logo
AfD ‘extremist' label sets up political high-wire act for Merz

AfD ‘extremist' label sets up political high-wire act for Merz

The Guardian02-05-2025

The decision by Germany's domestic spy agency to call the far-right Alternative für Deutschland party 'extremist' amounts to the starkest move yet by authorities to try to stop the advance of the populist political force.
Friday's classification by the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV) will open up the possibility for the security services to monitor the country's largest opposition party, including by recruiting people to inform against it and enabling interception of its communications.
AfD leaders denounced it as a 'blow against democracy', and nothing short of an attempt to disfranchise the more than 10 million people who voted for it in February's election.
Its leaders vowed to take legal action against what they called 'defamatory' and 'politically motivated attacks'.
According to the experts who compiled the BfV's 1,100-page report, the AfD is 'a racist and anti-Muslim organisation', which, through its strict, ethnically and ancestrally defined version of who is German and who is not, 'deprecates whole sections of the population in Germany and infringes their human dignity'.
It has also 'incited irrational fears and hostility' in society, steering the blame towards individuals and groups, the report read.
In itself, the step is not much of a surprise, although the timing is. The outgoing interior minister, Nancy Faeser, made the bombshell announcement on what is effectively her last day in office.
Faeser said that 'there was no political influence on the assessment', despite the AfD's insistence to the contrary. But the move puts the incoming conservative-led government of Friedrich Merz under great pressure, as well as Faeser's Social Democrat colleagues, who will be the junior partners in the new coalition which gets to work next Tuesday.
On the back of the decision, Merz will now be responsible – on top of the myriad other challenges in his in-tray – for deciding whether and how to ban the AfD, a decision which will involve the most precarious of political tightrope walks.
Migration, Ukraine, Trump and an ailing economy are among the burgeoning issues that he will also have to tackle with urgency. The growing mood of dissatisfaction over these and other issues, exacerbated by the six months of political deadlock that followed the premature collapse of the previous government – which induced an added layer of nationwide ennui – has already caused the AfD to creep up in the polls.
Having won second place in February's election – doubling its previous result and making it the strongest opposition party, second only to the conservative CDU/CSU – in recent days, the AfD has come top of the polls for the first time ever.
The ruling by the BfV is unlikely to put people off supporting the AfD.
Finding a way to reduce the AfD has been at top of the agenda among all of the political parties since it emerged as a protest force of professors and academics in 2013 on the back of anger over the Euro bailouts. The challenge has only grown in importance, as the populists – morphing from anti-Euro to anti-migrant over time – have grown their success at the ballot box.
Merz would like to be seen as a pragmatic rationalist, aiming to reduce the AfD to what he refers to as the 'marginal phenomenon' it once was by addressing the nation's concerns, taking the wind out of the sails of the AfD's successful modus operandi of inciting fear and insecurity.
Tackling 'irregular' immigration is therefore at the top of his domestic agenda, as he seeks to address the topic viewed as having added the most fuel to the AfD's fire.
But many others believe it is too late for that, arguing that an extremist classification, followed by a ban, would be the only way to stop the flourishing party.
Others say such a move would be grave danger of backfiring, arguing that the AfD would turn such a branding by the state into their own 'seal of approval', which will serve to enhance its already strong sense of victimhood or martyrdom.
Merz's party, the CDU, has been torn over how to deal with the AfD. Merz tacitly cooperated with the party earlier this year – despite insisting he would not – to push migration policies through parliament. And on the local level, his party and the AfD have cooperated on issues such as a ruling that the German flag should be hoisted in schools.
Jens Spahn, Merz's close ally, recently prompted scorn by suggesting the AfD should be treated as a 'normal opposition party', arguing that excluding the party from parliamentary procedures only boosted its popularity.
Those who reject that approach say Friday's ruling will now give them more justification to block the party at every opportunity – but they argue that this will only work if a cross-party consensus prevails.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Donald Trump makes huge World War I blunder in fiery speech as LA riots rage
Donald Trump makes huge World War I blunder in fiery speech as LA riots rage

Daily Mirror

time41 minutes ago

  • Daily Mirror

Donald Trump makes huge World War I blunder in fiery speech as LA riots rage

Donald Trump made a huge blunder about World War I in a fiery speech at Fort Bragg, as the U.S. continues to be rocked by riots over the President's mass deportation order US President Donald Trump delivered a speech at Fort Bragg on Tuesday, as unrest continued in Los Angeles between protesters and ICE officials over his far-reaching deportation order. Fort Bragg, situated near Fayetteville, North Carolina, is home to the military's Special Operations Command, which includes elite units such as the Green Berets and Rangers. ‌ During his address, Trump made a significant historical blunder, claiming that many countries had recently commemorated the end of World War I, while the US did not participate in the celebrations, despite asserting "we're the ones who won the war." ‌ "Without us," Trump said, "You'd all be speaking German right now." "Maybe a little Japanese thrown in. But we won the war," he added. "We're gonna celebrate on Saturday." However, Trump's claim that citizens would have been speaking Japanese is inaccurate, as Japan was an ally of the US, France, Great Britain, Russia, and Italy against the Axis powers of Germany, Austria-Hungary, Bulgaria, and the Ottoman Empire, reports the Mirror US. It appears the President was actually referencing WW2, which was commemorated recently during VE celebrations. The end of WW1 is traditionally commemorated on "Armistice Day" on November 11 each year. The event at Fort Bragg was also attended by Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and Army Secretary Dan Driscoll, and included both active service members and their families. The speech comes ahead of the 250th anniversary of the army and coincidentally, Trump's 79th birthday, which will be marked with a parade in Washington, D.C. ‌ The city is bracing for a massive turnout at the parade this Saturday, with officials already setting up 18 miles of "anti-scale fencing" and deploying drones, despite the usual no-fly zone rules. City representatives have told The Associated Press they're expecting an "preparing for an enormous turnout." ‌ Secret Service's Matt McCool from the Washington Field Office is preparing for "hundreds of thousands" to line the streets, while military sources estimate around 200,000 will join the celebrations. "We have a ton of magnetometers," McCool said. "If a million people show up, then we're going to have some lines." To manage the expected crowds, 175 magnetometers will be in place at security checkpoints throughout the day and for the evening parade. ‌ Metropolitan Police Department Chief Pamela Smith has warned of "major impacts to traffic" and advises attendees to consider using the Metro instead of driving. "This is a significant event with a large footprint," she stressed. "We're relying on the public to be an extra set of ears and eyes for us." ‌ The event has hit the headlines as a National Special Security Event, with security measures on par with presidential inaugurations or state funerals. This elite status is reserved for high-profile functions drawing sizeable gatherings and the likelihood of significant protests, triggering an increased security collaboration between local officials, the FBI, Capitol Police, and the National Guard, all led by the watchful Secret Service. Officials are also on high alert for possible immigration-related protests, mirroring those in Los Angeles, potentially hitting D. C. 's streets. "We're paying attention, obviously, to what is happening there. We'll be ready," affirmed McCool, underlining the extensive preparations in place to manage any civil unrest.

Police attacked with fireworks on second night of violence in Northern Ireland
Police attacked with fireworks on second night of violence in Northern Ireland

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

Police attacked with fireworks on second night of violence in Northern Ireland

Police were attacked with fireworks during a second night of anti-migrant riots in Northern Ireland following the attempted rape of a teenage girl. Crowds of masked rioters launched fireworks at riot police in Ballymena, County Antrim, on Tuesday night. The disorder came a day after two 14-year-old boys, thought to be Romanian, appeared in court charged with the attempted rape of a girl. Fireworks and other projectiles were launched at police officers and their armoured land rovers as about 300 people gathered in the vicinity of Clonavon Terrace, in the town centre. A large fire was started by rioters shortly after 9pm in the middle of North Road, an A-road which overlooks the area. A water cannon and rubber bullets have been used against the rioters to contain the 'serious disorder'. The unrest has been condemned as 'racist thuggery' by police. Assistant Chief Constable Ryan Henderson said the violence was 'clearly racially motivated and targeted at our minority ethnic community and police'. A 29-year-old man has been charged with riotous behaviour following the disorder and will appear before Ballymena magistrates' court on Thursday. The victim's family condemned the riots, which were reminiscent of the disorder in England and Northern Ireland after the murder of three girls at a dance class in Southport last year. The Prime Minister's official spokesman said 'there is no justification for attacks on police officers while they continue to protect local communities'. Jim Allister, the North Antrim MP, said Ballymena had been 'overburdened' by 'unchecked migration', which was a source of 'past and future tensions'. On Monday, masked rioters threw petrol bombs, masonry, fireworks, and bricks at police after splitting from a peaceful vigil and setting up barricades in the Clonavon Terrace area of the town. Several officers needed hospital treatment and two police vehicles were damaged. Along Clonavon Terrace, six houses had their windows smashed, with two of them taped off after suffering significant fire damage. Those attacks are being treated as racially motivated hate crimes. In one video, one woman was recorded saying: 'If they are not local, let them f---ing stay there.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store