Ita Buttrose claims ‘inconsistencies' in ABC boss David Anderson's affidavit in Antoinette Lattouf case
Former ABC chair Ita Buttrose has pointed to alleged 'inconsistencies' in David Anderson's affidavit for a federal court case, citing differing details of where and when the outgoing managing director told Buttrose that Antoinette Lattouf had been sacked.
In an explosive letter to ABC lawyers seen by Guardian Australia, Buttrose last week urged the ABC to tell Lattouf's lawyers about the alleged inconsistencies in Anderson's version of events as set out in his affidavit. The affidavit was filed in court in Lattouf's unlawful termination case against the ABC which returns for closing arguments on Thursday.
Guardian Australia does not suggest that Anderson's testimony in the federal court case was anything but his honest recollection of events that took place in late 2023.
Buttrose in her letter demanded the ABC contact Lattouf's lawyers 'as a matter of absolute urgency' and, if they failed to do so, she said she would 'take the appropriate action'.
The evidence Buttrose refers to is an invoice from a hire car company which transported the chair and the managing director to a Christmas lunch on Wednesday 20 December 2023 – which she claims suggests that Anderson's affidavit was contradictory.
It was the same day that Lattouf was told she would not be returning for the final two days of the ABC radio show she was hosting. Phone calls and texts were flying between Anderson and the ABC's content chief, Chris Oliver-Taylor.
When Anderson left for the lunch Lattouf had not yet been removed.
A casual broadcaster, Lattouf was dismissed from hosting ABC's Sydney Mornings program in December 2023 and later brought an unlawful termination case before the federal court.
'In the interests of transparency and our legal obligations to do so, the invoice from 'Corporate Cars Australia' must be provided to Ms Lattouf,' Buttrose writes in Thursday's letter, adding a deadline of 2pm on Friday.
The ABC does not appear to have taken any action in response to Buttrose's letter. The publicly available court file does not show any documents having been filed by the ABC since it received Buttrose's letter.
According to Buttrose, she was picked up at home on 20 December 2023 and driven in the hire car to pick up Anderson at the ABC's Ultimo headquarters.
Buttrose points to Anderson's affidavit where he states the two met at the ABC Ultimo office 'outside her office on Level 14 to travel to lunch together'.
'Clearly, Mr Anderson was not having a conversation with me on Level 14 at Ultimo, when I wasn't even in the building,' Buttrose wrote to the ABC's lawyers last week.
She also highlights his account of a conversation he had with Buttrose in which she said words to the effect of 'we're just going to have to agree to disagree' that management had decided to keep Lattouf on air until Friday.
Buttrose alleges 'no such conversation ever took place; and this is corroborated with irrefutable evidence which the ABC now has'.
A conference call with the ABC's legal department on 18 February 'discussed evidence [Buttrose] had that completely refuted Mr Anderson's affidavit', according to the letter. 'I then emailed that evidence to everyone in this group,' Buttrose said.
'That evidence being, an invoice from 'Corporate Cars Australia' that showed that at 12:10pm on 20 December 2023, a car picked me up from my home address in Redfern; and at 12:30pm, that car pulled up to the front of the ABC offices at Ultimo.'
Buttrose's alleged inconsistencies do not appear to be material to the case. The federal court has heard that Lattouf was sacked while Anderson and Buttrose were at lunch and Oliver-Taylor told the managing director initially via text of his decision, which was then conveyed to Buttrose.
Buttrose disputes Anderson's version of events about how the matter unfolded.
She disputes Anderson's recollection that after the lunch Anderson had a conversation with Oliver-Taylor about Lattouf's sacking 'as he travelled in a taxi back to the ABC offices'.
'He was, in fact, in a hire car with me,' Buttrose said in her seven-page letter.
Buttrose said the hire car invoice shows they left the restaurant at 3pm and Anderson was dropped back at the office first – before she was driven home.
In his affidavit sworn in October 2024, and released by the federal court, Anderson states he rang Oliver-Taylor back during lunch and was told 'we have decided we need to take her [Lattouf] off the air'. Anderson said 'immediately after hanging up from the call with Mr Oliver-Taylor, I informed Ms Buttrose about the conversation'.
In her October 2024 affidavit released by the court, Buttrose states: 'I do not now recall the discussions that Mr Anderson and I had during the course of lunch on 20 December … I do not recall whether we discussed Ms Lattouf.'
He further states that after the lunch he assisted Buttrose to her hire car and then got a taxi back to the ABC. 'During my taxi ride back to the office, I called Mr Oliver-Taylor, and (to the best of my recollection) we had a conversation' where Oliver-Taylor provided more details including the allegation that Lattouf 'posted on social media against instructions'.
An ABC spokesperson declined to comment on the substance of Buttrose's letter.
'The matter is before the court and it would be inappropriate for the ABC to comment while proceedings are under way,' he said.
Buttrose declined to comment.
Final submissions in the unlawful termination case are scheduled to be heard on Thursday and Friday before justice Darryl Rangiah retires to consider his verdict.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
13 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
Llandrindod Wells dad stabbed after drug deal went wrong
A Powys dad is lucky to still be alive after being stabbed multiple times after a drug deal went wrong, police say. Scott Weale suffered four stab wounds to the chest and lower back near his family home during the lead-up to Christmas. Ricco Douglas, 25, was jailed for more than five years after pleading guilty to wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm using Weale's own knife which he grabbed during a scuffle. The horrifying attack unfolded in a residential street in Llethyr Bryn, Llandrindod Wells on December 14 which led to armed police attending, and the area cordoned off by crime scene investigators who were treating the incident as an attempted murder. Dyfed-Powys Police said it would "always" respond to community concerns in Llandrindod Wells, adding that Douglas' sentencing proves that their officers "will not tolerate violent on our streets". Newport Crown Court was told that Ricco Douglas travelled from his home in Birmingham on the day of the stabbing to meet with Mr Weale in order to obtain or exchange cocaine. Within 14 mins of being in Llandrindod Wells, Douglas had stabbed his victim. It was believed the attacked took place after as a result of the drug deal going wrong. Douglas was arrested three days later after police used a stinger to stop his car in the Birmingham area. An abandoned vehicle, belonging to Douglas' stepmother, was found on the night of the stabbing with traces of the victim's and the defendant's blood inside. Dyfed-Powys Police Detective Chief Superintendent Ross Evans said: 'This was a violent incident which occurred on a residential street, just before Christmas last year. "It was highly fortunate that there was no loss of life which would have deprived a family of a loved one. 'We know this incident has been a shock for the local community, in particular for those most affected. 'We welcome the sentencing of Ricco Douglas and hope it provides clear reassurance to everyone that we will not tolerate violence on our streets." DCS Evans added: "I would like to thank all the first responders and the staff at the University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, on the night for the level of care and treatment provided to the victim, which may well have saved his life. "I would also like to thank our police officers and staff, who demonstrated great determination to bring the offender to justice on behalf of the victim and his family and the wider community.' DCS Evans appealed to the public to report any suspicious activity and crimes which can help officers gain vital intelligence, which ensures perpetrators of crime are caught and brought to justice. He added: 'To help us prevent such incidents, I am appealing to anyone with information about any type of serious crime to let us know. "You can speak to local officers, report online or do so completely anonymously via Crimestoppers. 'We will always respond to community concerns, and it is important to remember that we rely on the support of the public of Llandrindod Wells and Powys to keep our local area safe'.
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Birmingham man jailed for stabbing Powys man four times
Ricco Douglas, 25, took a knife being held by Scott Weale and stabbed him twice in the front and twice in the back after an argument in a car in Llethyr Bryn in Llandrindod Wells last year, a court heard on Monday (June 9). Mr Weale managed to stagger home before collapsing and being rushed to hospital in Cardiff with "life-threatening" stab wounds, including a collapsed lung. Douglas, of Edgbaston, Birmingham, was jailed for five years and three months by a judge at Newport Crown Court on Monday (June 9) after admitting wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. He had initially been charged with attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder, but no evidence was offered on those charges. The court was told that at around 8pm on December 14, Douglas and Mr Weale had been in a car arguing over a drug deal. The pair were not known associates but knew Brecon drug dealer Callum Samuel, who served prison time with Douglas, and was in contact with the 25-year-old before and after the stabbing, the court was told. The argument continued outside the vehicle which led to Mr Weale chasing Douglas with a knife before the pair grappled and Douglas disarmed the other man. READ MORE: Police make arrest in Llandrindod attempted murder case He then stabbed him four times with his own knife. Mr Weale managed to run home where his friend Liam Langley had been waiting to collect his wages, and threw his keys to him and "in a panicked and shaken voice" told him to lock the door, prosecuting barrister Mr Jones told the court. Mr Langley saw his friend's shirt was soaking with blood, and was told 'I don't feel good. I think I've been hit" before passing out in the kitchen. Mr Langley called 999 and Mr Weale's family while applying pressure to his wounds fearing that he was watching his friend bleeding out and struggling to breathe. Emergency services received a 'red call' and rushed Mr Weale to Cardiff in a land ambulance on blue lights, arriving an hour-and-a-half later. Surgeons removed a one-litre blood clot from his chest, fixed a collapsed left lung and closed his stab wounds, which measured from two to five centimetres in length. Mr Weale spent eight days in hospital before going home in time for Christmas. He did not engage with the court proceedings, the judge was told. Dyfed-Powys Police officers who secured the scene found blood in the street, bank notes and traces of cocaine. Newport Crown Court (Image: Archive) Douglas fled immediately after the stabbing in a black Ford Kuga, which was seen by police in Worcestershire at 9.50pm before driving off at speed. The car, Douglas' stepmother's, was later found abandoned in Birmingham with the keys still inside. Red staining on a handle was found to be the victim's blood, and Douglas' fingerprints and blood were also found. Three days after the stabbing, on December 17, police stung Douglas' Audi A3 along Coventry Road in Birmingham before handcuffing and arresting him on suspicion of attempted murder. On his fifth and final interview at Newtown Police Station, Douglas provided a prepared statement claiming the stabbing was in self-defence. Newport Crown Court was told that Douglas had convictions for robberies during a ten-year period which started when he was 15 years old. The stabbing in Llandrindod Wells happened months after he was released from prison on licence for robbery at knifepoint. Defence barrister Michael Mather-Lees told the judge that the "intelligent lad" was initially unarmed when Mr Weale chased him in the street. "He disarms Mr Weale amid a violent struggle. He was defending himself, but he went over the top," the barrister said. "They were plainly excessive actions, and he accepts that. He added: "You have got a victim who has a dubious background and substantially armed. There is credence for [Douglas'] version of events. It doesn't excuse it, and we know why they were there. "He accepts that he has behaved excessively and is looking at a substantial sentence. "He says in a very intelligent letter that he accepts his immaturity and has made very substantial mistakes behaving badly in the past." Judge Daniel Williams told Douglas that that the prosecution didn't challenge his version of events. "Scott Weale was found bleeding and with a collapsed lung; wounds which could be life threatening and required immediate treatment," he said. "The harm caused to Mr Weale was particularly grave or life-threatening with severe stab wounds to the chest." After reflecting Douglas' age and positive references, the judge sentenced him to five years and three months in custody, which half will be spent behind bars.
The Guardian
6 hours ago
- The Guardian
Should young Australians be worried about Labor's superannuation tax changes?
As debate rages over the Labor government's tax changes for large superannuation accounts, some young workers have asked their financial advisers whether they will be caught by the reforms. Advisers have told Guardian Australia that some young workers have even questioned whether they should stop making additional contributions. Experts say it's unlikely that younger Australians will get caught by the changes, with older, high-income earners the most exposed to the reforms. Here's what young Australians need to know about the changes. Most workers are legally entitled to be paid a guaranteed 11.5% of their wages into their superannuation fund, or 12% from July this year. The government levies a tax of 15% on the earnings on super balances of workers yet to retire and of retirees with more than $2m. Labor has proposed to lift that 15% tax to 30%, but only for the earnings from the portion of the balances over $3m. Earnings on the first $3m in an account would still be taxed at 15%. The tax would be levied each year. You can read a broader breakdown here. Economists expect most young people currently working will not hit $3m balances, though higher-income earners will have a higher chance at getting there. By the 2050s, when millennials will be looking at retirement and gen Z and Alpha will dominate the workforce, one in 10 people will have $3m balances, Treasury and Grattan Institute modelling shows. That could rise to three or four in every 10 people in the 2060s according to Diana Mousina, an AMP economist. But she says it is unlikely that 'half of gen Z' will reach $3m in super balances, contrary to some media reporting of her analysis. Mousina's modelling shows a worker earning more than $90,000 a year who works for 40 years consecutively with a 3% pay rise every year would probably achieve a $3m balance. This means a worker in their 20s who reaches $90,000 or over soon, then maintains it for the rest of their working life, could one day be affected. Workers on lower incomes who made no extra contributions and took time off work, for example to have a child, would be unlikely to reach $3m, according to Harry Chemay, a superannuation and wealth management consultant. The Financial Services Council, meanwhile, expects about 500,000 people of 14.6 million currently employed would earn enough to see their top-range tax breaks reduced slightly under the new proposal. While the reform would increase tax rates on big balances, superannuation would still be an effective way for high-income earners to reduce the tax they pay. The average superannuation balance in mid-2022 was $164,000, so most Australians are nowhere near balances over $3m. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email The proposed 30% tax rate is still lower than the top income tax rate of 45%, meaning superannuation contributions would continue to offer a tax break for well-paid workers. Public debate over the tax illuminated how lightly superannuation is taxed, according to Jonathan Philpot, a wealth management partner at accounting firm HLB Mann Judd in Sydney. 'It actually highlights that super actually has much lower tax rates than virtually any other structure you can have in your retirement years,' he says. 'I wouldn't want people changing their super plans.' Experts believe it is likely the threshold for the new tax would be lifted above $3m at some point in the future, so some young people who hit the $3m figure may not end up paying extra. Mousina is among those who agree the $3m benchmark for the new extra rate will probably rise but she suggests the increase could be baked into the new laws for the tax, which need the Greens' support to pass. 'We should think about indexing it, rather than just having no legislation around when it's going to cap out,' she says. The lack of assurance on whether the tax threshold will be lifted above $3m has attracted some media outcry, despite expert consensus that the figure would have to rise. Debate has also focused on the proposal to tax a type of investment return called unrealised gains, which would see high earners pay tax on a rise in value of some assets on paper while leaving them unable to get that money back if the asset value falls in the future. Most super accounts would have limited exposure to unrealised gains, according to Chemay. Australians with self-managed super funds are more likely to struggle with this type of investment. However, self-managed super funds only make up about 1 million of the 20 million or so super savers – and just 15% of them are under the age of 45. For perspective, four million Australians have more than one super account. The government in 2018 estimated the resulting extra fees would leave the average worker about $50,000 worse off by the time they retired.
