OPINION: The Trojan Horse — Al Quds Day
In the coming weeks and months, courts in the U.S. will be deliberating one of the most consequential questions of our time: What is free speech? Perhaps an even more important part of the equation is: What is not free speech? This debate dates back to the renaissance in Europe and in many ways still rages on.
Case in point is Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian student at Columbia University, who allegedly carried his First Amendment right of free speech a bit too far and, according to authorities, got involved in organization and coordination of protests, often violent in nature, to support Hamas terrorism during the Gaza war. Khalil came to U.S. on a student visa and married a U.S. citizen to obtain his green card.
Not surprisingly, Khalil — who is awaiting trial on charges of vandalism and coordinating violent protests that targeted Jewish students and community — is hiding behind the same old time-tested agenda of 'supporting the Palestinian cause,' while explicitly supporting Hamas.
He is seeking to invoke his First Amendment rights. So, the courts in the U.S. will have an opportunity to settle, once and for all, what is free speech and what is protected under the First Amendment. Is hate and violent behaviour targeted against one community protected under the First Amendment? If a student is violating host country's laws and is engaged in coordinating hate-based violent protests, can he be still entitled to First Amendment rights? It's important to remember that the war he was protesting did not involve the host country and the community he was protesting against are law-abiding citizens of the host country.
During this Gaza war, Canadian streets and communities experienced far worse. The hate-fest and vandalism were not confined to campuses but involved shootings at two Jewish girl's schools in Toronto and a similar attack in Montreal, as well as the vandalization of businesses and synagogues. At University of Toronto, pro-Palestine encampments were displaying banners reading 'From the River to the Sea' – a Hamas war cry and a rejection of Israel's right to exist.
A lax approach to maintain order by city police forces across the country shredded the peace and Canadian values to smithereens.
The threats and bluster blaring out of loudspeakers by Hamas supporters on the streets was something extraordinary. The playbook is allegedly the same as Khalil's – Hamas supporters in Canada, too, are seeking refuge in free speech laws.
City law enforcement kind of grants a tacit approval to this behaviour without considering that a vast majority of Canadians are not Hamas fans, and they have their right to peaceful existence, too.
On Sunday, a hate fest called Al Quds Day took place in Toronto. Al Quds Day was started by Ayatullah Khomeini's decree in Iran with the signature slogans 'Death to America' and 'Death to Israel' to incite Iranians after the Islamic revolution of 1979. It was then exported as a Palestinian cause across the world.
The common-sense question is what is this festival of hate doing in Canada?
It has been going on for decades despite the fact that Canadian Parliament in its foreign interference report cited Iran's IRGC as foreign entity involved in undesirable activities on Canadian soil. Is it in accordance with Canadian values?
We are witness to how Islamist terrorism operates. Their standard operating procedure is wrapping their hate for the West and Jews in widely acceptable and benign notions of human rights and self-determination. The strategy reaps instant advantages of rallying public support behind a 'just cause' until the time comes when 'armed struggle becomes essential to achieve the just cause.' And armed struggle often means terrorist attacks on innocent civilians.
Events like Al Quds Day act as sounding board and kind of 'softening the soil' before the seeds of terrorism are sown.
Hope is that the U.S. and Canadian authorities have learned their lessons by witnessing the 'protests' during the last two years.
— Raheel Raza and Mohammad Rizwan are directors of the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
27 minutes ago
- New York Post
Amid the horrific rise in Jew-hatred, the US Holocaust Museum must reexamine its role
The murders of Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Milgrim in Washington and the attack on Jewish seniors, including Holocaust survivor Barbara Steinmetz, in Boulder, Colo., remind us that the lessons of the Holocaust remain unlearned. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum can help teach those lessons — if it concentrates on antisemitism as opposed to other hatreds, as it should, and goes beyond the Nazi horror. Advertisement Recall that the Holocaust occurred in European countries where ordinary citizens cooperated or stood indifferent to the mass murders of their neighbors. Today, after decades of proclaiming 'never again,' antisemitism in the US has hit a frightening new peak. The Holocaust Museum is supposed to educate about the dangers of antisemitism. Advertisement But as a proud member of its council, I know first-hand that it needs to do much more to fulfill that important role. The museum's weak connection to the Jewish people stems from its design, created when antisemitism seemed a thing of the past. Since then, it has shifted focus to combatting other forms of hate. The museum also provides no context of Jewish history before 1930 or after 1945. Advertisement And a planned multimillion-dollar renovation of the main exhibit hall could make the museum even more woke and disconnected. Frankly, the operation is in danger of becoming a liberal monument to the dangers of immigration enforcement and conservative politics. What the museum should be doing instead is teaching Americans that antisemitism is the world's oldest hatred, dating back 4,000 years when Nimrod is said to have thrown Abraham into a fiery furnace, and gaining steam with the rise of Christianity. More important, the museum needs to teach the story of Jewish survival; the founding of Israel in 1948, the wars of 1967 and 1973, and the Oct. 7, 2023, massacre. Advertisement It should cover pogroms that spurred the Zionist movement, helping make the case for the existence of a Jewish state. And it should emphasize America's cherished opportunities for Holocaust survivors and their families. Nineteen months after the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust, the museum lacks focus on the ongoing crisis. It reaches thousands of teachers and visitors but teaches broadly about hate, and not enough about antisemitism in particular. It fails, for example, to address antisemitism's recent surge, particularly at US universities. A Harvard-Harris poll in April found 51% of American 18- to 24-year-olds favored Hamas over Israel. Clearly, the museum needs to do a better job of reaching and teaching young people about Israel, Jewish history and current events. Indeed, no metric shows the museum contributing to any reduction in antisemitism. Sadly, all signs suggest it is failing in this regard. Advertisement The good news: President Donald Trump has made combatting antisemitism a priority and has begun cleaning house at the museum. Last month, he removed several Biden appointees, including Ron Klain, Doug Emhoff, Tom Perez, Susan Rice, Jon Finer and Anthony Bernal, none of whom were suited for the council. Rice had politicized Biden's National Strategy to Combat Antisemitism by excluding anti-Zionism and including Islamophobia. Advertisement Finer called members of the Israeli government 'abhorrent,' slamming it at a meeting with Arab American leaders in Dearborn, Mich., last year. Emhoff, appointed just three days before Trump took office, resisted his removal, claiming it 'dishonors the memory of 6 million Jews murdered by Nazis that this museum was created to preserve.' That's nonsense: Replacing these partisan figures has nothing to do with the 6 million murdered Jews, the Holocaust survivors or their descendants. On the other hand, the new council members appointed by President Trump will bring expertise from their careers as well as their skills and their important values. Advertisement Again, the US Holocaust Museum was created to preserve the memory of the Shoah and protect future generations from violent antisemitism. To accomplish this at a time when Jews face their biggest threats in decades requires greater oversight by the council and a broader, bolder outlook that addresses today's emerging problems. It's time to rethink the facility's role and what it is supposed to do to combat antisemitism. Advertisement It's time make the US Holocaust Museum great again. Martin Oliner, a lawyer and the son of Holocaust survivors, was mayor of Lawrence village from 2010 to 2016.
Chicago Tribune
33 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Mobile tolerance museum brings its anti-hate, anti-Semitism lessons to Jewish Festival in Morton Grove: ‘We need more of this'
The Greater Chicago Jewish Festival drew big crowds to the St. Paul Woods forest preserve area in Morton Grove Sunday for a day filled with community and family entertainment, and an exhibition from the Los Angeles-based Mobile Museum of Tolerance. The biennial festival included usual accoutrements of a summertime cultural festival, including dancing, live music, roasting food and crafts tables. But a standout was the security on hand. Signs near the entrance assured visitors undercover law enforcement would be patrolling, and uniformed officers from seven different agencies walked the grounds. The festival was fenced in and visitors had to pass through a security checkpoint. The mobile exhibit, which was displayed on a bus, is described by its owners as 'a self-contained classroom on wheels' that offered festival goers an opportunity to explore anti-hate and antisemitic workshops and other activities. The mobile museum arrived in the Cook County woods nearly two years after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel. On May 21, two Israeli embassy staff workers were fatally shot in Washington, D. C. And more recently, an Egyptian man is facing attempted murder and federal hate crime charges, accused of throwing Molotov cocktails at a group of people in Boulder, Colorado June 1 who were holding their weekly demonstration for the release of Israeli hostages in Gaza. 'Right now, it's a very tense time for the Jewish community,' Alliya Kazan said as she left the bus Sunday. A regular visitor to libraries, schools and community events since it launched in 2021, the exhibit teaches visitors about two recent periods of injustice, the Holocaust and the pre-Civil Rights Movement era in the South. Videos showcase interviews with people who lived through these pivotal times. Modern voices are also featured alongside video and photos from those events. Kazan said there's too much miscommunication across cultures and the exhibit's videos show how communities have in the past worked together during times of intolerance. 'We need more of this in the political discourse,' she said. Videos featured as part of the mobile museum don't mention the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks, much less the antisemitism that's happened since then, but visitors said that given all of the recent events, the exhibit's approach to history is welcoming. 'It was a very immersive experience,' Kazan said. 'It gives people the opportunity to have an immersive experience as opposed to just reading something and I think that's really great.' Another visitor, a man who didn't want to give his name given the political climate, said he hopes the mobile exhibit can bring people together. 'I'm here to be part of this, and in light of all the horror and tragedy that happens in the Jewish community, the community needs to stand together,' he said. The bus was accessible from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. at the festival. Elizabeth Blair, the mobile museum's education coordinator, said that after only a few hours of being open, hundreds of people had stopped by. She said that while the video presentation hasn't changed to incorporate specific recent world events, the headlines trickle into conversations that guests have after they visit the exhibit. 'In terms of people's comments, we're hearing people say we need this [mobile exhibit],' Blair said. 'They've been very supportive. … I've been sort of encouraged by the lack of pushback over the last few years.' The Mobile Museum of Tolerance will roll to the Grayslake Area Public Library June 19 the library's Juneteenth celebration.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump's Border Czar Dramatically Changes His Tune About Arresting Newsom
President Donald Trump's border czar is furiously backpedaling after suggesting California Governor Gavin Newsom could be arrested for interfering with the administration's crackdown on protesters in Los Angeles. Speaking to Fox News Monday morning, Tom Homan said that Newsom could 'absolutely' be arrested if found to have committed a crime such as impeding law enforcement, but claimed his original remarks on the matter were misconstrued by host Jacob Soboroff during an interview for MSNBC. 'He's just a joke. He's a dishonest reporter,' Homan said. 'I said many times, 'You can protest; you get your First Amendment rights'—but when you cross that line, you put your hands on an ICE officer, or you destroy property or impede law enforcement, or you're knowingly harboring and concealing an illegal alien, that's a crime. And the Trump administration is not going to tolerate it." Homan continued to recount the interaction. 'Then the reporter asked, 'Could Governor Newsom or Mayor [Karen] Bass be arrested?' I said, 'Well, no one's above the law. If they cross the line, commit a crime—absolutely, they can. So there was no discussion about arresting Newsom,' Homan added. Homan's original remarks to Soboroff on Saturday came amid widespread demonstrations and rioting across Los Angeles over federal immigration raids being carried out by Immigration and Customs Enforcement. In his remarks on MSNBC, Homan said anyone found obstructing immigration enforcement could face arrest and did not rule out Newsom or Bass being detained under such circumstances. 'I'll say it about anybody,' Homan told MSNBC. 'You cross that line—it's a felony to knowingly harbor and conceal an illegal alien. It's a felony to impede law enforcement doing their job.' Homan admitted that neither of the Democratic politicians is accused of breaking any law during the protests. Newsom called Homan's bluff in his own interview with Soboroff on Sunday. 'He's a tough guy—why doesn't he do that? He knows where to find me,' Newsom said. 'Arrest me. Let's get it over with, tough guy. I don't give a damn.' Newsom has also repeatedly attacked Trump for his response to the L.A. protests, which include deploying thousands of National Guard troops without prior approval from the state of California and posting inflammatory remarks that risk inflaming tensions. Elsewhere during his Fox News interview, Homan attacked Newsom for putting a negative spin on the immigration crackdowns in L.A. 'ICE took a lot of bad people off the street that day. We arrested a sexual predator, arrested gang members, arrested somebody that had an armed robbery conviction. So we made L.A. safer, but you're not hearing any of this,' Homan said. 'All you hear is rhetoric about ICE being racist and ICE being Nazis and terrorists, and Governor Newsom feeds that.'
