
Euphemistic Practices: The IDF, Killing Aid Workers And Self-Investigation
Few armed forces have managed to make murder and executions the stuff of procedural aberration rather than intentional practice. Killing civilians and unarmed personnel is the stuff of misreading and misunderstandings, albeit arrived at with good conscience. And so it was that the killing of 15 aid and emergency workers in Gaza by the Israeli Defense Forces on March 23 could be put down to 'professional failures, breaches or orders and a failure to fully report the incident', a finding identified by an investigation conducted by the same organisation into its own personnel.
In marking its own report card, and giving it a credible pass, the IDF found, using the dulling terms that make murder an afterthought, that the deaths were of minor if regretful consequence. While not explicitly libelling the dead workers, the official press release teeters on excuse and general exculpation, making it clear that, on March 23, 'the troops were conducting a vital mission aimed at targeting terrorists.' The killings took place 'in a hostile and dangerous combat zone, under a widespread threat to the operating troops.' The armed forces were presented with the dilemma of protecting medical and facilities (something the IDF has conspicuously failed to do), with the use by Hamas 'of such infrastructure for terrorism, including ambulances to transport terrorists and weapons.'
The thick insinuation that the aid workers were more or less asking for it by being there in the first place emerges with unadorned rawness. And to suggest claims of execution or the bounding of any of the murdered before or after shooting were 'blood libels and false accusations against IDF soldiers.'
The IDF press release leaves an impression of forced thoroughness. There had been 'extensive data collection from operational systems, the forces on the ground, and along the entire chain of command.' This had also included 'relevant operational orders and directives, footage from various surveillance systems active during the event, radio recordings.' There was even a reconstruction of the events, the personnel involved questioned.
The inquiry identified three shooting incidents: the first involving troops firing on an alleged Hamas vehicle; the second, involving firing on a fire truck and ambulances close to the area where the troops were operating after the deputy battalion commander identified the vehicles as 'employed by Hamas forces, who arrived to assist the first vehicle's passengers'; and the third involving an attack by the IDF on a Palestinian UN vehicle 'due to operational errors in breach of regulation.'
The inquiry did little to consider the damning evidence arising from a video of one of the slain workers, Red Crescent paramedic Rifaat Radwan, which prompted the IDF to change its initially fabricated story: that the vehicles had stealthily approached them without lights or markings in the menacing dark. It is hard to imagine, for instance, that 'the deputy commander did not initially recognize the vehicles as ambulances' given 'poor night visibility'. The vehicles were illuminated, the markings palpably visible. But no matter: of the fifteen Palestinians butchered that night, six were Hamas terrorists. None were armed, but that hardly mattered.
As for the subsequent gruesome treatment of the bodies, the inquiry also finds little fault. The battalion's covering of the aid workers in shallow graves was intended 'to prevent further harm' (well, they were dead, the harm well and truly done) while clearing the vehicles to allow 'civilian evacuation', another euphemism used by the public relations arm of the IDF to justify expulsions and displacement. Removing the bodies was deemed 'reasonable'; the crushing of the vehicles, suggesting the workings of guilty minds, was not. There had been no intention to 'to conceal the event, which was discussed with international organizations and the UN, including coordination for the removal of the bodies.'
In watering down the murderous significance of the killings, the matter of failings, breach of orders and inadequate reporting are eclipsed by the continued commitment to battle Hamas 'while upholding IDF values, operational discipline and orders.' The Golani Reconnaissance Battalion had acquitted itself well, 'operating with great distinction for a year and a half.' Troops had opened fire on 'suspects […] after perceiving an immediate and tangible threat.' This is what happens when students grade their own papers, without invigilation and supervision by an independent authority.
The consequence of the inquiry will be mild and, as the entire process has proven to be, bureaucratic in its self-justification. The execution of 15 Palestinian emergency workers on the blood ledger will get you the dismissal of a battalion deputy commander for 'incomplete and inaccurate reporting' and a reprimand for a brigade commanding officer, in this case the 14th Brigade. It's a calculus fantastically obscene, but it is one repeatedly used in various forms when it comes to slaying Palestinians and those who fall victim to the doctrine of expansive force taken by Israel after October 7, 2023.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
10 hours ago
- Scoop
Palestine Forum Of New Zealand Calls For Safe Passage Of Madleen And Urgent Sanctions Against Israel
The Palestine Forum of New Zealand strongly condemns the violent interception of the Madleen, a civilian aid vessel attempting to deliver essential humanitarian aid to the besieged people of Gaza, by the Israeli military. We demand the immediate safe passage of the vessel and call upon the New Zealand Government to urgently implement meaningful sanctions against Israel for its ongoing war crimes and illegal occupation of Palestine. 'The Madleen was carrying life-saving aid to a population enduring unimaginable suffering under Israel's illegal siege. Its interception is a flagrant violation of international law and a direct attack on humanitarian principles,' said a spokesperson for the Palestine Forum of New Zealand. The unlawful blockade of Gaza — now in its 18th year — has turned the region into what human rights organisations have described as the world's largest open-air prison. The systematic denial of aid, food, water, fuel, and medical supplies is part of Israel's ongoing campaign of collective punishment against the Palestinian people. Palestine Forum of New Zealand reiterates the following urgent demands: Immediate safe passage for the Madleen and all humanitarian vessels to Gaza. The New Zealand Government is to impose targeted sanctions against Israel, including an end to military, economic, and diplomatic cooperation. Support for the Unlawful Occupation of Palestine Sanctions Bill and pressure on Parliament to prioritise it for debate. Active support for international legal mechanisms, including the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court, to hold Israel accountable for its war crimes and crimes against humanity. 'Aotearoa cannot remain silent while innocent people are bombed, starved, and denied medical care. New Zealand has a proud history of standing on the side of justice — from opposing apartheid in South Africa to advocating for nuclear-free policies. It's time our government showed the same moral courage for Palestine,' the spokesperson added. The Palestine Forum of New Zealand stands in unwavering solidarity with the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, the Madleen crew, and the people of Gaza. It will continue to amplify the call for justice, dignity, and the right of return for all Palestinians.


Scoop
10 hours ago
- Scoop
Israeli Attack On Gaza Aid Flotilla Is State Piracy, Genocidal Violence — New Zealand's Silence Is Complicity
Today, in a staggering act of violence and defiance of international law, the Israeli military attacked and boarded the Madleen, a humanitarian flotilla attempting to deliver food and medical aid to the people of Gaza. The vessel was in international waters, carrying aid workers, doctors, journalists, and supplies desperately needed by a population Israel has systematically bombed, starved, and displaced. This was not a military confrontation. It was the assault of an unarmed civilian aid ship by a state acting with total impunity. This is piracy, it is state terror, and it is a genocidal act of war. A regime engaged in genocide would send sends drones and armed commandos to detain civilians in international waters. We are witnessing the total moral collapse of a state, supported for years by Western Governments to act with utter impunity, violate our global legal system, morality and principles. No amount of spin or military propaganda can hide the cruelty of deliberately starving a population, targeting children, bombing hospitals and bakeries, and then violently stopping others from bringing aid. This attack on the Madleen not a separate incident — it is part of the same campaign to eliminate Palestinian life, hope, and survival. It is why the International Court of Justice has already ruled that Israel is plausibly committing genocide. This is not complicated. Israel has no legal authority in international waters. Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), Israel's boarding of a civilian aid ship beyond its territorial waters is an act of piracy, unlawful kidnapping, forcible abduction and armed aggression. Under international humanitarian law, deliberately blocking aid to a population facing starvation is a war crime. Under the Genocide Convention, when a state intentionally denies food, water, and medicine to a population it is bombing and displacing, this constitutes part of a genocidal campaign. The silence of the New Zealand Government is no longer neutral, and it demonstrates a shocking lack of respect for international law, for human rights, and for the safety of global humanitarian workers. It reflects a broader decay in foreign policy — where selective outrage and Israeli exceptionalism undermine the credibility of everything New Zealand claims to stand for. We call on the New Zealand Government to: • Publicly condemn Israel's illegal assault on the Madleen and its passengers. • Demand the immediate release of all aid workers, journalists, and civilians abducted by Israeli forces. • Suspend all diplomatic, military, and trade cooperation with Israel until it complies with international law. • Support international accountability mechanisms, including referring Israel's crimes to the International Criminal Court and backing enforcement of the ICJ's provisional measures on genocide. This Has to Stop. This is not just a crisis in Gaza. It is a crisis of global morality, of international law, and of our basic shared humanity. We stand with the people of Gaza. We stand with the brave souls aboard the Madleen, and we demand an end to this madness before the world forgets what it means to be human. We need a government that stands for all that is right, not all that is wrong. Aid is not terrorism. International waters are not Israel's territory. And silence in the face of evil is complicity.


Otago Daily Times
16 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Israeli military boards charity ship bound for Gaza
Greta Thunberg is one of the activists on board the Freedom Flotilla Coalition's ship. File photo: Freedom Flotilla Coalition/via REUTERS Israeli forces have boarded a charity vessel attempting to reach the Gaza Strip in defiance of an Israeli naval blockade, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) said early on Monday. The British-flagged yacht Madleen, operated by the pro-Palestinian FFC, had departed from Sicily on June 6 and had hoped to reach Gaza later in the day, when the interception occurred, the group said on its Telegram account. Among those on board the boat are Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg and Rima Hassan, a French member of the European Parliament. The Israeli military had no immediate comment. Shortly before the FFC statement, the Israeli Foreign Ministry posted a video on X showing the Israeli Navy communicating with the Madleen over a loudspeaker, urging it to change course. "The maritime zone off the coast of Gaza is closed to naval traffic as part of a legal naval blockade," a soldier said. "If you wish to deliver humanitarian aid to the Gaza Strip, you are able to do so through the (Israeli) port of Ashdod." The yacht, with its 12-person crew, was carrying a symbolic shipment of humanitarian aid, including rice and baby formula. Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz ordered the military on Sunday to prevent the Madleen from reaching Gaza, calling the mission a propaganda effort in support of Hamas. Israel imposed a naval blockade on the coastal enclave after Hamas took control of Gaza in 2007. The blockade has remained in place through multiple conflicts, including the current war, which began after a Hamas-led assault on southern Israel on October 7, 2023, that killed more than 1,200 people, according to an Israeli tally. Gaza's health ministry says over 54,000 Palestinians have been killed since the start of Israel's military campaign. The United Nations has warned that most of Gaza's more than 2 million residents are facing famine. The Israeli government says the blockade is essential to prevent weapons from reaching Hamas.