Still no decision on hate charges for B.C. woman 1 year after praising Hamas attack
Canadian Jewish groups are questioning why B.C. prosecutors have taken more than a year to decide whether a woman who made explosive comments at a Vancouver rally last year should face hate crime charges.
Vancouver police arrested Charlotte Kates and recommended she be charged with wilful promotion of hatred and public incitement of hatred for an April 29, 2024 speech at the Vancouver Art Gallery in which she praised the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel as 'heroic and brave.'
Kates further led the crowd in a chant of 'Long live Oct. 7,' and called for the delisting of Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hezbollah and several other groups as terrorist organizations, describing them as 'resistance fighters' and 'heroes.'
Kates' own group, the Samidoun Palestinian Prisoner Solidarity Network, was later itself declared to be a terrorist entity by the Canadian government.
Story continues below advertisement
1:58
Police raid Vancouver home of international coordinator of declared terrorist group
But despite the Vancouver police recommendation, the B.C. Prosecution Service has yet to decide whether or not to approve charges 13 months later.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Aron Csaplaros, B.C. regional manager for B'nai Brith Canada, called the delay 'concerning.'
'It's really in the hands of the BC Prosecution Service and the attorney general of British Columbia to approve charges, because for the charge of wilful promotion of hatred, the attorney general or the deputy attorney general does have to sign off on that charge,' he said.
'This ongoing inaction raises serious questions about enforcement and protections for vulnerable communities in general, not just the Jewish community.'
In a statement, BC Prosecution Service communications counsel Damienne Darby said the 'matter remains under charge assessment, and I am unable to provide a timeline for completion.'
Story continues below advertisement
Former Crown prosecutor Rob Dhanu, K.C., who is not involved with the case, questioned why the prosecution service has yet to make a decision.
2:20
Iran gives human rights award to B.C. activist
'Here, the smoking gun, so to speak, is the video. And the video essentially shows what Ms. Kates said at that time. So the evidence is straightforward,' he said.
'The prosecution service has not really provided any real reason as to why this case is taking so long to determine whether it should be charge-approved or not.'
Dhanu said if it proceeded to trial, the case could hinge on whether prosecutors could prove that Kates' statements went beyond an expression of opinion, and into incitement.
'Section 319 of the (Criminal) Code is very specific in that the Crown has to have evidence to show there is a likelihood because of that hate speech is that the peace will be breached,' he said.
Story continues below advertisement
'Really, it is Ms. Kates expressing her opinion, it is not a black-and-white case in terms of the facts. For instance, if Ms. Kates said, well look, Israel doesn't have the right to exist, and to facilitate that, we should be attacking synagogues, we have a very direct cause and effect where we can see why people would follow what she's saying and follow what she is asking for. Here it's far more grey.'
Global News is seeking comment from Samidoun.
— with files from Rumina Daya
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
In the news today: Cooler week ahead as fires burn by Flin Flon, Man.
Here is a roundup of stories from The Canadian Press designed to bring you up to speed… Cooler week ahead as fires burn by Flin Flon, Man. Cooler temperatures and a chance of rain this week is forecasted in a northwestern Manitoba city that's had to evacuate thousands due to wildfire. As of Sunday night, Environment Canada is projecting temperatures in the mid teens to mid 20s over the next week, with a good chance of rain coming next Saturday in Flin Flon. Crews have been trying to keep a blaze burning nearby at bay, as they have said the fire has been contained to outside its perimeter highway. At this time, crews say there have been no structure losses. To date, more than 17,000 people have been displaced by wildfires in Manitoba, including 5,000 from Flin Flon. Here's what else we're watching… Carney, premiers meeting in Saskatoon Canada's premiers are meeting with Prime Minister Mark Carney in person for the first time since the federal election to pitch which major projects they think should get fast tracked. The recent campaign saw Carney vow to slash federal approval times on major infrastructure projects considered to be in the national interest to help make the country an 'energy superpower.' The full list of big industrial projects they're discussing is being kept secret, since they don't want to send a bad signal about anything that doesn't make the short list. But Ontario Premier Doug Ford says his pick is the Ring of Fire mining project in northern Ontario, while Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she wants to see the Port of Prince Rupert become a major trade corridor. The first ministers are also expected to discuss breaking down interprovincial trade barriers, which would make it easier to purchase Canadian-made goods from other provinces and territories. Bank of Canada faces 'risky' rate decision Few would confuse Hollywood action star Tom Cruise with Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem. But while Cruise rides a plane in tailspin to his latest box office smash, some economists say Macklem finds himself in his own high-stakes circumstances with the central bank's interest rate decision on Wednesday. Macklem's mission is to chart a path for interest rates that keeps Canada's economy afloat at a precarious moment without straying from its inflation-taming mandate. 'It really is mission impossible,' said Andrew DiCapua, principal economist at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce. The Bank of Canada's policy rate stands at 2.75 per cent following a pause at the central bank's last decision in April, snapping a streak of seven consecutive cuts. Most economists expect the central bank will hold rates again on Wednesday. Ontario to limit debate on controversial Bill 5 Ontario Premier Doug Ford's government is moving to shut down debate on its most controversial piece of legislation this session, one of a plethora of bills getting the fast-track treatment before the legislature rises for a summer break. A mining law known as Bill 5 that would give the government power to suspend provincial and municipal laws for chosen projects in areas deemed to have economic importance – and remove some endangered species protections – has sparked a lot of opposition. A legislative committee heard from First Nations leaders and environmental groups, as well as mining groups, over two days and as the committee was considering amendments last week the NDP and Liberals used procedural tools to grind the process to a halt, in protest. Government house leader Steve Clark is now stepping in to limit further committee time and require the bill to go back to the house for third reading, with just one hour of debate, and a final vote that same day. While Bill 5 got two days of committee hearings, the six other pieces of legislation the government is speeding up have had no hearings, and will have as little as half an hour of third-reading debate, with just nine minutes each allotted to the two recognized opposition parties. Hockey players' sex assault trial continues The sexual assault trial of five former members of Canada's world junior hockey team is expected to hear today whether another one of the players will take the stand. Alex Formenton's legal team is expected to tell the court whether they will call any witnesses, including their client. Another accused, Carter Hart, testified over two days last week, which included one day of cross-examination by the Crown. Formenton, Hart and their ex-teammates Michael McLeod, Dillon Dube and Callan Foote have pleaded not guilty to sexual assault. The trial centres on an encounter with a woman inside a London, Ont., hotel room in the early hours of June 19, 2018. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 2, 2025.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Premiers huddle with Carney in Saskatoon to decide what major projects to prioritize
SASKATOON – Canada's premiers are meeting with Prime Minister Mark Carney in person for the first time since the federal election to pitch which major projects they think should get fast tracked. The recent campaign saw Carney vow to slash federal approval times on major infrastructure projects considered to be in the national interest to help make the country an 'energy superpower.' The full list of big industrial projects they're discussing is being kept secret, since they don't want to send a bad signal about anything that doesn't make the short list. But Ontario Premier Doug Ford says his pick is the Ring of Fire mining project in northern Ontario, while Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says she wants to see the Port of Prince Rupert become a major trade corridor. The first ministers are also expected to discuss breaking down interprovincial trade barriers, which would make it easier to purchase Canadian-made goods from other provinces and territories. Many provinces, including Quebec and Ontario, are coming to the table with legislation already put forward that would eliminate some of these longstanding blocks to internal trade. — With files from Rob Drinkwater in Edmonton This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 2, 2025.
Calgary Herald
an hour ago
- Calgary Herald
Carney and premiers meet to talk fast-tracking national interest projects
SASKATOON, Sask. — Prime Minister Mark Carney will meet with premiers in Saskatoon today to discuss efforts to knock down trade barriers and fast-track projects deemed as benefiting the national interest. Article content Article content Carney had asked the 13 provincial and territorial leaders to come up with major infrastructure and energy projects that could be fast-tracked for approvals under a new federal process. Article content Article content The premiers will spend part of Monday's meeting receiving an overview of the proposed process set to be introduced through legislation by the end of June. Article content Article content Under the proposed bill, details of which were shared for consultation with First Nations groups, including the Assembly of First Nations, the federal Liberal government would establish a major projects office through which selected proposals would flow for approvals. Article content The proposed legislation would allow projects to be deemed as carrying national significance to be exempt from certain steps of the existing approvals process. Article content Carney has promised to shrink the timeframe for approvals of major infrastructure and energy projects to two years, down from five. Article content But which projects could make the list is what the premiers are looking to hear from Carney and that will be the topic of discussion when the leaders meet behind closed doors. Article content Article content Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has said an oil pipeline from Alberta to British Columbia's coast 'must be on the initial list.' Article content Should it not be, it would not only send a bad signal to investors, but also 'send an unwelcome signal to Albertans concerned about Ottawa's commitment to national security,' she wrote in a letter to Carney on May 16, which her office released last Saturday. Article content Separatist sentiments have been rising in both Alberta and Saskatchewan. Article content For his part, Carney has said he wants Canada to become an 'energy superpower.' Article content As he meets with premiers, he faces calls from the CEOs of major Canadian energy companies, as well as Smith and Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe, to scrap policies critics say are hostile to pipeline development, such as the tanker ban off the coast of northern British Columbia and the Impact Assessment Act.
