Precious crafts of thatching and violin-making are under threat
Your article on the sad decline in some British crafts
(Welsh thatching and ship figurehead carving added to UK crafts red list, 13 May) noted that 'thatched roofs in Wales are becoming 'more similar to English styles of thatch'. The Welsh style is different, with a rounder outside appearance.' There is in fact no such thing as 'Welsh' thatching, or 'English' come to that. In both the north and south of Wales, the craft has long shared styles with its English neighbours. Angular work in the north is also found in Lancashire and Cheshire, while rounded thatch in combed cereal straw in the very south is identical to that found in Somerset, Devon and Cornwall. This has been the case for at least two centuries.
The type of thatch seen in the photo published online with your article was common in south-west Wales, but the 'rolled gable' feature can be still found from Northamptonshire to Dumfries. The original straw roping on these Welsh roofs was also seen in Ireland, along with the decorative 'rope top' ridging, once widespread throughout Wales. In doing research for my website, thatchinginfo.com, I realised that the craft follows no political boundaries. The various traditional styles are essentially a combination of climate and material supply, perhaps combined with some very early folk movements.Graham CookMilborne Port, Somerset
Steven Morris's article prompts me to mention two severe blows that have hit the craft of violin-making and restoration in this country. The first was the recent death of Charles Beare, internationally renowned as the leading authority and connoisseur of violins, violas and cellos, and a lifelong, generous supporter of young makers. His passing leaves London very much the poorer as a world centre of expertise in this specialised field. The second blow is that the degree programme at the Newark School of Violin Making will not be running this year, apparently because there were not enough applicants.
Over the last 50 years, the Newark school, in Nottinghamshire, has nurtured a generation of people from all over the world dedicated to the craft, which can be traced back to the Tudor period in this country, and came to rival similar schools in Cremona, Italy, and Mittenwald, Germany. The abandonment of the violin-making course would be a great loss to craft and music.
I should add that my entire career in this fantastic trade was given to me by the Newark school and by Charles Beare. So I am biased, but particularly sad.John DilworthTwickenham, London
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
The 20 history books that everyone should read
Everyone should study history, and here are 20 books I think everyone should read. They are expressly not the 'best' history books ever written: no one can possibly have read the tens of thousands in English alone that would be required to begin forming such a judgment. But they are books that have greatly illuminated my understanding of history, and that in some cases took a remarkably original view of their subject. I have prized readability: no one will finish a turgid book unless forced to do so. Some are classics whose scholarship has long been superseded: but their place in historiography will never wane, and they show the regard for history of the era in which they were written. I have not included biographies or diaries, even though they often make a significant contribution to our understanding of history. The common theme of these books is that they fulfil a requirement for the successful study of history: they tell us why we are where we are. Jump to a particular era: Medieval to early modern The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (6 vols, 1776–89) by Edward Gibbon Gibbon was a formidable scholar of the classical and post-classical periods; his work stands up despite the discoveries of a further two and half centuries of scholarship. The Decline and Fall is a stunning work of literature, with superb prose, giving as good an account of the period from the first century AD to the late 16th century as you will find; and if Gibbon's reasoning about why Rome's power declined – too much decadence, and the baleful effect of Christianity – is questionable, he at least supports his arguments with evidence. He also has wonderful turns of phrase – 'the barbarian whom we condescend to style the Emperor of Morocco'. Gibbon writes about the foundation of our Western world: we must read him. by Steven Runciman This work has been as widely criticised as it has been praised, not least for its debunking of the romantic image of crusaders that had grown up in the 19th century. As in Gibbon, with which it overlaps, Runciman's history helps to describe some of the foundations of our own society, notably the continuing tension between Christianity and Islam. It is a well-researched and at times provocative book, and its great popularity owes much to the clarity with which it is written. Buy the book by Jonathan Sumption This contemporary epic has a claim to be the finest achievement by a living historian. One should read it because of the clear, reliable and deeply researched account it gives of English (and French) history in the 14th and 15th centuries, and particularly the lessons it teaches about the decline of English power. Sumption writes with a freshness and a clarity that highlight his percipience and make him easily comprehensible. Buy the book by James Anthony Froude Such is the popularity of the Tudors that there has been a tidal wave of books about them recently: some good, most mediocre, some dismal. Froude's magisterial epic, which covers 75 turbulent years from the late 1520s to the early 17th century, has an agenda: in the age of the Oxford Movement, it reasserts the righteousness of the Reformation. The section on Mary Tudor is in places so virulently rude as to be unwittingly entertaining. This is a forgotten gem. Buy the book 17th and 18th centuries by Blair Worden Tracing as it does the fissures in English society and politics over the preceding 350 years back to the civil wars of the 1640s, this book more than most tells us why we are where we are. Neither the execution of Charles I, the Restoration nor the Glorious Revolution ended anything: Worden shows us how the conflicts of the mid-17th century are still being played out. It is a revelatory and highly original book. by John Adamson The history books one most needs to read are those that prove that what one thought one knew for sure was, in fact, wrong. There were stalwart farmers from the Eastern Counties such as Cromwell who brought down Charles I: but the real motivation for the civil wars came from the aristocracy, as Adamson, with formidable research, proves. There simply is no better explanation of why the English fought themselves in the 1640s. Buy the book The History of England from the Accession of James II (5 vols, 1848–60) by Thomas Babington Macaulay Macaulay deals in depth with a period of just 17 years, from 1685 to 1702, the pivot being the Glorious Revolution. He has had numerous critics, not least because his is the definitive Whig history, detailing what the author regards as progress. But this was a time of modernisation and the creation of institutions, and a key epoch in history: and as well as the detail, Macaulay presents a magnificent work of literature. Buy the book by Thomas Carlyle Carlyle set out to counter what he termed 'dryasdust' historians, and although his work has been surpassed in scholarship in nearly 200 years, it remains a classic history. He did extensive research, but applied his imagination in a way no serious historian would dare today. At times, this book reads like a screenplay. It may no longer be definitive history, but is a landmark of our culture, and of our historiography. Buy the book 19th century by Fritz Stern This remarkable work of scholarship, by an American historian of Jewish-German birth, shows how the Second Reich was built thanks to a partnership between Otto von Bismarck and his Jewish financier, Gerson Bleichröder. Thus, inadvertently, were the foundations laid of a great power that helped precipitate the Great War, and the decades of strife, division and genocide that tore Europe apart thereafter. Stern is highly original and has the power to surprise, as well as to disturb. Buy the book The Expansion of England (1883) by JR Seeley Why did Britain have an empire? Read Seeley and he will tell you, complete with his legendary observation that 'we seem, as it were, to have conquered and peopled half the world in a fit of absence of mind.' His was probably the most influential history book of the late Victorian era, and tells readers of today much that we should understand about the Victorian cast of mind. Seeley foresaw that Britain might struggle to hold on to India, and that the Dominions might govern themselves: but he also saw empire as central to the fulfilment of the national destiny to be one of the world's great powers. We must read him to understand our recent past. by Owen Chadwick Religion is central to the history of the world; and to understand Britain and Europe, we must understand how central Christianity is to their history. Since Darwinism, that also entails the secularisation of society, the subject of Chadwick's comprehensive book, which becomes an intellectual history of the age not just of Darwin, but of Marx and John Stuart Mill, and the effect they all had on society and its institutions in removing religion from their forefront. Buy the book 20th century The Sleepwalkers: How Europe Went to War in 1914 (2012) by Christopher Clark Clark tore up the accepted view of the causes of the First World War, tracing a history of Central European tensions back to 1903, and arguing that all the main combatants stumbled into the war: it was not caused by the Germans. The important history to read is the well-researched type that defies what one is sure one knows: this is the model of such a book. Buy the book by Hew Strachan Twenty-four years later, we still await Sir Hew's second volume, but the first, which goes up to 1916, is a monumental masterpiece of research and writing. The detail and scholarship surpass any other book covering the opening phase of the Great War. It was a conflict that shaped all our lives, and Strachan provides a superlative way of understanding it. Buy the book by George Dangerfield Why, after it entered a coalition in 1915, did the Liberal party never govern Britain again? Dangerfield lists the badly conducted fights with the trades unions, Suffragettes, the House of Lords and the Ulster Unionists that undermined the Asquith administration; but with a wit and style that make his book outstandingly readable, and caused it to be hugely influential. It has been attacked for its analysis, but it's hard to fault its thesis. Buy the book English History 1914–1945 (1965) by AJP Taylor This was the final volume in the massive Oxford History of England, and partly because of Taylor's fame as a 'telly don', it sold more copies than all the rest put together. The book, however, has much more merit than the author's celebrity. It is a sharp picture of our country during the day before yesterday. It's both factual and provocative – and it is beautifully written. Taylor's description of Armistice Night, with couples 'copulating in shop doorways, celebrating, as it were, the triumph of life over death' is unforgettable. The Third Reich: A New History (2000) by Michael Burleigh Much writing about the Nazis is either biography, or focuses on specific aspects of the horror story. Michael Burleigh's account of the whole Hitler project remains unsurpassed after a quarter of a century. He tells the story in the context of a Europe-wide move to extremism after the First World War, and how the Germans in desperation to regain their self-esteem chose a madman supported by a group of self-interested gangsters, and backed him with a form of religious mania. It is an indispensable work. Buy the book The People's War: Britain 1939–45 (1969) by Angus Calder Calder's book, published when he was just 27, remains the outstanding popular history of Britain in the Second World War, though it is scrupulously academic in tone. It was profoundly researched and details everyday life during six years of total war with clarity and verve. For the contemporary reader, it is the perfect primer for our world. Buy the book France: The Dark Years: 1940–1944 (2001) by Julian Jackson This was the first detailed history of the German occupation of France, written by our most formidable historian of that country in the 20th century. It deals uncompromisingly not just with the French people's suffering, and their resistance, but also with their collaboration, a subject that 80 years after the war remains an open wound. Jackson took the testimonies of many who had lived through the nightmare, and his book is as authentic as it gets. Buy the book by Correlli Barnett The title of the first volume, The Collapse of British Power, sums up the thesis of the whole four: how the British ruling elite, which until mid-Victorian times had been hard-minded and possessed of hard will, became steadily more obsessed with ethical considerations and social guilt. A particular target is the Attlee administration and its undermining of the British spirit by creating a welfare state. Many will dispute the thesis, but the tetralogy is a candid picture of Britain in the 20th century, and its contentions demand consideration. Buy the book The End of History and the Last Man (1992) by Francis Fukuyama This is probably the most debated book of the last 40 years: Fukuyama argues that capitalism and liberal democracy had become so prevalent – he was writing as the Soviet bloc dissolved – that a centuries-long political argument had ended, and a norm for the future had been set. In a world of Putin, Xi and even the autocratic Trump, the analysis, more than 30 years later, looks rocky. But this remains an essential book for those who think about the course of history, even if it is becoming counterfactual, to show what might have been – and, perhaps, what one day still could be.
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Christmas star church in Coventry set for local listed status
A former Baptist church that has featured a distinctive Christmas star is set to be locally Hearsall Baptist Church, on Queensland Avenue in Coventry, first opened as a Sunday School in 1928 and became a church in building, which traditionally has a popular "Star of Hope" illuminated on its tower for Christmas, was nominated for locally-listed status last City Council is due to discuss the nomination at a meeting on Thursday, and a report submitted to the local authority has recommended that it endorses the listing. The listing applies to the Baptist church's original building, also known as Hearsall Church Hall, and not the modern-day church building on the same a building has locally-listed status, its heritage must be considered in any proposed redevelopment, although the move does not afford full statutory protection. 'Local identity' The church was nominated for local listing after a petition calling for the move attracted over 1000 signatures. Council officers said the Hall's "artistic and architectural value" meant the nomination should get the green added that the building also contributed to a sense of "local identity".Many respondents to the public consultation focused on their attachment to the Star of Hope, rather than the Hall itself, the report local listing would only cover the building as the star is "a moveable fixture", but the council had been made aware of a commitment from the church's new owners to ensure the star continues to be a local monument, the report said. Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Country diary 1925: Snipe fly to their own beat
NEW FOREST: Where the forest ends on the west with the River Avon you pass in a moment from forest to lush water-meadows, yellow just now with buttercups and yellow flags. A yellow wagtail was running on the banks, and in the bend of the river by the bridge we watched a family of coots. Above the yellow meadows snipe were flying to and fro, rising with quickly beating wings and their bright clipper-like note – their long bills silhouetted against the sky – and descending with the mechanical goat-like noise of their 'drumming.' One bird sat on a post calling continually, opening her bill to emit the sound; probably a mother bird calling to her young, but no young were visible. Going back to the forest we found more snipe in a stretch of ground fragrant with bog myrtle, near a little stream. By the bridge that crossed it were the triform leaves of the bog bean (Menyanthes trifoliata) in abundance. But we were too late for the flower, one of our loveliest, with its rosy buds and soft white fringe inside the fully opened flower. Only one withered flower head was left. Close by I found the pale, dark-veined marsh violet, but, oddly enough, growing in a dry gorse bush.
