Film festival to premiere clergy sex abuse documentary partly based on Guardian reporting
A new documentary examining the Catholic clergy molestation scandal in New Orleans – based in part on journalism by the Guardian and its local reporting partner WWL Louisiana – is making its world premiere at London's Raindance film festival in June.
God As My Witness is also nominated for best feature-length documentary at the major film festival's 33rd edition, according to the movie's director, Lindsay Quinn Pitre.
The producer of the 82-minute film is Michael Brandner Sr, who in 2018 discovered a pile of what were essentially love letters to his younger brother, Scot, from a Roman Catholic priest named Brian Highfill. Scot – who was a teenager when he received the letters – never told anyone about them and died by suicide at age 29 in the early 1990s.
Michael presented the letters to New Orleans' Catholic archbishop, Gregory Aymond. In a recorded phone call between the men, Aymond told Brandner that the letters were likely grooming material but 'weren't explicit enough' to warrant Highfill's inclusion on a list released by the archdiocese that identified clergymen faced with substantial allegations of child molestation.
Aymond ultimately added Highfill to that list in October 2020 after WWL Louisiana and a reporter now at the Guardian questioned the archdiocese about at least three other victims who had reported their own allegations of sexual abuse at the hands of Highfill over the previous 18 years.
God As My Witness in part recounts the experiences of Brandner's family with Highfill, who died in 2021, and a number of people who endured being sexually molested as children by clergymen while growing up in the Catholic church in New Orleans. It also tells the stories of the attorneys who have advocated for clergy abuse survivors after the New Orleans church faced so many clerical molestation claims that it filed for federal bankruptcy protection in May 2020.
The case has cost the archdiocese more than $40m in fees but remained unresolved as the 26 June premiere of God As My Witness was announced.
Pitre recently told WWL Louisiana that the film is intentionally left 'open ended because this is still a growing process – it's still being unraveled in front of our eyes'.
Brandner said the clergy abuse survivors seeking to be made whole through the bankruptcy do not include 'the ones who didn't come forward or the ones that are deceased' – his younger brother among them.
'I think Scot is [speaking] right now through me,' Brandner told WWL Louisiana. 'I believe that with my entire heart.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Mahmoud Khalil: US judge denies release of detained Palestinian activist
A federal judge declined to order the release of Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil, a setback for the former Columbia University student days after a major ruling against the Trump administration's efforts to keep him detained. Khalil, a green-card holder who has not been charged with a crime, is one of the most high-profile people targeted by the US government's crackdown on pro-Palestinian campus activism. Despite key rulings in his favor, Khalil has been detained since March, missing the birth of his son. His advocates were hopeful earlier in the week that he was close to walking free. On Wednesday, Judge Michael E Farbiarz ruled the Trump administration could no longer detain Khalil on the basis of claims that he posed a threat to US foreign policy. The federal judge in New Jersey said efforts to deport him based on those grounds were likely unconstitutional. Farbiarz had given the US government until Friday morning to appeal against the order, which the Trump administration did not do. Khalil's lawyers then argued he must be released immediately, but the government said it would keep him detained in a remote detention facility in Louisiana. The administration argued it was authorized to continue detaining him based on alternative grounds – its allegations that he lied on his green-card application. On Friday, Farbiarz said Khalil's lawyers had failed to present enough evidence that detention based on the green-card claims was unlawful, suggesting attorneys for the 30-year-old activist could seek bail from a Louisiana immigration judge. Khalil's have strongly rejected the government's assertions about problems with his green-card application, arguing the claims were a pretext to keep him detained. 'Mahmoud Khalil was detained in retaliation for his advocacy for Palestinian rights,' Amy Greer, one of his attorneys, said in a statement on Friday evening. 'The government is now using cruel, transparent delay tactics to keep him away from his wife and newborn son ahead of their first Father's Day as a family. Instead of celebrating together, he is languishing in [immigration] detention as punishment for his advocacy on behalf of his fellow Palestinians. It is unjust, it is shocking, and it is disgraceful.' Khalil has previously disputed the notion that he omitted information on his application. In a filing last week, he maintained he was never employed by or served as an 'officer' of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees, as the administration claims, but completed an internship approved by the university as part of his graduate studies. Khalil said he also stopped working for the British embassy in Beirut in December 2022, when he moved to the US, despite the administration's claims that he had worked in the embassy's Syria office longer. The Friday ruling prolonging his detention came the same day a group of celebrity fathers filmed a video reading Khalil's letter to his newborn son. The Father's Day campaign, published by the American Civil Liberties Union, called for Khalil's freedom and included actors Mark Ruffalo, Mahershala Ali, Arian Moayed and Alex Winter. Earlier in the week, when there was a ruling in Khalil's favor, Dr Noor Abdalla, his wife, released a statement, saying: 'True justice would mean Mahmoud was never taken away from us in the first place, that no Palestinian father, from New York to Gaza, would have to endure the painful separation of prison walls like Mahmoud has. I will not rest until Mahmoud is free.' Marco Rubio, the US secretary of state, has previously claimed Khalil must be expelled because his continued presence would harm American foreign policy, an effort that civil rights advocates said was a blatant crackdown on lawful free speech.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Hiding in the fields - farm workers fearing deportation stay in California's shadows
The women crouch down motionless, kneeling between endless rows of fruit bushes, almost hidden from view."Are you from ICE?" one of the women, a farm worker in a hat and purple bandana, asks us assuring her that we're not with US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), which has been raiding nearby farms and arresting workers over the past week, she straightens her back, rising slightly out of the dirt."Have you seen any ICE vans? Are there patrol cars out there?" she asks, still unsure if we can be trusted and she can woman, an undocumented migrant from Mexico, has been picking berries in Oxnard, California since arriving in the US two years ago. It's a town which boasts of being the "strawberry capital of the world".As her work shift ended on Wednesday, she and her co-workers hid in the fields, waiting to be picked up by a friend and unsure whether it was safe to venture out into the parking the previous day, nine farms in the Oxnard area were visited by ICE agents, say local activists, but without search warrants they were denied entry and instead picked up people on the nearby streets, arresting 35. The workplace raids are part of President Donald Trump's goal of arresting 3,000 undocumented immigrants per day. On the campaign trail he had vowed to deport noncitizens accused of violent crimes, a promise that received widespread support, even among some Hispanics. But in Los Angeles there was a public backlash and street protests that sometimes turned violent, prompting him to controversially send in the military to the second largest city in the US."They treat us like criminals, but we only came here to work and have a better life," says the woman, who left her children behind in Mexico two years ago and hopes to return to them next year."We don't want to leave the house anymore. We don't want to go to the store. We're afraid they'll catch us." Large-scale raids on workplaces in California's agricultural heartland haven't been seen for the last 15 years, says Lucas Zucker, a community organiser in California's Central Coast that seems to have changed this past week."They are just sweeping through immigrant communities like Oxnard indiscriminately, looking for anyone they can find to meet their politically-driven quotas," he than 40% of US farmworkers are undocumented immigrants, according to a 2022 report by the US Department of Agriculture. In California, more than 75% are undocumented, according to the University of California, at farms and businesses that rely on the agricultural industry throughout California, and across the entire country, have ramped up this arrests have raised fears of shortages to America's food supply, if the migrants are arrested or forced into hiding, afraid to come to work. This impact has not been lost on the White House. Despite winning the election decisively after promising mass deportations, Trump on Thursday acknowledged the tough time his crackdown is inflicting on the farming sector."Our farmers are being hurt badly. You know, they have very good workers. They've worked for them for 20 years. They're not citizens, but they've turned out to be, you know, great."Who has been arrested by ICE under Trump?In April, he said that some migrants may be authorised to continue working in the US, on the condition that they have a formal recommendation from their employer and that they first leave the US. The result of one raid on Tuesday in Oxnard, a municipality 60 miles (100km) from downtown Los Angeles, can be seen in a video posted to Instagram by a local flower short clip shows a man running in a vast field of crops, through a haze of thick morning fog, as agents give chase on foot and in trucks. He is then seen falling to the ground, among the rows of plants, as agents move to arrest the BBC visited Oxnard on Wednesday, a US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) truck was seen parked outside an organic produce trucking company. A security guard insisted their visit was not related to immigration, saying: "This is not ICE. We would never let ICE in here."Many tractors and trucks sat idle surrounded by acres of farmland, as an unknown number of workers chose to stay and peril in Newsom's fight with TrumpJesus polished luxury cars in LA - then ICE showed upThe impact is having ripple effects on other businesses. Watching from her family's Mexican restaurant, Raquel Pérez saw masked CBP agents attempt to enter Boskovich Farms, a vegetable and herb packing facility across the her business, Casa Grande Cafe, has only one customer during the normally busy lunch hour, because farm workers have stayed home. She estimates that at least half of her normal clientele are undocumented."No one came in today," says her mother, Paula Pérez. "We're all on edge."Raquel says she's more concerned now for the future of the restaurant - serving chilaquiles, flan, and other Mexican delicacies - than she was during Covid, when her customers continued their work as usual, keeping the nation supplied with fresh foods."They don't realise the domino effect this is going to have," she says about the raids. Other companies around her that rely on agriculture have already been affected. The adjacent business buying and selling wooden pallets is closed, and a local car mechanic too."If the strawberries or vegetables aren't picked, that means there's gonna be nothing coming into the packing houses. Which means there's not gonna be no trucks to take the stuff." A migrant selling strawberries from his truck on the side of the road says the raids have already had a devastating effect - on both his business and his hopes of becoming a legal resident of the US."Fewer people are going out for trips, and they buy less from me," says Óscar, who comes from the Mexican state of Tlaxcala and, while undocumented himself, has children who were born in the US."I'm scared, but I can't stop going out to work. I have to provide for my family," he says.Óscar says he has been working to finalise his immigration status, but with ICE agents now waiting outside courthouses for migrants seeking to process paperwork, he's unsure of what to do next."There aren't many ways left to be here legally."
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Trump admin finds new reason to keep Columbia student in jail after judge ordered release
The Justice Department found a new legal rationale to keep Mahmoud Khalil in custody after a federal judge ordered that the Columbia University graduate be released. On Wednesday, New Jersey District Judge Michael E. Farbiarz said the Trump administration could no longer hold Khalil using an infrequently-cited law that he believes is likely unconstitutional. The law gives the secretary of state the power and discretion to order the deportation of any illegal immigrant who presents 'potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States.' The current secretary of state, Marco Rubio, invoked this law after Khalil's arrest in March, arguing that his continued presence in the country would undermine America's ability to combat anti-Semitism and its 'efforts to protect Jewish students from harassment and violence in the United States.' Khalil was involved in pro-Palestine protests on Columbia's campus in Manhattan, often serving as a conduit between university administrators and the students who had set up encampments to rail against Israel 's war in Gaza. The reason Rubio had to initially claim Khalil undermines US foreign policy goals is because Khalil is a legal permanent resident with a green card. Crucially, Judge Fabiarz did not immediately order the release of Khalil, instead giving Justice Department lawyers until Friday to respond and allowing them wiggle room to detain Khalil for other reasons. Secretary of State Marco Rubio initially said Khalil's detention was because he undermined America's ability to combat anti-Semitism and its 'efforts to protect Jewish students from harassment and violence in the United States' In a legal filing on Friday afternoon, the government has settled on a new reason to hold him at an ICE facility in Louisiana, where he's been for more than three months. The Trump administration claimed that Khalil lied on his green card application in March 2024 by failing to disclose his membership in certain organizations. Lawyers for the government said Khalil did not mention his work with a United Nations agency that assists Palestinian refugees. They also claim he didn't disclose his membership in Columbia University Apartheid Divest, a student group involved in the rowdy demonstrations at the college in 2023 and 2024. Finally, Khalil allegedly did not list his ongoing employment with the Syria Office in the British Embassy in Beirut, Lebanon, after 2022. Khalil's lawyers have acknowledged that he had an internship at the UN agency through Columbia, but argued that he considered it to be coursework, not a job. They have said Khalil wasn't officially part of Apartheid Divest but rather served as a mediator. They also claimed he took on this role after he had applied for permanent residency. They have also said that his employment in Syria ended when he said it did, a point the judge agreed with them on. The judge has yet to rule on the other two claims from the government. Khalil is married to US citizen Dr. Noor Abdalla and was in detention when his first child was born two months ago Marc Van Der Hout, one of Khalil's lawyers told The New York Times on Friday that the allegations against his client were 'completely bogus and completely retaliatory for his First Amendment activity, speaking out on what's going on in Gaza.' The protests Khalil participated in last spring became violent, eventually ending with students breaking into a building on campus and occupying it. NYPD officers retook the building by force and made 112 arrests. With the government's new three-pronged rationale for holding Khalil, the judge declined to release him in accordance with his Wednesday order. In his most recent order, the judge pointed out that Khalil's lawyers have not 'put forward factual evidence' rebutting the legality of detaining him on the basis of allegedly fudging his permanent residency application. The shifting legal strategy for Trump administration lawyers in this case has diverged from the political rhetoric used against Khalil by President Donald Trump himself. Right after Khalil's arrest, Trump said his detention was 'the first of many to come' before calling him a 'Radical Foreign Pro-Hamas Student.' The White House press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, accused Mr. Khalil of 'siding with terrorists.' So far, the Justice Department hasn't disclosed any possible connection between Khalil and Hamas, which attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, and killed around 1,200 civilians. Khalil is married to US citizen Dr. Noor Abdalla and was in detention when his first child was born two months ago.
