No inheritance benefits for adopted minors
LAHORE:
The Lahore High Court (LHC) has upheld a family court's ruling, declaring that biological parents have the preferential right to a child's custody, declaring the oral adoption arrangement unjustified.
The court further observed that the minor could not inherit from the adopter family, reinforcing the legal and Islamic principles governing guardianship and inheritance.
The case revolved around Ameer Hamza, a minor born on July 7, 2021, as the third son in his family. On the day of his birth, he was given in adoption to his father's maternal uncle and aunt, with the full consent of his biological parents and paternal grandparents.
The agreement hinged on a condition that if the biological parents were later blessed with another son, they would allow his adoption to the couple, who had three daughters but no sons.
However, after nearly 20 months, the biological mother filed a petition on April 14, 2023, seeking her son's custody, arguing that she had been coerced into the adoption agreement.
She stated that her consent was conditional, based on an assurance from the adopter family that she would be allowed unrestricted access to her child.
She alleged that the adopter family violated this agreement and, around 15 days before she filed the petition, forcibly took the minor away while he was with her.
During the proceedings, the adopter family presented a birth certificate showing the child's parentage under their names rather than the biological parents.
The counsel of the real family argued that as such, it is inviolable right of the real parents to seek custody of the minor being her natural guardian. Accordingly, the real family prayed that custody of the minor be conferred to the real parents and his birth certificate be also amended by incorporating their names.
The counsel for the adoptive family contended before the court that his clients have the deepest love for the minor, who, in turn, is profoundly attached to them and recognizes them as his parents.
He argued that his clients have left no stone unturned in ensuring a peaceful and flourishing life for the minor's well-being and have never created any impediment to the real parents' free access to meet him whenever they wished.
Furthermore, they are willing to undertake any additional arrangements to facilitate the real parents' access to the minor. Hence, he implored the court that the minor's best welfare lies with them, entitling them to retain his custody.
After framing issues and recording evidence, the family court held that, as an adopted child, the minor cannot inherit from the adoptive family, which is considered alien to him and falls within the prohibitory degree.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
21 hours ago
- Business Recorder
First responders say 14 injured by Iranian missile hit on Israeli home
JERUSALEM: Israel's emergency services said Saturday that an Iranian missile hit on a home in the country's northern region of Galilee near Haifa wounded 14 people, leaving one in a critical condition. 'Teams have reported 14 casualties at a two-storey home in the Western Galilee, including one in critical condition and the rest with varying levels of injury,' Israel's Magen David Adom agency said in a statement. An AFP journalist reported people took cover in community bomb shelters in the coastal Israeli city of Tel Aviv after alert sirens rang throughout the country. In Jerusalem and in the West Bank city of Hebron Iranian missiles lit up the night sky, many of them intercepted by Israel's air-defence system, other AFP journalists reported. Israel and Iran strike at each other in new wave of attacks Many people drove through red lights without stopping when military alerts instructed citizens to seek shelter. Israel's military censorship forbade journalists from sharing footage or the exact location of missile hits inside the country. Iran's initial waves of drone and missile strikes at Israel on Friday killed three people and wounded dozens more. Iran's attacks come in retaliation to Israel's massive strikes on the Islamic republic, which hit nuclear and military facilities, killed top commanders, nuclear scientists and dozens of civilians, and sought to destroy the country's defence capabilities. Israel's military said it had continued its unprecedented attack on Iran Saturday, striking the capital Tehran as well as an underground facility in the Islamic republic's west.
Business Recorder
21 hours ago
- Business Recorder
RTI doesn't extend to any legitimate privacy interest: LHC
LAHORE: The Lahore High Court (LHC) held that right to information (RTI) does not extend to any legitimate privacy interest and request for provision of information can validly be withheld which violates the privacy of an individual. The court passed this order in an Intra Court Appeal (ICA) of a citizen Shahbaz and burdened the appellant with special cost of rupees one million. The court held that the amount of special cost should be recovered as decree in favour of the respondent department. The court said that the single bench has rightly allowed the constitutional petition of the respondent department; however, the Punjab Information Commission passed the order in blatant excess of its jurisdiction, the court added. The court said the appellant made request for getting information qua disclosure of names of taxpayers and information regarding their properties but imparting of requisite information is subject to an unambiguous consent of said individuals; otherwise, the request could validly be regretted under Section 13 (1) (b) of the Act, the court added. The court observed that the privacy directly relates to an individual's personal life, such as his name, address, phone number, family details, medical history, financial status; etc., which has validly been safeguarded in almost every law, the court added. The court said that any legitimate privacy interest of an individual is protected under the Punjab Transparency and Right to Information Act and it can be withheld under Section 13 (1) (b) of the Act. The court said the right to information is primarily intended to give access to the citizen to the information gathered and maintained by public authorities to ensure that government is functioning in a transparent manner and accountable to the people it serves. The court; however, observed that the provisions of the Act gives the power to public information officer to refuse the application for access to information where such disclosure of information is likely to harm the legitimate privacy or interest of individual unless the person concerned has consented to disclosure of information. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
6 days ago
- Express Tribune
15 killed in Malaysia bus crash
A bus carrying university students back to their campus smashed into a minivan in northern Malaysia on Monday, killing at least 15 people, police and rescue services said. Thirteen victims died at the scene near the town of Gerik, on the busy East-West Highway near the Thai border, while two died in hospital. The accident is the deadliest in more than a decade on Malaysia's hazardous roads and came as students were returning to school after an Islamic public holiday over the weekend. "It looked like the bus had lost control and hit the (minivan) from behind," Perak State Police Chief Hisam Nordin said, based on initial investigations. Images from the scene taken by the fire and rescue department showed a green bus overturned on its right side with a smashed rear end cover, while the red minivan had slid into a ditch, with its windows blown out. "Some victims managed to get out on their own, some victims were thrown out while others were still (trapped) in the bus," the Perak state disaster management authority said in a statement.
