DEVELOPING: More black smoke, still no new Pope
Thick black smoke billowed on Thursday from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel in a sign that cardinals again failed to elect a new head of the Catholic Church.
Among the thousands of Catholics and curious tourists massed in St Peter's Square, there was applause but also sighs at the result, which came after the second and third ballots.
The 133 cardinals voting for a successor to Pope Francis as head of the world's 1.4 billion Catholics were shut in for the secretive conclave on Wednesday evening.
Sequestered away from the world, they communicate their progress by burning their ballot papers and sending up smoke through the chimney of the frescoed 15th-century chapel.
Black smoke means no one has secured the minimum two-thirds majority – 89 votes – and white smoke signals the election of the 267th pope.
The first black smoke on Wednesday evening arrived some three hours and 15 minutes after the cardinals closed their doors, greeted with some disappointment by the assembled crowds.
But many people returned on Thursday, where the red-robed prelates held two more ballots in the morning. They were scheduled to hold another two in the afternoon and then four more on Friday, unless a pope is elected sooner.
'I don't want it rushed – whatever they need to do to make the right decision,' said Barbara Mason, 50, who travelled from Canada for the conclave.
She was hoping for a pope who will continue in Francis's progressive footsteps, especially as a champion of the environment and migrants, 'going forward, not going backward'.
Francis, a charismatic Argentine reformer who sought to open up the Church during his 12 years as pope, died on April 21 aged 88.
Paolo Cabrera, 40, from the Philippines, arrived early at the Vatican with his wife Cynthia to secure a spot as close as possible to St Peter's Basilica, where the new pontiff will be presented to the world from the balcony after the vote.
'It is very, very exciting to be here,' he said.
As Filipinos, they said they were rooting for their compatriot Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, one of the favourites – but said that they would be happy with 'anybody appointed by God'.
The cardinal electors – all those aged under 80 – spent the night in the Santa Marta guesthouse and were to seek divine inspiration at private mass early on Thursday before starting to vote again.
Seated at tables and chairs laid out beneath Michelangelo's frescoes in the Sistine Chapel, each cardinal must write down their choice for pope on a ballot paper and take it to the altar, where it is put in a silver urn.
After the ballots have been counted, they are burned in a cast iron stove dating back to 1939. Chemicals are added to a second, newer stove, connected to the same flue, which colour the smoke.
While their procession into the Sistine Chapel on Wednesday was broadcast live by the Vatican, including on screens in St Peter's Square, the feed cut as soon as they locked the doors.
The cardinals had to leave their phones behind and took an oath not to reveal the secrets of the conclave on pain of excommunication – and they will stay until they make a decision.
In 2005, Pope Benedict XVI was elected in four ballots and Pope Francis in 2013 in five ballots.
But experts warn the 2025 conclave – the largest and the most international ever, assembling cardinals from around 70 countries – could take longer.
There is no clear frontrunner to succeed Francis, with the cardinals representing a range of progressive and conservative traditions within the Church.
The challenges facing the 2 000-year-old institution are clear, and the new pope after his election will need to tread carefully amid geopolitical uncertainty, while addressing deep fractions within the Church.
There is also the continued fallout from the global clerical sex abuse scandal and, in the West, increasingly empty pews.
Around 80 percent of the cardinals voting were appointed by Francis – an impulsive yet energetic champion of the downtrodden.
But while some cardinals are looking to a new pope to protect and develop his legacy, others want a more conservative defender of doctrine.
More than a dozen names are circulating, from Italian Pierbattista Pizzaballa to Hungary's Peter Erdo and Sri Lanka's Malcolm Ranjith.
'The church has many divisions between liberals and conservatives, which are divisions that should not be, because I believe that the Church is universal,' said Juan Benitez, a 37-year-old Colombian.
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1
Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
By Garrin Lambley © Agence France-Presse
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
2 days ago
- eNCA
World leaders urged to step up for overexploited oceans
NICE - World leaders arrive in the French Riviera on Sunday ahead of a high-level summit on ocean conservation, as nations face pressure to adopt tougher stances on overfishing, pollution and marine protection. The United Nations has sounded the alarm over an oceans "emergency" and leaders gathering in Nice will be called to commit money and stronger protections for the seas. The UN Ocean Conference, starting Monday, seeks to turn a corner as nations feud over deep-sea mining, plastic litter and exploitative fishing, against a backdrop of wider geopolitical tensions. "We have a duty to mobilise, because the science is clear and the facts are there," said French President Emmanuel Macron in Monaco on Sunday, where he attended a pre-conference event on ocean finance. Some 60 heads of state and government are expected in Nice, including Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and his Argentine counterpart Javier Milei. "The planet can no longer tolerate broken promises," said Lula on Sunday. "Either we act, or the planet is in danger." - 'No excuses' - Later Sunday, Macron was to arrive in Nice from Monaco and tour the conference venue, made to look like the cavernous belly of a whale. In the evening, he was to host leaders for a dinner of Mediterranean fish. France has deployed 5,000 police to Nice for the five-day summit where scientists, business leaders and environmental activists were also to attend in big numbers. A strong turnout was expected from Pacific Island nations, whose delegations will urge financial aid to combat the rising seas, marine trash and plunder of fish stocks. The United States under President Donald Trump -- whose recent push to fast-track seabed mining in international waters sparked global outrage -- was not expected to send a delegation. Conservationists have warned the summit -- which will not produce a legally binding agreement -- risks being a talkfest unless leaders come up with concrete proposals to restore marine health. On Saturday, Macron said France would restrict bottom trawling -- a destructive fishing method that indiscriminately scrapes the ocean floor -- in some of its marine protected areas. Britain also said it would announce plans looking to extend a ban on bottom trawling to more than half of protected English seas. Environmental groups said such steps were good but do not go far enough. - Pay up - Nations will also face calls to cough up the missing finance to protect 30 percent of the world's oceans by 2030, a target agreed by nearly 200 countries in 2022. "We've created this sort of myth that governments don't have money for ocean conservation," Brian O'Donnell, director of Campaign for Nature, told reporters. "There is money. There is not political will," he said. So far, only around eight percent of oceans are designated marine conservation zones and even less are considered truly protected. Greenpeace says at this rate, it could take another 82 years to reach the 30 percent goal. In a boost this week, Samoa declared 30 percent of its national waters under protection with the creation of nine new marine parks. Conservationists hope others at the summit follow suit. "All eyes should be on the many Pacific leaders attending.... Their ambition and dedication to ocean protection can serve as inspiration to all countries," said Kevin Chand from the nonprofit group Pristine Seas. Another summit priority will be inching towards the numbers required to ratify a global treaty on harmful fishing subsidies, and another on protecting the high seas beyond national control. France is also spearheading a push in Nice to build support for a moratorium on deep-sea mining ahead of a closely-watched meeting of the International Seabed Authority in July. By Nick Perry, Antoine Agasse And Fanny Carrier
eNCA
3 days ago
- eNCA
World leaders head to France for UN summit on ocean threats
NICE - World leaders descend on the French Riviera on Sunday ahead of a high-level summit to tackle a deepening crisis in the oceans driven by overfishing, climate change and pollution. The United Nations says oceans face an "emergency" and leaders gathering in Nice will be under pressure to commit much-needed money and stronger protections for the ailing seas and the people that depend on them. The UN Ocean Conference must try to turn a corner as nations feud over deep-sea mining, plastic litter and exploitative fishing, against a backdrop of wider geopolitical tensions. Some 50 heads of state and government are expected to attend, including Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and his Argentine counterpart Javier Milei. On Sunday, French President Emmanuel Macron is expected to sail to Nice from Monaco, where he is attending a related event aimed at raising private capital for ocean conservation. He will be joined on the shimmering Mediterranean Sea by other vessels in a colourful maritime parade, before touring an exhibition centre on land transformed into the cavernous belly of a whale. That evening, Macron will host leaders for a dinner of Mediterranean fish ahead of the summit's formal opening on Monday. Peaceful demonstrations are expected over the five-day event and France has deployed 5,000 police to the heritage-listed city where scientists, business leaders and environmental activists are also attending in big numbers. A strong turnout is also expected from Pacific Island nations, whose delegations will demand greater financial assistance to fight the rising seas, marine trash and plunder of fisheries that threatens their very survival. The United States under President Donald Trump -- whose recent push to fast-track seabed mining in international waters sparked global outrage -- is not expected to send a delegation. - Political will - Conservationists have warned the summit -- which will not produce a legally binding agreement -- risks being a talk fest unless leaders come armed with concrete proposals for restoring marine health. Chief among these is securing the missing finance to get anywhere near protecting 30 percent of the world's oceans by 2030, a globally agreed target. "We've created this sort of myth that governments don't have money for ocean conservation," Brian O'Donnell, director of Campaign for Nature, told reporters. "There is money. There is not political will," he said. So far, only around eight percent of oceans are designated marine conservation zones and even less are considered truly protected. Greenpeace says at this rate, it could take another 82 years to reach the 30 percent goal. In a boost this week, Samoa declared 30 percent of its national waters under protection with the creation of nine new marine parks. Conservationists hope others at Nice follow suit. "All eyes should be on the many Pacific leaders attending... Their ambition and dedication to ocean protection can serve as inspiration to all countries," said Kevin Chand from the nonprofit group Pristine Seas. There has also been a concerted push for nations, including France, to ban bottom trawling -- a destructive fishing method that indiscriminately scrapes the ocean floor. On Saturday, Macron told the Ouest-France newspaper that bottom trawling would be restricted in some national marine protected areas. Inching closer toward the numbers required to ratify a global treaty on harmful fishing subsidies, and another on high seas protection, will also be a summit priority. France is spearheading a separate push in Nice to build support for a moratorium on deep-sea mining ahead of a closely-watched meeting of the International Seabed Authority in July. On Sunday, an expert scientific panel will hand Macron a list of recommendations for leaders at the summit, including pausing seabed exploration when so little is known about the deep oceans.
IOL News
27-05-2025
- IOL News
Pope's call to tame AI sets tone for Christian leaders
New pope greets world from St Peter's Newly elected Pope Leo XIV, Robert Francis Prevost (L) gestures on the main central loggia balcony of the St Peter's Basilica, after the cardinals ended the conclave, in The Vatican, on May 8, 2025. The pope was cited by Protestant American Evangelical leaders who launched an open letter to President Donald Trump published Wednesday, calling for an "AI revolution accelerating responsibly" while warning of "potential peril". Image: Andrej ISAKOVIC / AFP Pope Leo XIV singled out the challenges of artificial intelligence as he took office this month, underscoring religious leaders' hopes to influence a technology freighted with both vast hopes and apocalyptic fears. The pope was cited by Protestant American Evangelical leaders who launched an open letter to President Donald Trump published Wednesday, calling for an "AI revolution accelerating responsibly" while warning of "potential peril". Leo XIV told cardinals on May 10 that he had taken his papal name in honour of Leo XIII (1878-1903). He had "addressed the social question in the context of the first great industrial revolution", said the pope. Today, "the Church offers to everyone the treasury of her social teaching in response to another industrial revolution and to developments in the field of artificial intelligence," he added. Wednesday's letter from the Evangelicals called for the development of "powerful AI tools that help cure diseases and solve practical problems". But it also warned of "autonomous smarter-than-human machines that nobody knows how to control" -- echoing the language of Silicon Valley's so-called "AI doomers". 'Epochal change' Leo's highlighting of AI follows years of interventions at different levels of the Catholic Church, said Paolo Benanti, 51, a priest with a PhD in engineering. Benanti has advised both the Vatican and the Italian government on technology. The late pope, Francis, wove his thinking about technology and AI into wider reflections on climate change and society. In a January speech, he cited "concerns about intellectual property rights, the job security of millions of people, the need to respect privacy and protect the environment" as well as misinformation. Such 21st-Century challenges animated Francis's 2015 remark that "we are not living an epoch of change so much as an epochal change", Benanti told AFP. And he was at pains to say that the Vatican was not looking to hold back progress. "Look at the huge improvement that AI can produce" in cases like assisting medical diagnosis in regions without enough doctors, he said. "AI could be a wonderful tool but could be weaponised... this is something that could happen with every kind of technology, from the hammer... up to nuclear power," Benanti added. Ethical algorithms Francis called for crafting a new "algor-ethics" (a portmanteau of "algorithm" and "ethics") to govern emerging artificial intelligence. One key moral concept in Church documents about technology is upholding "human dignity". This means avoiding "some kind of system that simply cannot recognise the uniqueness of the human being and respect it," Benanti said. He gave the hypothetical example of an automated process for deciding on asylum applications "based on correlation with other data and not with your own and unique story". Such technology would recall the Holocaust, "the darkest page of the last century" when "one piece of data" on whether a person was Jewish or not could condemn them, Benanti said. In the world of work, the friar hopes to see "human-compatible AI innovation", with people "putting something unique inside the process". Humans should "remain in a position to produce value" rather than being relegated to filling in the gaps around machine capabilities, he urged. 'Reduce the risks' Francis said in January last year that "highly sophisticated machines that act as a support for thinking... can be abused by the primordial temptation to become like God without God". "It's very perilous when individuals assume for themselves godlike powers, to make decisions for the rest of us," agreed Reverend Johnnie Moore, President of the US-based Congress of Christian Leaders and a lead signatory of Wednesday's open letter. Rather than allowing tech bosses and scientists to set the terms of the future, leaders should "go to the well" of religious thought's "compounding wisdom over the centuries" to help chart the course, he told AFP by phone from Washington. Where Pope Leo highlighted "new challenges for the defence of human dignity, justice and labour" from artificial intelligence, the Evangelical leaders went further. They quoted OpenAI chief Sam Altman's 2015 remark that "AI will most likely lead to the end of the world -- but in the meantime, there'll be great companies". "The current risk equation is just way too high to be tolerable," Moore said. "We have to reduce the risk to human beings in this process."
