Supreme Court to hear Mt Messenger Public Works Act appeal
Tony and Debbie Pascoe.
Photo:
RNZ / Robin Martin
The Supreme Court will hear a penniless Taranaki farming couple's appeal against the compulsory acquisition of 11 hectares of their land for the Mt Messenger Bypass.
But the country's highest court has indicated the hearing would have a narrow focus.
New Plymouth's mayor denounced the move which he said would add
extra time and money
to the already over budget project.
The six-kilometre, $360 million bypass aims to deliver a safer, more resilient route north out of Taranaki, avoiding an existing steep and windy stretch of highway which includes a narrow tunnel.
NZ Transport Agency (NZTA) contractors were currently constructing the road from the southern and using a gondola to access the centre of the project because the Pascoe's land had not yet been secured.
In its decision to allow the Pascoes leave to appeal, the Supreme Court said a central question would be to decide whether it was permissible for negotiations prior to the compulsory acquisition of the couple's land under the Public Works Act to be undertaken by a contractor, rather than by the Minister for Land Information, Chris Penk, or his officials.
It would also examine whether outsourcing of negotiations to NZTA contractor The Property Group was consistent with the minister's statutory duty "to make every endeavour to negotiate in good faith".
Tony Pascoe, who owns a farm with his wife on the northern boundary of the project, said the decision to allow the appeal was significant for all landowners.
"Oh, it's huge. It's huge. This is huge for all land owners. To be off to the Supreme Court and then for them to also supply a barrister," he said. "Now the barrister's also asked the court to supply another counsel to be able to help her get this right.
"So, we're pretty happy about it. We don't know what's going to happen, but were pretty happy."
The courts had previously recognised
the Pascoes
- who face a $180,000 bill for legal costs from previous unsuccessful litigation - had little to no money.
The Supreme Court said due to the complexity and nature of the appeal a lawyer would be appointed to represent the couple.
Currently, the Pascoes were being offered $176,000 for the land required for the project and would need to relocate during construction because their home would become unliveable.
Tony Pascoe wanted the Public Works Act process in relationship to his land to
be restarted
.
If the Supreme Court agreed, he had a vision of the future.
"A home, a farm hub and an income anywhere on our property. To be able to relocate our home and farm hub, to put a new home or relocatable home on a place that's geo-teched and suitable to put there," he said.
"It's basically bloody easy but they've made it extremely hard for us."
Long-time supporter of the Pascoes Marie Gibbs said granting leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was significant.
"It shows that the issues around the Mt Messenger Bypass and the use of the Public Works Act are important not only for the Pascoes but also for every other landowner that faces having their land taken by force for a any sort of project like the bypass."
She hoped the case would improve the process.
"If the minister and LINZ are making every endeavour to negotiate in good faith to reach and agreement acceptable to the landowner then it's going to make the whole process less intimidating for landowners and they will actually get what they are entitled to."
Mt Messenger bypass protester Marie Gibbs.
Photo:
RNZ / Robin Martin
New Plymouth Mayor Neil Holdom had sympathy for the Pascoes, but said enough was enough.
"I do love that movie
The Castle
and I do believe everyone has a right to their day in court, but they shouldn't have the right to appeal a court's decision 15 or 16 times," Holdom said.
"And every single time, the court has found in favour of the project going ahead, but here we are again with another expensive delay."
New Plymouth Mayor Neil Holdom.
Photo:
RNZ / Robin Martin
Holdom wasn't sure if some of the people supporting the Pascoes had the couple's best interests at heart.
"This is a vital project linking Taranaki to the north and a small group of essentially vexatious litigants have cost Kiwis hundreds of millions of dollars and seven years by using every trick in the book to ensure they've had more than a dozen days in court."
Holdom said the latest appeal would also likely be unsuccessful and mean the loss of another construction season adding about $40 million to the project's ballooning costs.
Land Information and NZTA were unable to comment because the case was before the courts.
The appeal was set to be heard in October.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
11 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Former New Plymouth mayor remembered as a 'visionary'
Former New Plymouth mayor David "Daisy" Lean is being remembered as a "visionary" who injected a youthful energy into the role. Robin Martin reports. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.

RNZ News
41 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean remembered as a 'visonary'
Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean - seen here at the opening of the New Plymouth Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1984 - has died aged 76. Photo: Taranaki Daily News Former New Plymouth mayor David "Daisy" Lean is being remembered as a "visionary" who injected a youthful energy into the role. The 76-year-old, who died earlier this week, was one of the country's youngest ever mayors when elected in 1980 - at just 32 years of age. He wore the mayoral chains until 1992. Lean has been credited with halting the pumping of New Plymouth's untreated wastewater into the Tasman Sea and securing railway land critical to the city's celebrated Coastal Walkway among other achievements, including the construction of the Todd Aquatic Centre and TSB Stadium. Former New Plymouth mayor David Lean in his mayoral robe. Photo: Supplied Peter Tennent - who was mayor between 2001 and 2010 - had an abiding memory of Lean's ascent to the mayoralty in 1980. "I remember the Oakura Beach Carnival the previous year when Denny Sutherland was mayor, he wore a three-piece suit to present the sash to winner of the Miss Taranaki beach resorts competition. "The following year, we had a new young mayor by the name of David Lean and he was wearing a pair of speedos when he jumped up on stage and made the presentation to the winner." Tennent said Lean brought a new energy and focus to the role. "He was an awfully nice guy, supportive of me and others who've been privileged enough to represent this community and my heart goes out to his wife Janet and all of the family. They've lost a a wonderful family man." Lean had been a huge contributor to New Plymouth, he said. "He was man of vision, a man who believed that it was not appropriate that we pushed our wastewater straight into the ocean. That it was treated, it was a big issue when he was elected an awful lot of money, but I've got to say none of us would even think of dumping raw sewage into the ocean now." Kinsley Sampson was chief executive during David Lean's mayoralty and his right hand man. David Lean at the opening of the New Plymouth Wastewater Treatment Plant in 1984 with his wife Janet. Photo: Taranaki Daily News He remembered the young mayor famously drinking a glass of water from the wastewater treatment plant once it was commissioned. The stunt had a point. "There is still some argument about it, but what he drank was water that had been through the carousel plant and then before it went to the sea it was chlorinated so it was perfectly safe. "But what he had demonstrated was that we were now releasing germ-free water to the Tasman Sea via our outfall." Sampson said the Coastal Walkway was just a dream when Lean came to office. "But the New Zealand Railways decided to shift their marshalling yards and railway station from the where the wind wand is now and David was determined that we would buy that land because he wanted to turn the city to the sea again and create Puke Ariki Landing, the area where the wind wand is and the port to Waiwhakaiho River walkway." There were tough times too. In 1995, Lean was assaulted outside a restaurant he and wife Janet established after he lost the mayoralty. Sampson said it was a dark day. "In closing one evening, there was some unpleasant young men and it ended up in David being assaulted and he was hurt very, very badly and suffered brain damage which amongst other things affected his sense of taste and smell, but yeah ,that was pretty awful." But it did not end Lean's public service. David Lean in recent years. Photo: SUPPLIED / ANDY JACKSON He was the region's Civil Defence controller for 35 years, inaugural chair of Sport Taranaki, a long-time district health board member and still a current regional councillor after almost three decades on council. Taranaki Regional Council chairman Craig Williamson - who was to speak at Lean's funeral - said service was in his blood. "He just wanted to make a difference and he wanted to give back. He was also involved outside of politics with other organisations that are for the betterment of the community too. It was just his thing from way back in the day until now. He was a champion and a good friend and a good bloke. He'll be missed." A celebration of David Lean's life was to be held at Butlers Reef in Ōākura on Thursday. He was survived by this wife Janet, children Kirsten, Brooke, Greer and Kent, and seven grandchildren. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
41 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Lawyers sue govt over emissions reduction plan
environment 27 minutes ago Lawyers for Climate Action NZ have launched action against Climate Minister Simon Watts over country's emissions reduction plan. The group's executive director Jessica Palairet spoke to Corin Dann.