ECB would be selfish to offer Ben Stokes England ODI captaincy
Michael Vaughan believes it would be 'selfish' to hand Ben Stokes England's ODI captaincy, with reports suggesting he and Harry Brook could be offered a white-ball job split.
Brook recently served as deputy to Jos Buttler before the latter stood down and looks increasingly likely to take the reins of the T20 side.
The Yorkshireman is also a candidate for the 50-over job but it is almost impossible to play a leading role in all three England teams given the demands of the schedule.
Enter Stokes, who has proved a natural skipper in the Test arena and was publicly mooted as a cross-format option by Rob Key, the director of men's cricket.
While there is an obvious temptation to extend his partnership with Brendon McCullum in the limited-overs arena, where England have struggled badly since their heyday under Eoin Morgan, he is currently recovering from his second hamstring tear in the space of six months.
He retired from ODI cricket in 2022 to manage his workload and prioritise the Test team, later agreeing to return for the 2023 World Cup.
Vaughan has no doubt the 33-year-old would answer the call again but thinks it would be an irresponsible move.
Speaking at the MCC's Cowdrey Lecture at Lord's, he said: 'In a way, I think it's quite selfish to even consider him. He will say yes because he is Ben Stokes. He will do whatever England ask him to do. Just don't ask him and let him be.
'He gives absolutely everything, not just when he's playing for England but when he's training. He is all or nothing. It's an absolute nonsense to think that Ben Stokes is going to play white-ball cricket.'
England's first game of the summer is a one-off Test against Zimbabwe from May 22-25, with their white-ball campaign beginning four days later against the West Indies.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
14 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
England jeered after unimpressive win over minnows Andorra
England were booed after limping to a lifeless 1-0 win against Andorra as Thomas Tuchel's first away match in charge ended in forgettable and frustrating fashion. The German coach called for relentlessness and patience against the side 173rd in Fifa's world rankings but got neither as the stuttering Euro 2024 runners-up were jeered at the end of both halves. Advertisement This was the third time England have failed to score a first-half goal against Andorra in Barcelona, where the minnows kept out Steve McClaren's side in 2007 and Fabio Capello's team the following year. A 1-0 win for the #ThreeLions in Barcelona 👊 — England (@England) June 7, 2025 There was a breakthrough shortly after the break in both of those matches, just as there was in Saturday's World Cup qualifier when Harry Kane finally gave the 6,950 travelling fans something to cheer about. England's captain turned in lively Noni Madueke's cross in the 50th minute, yet the goals did not flow from that point and slow play brought further grumbles. Some fans made an early exit and there were more boos at the end of Tuchel's third win in charge. Advertisement The England boss had named an attack-minded line-up at the RCDE Stadium – where the match was held as Andorra's new ground was not quite ready – and saw his side boss 83 per cent of first-half possession. Jude Bellingham went close for England (Bradley Collyer/PA) But the Group K leaders were unable to turn dominance into a first-half opener as well-drilled, defence-minded Andorra held firm on a warm evening in Spain. Jude Bellingham saw a shot saved inside the opening minute and Curtis Jones soon saw an attempt blocked, with Ezri Konsa then denied a penalty despite being wrestled to the ground. Andorra goalkeeper Iker Alvarez looked uncertain at some set-pieces but produced some important stops, with his 14th-minute save from Madueke the most impressive. Advertisement Kane struck wide from close range and Bellingham saw an attempt through a crowd saved but England's play was lacking incision. England's Harry Kane celebrates with teammate Noni Madueke after scoring (Bradley Collyer/PA) Andorra's support whistled for half-time as Bellingham saw a flicked header held in stoppage time, which ended with boos from unimpressed England fans. It was not only the performance that some supporters expressed anger with as Prime Minister Keir Starmer copped some flak at points during the first half. Ricard Fernandez's attempt to score Andorra's first goal against England went well wide early in the second half and the visitors finally broke the deadlock in the 50th minute. Advertisement Jones slipped a ball through for stretching Kane to prod goalwards, with Madueke reacting quickest to Alvarez's save and sending a low ball back across for the skipper to stab home. England goal number 7️⃣2️⃣ for @HKane ⚽️🏴 — England (@England) June 7, 2025 Madueke was denied before Tuchel turned to Trent Alexander-Arnold and Eberechi Eze. The latter saw a header tipped over by Alvarez, increasing Andorran anticipation when substitute Guillaume Lopez skipped past Dan Burn to see a shot blocked by Konsa. Play petered out as some England fans made an early exit, understandably preferring to get their Saturday night started in Barcelona rather than see through a dreary conclusion. There was a chance at the death but Andorra escaped, England fans letting their annoyance known but later applauding the players. Advertisement
Daily Mirror
16 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Roy Keane left 'really disappointed' as Man Utd icon accuses England players
England beat Andorra 1-0 in a World Cup qualifier in Barcelona, but their dismal performance prompted criticism from Roy Keane, who accused them of getting bored Roy Keane accused England of showing a bad attitude and of getting bored in their limp 1-0 win over Andorra. The Three Lions made it three wins out of three for Thomas Tuchel in their World Cup qualifier in Barcelona on Saturday evening, but their performance left a lot to be desired. After a dreary first half, which saw England booed off, Harry Kane opened the scoring by tapping in Noni Madueke's cross. That ended up as the only goal, and moment of minor excitement, in the entire 93 minutes as Tuchel's players went through the motions against the minnows. It was an uninspiring performance from England, who didn't get going, and former Manchester United captain Keane was typically scathing in his post-match assessment. "We try to make excuses for England a little bit. Obviously it is the end of the season and it's been tough on the players," he said on ITV. "I thought, first half, was OK. But I felt when they scored the goal, they felt it was job done. READ MORE: England fans let Thomas Tuchel know their feelings as Harry Kane averts total humiliation "I was really disappointed with England's attitude after the goal went in. The manager can't be happy with that effort in the last half an hour. I know it's job done, but you still expect more from England. "Good goal from Kane - you can always rely on him - a really good ball from [Curtis] Jones - that bit of quality - but overall, and particularly in the second half, the attitude of the players, I didn't think was great." He added: "I worry when I see players getting bored. I felt some of the players got bored in the last half an hour and I don't like to see that. It's when the goal went in, it was job done. It's Andorra - go and get some more goals! "These players have to impress this manager, he's still new to the job. You show that with your attitude. Go and get some more goals! You're attacking players, you can't keep looking at Kane. Kane's been your main man for years, but the other attacking players have to say 'I have to have an impact here'." Tuchel agreed with Keane's take, giving an honest assessment of the performance to ITV. "I was most worried in the last 20 minutes because I did not like the attitude that we ended the game with," he said. "I didn't like the lack of urgency and it did not match the occasion. It is still a World Cup qualifier. We will let them know tomorrow what we want from them." Former England international Karen Carney said: "It started slow, and how you start the game, usually it's hard to bring up those levels and gears. And it did feel a bit like holiday mode. I said at the start make sure the tempo is high and it's not walking football. "I know it's hot, but the ball can still move fast. We didn't really see that today. I think Madueke was the only one who changed gear and saw a little bit of pace and energy." Former England goalkeeper Rob Green said on BBC Radio 5 Live: "It was sufficient. It had the feeling of a pre-season friendly. Everything lent itself to an England team sleepwalking through the game." Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
The Herald Scotland
29 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
England jeered after unimpressive win over minnows Andorra
This was the third time England have failed to score a first-half goal against Andorra in Barcelona, where the minnows kept out Steve McClaren's side in 2007 and Fabio Capello's team the following year. There was a breakthrough shortly after the break in both of those matches, just as there was in Saturday's World Cup qualifier when Harry Kane finally gave the 6,950 travelling fans something to cheer about. England's captain turned in lively Noni Madueke's cross in the 50th minute, yet the goals did not flow from that point and slow play brought further grumbles. Some fans made an early exit and there were more boos at the end of Tuchel's third win in charge. The England boss had named an attack-minded line-up at the RCDE Stadium – where the match was held as Andorra's new ground was not quite ready – and saw his side boss 83 per cent of first-half possession. Jude Bellingham went close for England (Bradley Collyer/PA) But the Group K leaders were unable to turn dominance into a first-half opener as well-drilled, defence-minded Andorra held firm on a warm evening in Spain. Jude Bellingham saw a shot saved inside the opening minute and Curtis Jones soon saw an attempt blocked, with Ezri Konsa then denied a penalty despite being wrestled to the ground. Andorra goalkeeper Iker Alvarez looked uncertain at some set-pieces but produced some important stops, with his 14th-minute save from Madueke the most impressive. Kane struck wide from close range and Bellingham saw an attempt through a crowd saved but England's play was lacking incision. England's Harry Kane celebrates with team-mate Noni Madueke after scoring (Bradley Collyer/PA) Andorra's support whistled for half-time as Bellingham saw a flicked header held in stoppage time, which ended with boos from unimpressed England fans. It was not only the performance that some supporters expressed anger with as Prime Minister Keir Starmer copped some flak at points during the first half. Ricard Fernandez's attempt to score Andorra's first goal against England went well wide early in the second half and the visitors finally broke the deadlock in the 50th minute. Jones slipped a ball through for stretching Kane to prod goalwards, with Madueke reacting quickest to Alvarez's save and sending a low ball back across for the skipper to stab home. Madueke was denied before Tuchel turned to Trent Alexander-Arnold and Eberechi Eze. The latter saw a header tipped over by Alvarez, increasing Andorran anticipation when substitute Guillaume Lopez skipped past Dan Burn to see a shot blocked by Konsa. Play petered out as some England fans made an early exit, understandably preferring to get their Saturday night started in Barcelona rather than see through a dreary conclusion. There was a chance at the death but Andorra escaped, England fans letting their annoyance known but later applauding the players.
