability. 'We have had people in contact with us about rehoming these rats, but it will be a long time until they are ready to leave us. We are all working hard to help them overcome their chest infections and any other conditions they may have,' he said. Assisi set up a fundraiser for the rats and has currently raised over £1,700. Dylan said he was pleasantly surprised by how much money has been raised already to help animals that many people only see as vermin. 'I think it's a testament to these rats that they have raised this much, despite their reputation,' he said. 'It's a lot better than it was. Thanks to TikTok and Instagram, people don't just think of the Black Death — people see that you can teach them to do these tricks and things, and they are becoming very popular.
Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'I'm a dietitian and this is what I have for breakfast, lunch and dinner'
You'll be glad to know her diet includes chocolate! A dietitian has revealed her typical daily meals - from breakfast to dinner, including dessert. Josie Porter, known as @thedietitianmethod on TikTok, follows one key principle: avoiding ' weird food rules.' As a registered dietitian, she completed her training at several leading NHS trusts in London. Porter, BSc MSc RD, introducing the video, saying: 'This is everything a dietitian eats in a day with no weird food rules.' Because it's the weekend, she decided to go on a run and fueled up on a banana before heading out. After she came back, she then had her "proper breakfast". She makes a delicious pistachio tiramisu granola bites with a mascarpone base, calling the dish "up there with one of my favorite variations." Next, she has her lunch which consists of boiled eggs, lots of chilli oil, edamame beans and spring onions. She has this all together on a chopping board and chops it all up and stuffs it into a soft pitta. When it comes to dinner, she enjoys variety and colour. She chose jerk salmon, kidney beans, coriander rice, and a cashew and mango slaw. Speaking about her dinner, she says: "It has everything you need from fiber, protein, flavour and the juicy mango." And to end the day, she tucks into some chocolate. Dietitian's diet - breakfast, lunch, dinner and dessert Pre-run food: One banana Breakfast: Pistachio tiramisu granola bites with a mascarpone base Lunch: Boiled eggs, chilli oil, edamame beans and spring onions in a soft pitta Dinner: Jerk salmon with a cashew and mango slaw, kidney beans and coriander rice Dessert: Chocolate Pistachio tiramisu granola bites with a mascarpone base - how to make In a separate video, the food expert said she loves to "make a batch ahead of time and store in the fridge". It's "ideal for brunch spreads, breakfast on-the-go, or when you want a little snack that still offers some nutritional oomph." Ingredients serves 1, double for 2 etc... 1 ripe banana 30g rolled oats 2 tbsp chopped pistachios 1 tbsp maple syrup (optional, for sweetness) 1 tsp instant espresso or coffee powder 1 tsp cacao powder Pinch of salt 2 tbsp Greek yogurt (full fat works best, but any does the trick!) 1 tbsp mascarpone Cocoa powder (for dusting) Optional: pistachio butter for drizzling Method Preheat oven to 180°C fan if using over an airfryer. Skip this step if using an air fryer. In a bowl, mash the banana with espresso powder, salt, and cacao powder, then mix in oats, maple syrup (if using), vanilla, and pistachios. Onto baking paper, add all and press flat with a fork or spoon. Bake for 10 mins in air fryer on 180, or 15–18 mins in oven until just golden. Meanwhile, mix the Greek yogurt and mascarpone until smooth and creamy. Add maple syrup if you want it sweet. Place into your serving bowl as your base. Once your bites have cooled slightly, scrap into clusters with a spoon or fork. Then crumble over the creamy base, dust with cocoa powder, and finish with pistachio butter (if using!)
NBC News
5 hours ago
- NBC News
Celebrity breast cancer announcements highlight rising rates in young women
Several young celebrities have announced breast cancer diagnoses in the past year — a public reminder that rates are rising among women under 50 in the U.S. Pop singer Jessie J, 37, revealed this week on Instagram that she has early-stage breast cancer and plans to undergo surgery later this month. Katie Thurston, former star of 'The Bachelorette,' has documented her journey with Stage 4 breast cancer on social media after being diagnosed earlier this year at age 34. And actor Danielle Fishel, known for her role on the '90s sitcom 'Boy Meets World,' revealed her diagnosis at age 43 to fans last summer. New breast cancer diagnoses in young women have gone up considerably in the last decade. From 2012 to 2021 — the most recent decade of data — the rate increased 1.4% annually in women under 50, compared with 0.7% annually in women 50 and up. The trend applies to all racial or ethnic groups, particularly Asian American and Pacific Islander women under 50, for whom diagnoses have risen nearly 50% since 2000. Black women have the highest rate of breast cancer before age 40 and are most likely to die of the disease. Women under 40 generally aren't advised to get mammograms unless they have a strong risk factor for breast cancer, such as a family history or genetic mutation. In that case, the American Cancer Society recommends mammograms starting at age 30, plus an annual breast MRI. Several breast cancer doctors said younger patients and their clinicians should be careful not to dismiss symptoms such as a lump or nipple discharge. 'The thought was always, if you had a change in your breast but you were a young woman, it was probably nothing,' said Dr. Rani Bansal, an assistant professor at the Duke University School of Medicine. 'As we're seeing more and more younger women get diagnosed … we need to take these cases seriously.' Dr. Oluwadamilola Fayanju, chief of breast surgery at Penn Medicine, said her youngest patient diagnosed with cancer was just 17. She recommended that young women with symptoms go to a center that's experienced in breast imaging. For women with an elevated risk of breast cancer, she said, 'it may be better for you to be connected with a dedicated breast provider who can keep a close eye on you and do regular exams even well before 40.' Breast cancer in young women is often more aggressive As treatment options for breast cancer have improved, the overall mortality rate among younger women with the disease declined from 2010 to 2020, according to research presented in April at the American Association for Cancer Research meeting in Chicago. But young women are still more likely to be diagnosed with aggressive breast cancer compared with older women. One reason could be that they're not getting screened as much, so it's harder to catch cases early. Young women are also more likely to be diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer, which tends to spread fast and has fewer treatment options. Dr. Virginia Borges, a professor of medical oncology at the University of Colorado Cancer Center, said all women diagnosed with breast cancer before age 35 have a higher likelihood of the cancer spreading to the rest of their bodies, for reasons doctors don't fully understand. 'It's like this great big puzzle of all these different factors that can contribute to why we see these cancers behave the way they do,' Borges said. Bansal said doctors are hoping to learn more about which treatments are better suited to women under 50. 'We need more data to better tailor our treatments towards younger women,' she said. 'A lot of the studies that are done are in older women.' Lifestyle, environment, hormones There are several mysteries as to why younger women are diagnosed with breast cancer at higher rates. Doctors generally agree that multiple factors are at play, including lifestyle, hormones and environmental exposures. Diets high in ultra-processed foods or a lack of physical activity can lead to obesity, which in turn elevates one's cancer risk. Women in their 30s and 40s have also increased their alcohol consumption in recent decades, and drinking alcohol is linked to breast cancer. Exposure to environmental toxins such as air pollution, forever chemicals or microplastics could also play a role. 'By the time women now in their 40s were babies, every single baby bottle had BPA. Everyone had Teflon pans in their home. Everyone was spraying Scotchgard around their home,' said Suzanne Price, CEO of Breast Cancer Prevention Partners, a nonprofit that works to eliminate exposure to toxic chemicals. Several researchers said more data is needed to definitively draw that link. 'Hopefully within the next few years, we should be having more insight into how those early life exposures drive the risk of breast cancer,' said Dr. Adetunji Toriola, a professor of surgery at Washington University School of Medicine. Some studies have suggested that chemical hair straighteners, which are predominantly used by Black women, may be associated with an increased risk of breast cancer. Fayanju said the straighteners 'can potentially have effects on our ability to process hormones in our body and how those hormones then interact with cells in our breasts, which have receptors for those hormones.' Changes in women's reproductive lives might have some effect as well. Girls in the U.S. are starting their periods slightly earlier in life compared with decades ago. That may increase the length of time in which they're exposed to higher levels of estrogen — a hormone that in some cases can feed cancer cells. A study last year found an increase in the number of women ages 20 to 49 diagnosed with breast cancer that was responsive to estrogen. Many women are also delaying childbirth until their 30s and 40s, which increases the risk of postpartum breast cancer — cancers that occur within five to 10 years of giving birth that appear to be linked to changes in the breasts during that time. Borges estimated that there are about 18,000 new cases of postpartum breast cancer each year. 'How do you get from the millions of women who are having children without ending up with one of these breast cancers to the 18,000 or so who are going to get one of these breast cancers?' she said. 'We're still working on figuring that out. Age is important.'
