
Revisiting Pacers-Celtics Aaron Nesmith trade: Memes to dreams. Who's laughing now?
The Tyrese Haliburton trade was franchise altering. The Pascal Siakam trade was transformational. But don't undersell the deal that sent Aaron Nesmith to the Pacers.
Nesmith plays with a chip on his shoulder. One firmly affixed there following his trade from Boston to Indiana in the summer of 2022.
The Celtics drafted Nesmith 14th overall in 2020, but their patience wore thin and swapped him and pieces to the Pacers for Malcolm Brogdon.
It was a trade many at the time lauded the Celtics and Brad Stevens for.
Boston robbed them. My god.
This is a robbery.
Pacers robbed in broad daylight.
You get the idea.
'It was a brilliant move for Stevens to acquire Brogdon without giving up one rotation player," Gary Washburn of The Boston Globe wrote following the trade. "Nesmith was an Ainge pick, and he never panned out as the pinpoint 3-point shooter he was projected to be coming out of Vanderbilt. Stevens told reporters last week Nesmith was an 'exceptional' shooter, but it did not translate to games.
'It was a troubling statement because Nesmith's struggles may be psychological and it became apparent it was time for a new team.'
In addition to Nesmith, Boston also sent Nik Stauskas, Daniel Theis, Juwan Morgan, Malik Fitts and a 2023 first-round pick to the Pacers.
One tweet in particular caught Nesmith's eye. Bleacher Report posted a SpongeBob SquarePants meme: "What the Celtics gave up for Brogdon," with an open hand with just a paperclip and spare string in the palm.
'As soon as the trade happened I saw the tweet and I saved it immediately,' Nesmith said in 2023. "I'm someone that takes things personally and I think that helps make me better. It's what makes me drive to the gym at night. Seeing that tweet is always on my mind for sure.'
Most of the trade grades skewed heavily in favor of the Celtics. But with time, it looks like a Pacers stroke of genius rather than a "Stevens masterclass."
Brogdon (14.9 ppg, 4.2 rpg, 3.7 apg) did go on to win Sixth Man of the Year, but only played one season in Boston. He was particularly poor in the Celtics' Eastern Conference Finals seven-game defeat to Miami, averaging just 5.7 points and 1.3 assists on 31% shooting, including 3-of-18 from behind the arc in the series. Boston upgraded in the 2023 offseason by sending Brogdon to Portland for Jrue Holiday.
With Holiday at point guard, the Celtics won the 2024 NBA Finals, while the oft-injured Brogdon has missed more games than played over the past two seasons with Portland and Washington.
Meanwhile, Nesmith has turned into a vital cog to an ever-improving Pacers team. He's averaged double-digit scoring each of his three seasons in Indiana, is a strong defender and just averaged a career-high 14.8 points and 6.4 rebounds in the Pacers' five-game series vs. the Bucks. His chase-down block on Bobby Portis in Game 4 was one of the standout moments of the series.
"He sacrificed himself, man," Pacers center Myles Turner said. "Landing on your back like that is not fun, but it sparked a big play for us. That's just not new for him. It's very on par for what Aaron Nesmith brings to our team. Just a hard-nosed guy. I think he does an amazing job of just selling out. He'll go out there and just put his body, his life on the line for the team."
"That's who Double-A is," Tyrese Haliburton added. "What he brings doesn't always show up on the scoresheet. Some people say, like, they're willing to die for this. Double-A is willing to die for this. He gives it his all every night and I think every team in the NBA wants a guy like Aaron Nesmith. Every team who wins big and ultimately wins it all always has a guy like Aaron Nesmith."
Let's take a look back at the trade grades and live reaction to the trade, which of course, favors the Pacers in hindsight.
∎ Andy Bailey, Bleacher Report: B+
"If this is the best they could get, great. Waiting for the trade deadline could've helped, but it also might've backfired. Given all the injuries Brogdon had suffered through over the last few years, another one in 2022-23 could've scared teams away from including any firsts. In this case, Indiana can at least tout that it got one, and Aaron Nesmith isn't a bad prospect to take a flier on."
∎ Michael Kaskey-Blomain, CBS Sports: B-
Called the Pacers' move a "prudent one" made with an eye toward the future.
"The pick probably won't be too high as the Celtics project to be very good again next season, but it's still valuable nonetheless. The argument could be made that they should have held onto Brodgon until the trade deadline in order to maximize his trade value, but that's simply speculation. The team found a deal they liked now, and moved on it. There's nothing wrong with that."
∎ Cole Huff, For The Win: B-
"Maybe Nesmith ends up being something. Theis could get flipped, but if not, he's a fine placeholder while the Pacers rebuild. Everyone else involved is unimportant. Nevertheless, I LIKE the trade for Indy but don't LOVE it."
∎ Michael Pina, Sports Illustrated: C+
"That haul isn't atrocious but was it really the best Indiana could do? Trades are complex negotiations and I'm sure they canvassed the league looking for some combination of young talent and draft capital. The list of interested teams that need a guard and are willing to shed both of those things for Brogdon might not have been so long, though."
"(Indiana is) a team that has a long way to go before they're good again. This was a decent enough move (albeit unspectacular) to get them where they want to go."
∎ Zach Harper, The Athletic: C-
"The Pacers could have done better here, but they're on their way to living in the depths of the lottery, and that's how they choose to reset.
"The problem I have with this return is the young guy the Pacers got isn't someone they couldn't have plucked out of the G League, the veteran role player is someone maybe they can flip for a second-round pick and the 2023 first-round pick doesn't give them a high likelihood of a definite contributor in the future."
Former IndyStar reporter Matthew VanTryon contributed to this story.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Haliburton dismisses injury fears ahead of Thunder clash
Indiana Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton has played down fitness concerns ahead of Wednesday's NBA Finals game three with Oklahoma City (MATTHEW STOCKMAN) Indiana Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton shrugged off fitness fears on Tuesday as his team prepared to regain momentum against the Oklahoma City Thunder in game three of the NBA Finals. Haliburton was seen walking with a limp following Sunday's rout by the Thunder in game two following a lackluster performance in which he struggled to trouble the Oklahoma City defense. Advertisement Haliburton though insisted on Tuesday his fitness was not a concern as Indiana look to regain the lead after Sunday's loss left the series tied at 1-1. "I'm fine," Haliburton told reporters. "Really just a lower leg thing. I'll leave it at that. I don't think there's anything more to elaborate. "I feel fine and I'll be ready to go for Game 3." Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle said Haliburton was experiencing "some discomfort" but said that was to be expected as the gruelling eight-month season reached its climax. "At this time of year, I don't know if anybody's feeling perfect," Carlisle said of Haliburton. Advertisement "He practiced. He went through everything. I know he has some discomfort. He feels it. But each day it's getting better. I don't think you're going to hear him making a big deal out of it." Carlisle added that while "a couple" of Pacers players were under the weather, nothing would prevent them from lining up for the remainder of the series. "I don't think anything is going to keep these guys from playing in the game," Carlisle added. The Pacers coach was more preoccupied with drawing up a gameplan that can deliver a more consistent performance following an uneven start to the finals. Advertisement The Pacers have trailed for most of the opening two games, winning game one with a last-second Haliburton basket before being blown out in game two in what was almost a wire-to-wire Thunder win. "I think we've lost, at least by scoreboard, six out of eight or seven out of eight quarters," Carlisle said. "We're playing a great team. So we've got to make adjustments. We got to play better. "Everything that's already happened doesn't matter, other than the score of the series. We have to move forward. There's a lot of things we have to do better. We realize that." Pacers ace Pascal Siakam meanwhile said the key to reigniting the team's finals challenge would be disrupting Oklahoma City's offense and winning the battle for rebounds. Advertisement "We got to get stops. You get stops, you get in transition. That's the first thing," Siakam said. "We got to also get rebounds. If you can't do those two things, I don't think you can be successful in transition. "We know we can run. That's what we do. It's not really possible to run if you're not getting stops or you're not getting rebounds." rcw/jc
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Pacers return to home court: What Indy is doing to keep downtown safe
'Why can't basketball players go on vacation?' joked Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Chief Chris Bailey during a safety briefing outside Gainbridge Fieldhouse. 'Because they'll get called for traveling.' The joke encapsulated the excitement felt citywide as public safety officials prepare for thousands to head downtown ahead of the Pacers' first NBA finals home game in 25 years. "No one in our city will go without police protection despite the festivities going on," Bailey said on June 10. There will be increased police presence, he said, including officers on horseback and some 'in places that you will not see.' IMPD will also use drones, and Indiana State Police will provide resources as needed. Fans can opt into safety alerts by texting 'IndyFinals25' to 67283, said Jacob Spence, director of the Metropolitan Emergency Services Agency. Starting 4:30 p.m. June 11, there will be a soft ticketing checkpoint around the Fieldhouse, said CEO of Pacers Sports & Entertainment, Mel Raines. Guests will be required to show their tickets to access Morris Bicentennial Plaza and the stadium grounds. Security will be on the plaza outskirts, she said, and bike parking will be available outside the perimeter. Bailey said guests should expect traffic restrictions on South Pennsylvania Street and Delaware Street. He did not announce any definitive road closures, but said lanes will be open and shut as necessary. Live updates will be posted on IMPD's X account, he said. Beginning at 5 a.m. June 14, I-65 southbound will be closed through June 16 as part of the first in a series of weekend closures. Traffic can be detoured using I-465 and I-70. More about Game 3, Pacers vs. Thunder: Wednesday's Pacers game could snarl traffic in downtown Indianapolis. How to get around it. Residents should expect increased traffic June 11 and June 13 as watch parties will take place outside the soon-to-be-packed stadium. Somewhere between 1,000 and 1,500 watch party tickets will be available for purchase, likely on June 11, Raines said. Fans will have access to multiple screens, furniture and bars, she said. Watch party guests will not be able to enter the Fieldhouse. (*-if necessary; all games are ET and on ABC) Game 1: Pacers 111, Thunder 110 Game 2: Thunder 123, Pacers 107 Game 3, Wed., June 11: at Pacers, 8:30 p.m. Game 4, Fri., June 13: at Pacers, 8:30 p.m. Game 5, Mon., June 16: at Thunder, 8:30 p.m. *-Game 6, Thurs., June 19: at Pacers, 8:30 p.m. *-Game 7, Sun., June 22: at Thunder, 8 p.m. This article originally appeared on Indianapolis Star: Pacers vs Thunder Game 3: What downtown Indianapolis should know
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
1 trade Boston Red Sox must avoid making before 2025 deadline
The post 1 trade Boston Red Sox must avoid making before 2025 deadline appeared first on ClutchPoints. The Boston Red Sox are four games under .500, and they sit 9.0 games back in the American League East division. However, the Red Sox are just 4.5 games back in the Wild Card race. There is still plenty of time for Boston to make some noise with the Summer just getting started. The one problem for the Red Sox right now is they are without one of their best hitters, Alex Bregman. Bregman suffered a strained quad, and he has been out for quite some time. The bad news for Boston is Bregman is still a long time away from returning to the diamond. However, the Red Sox did promote top prospect Roman Anthony, and prospect Marcelo Meyer has not been play too bad. Boston will need some other players to step up a little bit more, especially on the mound. With that in mind, there is no need for the team to panic heading into the dog days of the season. The Red Sox do not need to necessarily become buyers at the deadline, but they should definitely not be sellers. In fact, there is one player that has been thrown around in trade conversations recently that Boston needs to hang on to. As mentioned, the Red Sox are not out of the playoff picture just yet. There have been plenty of teams in history to start a season under .500 and still make the postseason. Just last year, the Detroit Tigers started the year 37-44 through their first 81 games. When the Washington Nationals won the World Series in 2019, they started the season off 19-31. The Tigers fell short last year, but making the playoffs should be the goal for Boston. Once the postseason starts, anything can happen. In order for the Red Sox to get to the postseason, they need their pitchers to get better. On the season, Boston's starting pitchers have the fifth-highest ERA (4.59), sixth-highest WHIP (1.41), and the third-highest batting average against (.271). The starting pitching has been the biggest problem for the team, and it needs to be addressed. If the Red Sox can fix their problems on the mound, there is a chance for them to make the playoffs in 2025. Jarren Duran is slashing .271/.324/.421 with four home runs, 37 RBI, 37 runs scored, and 79 total hits in 67 games played. The left fielder has been great for the Red Sox this year, and he still has four years of team control. If a team were to trade for Duran, Boston would get a fantastic return. They would be able to rebuild their pitching staff, or get a couple more top prospect hitters. However, that would not be the smart move for the Major League team or the organization. The Red Sox need to hang on to their star left fielder. He is the future in the outfield for Boston, and has the potential to be a building block for the Red Sox to get back to the Fall Classic. The team has to find a way to keep competing with the New York Yankees and the rest of the division. Duran is going to be a big part of that. If Boston needs to trade some players this season, there are plenty of options. Jarren Duran should not be one of those options. Related: Ken Rosenthal's Red Sox truth bomb after Roman Anthony promotion Related: Red Sox rookie Roman Anthony gets brutally honest on embarrassing gaffe in debut