Good for free speech
Times of India's Edit Page team comprises senior journalists with wide-ranging interests who debate and opine on the news and issues of the day.
SC gives a fine & necessary order
Overturning a Delhi HC verdict, Supreme Court on Friday held that public scrutiny of court orders is not just kosher, but also necessary 'as a check against judicial caprice or vagaries', in the words of an earlier 9-judge bench. SC reiterated public gaze was 'a powerful instrument for creating confidence of the public in the fairness, objectivity and impartiality of the administration of justice.'
The case was about Delhi HC's order to Wikimedia to take down a website page that discussed the court's order on the legal dispute between ANI and Wikimedia. ANI had accused Wikimedia of defamation; the page in question detailed the case – this, Delhi HC held, was 'contempt of court'. Wikimedia moved SC, which on Friday correctly said that 'it is not the court's job to tell the media: delete this, take that down.'
Courts frequently bristle at even bona fide criticism, using a very broad definition in the Contempt of Courts Act 1971, which criminalises acts that 'scandalise' a court. Even Chandrachud's pan-India initiative to live-stream court proceedings was also centred on enhancing transparency. SC in this case used twin tests of necessity and proportionality to conclude that to improve any system, including the judiciary, introspection was key, and only robust debate could ensure that, 'even on issues before the court'. This is not just a blow for free speech but a step towards a maturing of Indian democracy.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
33 minutes ago
- Indian Express
First stop in France, Jaishankar embarks on week-long trip to Europe
External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Sunday embarked on a week-long visit to Europe to hold talks with leaders of France, the European Union and Belgium to boost bilateral ties and reaffirm India's policy of zero-tolerance against terrorism. Jaishankar's visit to Europe comes a month after India launched Operation Sindoor in response to the dastardly Pahalgam terror attack and it is expected that he will apprise the European leaders about New Delhi's firm approach in dealing with cross-border terrorism. In the first leg of his tour, Jaishankar will visit France, a country that has emerged as an all-weather friend of New Delhi. 'The external affairs minister would travel to Paris and Marseille where he would be holding bilateral discussions with his counterpart minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs Jean Noel Barrot,' the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) said. Jaishankar would also participate in the inaugural edition of the Mediterranean Raisina Dialogue to be held in the city of Marseille. In Brussels, Jaishankar will hold a strategic dialogue with the EU High Representative and Vice President Kaja Kallas. 'India-European Union strategic partnership has strengthened over the years across diverse sectors and got a big boost with the first-ever visit of the EU College of Commissioners to India in February this year,' the MEA said. Jaishankar will engage also with the senior leadership from the European Commission and the European Parliament, besides interacting with think tank and media. In the third and final leg of his visit, the external affairs minister will hold wide-ranging talks with leaders of Belgium. 'India and Belgium share warm and friendly relations along with a very robust economic partnership. Today, the collaboration between the two countries spans various domains like trade and investment, green energy, technology, pharmaceutical, diamond sector and strong people-to-people ties,' the MEA said. It said Jaishankar would hold bilateral consultations with the Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister of Belgium Maxime Prevot and would also meet the senior leadership of the country. He will also interact with the members of the Indian community.
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
Why Harvard is easier to crack than IITs or IIMs for Indian students
U.S. President Donald Trump has halted funding to universities it disagrees with ideologically and temporarily suspended visa interviews required for foreign students planning to enroll this year. This move directly impacts Indian students, who make up nearly one-third of all international students in the United States, as per The Economist report. India has been losing academic talent to America for decades. At the famed Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs), over 60% of the top 100 performers migrate abroad, mostly for America. ALSO READ: Harvard University scores legal win against Trump's international student ban (Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates) The Economist report says that Trump's policies might cause Indian students' applications to American universities to plummet by a quarter from this year to the next. Live Events Easier to get into Harvard India is home to half the world's university-age population. On paper, India's top universities have a lot to offer. But getting into them is much harder—some accept as few as 0.2% of applicants, compared to 3–9% for Ivy League schools like Harvard , as per The Economist. Meanwhile, after Trump's stark steps, many parents who had been set on sending their children to the US are rethinking their plans. ALSO READ: Harvard vs Trump: As fresh salvos are fired, international students live in anxiety and fear Looking for options Indian students primarily went to the US to study STEM subjects – science, technology, engineering and maths – and so the focus had shifted to other countries strong in these areas, Piyush Bhartiya, a co-founder of the educational technology company AdmitKard told the Guardian. 'Germany is the main country where students are shifting to for Stem subjects,' he said. 'Other countries like Ireland, France, the Netherlands, which are also gaining substantial interest in the students. At the undergraduate level, the Middle East has also seen a lot of gain in interest given parents feel that it is close by and safer and given the current political environment they may want their kids closer to the home.' ALSO READ: Trump's birthright citizenship order to face first US appeals court review What is happening at Harvard? Harvard University has sued the Trump administration to preserve its ability to enroll international students and restore draconian cuts in research money, two matters that threaten the core functions of the centuries-old institution. The same federal judge in Massachusetts, Allison Burroughs, an appointee of President Barack Obama, is presiding over both cases. She has often sided with Harvard, including on Thursday when she issued a temporary restraining order against the administration's latest move to bar international students. On both fronts, the Trump administration has said that it is punishing Harvard because it has failed to keep Jewish students safe by allowing antisemitism to flourish. It has added on to these accusations as the court fights have drawn on, saying that the university has used racial preferences in admissions in defiance of a Supreme Court ruling and that it has broken rules related to foreign gifts. Harvard has denied the accusations. It says the administration is ignoring its efforts to protect the civil rights of its Jewish students, for example. And Harvard has argued that the federal government has violated its First Amendment rights and has ignored due process as it pursues its vendetta against the university.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
G7 Summit: Canada's PM Carney says New Delhi ‘belongs at the table'. Why is India important? Mint decodes
Canada Prime Minister Mark Carney, while highlighting India's economic stature and strategic role in global supply chains, said that the country's presence is 'essential' at the upcoming G7 Summit. 'It made sense,' Carney said, 'to have India, the fifth largest economy, at the G7 Summit." 'There are certain countries that should be at the table for those discussions in my capacity as G7 chair consultation,' he said. 'India is the fifth largest economy in the world, effectively the most populous in the world central to a number of supply chains, so it makes sense… I extended the invitation to Prime Minister Modi in that context and he has accepted," Carney said on Friday while responding to a question on extending an invitation for the Summit to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. PM Modi also confirmed he would attend the G7 Summit in Canada. According to Vina Nadjibulla, Vice President of Research & Strategy at the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, 'having India at the G7 Summit matters to everybody else.' In an interview on CBC NN, Nadjibulla highlighted how there was a strong push from the other G7 countries to have India at the table. According to her, Canada is the outlier as other six members of the G7 are interested in deepening their strategic partnerships with India. 'In terms of the G7, we are the outlier because the other six members of the G7 are interested in deepening their strategic partnerships with India, deepening their defence technology and economic ties. In fact, every day there is a new announcement about either France of the UK or the US doing more with India,' she said. 'So, having India there also matters to everybody else. I think there was a strong push from other G6 to have India at the table. And I think in order for Canada also to be able to show relevance on the world stage, we can't just engage in diplomacy with those whom we like. I mean, diplomacy is not a gift to our friends. It's not a concession. It's a necessary tool to be able to advance our interests and defend our values,' Nadjibulla added. Experts say given the increasing economic heft of the country, India cannot be outside the major policy issues confronting the West, an opinion Canada's Carney seconded on Friday. India surpassed Japan to become the world's fourth-largest economy in May this year. At present, India's economy is bigger than all the G7 countries except the US and Germany. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's two visits to India have been 'instrumental in infusing momentum and depth in the bilateral agenda between India and Italy' in PM Modi's own words. Italy is India's fourth largest trading partner in the European Union, according to the Embassy of India, Rome, Italy. Bilateral trade between the two countries reached $14.56 billion in 2023-2024, with India's exports at $8.76 billion. An India Brand Equity Foundation report said that the Indian community in Italy (estimated at 2.5 lakh including PIOs) is the third largest community of Indians in Europe after the UK and the Netherlands. India ranks 15th as the country of origin of Italian imports, accounting for 1.5% of Italian imports, the report added. While attending the Group of Seven (G7) Summit in Italy last year, PM Modi held bilateral discussions with then UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak and French President Emmanuel Macron. UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy will be in India to further advance an ambitious UK-India relationship during talks with PM Modi and External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar. The visit follows the historic Free Trade Agreement agreed between the two countries and will deliver on this government's commitment to boost jobs and prosperity back in the UK, as part of the government's Plan for Change, a UK government's press release said on Saturday. The new deal with India is expected to increase bilateral trade by over £25 billion every year, UK GDP by £4.8 billion, and wages by £2.2 billion each year in the long run, the report added.
