$145K Italy trip ‘symbolic of deeper structural problems' at Ontario school board: report
A $145,000 Italy trip by a group of Ontario school trustees is 'symbolic of deeper structural problems' within the school board.
That statement was made in the findings of a third-party review into the July 2024 trip by trustees of Brant Haldimand Norfolk Catholic District School Board (BHNCDSB), and released Wednesday as part of a group of reports into several school boards' use of finances and resources.
The week-long $45,000 trip, which sparked intense scrutiny after reports of it surfaced in October, saw trustees buy $100,000 worth of artwork for a new high school under construction in Brantford, which is near Hamilton.
The costs incurred have since ballooned by $63,000 due to legal fees to manage the fallout, the government said Wednesday, bringing the total cost to $190,000.
'This review was prompted by intense public and media scrutiny around the four members of the board of Trustees' trip to Italy, an event that quickly became symbolic of deeper structural problems within the BHNCDSB,' the report, authored by lawyer Aaron Shull, reads.
Story continues below advertisement
'While the Italy trip itself drew widespread criticism for questionable expenditures and insufficient oversight, the central finding of this review is that the board's governance framework and practices are the core cause of the challenges facing the school board.
'In other words, the Italy trip was the symptom, structural governance practices were the cause.'
A 'tale of two boards'
Shull's review found what it called a 'tale of two boards.' It read that the day-to-day operations of BHNCDSB were run 'efficiently and positively' by an education director many interviewees praised.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
On the other side, the governance role of the board of trustees had 'notable dysfunction.'
'Rather than providing broad strategic oversight, certain trustees (though not all) ventured deeply into operational territory, often bypassing established processes and failing to bring relevant decisions before all members of the board,' the report found.
Story continues below advertisement
'The contrast between these two approaches, one guided by a respected director, and the other marked by trustee overreach, illuminates the core governance issues at hand.'
0:29
Ontario school trustees 'deeply regret' $145K Italy trip, vow to repay expenses
Shull's report made 18 recommendations, all of which the government said the school board must submit an implementation report on by May 23.
It is also being directed to repay the amounts owing for trustee travel expenses within 30 days and recoup the total funds spent on the art and artifacts purchased in Italy within 30 days.
Furthermore, BHNCDSB must attest to conducting its business only in meetings that are compliant with regulations and legislation, and submit a learning plan for trustees' professional development highlighting governance responsibilities.
The chair of the school board claimed in October that several donors were 'very interested' in footing the $100,000 bill for artwork it commissioned. Rick Petrella, who the Brantford Expositor recently reported is now on a leave of absence, apologized after reporting on the trip's expenses came to light, and said the group of trustees were committed to 'making things right.'
Story continues below advertisement
Newly appointed Education Minister Paul Calandra threatened further action against BHNCDSB if it did not meet its deadline when speaking to reporters Wednesday.
'If that board doesn't do what we are asking them to do, if they don't follow through on the additional recommendations, then I will use the tools that are available to me to take further action,' he said.
— with files from Isaac Callan
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
16 hours ago
- Global News
BC NDP take more heat from opposition over contracts for consultants, advisers
British Columbia's NDP government is taking more fire from the opposition BC Conservatives over contracts it has awarded to top advisers. The opposition is raising new questions after the province hired Dr. Tim Stainton's consultancy to review Community Living B.C. Stainton was one of the people who helped create the Crown corporation tasked with caring for some of B.C.'s most vulnerable people. CLBC's board is also chaired by former NDP cabinet minister Shane Simpson. 3:42 BC Conservatives question top mental health advisor's salary 'It seems that the NDP continues to go to the well with former ministers, former electeds. It makes you wonder how little confidence they have in their own current cabinet members when they have to do this,' BC Conservative finance critic Peter Milobar said. Story continues below advertisement 'And the bigger problem is the lack of transparency. Never a disclosure of how much they are getting paid, what the deliverable is expected.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The BC Conservatives are also flagging the appointment of former NDP environment minister George Heyman as a special advisor on public sector bargaining. Milobar noted that the province didn't announce the appointment — rather, it emerged when Heyman changed his LinkedIn profile. 'The former head of the (B.C. General Employees Union) BCGEU is now advising the government on how best to negotiate with the BCGEU, that's certainly going to work out well for the taxpayer, I am sure,' he said. The questions come as the province faces scrutiny over two other contracts. Premier David Eby terminated a contract with Michael Bryant halfway through its six-month term, saying media coverage had become a distraction from the work Bryant was meant to do advising on the future of the Downtown Eastside. 2:32 Decision to hire Downtown Eastside consultant under fire And on Thursday, the opposition raised concerns about a $1 million open-ended contract with Dr. Daniel Vigo, B.C.'s chief scientific adviser for psychiatry, toxic drugs and concurrent disorders. Story continues below advertisement Vigo has been instrumental in spearheading the NDP government's efforts at implementing involuntary treatment for people with severe mental health, addiction and brain injury issues. Health Minister Josie Osborne said Friday she believed Vigo's work is 'worth every penny.' 'Having an expert like Dr. Vigo come and provide advice to government and undertake a very methodical and studious examination of the data that is out there, looking with legal experts at the Mental Health Act … this is not something that can be replicated inside government,' she said. 'It is really important at this point in time that we have this expert advice. And the recommendations that Dr. Vigo and his team have put forward to government are actions we are already seeing underway.' As a part of Vigo's work, the province has now opened 28 beds in two involuntary care facilities, one at the South Fraser Pretrial Centre and one at the Alouette Homes in Maple Ridge, for people who are not in contact with the criminal justice system.
Global News
19 hours ago
- Global News
Canadian, European space agencies reaffirm relations amid political, economic anxiety
Economic and geopolitical turmoil is forcing the Canadian and European space agencies to work together more closely, the organizations' leaders said Friday as they signed a joint statement reaffirming their long-standing collaboration. At the Canadian Space Agency's headquarters south of Montreal, Josef Aschbacher, director general of the European Space Agency, said economic uncertainty and global conflict are pushing Europe's space sector to establish its autonomy — and reassert links with allies. 'If we are aiming to be more … independent, this does not mean that we want to isolate ourselves,' Aschbacher said. 'We want to be strong and autonomous in order to have partnerships with other agencies.' Canada is the European agency's only non-European co-operating state, and as such Canadian companies are granted privileged access to Europe's space market. Lisa Campbell, president of the Canadian Space Agency, said every dollar awarded to Canadian firms generates three dollars in return. Story continues below advertisement Leaders at both organizations signed a joint statement Friday reaffirming the agencies' close ties; Canada has had a deal with the European Space Agency since 1979. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Aschbacher's two-day visit to Canada is the first in a quarter century by a European space chief and included discussions with government and industry leaders. Defence spending is rising across the globe, and the United States is pressuring NATO members to increase their spending on defence, he said. 'We should not forget that defence is tightly linked with space because you do need communication, Earth observation capabilities and many other space technologies in order to work hand in hand.' As well, Aschbacher added that the United States' space agency — NASA — could be facing deep budget cuts. 'You have all seen the budget proposals that have been released as a very first proposal of the White House,' Aschbacher said. 'I can only say this is a work in progress: the budget negotiations are ongoing, but be assured that Europe and the European Space Agency will get out of this stronger, more autonomous, more independent.' Campbell said that in uncertain times it's important to reaffirm relationships with like-minded allies. Canada is a spacefaring nation, she added, from rovers to instruments to robotics that will be in demand around the world in low Earth orbit and in deep space. Canada is already a partner with NASA and ESA in the James Webb Telescope, the world's most powerful telescope. Story continues below advertisement 'We're resilient because we're quite confident that there's going to be a growing need for what we do in low Earth orbit and in deep space,' Campbell said. With a need for independent access to space, nascent launch capability involving commercial firms on the East Coast could come into play, she said. 'It's just a matter of time before Canada is a launching nation as well.'
Global News
20 hours ago
- Global News
Fewer Ontario cities will hit housing targets amidst ‘major crisis': minister
Ontario's housing minister is conceding that the number of new homes in the province is stuttering and his government won't be able to hand out incentive rewards to many cities for hitting their targets, but says he hopes new legislation will help. On Friday, Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing Rob Flack accepted that the number of new homes in Ontario was lagging far behind the targets the province set itself, calling the situation 'a major crisis' across Canada. 'I can tell you, housing starts are down, we know that,' Flack said at a news conference in Toronto. The Ford government has set itself a target of 1.5 million new homes by 2031, winning a large majority in the 2022 provincial election under the promise. To meet that target, Ontario needed to see an average of 150,000 new housing starts every year for the decade. Story continues below advertisement The province has yet to get close to that number — and created a funding pot and targets for cities to try and reach the goal. A chunk of $1.2 billion was set aside over three years to be handed out to cities, ranked by their success in building new homes. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Last year, Premier Doug Ford and his then-housing minister toured the province, presenting giant cheques to cities that had achieved their 2023 housing goals. That year, Ontario achieved its lower goal of 110,000 homes by adding 10,000 long-term care beds and 10,000 basement or backyard units to the statistics. Flack indicated that this year, even with beds and basements thrown in, the province wouldn't hit its goal. 'We're going to hand out some nice building faster cheques — not as many and not for as much this year as we did last year,' Flack said. 'That's why we came up with Bill 17 to build the conditions to build more homes, faster.' Data from the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation shows housing starts are currently down roughly 35 per cent year-over-year. Bill 17 is Flack's first major piece of housing legislation since becoming the minister in March. Among other changes, it takes aim at development charges, looking to standardize the fees homebuilders pay to municipalities and delay when they have to be handed over, in some cases. Story continues below advertisement Major parts of the legislation were agreed to by a major municipal association and a group representing homebuilders. Flack said he believed the legislation could begin to move the needle. He has said the goal of 1.5 million homes remains his target. 'We know the numbers are down, but if we don't make the changes like we did in Bill 17, we're never going to hit our targets,' he said. The minister also promised to release months-delayed housing data, which will show which cities have hit their targets and how many long-term care beds have been added to boost the headline figure.
