B.C. company apologizes for '51st state' reference in ad following online outrage
A Richmond, B.C., company has apologized after an advertisement in a transit station drew online flak for its reference to the "51st state" amid public annexation threats by the U.S. president.
Vitamin company Herbaland's ad was featured at the Vancouver City Centre SkyTrain station. The mural displayed a selection of the company's products set against a maple leaf and large text that read, "Herbaland proudly made in (the 51st state) Canada." In it, "(the 51st state)" is crossed out in white.
Herbaland's vitamin gummies are made in Richmond, a Metro Vancouver suburb, and its website bills itself as Canada's largest nutritional gummy producer.
The ad was taken down Wednesday after online commenters called it "completely unacceptable, even as a joke", and a marketing professor described the furor as a lesson in timing and tone for companies.
WATCH | 9 in 10 Canadians don't want to be the 51st state:
The ad comes at a time when Canadian businesses are asserting their identity amid U.S. President Donald Trump's public threats to annex Canada and make it the 51st state.
However, online commenters said Herbaland's ad was not "reading the room," prompting the company to apologize. In a statement, it said it does not support the idea of Canada becoming the 51st U.S. state."Our goal with this mural was to take a stand against the idea of being the 51st state, which is why we crossed it out, but we can see that even mentioning this notion, even to disagree with it, is in poor taste," the apology read.
"We fully believe in Canada's independence and unique identity."
Roxanne Tayler says she thought the ad was being 'cheeky' with the text strike-through. (Liam Britten/CBC)
Some passersby at Vancouver City Centre station on Tuesday morning were less critical of the advertisement than the online commenters.
"I think it looks bold, but it also is a little bit cheeky with the cross out," said Roxanne Tayler. "Like, it's addressing it without being in a negative kind of way."
However, Joanne McNeish, an associate professor of marketing at Toronto Metropolitan University, said the online outrage showed the tone of the ad was off.
The professor said the advertisement comes at a time when Trump's tariffs are making life more tangibly difficult for people, and that his erratic behaviour is being taken very seriously, not as joke material.
"[There's] nothing wrong with saying we're a great Canadian company," she told CBC News. "The companies that have done this successfully have talked about their Canadianness, the length of their Canadianness, or what they're trying to do to be genuinely Canadian."
But in the case of Herbaland's wording, McNeish said it was, "Wrong time, wrong joke."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Magazine
36 minutes ago
- Time Magazine
Trump Delivers Almighty Threat to Iran as Its Conflict With Israel Erupts
Iranian missiles rained down on Israel overnight, into the early hours of Sunday morning, as the conflict between the Middle Eastern countries took another grave turn. At the same time, Israel continued its military operation against Iran, completing an ' extensive series of strikes on targets in Tehran related to the Iranian regime's nuclear weapons project.' The high-stakes targets included the Iranian Ministry of Defense Headquarters and the main base of the 'SPND nuclear project,' locations which Israeli authorities said advanced Iran's efforts to obtain nuclear weaponry and served as a place where the country 'hid its nuclear archive.' In the midst of the explosive scenes in the Middle East, U.S. President Donald Trump took to his social media platform, Truth Social, to issue a stark warning to Iran, with whom the U.S. has, until the recent flare-up of this conflict, been engaged in talks with regarding a potential nuclear deal. Much like the U.S. did after Israel's initial attack on Iran's nuclear hub, Trump used the public platform to state that the U.S. had 'nothing to do with' the overnight attack on Iran. He once more warned Iran not to target the U.S. as part of its retaliation. 'If we are attacked in any way, shape, or form by Iran, the full strength and might of the U.S. Armed Forces will come down on you at levels never seen before. However, we can easily get a deal done between Iran and Israel, and end this bloody conflict,' he said. Trump had aired his grievances with the lack of completion regarding the Iran-U.S. nuclear talks earlier in the week, in response to Israel's initial launch of its military operation against Iran. 'I gave Iran chance after chance to make a deal. I told them, in the strongest of words, to 'just do it,' but no matter how hard they tried, no matter how close they got, they just couldn't get it done,' Trump said. 'Certain Iranian hardliners spoke bravely, but they didn't know what was about to happen. They are all DEAD now, and it will only get worse.' Officials from Iran and the U.S. were set to meet in Oman's capital of Muscat on Sunday for the next round of nuclear talks. Oman's Foreign Minister Badr Albusaidi announced on Saturday afternoon that, in light of the Israel-Iran active conflict, those talks would no longer be going ahead. This came after state television reported that Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmail Baghaei called nuclear talks with the U.S. 'meaningless.' Despite Trump's eagerness to secure a nuclear deal swiftly, it remains to be seen if and how those talks will get back on track, especially as there seems to be no end in sight for this most recent flare-up in the Middle East. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said the strikes from his military, part of Operation Rising Lion, 'will continue for as many days as it takes to remove this threat.' Israeli residential areas were hit hard overnight into Sunday morning. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) issued a public statement as sirens called out across the country, saying that 'millions of Israelis are currently running for shelter.' As deadly missiles showered over civilians' heads, both countries have reported respective casualties. After the overnight combat, the Israeli death toll has now risen to at least 13, including three minors, according to officials in the country. Meanwhile, per the Iranian authorities, at least 75 people have been killed in Iran. Dozens more have been injured. Ahead of the latest exchange of missiles, Netanyahu hinted at what was to come in a video address. 'We have paved a path to Tehran. In the very near future, you will see Israeli planes, the Israeli Air Force, our pilots, over the skies of Tehran,' he said, going on to warn that Israel "will strike every site and every target of the Ayatollah's regime." Hours before, on Saturday morning, Israel's Defense Minister Israel Katz threatened dire consequences if Iran's Supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei didn't retreat. 'If Khamenei continues to fire missiles at the Israeli home front, Tehran will burn,' Katz said, after a meeting with Israeli military leaders. As Israel unleashed its next series of strikes against Iran overnight, Katz said: 'Tehran is burning.' On Sunday afternoon, local time, Katz delivered another update, reaffirming that Israel's course of military action is far from over. 'I instructed the IDF to issue evacuation notices to residents in Tehran living near weapons production complexes,' he said. 'The Iranian dictator is turning Tehran into Beirut and the residents of Tehran into hostages for the survival of his regime.' Katz doubled down, adding: 'The IDF continues to peel the skin of the Iranian snake with great force, from nuclear weapons to Tehran and everywhere else.' Meanwhile, according to state media in Iran, the country's President Masoud Pezeshkian warned of a "more severe" response if Israel continues its operation. "The continuation of Zionist [Israeli] aggression will be met with a more severe and powerful response from the Iranian armed forces," Pezeshkian is quoted as saying on Saturday, reportedly during a phone call with Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif. Amid the prolonged trade of deadly missiles between Israel and Iran, and with no immediate end in sight, there's rising concern that the conflict could spiral even further, directly involving other countries—an outcome that Trump and his fellow world leaders are likely desperate to avoid.
USA Today
44 minutes ago
- USA Today
What we know about the military parade on Trump's birthday (June 14)
What we know about the military parade on Trump's birthday (June 14) Show Caption Hide Caption Military equipment headed to DC ahead of Trump's birthday parade Battle tanks, fighting vehicles and infantry carriers departed Texas for D.C. for President Trump's military parade. A long-planned celebration in Washington for the U.S. Army's 250th anniversary will coincide with President Donald Trump's 79th birthday on Saturday. While the Army has said it has no plans to recognize Trump's birthday, the president will play a major role in the celebrations, which have been altered to include a parade. Here is everything we know so far: Where is the military parade taking place? There will be a wreath-laying ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery on Saturday morning, followed by a fitness competition and an Army birthday festival on the National Mall in Washington. The festival will include equipment displays and military demonstrations. The day will culminate with a parade through the city and an enlistment and re-enlistment ceremony presided over by Trump. There will also be fireworks. After the parade, the U.S. Army Golden Knights team will parachute in and present Trump with a flag. What military vehicles are being brought to Washington, D.C.? The U.S. Army is bringing 6,500 troops into Washington, along with 150 vehicles and 50 aircraft for the celebration. The vehicles are being moved to the city on trains and larger trucks, while the helicopters will fly in. The Army has said that more than 25 M1 Abrams tanks will feature in the parade. It will also include 28 Stryker armored vehicles, four Paladin self-propelled artillery vehicles, and artillery pieces including the M777 and M119. The flyover will include Apache and Black Hawk helicopters along with Chinooks. Older aircraft like the World War Two-era B-25 bomber and P-51 Mustang will also take part. The parade will include 34 horses, two mules and one dog. What security measures are being taken for the military parade? Law enforcement agencies are preparing for hundreds of thousands of people to attend the celebration, the U.S. Secret Service said. Washington, D.C., has started to place non-scalable fences at key points around the city, including the White House. Security preparations include 18.5 miles of anti-scale fencing and 17 miles of concrete barriers, while overhead drones operated by the Secret Service will keep watch. Thousands of agents, officers and specialists will be deployed from law enforcement agencies from across the country. Officials said they are not expecting protests against federal immigration enforcement similar to those in Los Angeles. The Federal Aviation Administration will close down arrivals and departures at Washington's Reagan National Airport during the peak of the celebration. How much is Trump's parade going to cost? The twin celebrations will cost the U.S. Army between $25 million and $45 million, U.S. officials have told Reuters. That includes the parade itself as well as the cost of moving equipment and housing and feeding the troops. The cost was several million dollars more than it would have been without a parade, the officials said. The officials' latest estimates exclude costs the city of Washington would have to bear, like trash cleanup. The military has already started taking steps to protect the streets of the capital from any potential damage caused by heavy tanks, including laying down metal plates in some areas. The Army says it will pay for any unexpected repairs if needed and has set aside several million dollars in case of damage. What is the controversy of the June 14 parade? Democratic lawmakers have said that Republican Trump is taking over the Army's birthday for himself. "This is Trump. This is all about his ego and making everything 'him,' which is, I think, a discredit to the military, the Army," said Senator Jack Reed of Rhode Island, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee. Representative Steve Cohen, a Democrat from Tennessee, introduced a bill to prohibit the use of public funds for "displays of military force for personal glorification." Officials have told Reuters that the planning for the Army's 250th birthday celebration started last year - before Trump won the November presidential election. The White House has said the administration was planning a historic celebration for the Army's 250th birthday. The Army was established on June 14, 1775, more than a year before the Declaration of Independence. Trump has made no secret of his desire to hold military parades in the past. During his first administration, he ordered the Pentagon to look into a display of military might after a 2017 trip to France where he and French President Emmanuel Macron reviewed that country's defense forces marching down the Avenue des Champs-Elysees in Paris. Trump ultimately settled for a display of tanks and other armored vehicles during a July Fourth celebration in 2019 in Washington. Has the US ever had a military parade? Critics have called a parade an authoritarian display of power that is wasteful, especially as Trump slashes costs throughout the federal government. Military parades in the United States are generally rare. Such parades in other countries are usually staged to celebrate victories in battle or showcase military might. In 1991, tanks and thousands of troops paraded through Washington to celebrate the ousting of Iraqi President Saddam Hussein's army from Kuwait in the Gulf War. (Reporting by Idrees Ali, Phil Stewart and Ryan Jones in Washington; Editing by Ross Colvin, Howard Goller and Alistair Bell)
USA Today
44 minutes ago
- USA Today
Lower Hudson Valley protests: 'If we aren't the melting pot, anymore... what are we?'
Lower Hudson Valley protests: 'If we aren't the melting pot, anymore... what are we?' Show Caption Hide Caption Watch thousands of pro-immigration New Yorkers protest in Manhattan. Thousands of New Yorkers protested against ICE policies during a rally and march in Manhattan June 10, 2025. The Lower Hudson Valley was the site of multiple protests Saturday, June 14, part of a reported 2,000 such demonstrations nationwide, following days of protest in Los Angeles and New York City. A national coalition of progressive organizations called for the protests on June 14, which coincides with President Donald Trump's 79th birthday and his unusual military parade in D.C. on the U.S. Army's 250th anniversary. The protests were held in response to the military spectacle in D.C. But the shorthand title for the protests, "No Kings," carries a further condemnation of Trump administration actions. Some include the use of National Guard and military troops to quell protests in Los Angeles over immigration sweeps; the executive branch's failure to comply with federal court rulings; and Trump's "One Big Beautiful Bill" that critics say favors wealthy Americans and adds to the federal deficit. ≽ See a schedule and map of protests in Westchester and Rockland counties here. Watch live: See video of June 14 No Kings protests from across the United States In Nanuet, people lined all the sidewalks along the intersection of Route 59 and Middletown Road known as the "Four Corners." It's been the sight of various demonstrations going back at least 50 years. In recent months, demonstrators rally most Saturdays between noon and 2 p.m. carrying signs blasting Trump, erstwhile DOGE engineer Elon Musk and the region's congressman, U.S. Rep. Mike Lawler, a Republican whose 17th District includes all of Rockland and Putnam counties, and parts of Westchester and Dutchess. Lynn O'Brien of Suffern, 86, had protested at the Four Corners in 2003 as the Iraq War brewed. She'd marched in Baltimore during the late 1960s for civil rights and against the Vietnam War. She said she was there again Saturday, June 14, because "we're in danger in this country." "People don't know what to do," O'Brien said. By 11:30 a.m., more than 100 protesters had gathered on the southwest corner at the intersection of Route 59 and Middletown Road, and a dozen more across the street for the protest that started at noon. Clarkstown police and protest organizers were having a calm and detailed discussion about perimeters. Vehicles honked frequently in the heavily-traveled corridor, earning appreciative cheers from the crowd. With well over 1,000 protesters present by noon, Clarkstown police could be seen putting up more orange barriers as a buffer between the roadway and sidewalk on Route 58. Ciara Sweeney, of Pearl River, made hand-painted posters with a caricature of president Trump behind bars and the words "IMMIGRANTS ARE NOT CRIMINALS BUT THE PRESIDENT IS." She and her mother turned out for the day's demonstration to counter the military parade in D.C. "just to show there are protests everywhere. People think people have given up," Sweeney explained. "That's not true." Sweeney said it was important to show up in the suburbs, too. "Don't count out Rockland County," the 20-year-old said. Penelope Tseteskos, 21, came out because she wants "all civil rights for everyone, that's what America's made of." The Pearl River resident carried one of Sweeney's painted signs. Xavier Malta of Spring Valley is a military veteran from the Cold War era. He served in Southeast Asia from 1975-79. "This is not what I served for," he said. "I believe in Democracy, I believe in our country ad our flag and I'm a patriot, but this is not a Democracy where we're going." Ayden Knapp, 19, of Park Ridge, New Jersey was concerned about the kind of immigration crackdowns seen in Los Angeles. Immigration was part of American tradition and culture, he said, "If we aren't the melting pot anymore, then what are we?" About half of the day's 1,000 expected protesters had arrived just before 11 a.m. at the Mount Kisco station protest spot, many dressed in clown or king costumes. The sounds of Aretha Franklin's "Respect" could be heard filtering through a nearby sound system's speakers. Chants of "No kings! No clowns! Don't be fascist! Let's run the fascists out of our town!" echoed among the crowd. Organizers could be seen in yellow vests directing demonstrators to appropriate places to stand, as crowds engaged with each other in the lively, almost festive atmosphere. Despite overcast skies, and rain in the forecast, the weather seemed to be holding out. A nun, Sister Rosemarie Milazzo, of the Maryknoll Sisters in Ossining, 93, was spotted carrying a sign that says "Let Freedom Ring, Not A King." "It's simple, I don't want a king running my country," she told reporters. "And I want to be a little more hospitable to refugees and immigrants, I'm a daughter of an immigrant." A Peekskill couple were among the younger demonstrators in the crowd, most of whom were over the age of 60, and overwhelmingly white. Thirty-five-year-old tech worker Michael Trapani, carrying a full sized American Flag on a pole over his shoulder, said he and his wife Stephanie, 38, were at the Mount Kisco protest because "we're moving towards authoritarianism, and we're trying to prevent that from happening." Stephanie, a nurse, remarked that the government was "single-handedly dismantling our health care system." "This is America. We were founded by overthrowing tyranny," Michael said. "Being here is the most American thing we could possibly do." Betty Marotta, 75, a retired RN from Holmes in Dutchess donned a jester's costume for the occasion. "Trump's a clown. He's just a clown," she said. "He thinks he is king and doesn't follow the rule of law." At 12:36 p.m., protest organizers in Mount Kisco announced the Minnesota shootings of two Democratic lawmakers and their spouses to loud gasps and cries of 'fascists!' A moment of silence came after, followed by a chorus of protesters singing Bob Dylan's "Blowing in the Wind." Many people were in tears. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz said state Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband Mark were shot and killed, and State Sen. John Hoffman and his wife Yvette were shot and wounded in 'targeted shootings' in Brooklyn Park and Champlin, two neighboring suburban cities 10 to 20 miles outside Minneapolis. Police were searching for at least one suspect alleged to have impersonated a law enforcement officer while carrying out the attack. Alan Levy of Peekskill, one of the event organizers, choked up addressing the crowd, only getting out '…May their memories be a blessing. "This is the next step we're all worried about. That people will take the words of this administration and use them as a cudgel to kill, murder, maim," Levy said. "It's what no one here wants to see." The day after protesting escalating tensions between Israel and Iran, New Yorkers once again hit the streets for another day of demonstration. Mayor Eric Adams said in a post to the social media platform X that the city's 34,000-plus members of the New York City Police Department would be present Saturday to "protect everyone involved — whether peacefully protesting or going about your day." "To those who seek to peacefully exercise their First Amendment rights tomorrow, we are ready to help you do that," New York City Police Department commissioner Jessica Tisch posted to social media Friday. "To those who intend to commit crimes, incite violence, or attack our cops, you will be met with the full strength of the greatest police department in the world." Celebrities like Susan Sarandon and Mark Ruffalo joined protesters in the street, as thousands made their way from Bryant Park down 5th Avenue. The demonstration was slated to end at 4 p.m. The day of protest coincided with day one of early voting in the Big Apple's much-anticipated mayoral primary. Front and center is the contest on the Democratic ballot, which pits 11 candidates against each other— including frontrunners former New York governor Andrew Cuomo, assemblyman Zohran Mamdani, city comptroller Brad Lander and others. Contributing: lohud's Alexandra Rivera and Ashley Catherine Fontones; USA TODAY. (This story was updated with new information.)
