OPINION: The Trojan Horse — Al Quds Day
In the coming weeks and months, courts in the U.S. will be deliberating one of the most consequential questions of our time: What is free speech? Perhaps an even more important part of the equation is: What is not free speech? This debate dates back to the renaissance in Europe and in many ways still rages on.
Case in point is Mahmoud Khalil, a Palestinian student at Columbia University, who allegedly carried his First Amendment right of free speech a bit too far and, according to authorities, got involved in organization and coordination of protests, often violent in nature, to support Hamas terrorism during the Gaza war. Khalil came to U.S. on a student visa and married a U.S. citizen to obtain his green card.
Not surprisingly, Khalil — who is awaiting trial on charges of vandalism and coordinating violent protests that targeted Jewish students and community — is hiding behind the same old time-tested agenda of 'supporting the Palestinian cause,' while explicitly supporting Hamas.
He is seeking to invoke his First Amendment rights. So, the courts in the U.S. will have an opportunity to settle, once and for all, what is free speech and what is protected under the First Amendment. Is hate and violent behaviour targeted against one community protected under the First Amendment? If a student is violating host country's laws and is engaged in coordinating hate-based violent protests, can he be still entitled to First Amendment rights? It's important to remember that the war he was protesting did not involve the host country and the community he was protesting against are law-abiding citizens of the host country.
During this Gaza war, Canadian streets and communities experienced far worse. The hate-fest and vandalism were not confined to campuses but involved shootings at two Jewish girl's schools in Toronto and a similar attack in Montreal, as well as the vandalization of businesses and synagogues. At University of Toronto, pro-Palestine encampments were displaying banners reading 'From the River to the Sea' – a Hamas war cry and a rejection of Israel's right to exist.
A lax approach to maintain order by city police forces across the country shredded the peace and Canadian values to smithereens.
The threats and bluster blaring out of loudspeakers by Hamas supporters on the streets was something extraordinary. The playbook is allegedly the same as Khalil's – Hamas supporters in Canada, too, are seeking refuge in free speech laws.
City law enforcement kind of grants a tacit approval to this behaviour without considering that a vast majority of Canadians are not Hamas fans, and they have their right to peaceful existence, too.
On Sunday, a hate fest called Al Quds Day took place in Toronto. Al Quds Day was started by Ayatullah Khomeini's decree in Iran with the signature slogans 'Death to America' and 'Death to Israel' to incite Iranians after the Islamic revolution of 1979. It was then exported as a Palestinian cause across the world.
The common-sense question is what is this festival of hate doing in Canada?
It has been going on for decades despite the fact that Canadian Parliament in its foreign interference report cited Iran's IRGC as foreign entity involved in undesirable activities on Canadian soil. Is it in accordance with Canadian values?
We are witness to how Islamist terrorism operates. Their standard operating procedure is wrapping their hate for the West and Jews in widely acceptable and benign notions of human rights and self-determination. The strategy reaps instant advantages of rallying public support behind a 'just cause' until the time comes when 'armed struggle becomes essential to achieve the just cause.' And armed struggle often means terrorist attacks on innocent civilians.
Events like Al Quds Day act as sounding board and kind of 'softening the soil' before the seeds of terrorism are sown.
Hope is that the U.S. and Canadian authorities have learned their lessons by witnessing the 'protests' during the last two years.
— Raheel Raza and Mohammad Rizwan are directors of the Council of Muslims Against Antisemitism.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
37 minutes ago
- Boston Globe
At Globe tech summit, Healey criticizes Trump on LA protests, says she's open to evaluating millionaire's tax
Sending troops in without the support of state and local leaders , she added, had only 'inflamed tensions' and made the situation 'really dangerous for the public and ... for law enforcement.' Advertisement Healey's criticism Tuesday extended to Trump's other policies: She reiterated the impact of Trump's cuts to research funding, and threats to the legal status of international students, which have harmed the life science and higher education industries. 'We're seeing an outright assault on our economic infrastructure, and not only is that bad for Massachusetts, it's bad for America,' Healey said, calling it 'cruel' for the administration cut funding from life-saving research. The state, she said, is looking for 'ways for government to work with the business industry and team up and weather the storm.' Advertisement At one point, Healey indicated she could be open to undoing the so-called millionaire's tax, which placed an additional tax on earnings over $1 million after Massachusetts residents approved a constitutional amendment to do so two years ago. That change has since generated billions of dollars for education and transportation-related initiatives Healey said she supports, such as making community college tuition-free for Massachusetts residents. That tax has also drawn backlash, however, from some in the business community who lament the tax has driven wealthy residents from Massachusetts. While there is currently not a concerted effort to undo that tax, Healey said Massachusetts should re-examine 'what we need to do within our existing tax regime' to attract people to the state. Asked whether she would oppose efforts to overturn the tax, Healey demurred: 'No, I think we need to evaluate what's going on, and I want to see the numbers. I just want to see what's happening in terms of any potential outmigration.' Healey next week will host governors from New York, Maine, Rhode Island, and Vermont as well as several premiers from Canada in an effort to 'show that the US-Canadian relationship remains' as Trump has imposed tariffs on the country's northern neighbor. That area, Healey added, is another in which Trump is 'self-sabotaging the United States.' Anjali Huynh can be reached at
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Associated Press seeks full appeals court hearing on access to Trump administration events
The Associated Press on Tuesday asked for a hearing before the full U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, seeking to overturn a three-judge panel's ruling that allowed the Trump administration to continue blocking AP access to some presidential events — a four-month case that has raised questions about what level of journalistic access to the presidency the First Amendment permits. Three judges of that court on Friday, in a 2-1 decision, said it was OK for Trump to continue keeping AP journalists out of Oval Office or other small events out in retaliation over the news outlet's decision not to follow his lead in changing the Gulf of Mexico's name. He had sought a pause of a lower court's ruling in AP's favor in April that the administration was improperly punishing the news organization for the content of its speech. 'The decision of the appellate panel to pause the district court's order allows the White House to discriminate and retaliate over words it does not like, a violation of the First Amendment,' AP spokesman Patrick Maks said. 'We are seeking a rehearing of this decision by the full appellate court because an essential American principle is at stake.' A hearing before the full court would change the landscape — and possibly the outcome as well. The two judges who ruled in Trump's favor on Friday had been appointed to the bench by him. The full court consists of nine members appointed by Democratic presidents, and six by Republicans. The news outlet's access to events in the Oval Office and Air Force One was cut back starting in February after the AP said it would continue referring to the Gulf of Mexico in its copy, while noting Trump's wishes that it instead be renamed the Gulf of America. For decades, a reporter and photographer for the AP — a 179-year-old wire service whose material is sent to thousands of news outlets across the world and carried on its own website, reaching billions of people — had been part of a small-group 'pool' that covers a president in places where space is limited. ___ David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at and
Hamilton Spectator
an hour ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Minister flags concern over BC Ferries' construction deal with Chinese shipyard
British Columbia's transport minister says he has raised concerns with BC Ferries about its decision to have a Chinese shipyard build four new ferries for its passenger fleet, amid an ongoing trade conflict between Canada and China. Mike Farnworth says he's worried about procuring services from 'any country that is actively harming Canada's economy' with tariffs and protectionism. Farnworth's remarks come hours after the announcement by BC Ferries CEO Nicolas Jimenez that China Merchants Industry Weihai Shipyards had won the contract. Jimenez said he wasn't worried about geopolitical tensions between Canada and China, adding his primary focus was getting the province a good deal. Farnworth says in a statement that BC Ferries is an independent company, but he's disappointed 'more involvement from Canadian shipyards' wasn't part of the contract. The first vessel is expected to come into service in 2029 with the others following in six-month intervals. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 10, 2025.
