
Revisiting Pacers-Celtics Aaron Nesmith trade: Memes to dreams. Who's laughing now?
The Tyrese Haliburton trade was franchise altering. The Pascal Siakam trade was transformational. But don't undersell the deal that sent Aaron Nesmith to the Pacers.
Nesmith plays with a chip on his shoulder. One firmly affixed there following his trade from Boston to Indiana in the summer of 2022.
The Celtics drafted Nesmith 14th overall in 2020, but their patience wore thin and swapped him and pieces to the Pacers for Malcolm Brogdon.
It was a trade many at the time lauded the Celtics and Brad Stevens for.
Boston robbed them. My god.
This is a robbery.
Pacers robbed in broad daylight.
You get the idea.
'It was a brilliant move for Stevens to acquire Brogdon without giving up one rotation player," Gary Washburn of The Boston Globe wrote following the trade. "Nesmith was an Ainge pick, and he never panned out as the pinpoint 3-point shooter he was projected to be coming out of Vanderbilt. Stevens told reporters last week Nesmith was an 'exceptional' shooter, but it did not translate to games.
'It was a troubling statement because Nesmith's struggles may be psychological and it became apparent it was time for a new team.'
In addition to Nesmith, Boston also sent Nik Stauskas, Daniel Theis, Juwan Morgan, Malik Fitts and a 2023 first-round pick to the Pacers.
One tweet in particular caught Nesmith's eye. Bleacher Report posted a SpongeBob SquarePants meme: "What the Celtics gave up for Brogdon," with an open hand with just a paperclip and spare string in the palm.
'As soon as the trade happened I saw the tweet and I saved it immediately,' Nesmith said in 2023. "I'm someone that takes things personally and I think that helps make me better. It's what makes me drive to the gym at night. Seeing that tweet is always on my mind for sure.'
Most of the trade grades skewed heavily in favor of the Celtics. But with time, it looks like a Pacers stroke of genius rather than a "Stevens masterclass."
Brogdon (14.9 ppg, 4.2 rpg, 3.7 apg) did go on to win Sixth Man of the Year, but only played one season in Boston. He was particularly poor in the Celtics' Eastern Conference Finals seven-game defeat to Miami, averaging just 5.7 points and 1.3 assists on 31% shooting, including 3-of-18 from behind the arc in the series. Boston upgraded in the 2023 offseason by sending Brogdon to Portland for Jrue Holiday.
With Holiday at point guard, the Celtics won the 2024 NBA Finals, while the oft-injured Brogdon has missed more games than played over the past two seasons with Portland and Washington.
Meanwhile, Nesmith has turned into a vital cog to an ever-improving Pacers team. He's averaged double-digit scoring each of his three seasons in Indiana, is a strong defender and just averaged a career-high 14.8 points and 6.4 rebounds in the Pacers' five-game series vs. the Bucks. His chase-down block on Bobby Portis in Game 4 was one of the standout moments of the series.
"He sacrificed himself, man," Pacers center Myles Turner said. "Landing on your back like that is not fun, but it sparked a big play for us. That's just not new for him. It's very on par for what Aaron Nesmith brings to our team. Just a hard-nosed guy. I think he does an amazing job of just selling out. He'll go out there and just put his body, his life on the line for the team."
"That's who Double-A is," Tyrese Haliburton added. "What he brings doesn't always show up on the scoresheet. Some people say, like, they're willing to die for this. Double-A is willing to die for this. He gives it his all every night and I think every team in the NBA wants a guy like Aaron Nesmith. Every team who wins big and ultimately wins it all always has a guy like Aaron Nesmith."
Let's take a look back at the trade grades and live reaction to the trade, which of course, favors the Pacers in hindsight.
∎ Andy Bailey, Bleacher Report: B+
"If this is the best they could get, great. Waiting for the trade deadline could've helped, but it also might've backfired. Given all the injuries Brogdon had suffered through over the last few years, another one in 2022-23 could've scared teams away from including any firsts. In this case, Indiana can at least tout that it got one, and Aaron Nesmith isn't a bad prospect to take a flier on."
∎ Michael Kaskey-Blomain, CBS Sports: B-
Called the Pacers' move a "prudent one" made with an eye toward the future.
"The pick probably won't be too high as the Celtics project to be very good again next season, but it's still valuable nonetheless. The argument could be made that they should have held onto Brodgon until the trade deadline in order to maximize his trade value, but that's simply speculation. The team found a deal they liked now, and moved on it. There's nothing wrong with that."
∎ Cole Huff, For The Win: B-
"Maybe Nesmith ends up being something. Theis could get flipped, but if not, he's a fine placeholder while the Pacers rebuild. Everyone else involved is unimportant. Nevertheless, I LIKE the trade for Indy but don't LOVE it."
∎ Michael Pina, Sports Illustrated: C+
"That haul isn't atrocious but was it really the best Indiana could do? Trades are complex negotiations and I'm sure they canvassed the league looking for some combination of young talent and draft capital. The list of interested teams that need a guard and are willing to shed both of those things for Brogdon might not have been so long, though."
"(Indiana is) a team that has a long way to go before they're good again. This was a decent enough move (albeit unspectacular) to get them where they want to go."
∎ Zach Harper, The Athletic: C-
"The Pacers could have done better here, but they're on their way to living in the depths of the lottery, and that's how they choose to reset.
"The problem I have with this return is the young guy the Pacers got isn't someone they couldn't have plucked out of the G League, the veteran role player is someone maybe they can flip for a second-round pick and the 2023 first-round pick doesn't give them a high likelihood of a definite contributor in the future."
Former IndyStar reporter Matthew VanTryon contributed to this story.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indianapolis Star
42 minutes ago
- Indianapolis Star
People protesting, Pacers fans and police gather in Indianapolis
Here's what it looks and sounds like outside of Gainbridge Arena as the Pacers get ready to play in Game 3 of the NBA Finals.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Puma Unveils Tyrese Haliburton Signature Sneaker Ahead of NBA Finals
NBA star Tyrese Haliburton is one of the major reasons the Indiana Pacers will be representing the Eastern Conference in the NBA Finals against the Oklahoma City Thunder, with Game 1 tipping off Thursday night on ABC. The 25-year-old Haliburton has not only played exceptionally well throughout this impressive Pacers' playoff run, he also happily embraced playing the role of the trolling villain to rabid Knicks fans under the bright lights at Madison Square Garden. Advertisement While the two-time NBA All-Star has always been a very good player, there probably hasn't been a time in Haliburton's five-year career where his name has been anywhere close to as hot as it's become over the last month. That's probably why Puma, who Haliburton signed a multi-year deal with before the season started, decided to strike while the iron's scorching hot and unveiled his signature sneaker literally hours before the start of the 2025 NBA Finals. This new line of signature Haliburton sneakers have been officially dubbed as The Puma Hali 1. What you're seeing in the above photos is The Puma Hali 1 "Hibiscus," which is reportedly set to release in September. Advertisement However, there won't be any kind of waiting game for Haliburton, who is expected to be debuting the signature shoe in the NBA Finals. "When I signed with Puma the first order of business was to sign a signature athlete," said respected designer Salehe Bembury, who also serves as VP of men's footwear at Versace. "They showed me a list of available and unavailable NBA athletes and told me to choose one to recruit. I chose Tyrese … He is him." Puma seems to have truly caught lightning in a bottle in choosing Haliburton, as he had just left Nike prior to this season. As of now, there has been no confirmed listed retail price for The Hali 1 "Hibiscus." Advertisement Haliburton and the Pacers are set to face the Oklahoma City Thunder in Game 1 of the NBA Finals on Thursday night at 8:30 p.m. ET on ABC. Related: Nike Makes Major Announcement for Sneaker Releases Puma Unveils Tyrese Haliburton Signature Sneaker Ahead of NBA Finals first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 5, 2025
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Caitlin Clark Refused to Sign Chicago Sky Fan's Merchandise
The Indiana Fever cruised to a dominant 79-52 win that was never in doubt over rival Chicago Sky on Saturday, June 7, impressively doing so without the services of injured star Caitlin Clark. Despite the game being played at Wintrust Arena in Chicago, prior to tip-off Clark was seen doling out a number of autographs for her many fans who opted to make the trip anyway, knowing full well Clark would not be playing. Advertisement But since the game was in Chicago, there were bound to be at least some autograph-seekers wearing Sky apparel. In rather humorous fashion, while the 23-year-old Clark was going down the line signing jerseys for delighted fans, she ran into one that was wearing a Chicago Sky t-shirt and more or less gave a "yeah, not happening" nod, quickly moving on to a fan wearing a "Fever 22" Clark t-shirt. It appeared to be all in good fun, though, as Clark gave a smile after the staunch denial while the Sky fan immediately began laughing, seemingly knowing she was probably taking a chance by serving up Sky merchandise for the Fever star to sign. Advertisement But the dismissal did kind of speak to Clark's renowned competitive nature—even when injured—with what's been somewhat of a media-driven rivalry between her and Sky star Angel Reese ever since the two entered the WNBA just a year ago. Related: Caitlin Clark Praised for What She Did Before Fever Defeated Angel Reese, Chicago Sky "I grew up loving rivalries," Clark said. "I grew up in Iowa. Iowa-Iowa State. That's like a pro matchup in the state of Iowa ... I think for the fans, it's great. They love it. I mean, Chicago is the closest team to us." In addition to the brief clip of the WNBA superstar opting out of signing some Sky merchandise, there was also a video over three minutes long of Clark signing autographs and posing for photos with fans before the game in Chicago, one that drew a packed house with nearly 20,000 in attendance. As for Clark's return to the court, she had stated it would become a "day-by-day" type of situation following Saturday's game against the Sky, and ultimately a decision left to what the Fever medical staff believes is the best course of action. Advertisement "I feel like I've made a lot of progress and I feel good, and I'm not going to rush coming back," Clark said. "It's just not worth it. But after this [past] weekend, I'll be reevaluated and we'll have a better idea of when I'll return." The Fever's next two games are against the Atlanta Dream on June 10 followed by a nationally televised game on ABC against the New York Liberty on June 14. Related: Puma Unveils Tyrese Haliburton Signature Sneaker Ahead of NBA Finals Caitlin Clark Refused to Sign Chicago Sky Fan's Merchandise first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 9, 2025