Business Leadership SA slams Transnet's new wage agreement as leadership failure
Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA) has criticised Transnet's new wage agreement with unions
Image: Leon Lestrade/ Independent Newspapers
Business Leadership South Africa (BLSA) has criticised Transnet's new wage agreement with unions, calling it a failure of leadership and warning that it undermines the country's economic recovery.
Last week IOL reported that Transnet concluded a three-year wage agreement with its recognised unions, SATAWU and UNTU, securing a 6% annual salary increase for workers over the next three years.
The deal also includes increases to key benefits such as pension contributions, medical aid, housing allowances, and the 13th cheque.
According to the state-owned freight and rail company, the deal came after the "conclusion of a conciliation process led by the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration (CCMA)".
BLSA President Busiswe Mavuso criticised Transnet's decision to provide an above-inflation increase to workers, saying that the agreement overlooks the country's weak economic growth, rising debt, and Transnet's poor performance record.
"I was astounded to see the news last week of Transnet's capitulation to union strike threats, agreeing to give workers 6% pay rises in each of the next three years. This agreement represents a failure of leadership on both sides – militant unions holding the country hostage with strike threats, and management caving to their demands without a fight," Mavuso said.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
She added that the increases come at a time when inflation is running at 2.7%, and the economy is expected to grow by only 1.4% this year.
'While South African businesses slash costs and workers face retrenchments, Transnet workers will get pay rises that are double the inflation rate, funded by taxpayers already struggling to make ends meet.'
Mavuso also pointed to Transnet's operational inefficiencies, citing an estimate from Professor Jan Havenga of Stellenbosch University that poor logistics performance is costing the South African economy R1 billion per da.
In a letter following the wage agreement reached last week, SATAWU defended the agreement by emphasising that it accepted the CCMA's proposal for a 0.5% increase in the third year, which would raise the final year's increase to 6%.
'Our correspondence dated 21 May 2025 stated that the union was prepared to accept the additional 0.5% increase,' the union said.
SATAWU also argued that the final agreement reflected existing provisions and legal frameworks already in place between Transnet and organised labour.
"When comparing the original retrenchment clause and the one contained in the final wage offer, it is evident that there is no significant difference, but only a reformulation of existing provisions. The only notable amendment in the final collective agreement is the additional 0.5% increase in Year 3".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
9 minutes ago
- Daily Maverick
Xenophobia spits on the freedom of all who live in SA (Part Two)
We need to understand and spread the notion that freedom belongs to all, it is not a freedom where some people are excluded. Part Two of a two-part series on xenophobia and democracy. Most xenophobic conflicts portray sections of the community as being extremely hostile towards foreign nationals. But there is some ambiguity, especially in urban areas where South African traders have tensions with foreign traders. What has happened is that communities form relationships with the traders that are capable of more than one interpretation. On the one hand, they are seen – by many who have testified – as often being beneficial to local communities, offering goods at lower prices than South African traders or providing credit to communities and keeping their shops open for long hours. This creates a bond between them and the foreign traders, who can lower prices through their sharing resources with other traders in bulk buying. However, this bond with communities is not without ambiguity, as there are also instances where the same people who speak highly of foreign traders act opportunistically during attacks against them and join other looters in robbing them. This has been admitted by members of many local communities and is documented in media records. Additionally, when local traders in the Western Cape claimed that foreign traders had an advantage they couldn't compete with, some foreign traders offered to train local traders in what they knew and practised, and in business practices the local traders did not practice or know. This was documented by Professor Heribert Adam of Canada. It is not at all established that foreign traders use unfair methods to succeed in their trade. What is important to note is that the success they have is in an extremely unfair situation where they have a fragile presence in communities. They think it is safe, but time and again, that safety is shattered by incidents, as we have seen in recent months. The truth of the matter is that the relationship between foreign traders and communities does not conform to one narrative. Many of these foreign traders provide services that other trading outlets do not offer. They are willing to give credit in many cases, and if they sell cigarettes or similar small items, they do not necessarily expect patrons to buy a full packet. They may sell one cigarette at a are open for long hours, early in the morning before children go to school, and late at night, and this is the pattern of work which has often integrated the traders into local communities. On the other hand, when there are attacks on such traders and someone has broken the security of their shops, local people – sometimes ones who have formed close relationships with these traders – also engage in the looting that follows. In other words, the same individuals who do not want the traders to leave because of the way they operate, indulge in looting. They do not think it is legitimate to attack the shops, but at the same time, because of their poverty and vulnerability, such people are often willing to engage in the raids. They feel a bit ashamed of or embarrassed by it, but they nevertheless do it. Xenophobia violates foundational humanistic values There are many violations of various kinds that go unpunished in South Africa – notably the Marikana massacre, and killings that demonstrate indifference to human lives. While we must demand the return to foundational humanistic values and abiding by the law, there is no doubt that the impact of repeated violations casts doubt on the current standing of the law. There is not a strong force or understanding of advancing rights and duties for all, and especially for foreign migrants in South Africa today. How we relate to xenophobia cannot simply be individualised as in calling for the removal of specific actors or perpetrators from public positions they may hold. We cannot restrict ourselves to who should be in the Cabinet – while it is desirable to remove such people from public posts, we also need to advance a set of values that explain what is at stake. Spirituality There is sometimes recourse to spiritual underpinnings to advance a non-xenophobic stance. In almost all spiritualities there are notions like 'Jesus was a refugee', 'welcome the stranger', or ubuntu, evoking notions of universalism. The church and other faith-based bodies can have an important impact on this limiting of xenophobia. Both the present pope, Leo XIV, and his immediate predecessor, the late Pope Francis, provided messages calling for respect and compassion. Limited legal basis Acting against these foreign nationals is illegal and reinforces insecurity. Foreign nationals who are legally present should be secure, with their legal rights secured, and those allegedly without papers are also entitled to due process and not subjected to being automatically thrown in prison or deported. When xenophobes want to justify their actions or sentiments, they tend to refer to legal reasons for curbing the presence of foreign nationals, or the porous borders we have. In fact, when foreign traders or workers are attacked, attackers do not follow legal prescripts or try to examine the legal basis for removal of these people, compared with others whose presence is acknowledged to have a legal basis. Most of the time there is not a substantial distinction between those with a legal basis for their presence in South Africa and 'illegals'. Attackers generally do not ask (or have the authority to ask) who among the migrants have a legal basis for being in South Africa, and ignore what qualities create a legal basis. It may be ('may' because there are no statistics) that xenophobia is no longer a phenomenon emanating from individuals – it may be that attacking foreign nationals may now be a phenomenon that enjoys popular support, even in areas with a significant Struggle background like Atteridgeville and parts of the East Rand. This is a dangerous phenomenon, deriving from a politics that is indifferent to ethical questions. The problem of xenophobia and the need for moral clarity in South Africa It is important that we should not restrict our commentary on Minister of Sport, Arts and Culture, Gayton McKenzie's outburst, to whether or not he should remain a member of the Cabinet. McKenzie might be removed, although it seems unlikely in the light of the low weight that is placed on xenophobia and the number of Cabinet ministers who have made such statements. The xenophobic threat remains. It remains a problem because there is no clarity as to why or whether xenophobia is wrong, and when we have a discourse in this country that has been more or less condoned, where xenophobic statements are not regarded as wrong. The discourse on 'too many foreigners in the country', porous borders and similar things are not part of people's consciousness of what is considered wrong and is contrary to the freedom provided in 1994 and 1996. It's important that we have people grow up in a country that does not condone certain things. There are certain values, mainly in regard to apartheid manifestations, but it does not seem that there is a moral question in people's minds regarding the wrongness of xenophobia. That must be remedied, because to practise xenophobic behaviour and make xenophobic statements is to spit on the freedom of all who live in South Africa. We need to understand and spread the notion that freedom belongs to all, and it is not freedom where some people are excluded. We must find the modalities for working this out in a way that does not repeatedly create hurtful attacks on foreign nationals, as in the aftermath of recent incidents with poisons allegedly emanating from some of the spaza shops. When one examines the evidence presented in that and many other cases, it's clear that a lower threshold is applied for people who are foreign nationals. That must end. DM
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Agribusiness Confidence Index shows slight decline amid global uncertainties
Agricultural Business Chamber said that despite the slight decline, the current level of the ACI, implies that South African agribusinesses remain optimistic about business conditions in the country Image: Supplied South Africa's Agricultural Business Confidence Index (ACI) edged down by five points to 65 in the second quarter, reflecting a slight dip in sentiment across the agribusiness sector, the Agricultural Business Chamber (Agbiz) said on Wednesday. The chamber noted that concerns over global trade uncertainty, persistent geopolitical tensions, and ongoing domestic animal disease outbreaks were among the main factors weighing on industry confidence. "Despite the slight decline, the current level of the ACI, implies that South African agribusinesses remain optimistic about business conditions in the country," said Wandile Sihlobo, the chief economist at Agbiz. 'The better summer rains and improvements at the ports which have enabled exports with minimal interruptions, are some of the positives. This survey was conducted in the second week of June, covering various agribusinesses operating in all agricultural subsectors across South Africa." The ACI comprises ten subindices; six of them declined in quarter two, while the rest remained unchanged. The turnover subindex confidence was down by 5 points to 55. There was a deterioration in sentiment among agribusinesses operating in the red meat sector, while others maintained a roughly unchanged view from the previous quarter. Similarly, the net operating income subindex fell by 5 points to 65 points. The drivers were the same as the turnover. The sub-index measuring export sentiment volume fell by 40 points to 60. Sihlobo said, 'This is still a relatively favourable level. For example, in quarter one, South Africa's agricultural exports totalled $3.36 billion (R54 billion), up 10% from the same period a year ago, according to data from Trade Map. Thus, the decline in sentiment in quarter two is a normalisation.' The general economic conditions subindex fell by 15 points to 50 in quarter two. "This indicates concerns about growth prospects this year due to both domestic and global constraints. The market share of the agribusiness subindex fell by 5 to 65 points in quarter two," Sihlobo said. "Most respondents maintained an essentially unchanged view, which enabled the high base to lead to a mild decline in sentiment.' Sihlobo said the second-quarter ACI results for 2025 reflect an overall optimistic sentiment in the agricultural sector, with expectations of a recovery continuing through the year. However, he cautioned that the rebound is likely to be uneven, as certain key subsectors remain under pressure from ongoing animal disease outbreaks. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ "The dominance of geopolitical concerns amongst respondents' views illustrates South Africa's agricultural sector's strong dependence on export markets and the need to work to diversify markets," Sihlobo noted. 'China, India, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt are among the key markets we should expand into.' Francois Rossouw, the CEO of Southern African Agri Initiative (Saai), said the slight decline in the ACI is understandable given the pressures facing the sector. 'While confidence remains in positive territory, ongoing threats like foot-and-mouth disease, amongst others, continue to weigh heavily on the red meat industry. Globally, escalating geopolitical tensions and uncertainty over key trade relationships- especially with major partners like the United States, raise concerns for export-driven agribusinesses," he said. These dynamics, alongside regional conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East create planning difficulties for producers. 'While confidence remains resilient overall, strengthening biosecurity and maintaining stable, trade-friendly diplomacy will be essential to support continued recovery,' Rossouw said. TLU SA general manager, Bennie van Zyl, is in agreement with most of the findings of ACI by Agbiz. 'It must be noted that the agricultural sector is in a fluctuation of seasonal realities especially with rain. Some years we have better rain , some years we have late rain and some years we have no rain," Van Zyl said, "This is something that has a huge influence on the climatic side of the agricultural sector. There's also the impact of crime on the agriculture sector such as produce theft and theft of cattle which is stock theft.'
eNCA
3 hours ago
- eNCA
South Africa's best brands announced
JOHANNESBURG - Despite the continued dominance of international brands in the country, South African brands are creeping up the rankings. WATCH | Italian designer Maria Grazia Chiuri out at Dior
