'Oh Hell No' - Crash Survivor Angry At Increased Speed Limits On SH3 Near Waitara
Trevor Dodunski understands the consequences of a head-on crash better than most.
In 1987, the car he was travelling in collided with another vehicle that had crossed the centre line on a stretch of State Highway 3 between Waitara and Urenui.
"I was driving along the road on a nice day happy as Larry and came around a corner and there was a car in front of me going flat out on my side of the road.
"It's hard to live with I tell you. It turned me into a vegetable, I couldn't read or write when I came out of hospital.
"Everything was changed, my whole life changed," said the former engineer who was trapped inside his wrecked vehicle for three hours.
Almost 40 years on, the Waitara community board member was angry about a plan to reinstate a 100kmh speed limit on SH3 between Waitara and New Plymouth.
"Oh hell no, we don't want that. Mine was probably an 80kmh crash head-on and you're doing 160kmh when they're coming the other way.
"The impact is phenomenal. Your windscreen leaves the car. You feel all your bones breaking and your teeth and everything are gone.
"Everything changes in a matter of seconds."
Dodunski, who suffered a brain injury and has not worked since, helped campaign for the construction of four roundabouts between Waitara and New Plymouth.
He reckoned the lower speed limit should remain in place.
"This should stay at 80kmh because if you're going to go up to 100kmh back to 80kmh and up to 100kmh again all the way through to New Plymouth, what's the point?
"It's a hell of a lot safer at 80kmh than it is at 100kmh, and I for one have had an experience I never thought I would have in my life and wouldn't wish that on anyone."
The government's new Speed Limits Rule required lower limits set on some roads in 2020 to revert to their previous limits by 1 July.
The Transport Agency could retain the 80kmh limit on SH3 from Waitara to Bell Block if the public supported the lower speed.
But only 43 percent of those who took part in an online consultation process backed keeping the lower limit.
New Plymouth mayor Neil Holdom found the consultation method curious.
"Having an internet-based opinion poll to set a State Highway speed limit is certainly an interesting legislative approach.
"But any local person will tell you the road is a patched-up and potholed shambles with significant work needed to be done.
"There's no doubt once they've thrown a bit of money at it it could go back to a 100kmh speed limit, but right now it's simply not safe."
Holdom, who described the stretch of highway as a "shooting gallery", said the lower limit was saving lives.
"Since we dropped the speed limit from 100kmh to 80kmh we've seen a reduction of serious injury accidents of around 60 percent and given that we've had 11 people die on this section of highway in the last 12 or 13 years we don't think they should increase the speed limit to 100kmh until all the safety upgrades are done."
New Zealand Transport Agency director of regional relationships Linda Stewart said for the speed-limit reinstatement process, the consultation result was the only factor NZTA could take into account in its decision-making.
"During consultation, the majority of respondents submitted in opposition to retaining the lower speed limits which is why this Waitara to Bell Block stretch makes up some of the 43 locations which will return to its previous higher speed limit."
Stewart said typically consultation feedback was only one factor used by NZTA to help inform the outcome of a speed review.
"Other factors, including safety or technical guidance, are normally weighted alongside consultation feedback to determine the outcome of a speed review.
"For a full speed review in the future, as we have always done in the past, themes from both the local community and key stakeholders from consultation will be considered alongside safety and technical data, including a cost benefit disclosure statement, to help inform decision-making."
Stewart said safety remained a key priority for NZTA and was a factor in decision making around road design, layout, modifications and speed.
She hoped new roundabouts being constructed at the intersections of Princess Street, Waitara Road, De Havilland Drive/Airport Drive, and SH3A, along with flexible median barrier and other improvements, would improve the safety and efficiency of the highway.
"But we appreciate the speed change will come into force ahead of the completion of the entire project."
On Waitara High Street there were mixed views on the speed limit change.
Bulk carrier driver David did not think putting up the speed limit was a good idea.
"Coming through there, they do dumb enough shit at 80kmh let alone if you put it back up to 100kmh again. I don't think it's a good thing."
A woman, who preferred not to give her name, thought the limit should go back up.
"I think the accidents that happen are usually through poor driving not so much the speed."
Jeremy could not see the reasoning behind changing the speed limit.
"They've gone and put all these roundabouts in, so what's the point of sticking the speed limit back up to 100kmh. You're just going to get to a roundabout faster. May as well keep it at 80kmh."
Another David was in favour of the change.
"I reckon it should go back to 100kmh because you're slowing traffic down and it's piling up, and with the road works in the meantime it's just pathetic trying to go to town."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
26-05-2025
- NZ Herald
Taihape crash: Three vehicles collide, close State Highway 1, detours in place
Hato Hone St John said one person with critical injuries was flown to Whanganui Base Hospital. Another person with moderate injuries was taken to the same hospital by ambulance. Two others, one moderately injured and another with minor injuries, were taken to Palmerston North Hospital. St John sent two ambulances, two helicopters, two rapid response vehicles, two operation managers and a prime responder. Police said: 'The road is blocked and diversions are in place. The diversions are not suitable for trucks at this stage. 'Motorists are advised to avoid the area if possible and expect delays.' The New Zealand Transport Agency said the road was closed at 2.40pm. 'All emergency services are on-site. Please avoid the area or consider delaying your journey.' UPDATE 2:40PM The road is now CLOSED, due to a serious crash near the intersection with Rauma Rd. All emergency services are on-site. Please avoid the area or consider delaying your journey. ^AP — NZ Transport Agency - Central North Island (@nztacni) May 26, 2025 One woman told the Herald more than 60 trucks, utes, buses and other large vehicles heading north were waiting for the crash to be cleared. 'I counted maybe 60 trucks, mainly big logistic trucks, pulled over,' she said. 'We were being directed off the main road. 'I was just using Google Maps, and it changed where it says we should go now, and we can't continue straight down the main highway. 'Everyone's being directed down Mangaone Valley Rd.'
1News
14-05-2025
- 1News
Century-old bridge replacement delayed despite damaging tyres
A century-old-bridge south of Whakatāne has been dropped as an urgent replacement project, despite having a road surface so bad it is accused of chewing up brand new tyres. Exposed screws and broken seal over a wooden plank surface have become a regular feature of Pekatahi Bridge which links heavy traffic from East Coast industry with Tauranga Port. Local politicians are pushing for the replacement of the one-lane bridge which has become a cause of complaint from road users who are fed up with damage to their vehicles and frequent closures for maintenance. New Zealand Transport Agency – Waka Kotahi had previously had it scheduled for replacement within the next 10 years. But the agency now says, due to health of the bridge's sub-structure, and a detour that adds only 20 minutes, it is no longer on their end-of-life bridge register. Instead, design work is underway for a full deck replacement for the bridge, but even this improvement, expected to cost 12 percent of a full bridge replacement, is subject to funding not available in the next two years. Mayor Victor Luca addressed the issue at a meeting of the Bay of Plenty Regional Council's regional transport committee last week as part of a presentation on his proposal for a second river crossing for Whakatāne. He said he had understood from conversations with former Waka Kotahi regional relationship manager David Spiers last year that the bridge had been on a schedule for replacement. This had since changed. The committee agreed to write a letter of support to the Minister of Transport for Luca's second bridge proposal. Ōpōtiki Mayor David Moore also spoke in support of a new river crossing. "Anything that goes over your bridge has often come from our district, and a lot of what comes through our district has come from Gisborne on the way over to the port [in Tauranga] ... you suddenly take that all out and you've got a problem for the port and for this country. It's not just our two districts. It affects everyone." The agency's maintenance and operations regional manager Roger Brady said bridge replacements were prioritised according to the age and condition of the bridge and suitability for current traffic volumes and Pekatahi did not rate as highly as other similar bridges across New Zealand. Despite three-and-a-half days of closures just before Easter for regular maintenance, the current surface is still bumpy and uneven. The agency's Bay of Plenty system manager Sandra King said the closure was to remove and replace broken surface planks along the length of the bridge's deck. "Crews repaired all significant surface plank breakages and made safe any protruding screws. Due to time restrictions and poor weather, re-surfacing of patches had to be deferred and the repair of planks was prioritised," she said. A further one-day closure was planned for next Monday to address any further broken or protruding screws, and depending on weather and temperatures, undertake chipseal surface patching. She said the bridge deck consisted of surfacing planks screwed into transverse beams, overlain by chipseal to help reduce friction. Ongoing maintenance work was needed for repairs and required full road closures. A concrete surface was out of the question as it would be too heavy. The next full closure was scheduled for the next school holiday period, or earlier depending on bridge surface condition. Whakatāne district councillor Nandor Tanczos said the district needed to be working together with other affected districts, businesses, landowners and other stakeholders to lobby Waka Kotahi for a replacement bridge. "We need some way of pulling all the interested parties together and creating one unified voice," he said. He described the state of the bridge's surface as "horrendous". "I've heard of people getting their brand new tyres chewed up by the studs that are coming out of the surface. Its really frustrating. It's dangerous. "This Government has sucked all of the money for regional roads and it's all being funnelled into dealing with city congestion. That's left things like dealing with the Pekatahi Bridge high and dry. They're basically saying 'Whakatāne, suck it up'." He felt those calling for a second river crossing for the Whakatāne township should also join their voices to the cause. "It needs two lanes, it needs a proper surface, for freight trucks as well as local traffic. It needs to be resilient for flooding, which we know is increasing because of climate change. "Exactly where it goes, that can be decided. I understand that the cost of replacing Pekatahi is really high because it's got such a long span. There maybe better places to cross, but we need to have that crossing out of town because we want heavy traffic to be bypassing town. "Collectively, we can be quite a strong voice. We need some ability to pull a coalition together and using the connections that we collectively have in Wellington." East Coast MP Dana Kirkpatrick said the bridge was a critical piece of the roading infrastructure and many people had contacted her recently and sent photos showing the state of the road surface. "I have had reports of trucking companies with repeated damage to tyres at $1200 each time." She said over the past 10 years Waka Kotahi had spent $4.6 million on repairs and maintenance to the bridge. "The lion's share of that in 2017-2018 when $3.6m was spent removing the train tracks and altering the surface. "I think it is time the community has the conversation about what the roading priority should be."
Scoop
14-05-2025
- Scoop
Pekatahi Bridge No Longer On Replacement List
Despite having a road surface so bad it is accused of chewing up brand new tyres, a century-old-bridge south of Whakatāne has been dropped as an urgent replacement project. Exposed screws and broken seal over a wooden plank surface have become a regular feature of Pekatahi Bridge which links heavy traffic from East Coast industry with Tauranga Port. Local politicians are pushing for the replacement of the one-lane bridge which has become a cause of complaint from road users who are fed up with damage to their vehicles and frequent closures for maintenance. New Zealand Transport Agency – Waka Kotahi had previously had it scheduled for replacement within the next 10 years. But the agency now says, due to health of the bridge's sub-structure, and a detour that adds only 20 minutes, it is no longer on their end-of-life bridge register. Instead, design work is underway for a full deck replacement for the bridge, but even this improvement, expected to cost 12 percent of a full bridge replacement, is subject to funding not available in the next two years. Mayor Victor Luca addressed the issue at a meeting of the Bay of Plenty Regional Council's regional transport committee last week as part of a presentation on his proposal for a second river crossing for Whakatāne. He said he had understood from conversations with former Waka Kotahi regional relationship manager David Spiers last year that the bridge had been on a schedule for replacement. This had since changed. The committee agreed to write a letter of support to the Minister of Transport for Dr Luca's second bridge proposal. Ōpōtiki Mayor David Moore also spoke in support of a new river crossing. 'Anything that goes over your bridge has often come from our district, and a lot of what comes through our district has come from Gisborne on the way over to the port [in Tauranga] ... you suddenly take that all out and you've got a problem for the port and for this country. It's not just our two districts. It affects everyone. The agency's maintenance and operations regional manager Roger Brady said bridge replacements were prioritised according to the age and condition of the bridge and suitability for current traffic volumes and Pekatahi did not rate as highly as other similar bridges across New Zealand. Despite three-and-a-half days of closures just before Easter for regular maintenance, the current surface is still bumpy and uneven. The agency's Bay of Plenty system manager Sandra King said the closure was to remove and replace broken surface planks along the length of the bridge's deck. 'Crews repaired all significant surface plank breakages and made safe any protruding screws. Due to time restrictions and poor weather, re-surfacing of patches had to be deferred and the repair of planks was prioritised,' she said. A further one-day closure was planned for next Monday (May 19) to address any further broken or protruding screws, and depending on weather and temperatures, undertake chipseal surface patching. She said the bridge deck consisted of surfacing planks screwed into transverse beams, overlain by chipseal to help reduce friction. Ongoing maintenance work was needed for repairs and required full road closures. A concrete surface was out of the question as it would be too heavy. The next full closure was scheduled for the next school holiday period, or earlier depending on bridge surface condition. Whakatāne district councillor Nandor Tanczos said the district needed to be working together with other affected districts, businesses, landowners and other stakeholders to lobby Waka Kotahi for a replacement bridge. 'We need some way of pulling all the interested parties together and creating one unified voice,' he said. He described the state of the bridge's surface as 'horrendous'. 'I've heard of people getting their brand new tyres chewed up by the studs that are coming out of the surface. Its really frustrating. It's dangerous. 'This Government has sucked all of the money for regional roads and it's all being funneled into dealing with city congestion. That's left things like dealing with the Pekatahi Bridge high and dry. They're basically saying 'Whakatāne, suck it up'. He felt those calling for a second river crossing for the Whakatāne township should also join their voices to the cause. 'It needs two lanes, it needs a proper surface, for freight trucks as well as local traffic. It needs to be resilient for flooding, which we know is increasing because of climate change. 'Exactly where it goes, that can be decided. I understand that the cost of replacing Pekatahi is really high because it's got such a long span. There maybe better places to cross, but we need to have that crossing out of town because we want heavy traffic to be bypassing town. 'Collectively, we can be quite a strong voice. We need some ability to pull a coalition together and using the connections that we collectively have in Wellington.' East Coast MP Dana Kirkpatrick said the bridge was a critical piece of the roading infrastructure and many people had contacted her recently and sent photos showing the state of the road surface. 'I have had reports of trucking companies with repeated damage to tyres at $1200 each time.' She said over the past 10 years Waka Kotahi had spent $4.6 million on repairs and maintenance to the bridge. 'The lion's share of that in 2017-2018 when $3.6m was spent removing the train tracks and altering the surface. 'I think it is time the community has the conversation about what the roading priority should be.'
