Family of bin man allegedly hit by refuse truck in Dublin settle action over his death
The family of a bin man who was killed when it was claimed he was hit by a refuse truck as he gathered up wheelie bins in a Dublin estate has settled High Court actions over his death.
Tomasz Orzel was an employee of Padraig Thornton Waste Disposal Ltd when the accident happened at an estate in Tallaght five years ago.
Advertisement
Counsel for the Orzel family Sara Moorehead SC instructed by Anderson and Gallagher solicitors told the court, cases brought for nervous shock and also over the death of Mr Orzel had been settled. Counsel said the actions arose out of a very tragic accident.
Mr Orzel's wife, Anna of Clondalkin, Dublin, had sued Padraig Thornton Waste Disposal Ltd with offices at Park West Business Park, Dublin, as a result of the accident.
Mr Orzel was an employee of Thornton Waste Disposal and it is claimed on March 19th, 2020, he was working at Dun and Oir Road, Old Bawn, Tallaght, Dublin, when suddenly and without warning the bin truck reversed and collided with him.
In the proceedings it was claimed there was an alleged failure to provide a safe place of work for Mr Orzel and an alleged failure to notice him timely or at all.
Advertisement
World
Champion Irish jockey (29) charged with drink driv...
Read More
It was further claimed there was an alleged failure to use any or any adequate care when reversing the bin lorry and that music and been allegedly playing at such a volume that the alarm was not heard.
It was further contended that there was an alleged to ensure that there was any or any adequate system in place for raising an alarm when the bin lorry was being reversed so as to avoid a risk of injury to employees,
All of the claims were denied.
Noting the settlements, Mr Justice Paul Coffey extended his deepest sympathy to Ms Orzel and her son.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
33 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Like his good friend Donald Trump, Conor McGregor rides out any scandal
When Conor McGregor was convicted of sucker-punching a man in a Dublin pub in 2019, he bought the pub and 'barred' his victim. Fast-forward to last week and he reportedly did not even need to lift a finger for the latest recipient of one of his left hooks to be thrown out of Ibiza's Pacha nightclub. It seems that whatever the crime or controversy, sooner or later the world's most infamous mixed martial arts fighter ends up coming out of it on top. Next week he could take major step in that direction when it comes to the most serious alleged offence committed by a man who has become the living embodiment of his nickname, 'The Notorious'. The Republic of Ireland's Court of Appeal is set to consider an application for new evidence to be introduced in his battle against a civil ruling that he raped Nikita Hand at a Dublin hotel in December 2018. That ruling, delivered by a jury at the Irish capital's High Court in November, meant McGregor was ordered to pay the mother of one more than €248,000 (£206,000) in damages. McGregor, who faced no criminal charges over the alleged rape after prosecutors deemed there was 'no reasonable prospect of conviction', immediately announced his intention to appeal. That appeal was lodged in February, and it emerged in April that he was attempting to introduce new evidence alleging Hand had been assaulted by her then partner on the night McGregor was found to have raped her. The evidence has been provided by two former neighbours of Hand, one of whom has signed a sworn affidavit claiming to have seen her being punched after she returned home that evening. Hand, who told November's civil trial that McGregor had 'brutally raped and battered' her, signed an affidavit calling her neighbours' allegations 'lies'. Even if the Court of Appeal rules the new evidence inadmissible or refuses to quash last year's verdict, McGregor already appears to have found a way of emerging from it all remarkably unscathed. It all comes amid a burgeoning 'bromance' with the man who arguably laid out the blueprint for him to do so. McGregor was still awaiting his trial last year when Donald Trump became the first former US president to be convicted of a felony after being found guilty of 34 charges linked to hush-money payments made to ex-adult star Stormy Daniels. The verdict did not prevent Trump running for re-election and, weeks later, he survived a would-be assassin's bullet on the campaign trail. McGregor, who had caused a political earthquake at the end of 2023 by signalling his intention to run for the presidency of his own country, posted to his 10 million followers on X: 'A 78 year old multiple billionaire he should be on a yacht on the med touring golf courses. But he is not. He is in Pennsylvania spitting out bullets! Running for the love of his country! God speed Donald! God bless the United States.' Whether Trump saw the message or not, less than two months after McGregor's own court defeat, the Irishman was among the guests at the US president's second inauguration and also posed for a photograph with Nigel Farage at a pre-event rally. By the time Ireland's prime minister Micheal Martin visited the White House in the week leading up to St Patrick's Day, Trump was publicly singling out McGregor as his favourite Irishman. If that was embarrassing for the taoiseach, it became even more so on St Patrick's Day when McGregor was invited for an audience with Trump and seized a platform to spout anti-immigration rhetoric he had begun to voice in the preceding months and years. That had included in the build-up to a riot in Dublin in November 2023, which was triggered by the stabbing of three young children outside a primary school. McGregor posted on X: 'Innocent children ruthlessly stabbed by a mentally deranged non-national in Dublin, Ireland today. There is grave danger among us in Ireland that should never be here in the first place, and there has been zero action done to support the public in any way, shape or form with this frightening fact. NOT GOOD ENOUGH.' Following the riot, and facing accusations of incitement, McGregor said he did not condone the violence. His White House visit was followed by an announcement that he would run for the presidency of Ireland later this year. But despite previously being publicly endorsed by Elon Musk and claiming to have the support of Trump himself, McGregor faces what would appear insurmountable hurdles to becoming his own country's head of state. Under the current rules, candidates must garner the support of 20 Oireachtas (parliament) members, or the backing of four of Ireland's local authorities in order to stand. A recent Irish Times survey of 949 local councillors found not one of the 187 who responded said they would nominate him for the role. Stiofán Conaty, a Sinn Fein councillor from Cavan County Council, told the publication: 'No such pressure would ever influence me to even consider voting for that horrid man.' McGregor's presidential ambitions could hardly be further removed from his stance on politics a decade ago after he was criticised for wearing a Remembrance Day poppy. 'F--- politics and f--- religion,' he wrote on Twitter in October 2015. 'I just want to swing a few lefts and a few rights for a couple of hundred mill in peace.' Back then, McGregor was at the peak of his powers in the Ultimate Fighting Championship with a five-year, 15-bout winning streak that included becoming the first man to hold championships in two weight classes simultaneously. Arguably the world's most recognisable MMA fighter, he was even named the following year as RTE Sports Person of the Year – Ireland's equivalent of the BBC's Sports Personality of the Year award. By then, McGregor had announced his retirement from UFC amid speculation about who would win in a fight between him and the world's best boxer, Floyd Mayweather Jnr. That planted the seed for a crossover boxing match between the pair on August 26, 2017, which became the second-highest-selling pay-per-view event in history. McGregor was beaten but, in reality, there were no losers from a fight in which he later said he earned 'around' $100 million. He went on to be ranked by Forbes as the world's fourth-highest-paid athlete on $99 million. The Mayweather fight also brought unprecedented public scrutiny on McGregor, who was accused of racism after telling his black opponent to, 'Dance for me, boy', during a promotional event. Mayweather later claimed McGregor had 'called black people monkeys' and had spoken 'disrespectfully to my mother and my daughter'. Responding on Instagram, McGregor wrote: 'Floyd Mayweather, don't ever bring race into my success again. I am an Irishman. My people have been oppressed our entire existence. And still very much are. I understand the feeling of prejudice. It is a feeling that is deep in my blood. In my family's long history of warfare there was a time where just having the name 'McGregor' was punishable by death. Do not ever put me in a bracket like this again …' Following the bout, McGregor looked likely to return to UFC before the end of the year. But plans were scrapped when he pushed a referee and slapped another official at a rival MMA event in Dublin, in which he was not even competing. The next day, the head of the commission for the event issued a statement accusing McGregor of having 'assaulted' the pair. McGregor apologised and UFC president Dana White later blamed his behaviour partly on his rapid rise to fame, branding his entourage 'cling-ons'. 'He's a young, rich kid who is a god in Ireland,' White said. 'That's not the healthiest environment either. When you make that kind of money, you're that famous and you're a professional athlete, you're gonna have an overload of cling-ons.' McGregor's MMA return was still on hold when, in April 2018, he was filmed in New York throwing a metal equipment dolly at the window of a bus carrying his UFC nemesis and heir apparent, Khabib Nurmagomedov. The window shattered, injuring two other fighters. White called the incident 'the most disgusting thing' in the history of the organisation. McGregor turned himself in to police and was charged with assault, criminal mischief and other crimes. He pleaded no contest to a count of disorderly conduct and was ordered to carry out five days of community service and attend anger-management classes. One of his victims, Michael Chiesa, later sued McGregor over his injuries. The case was settled out of court more than four years later. White's condemnation did not prevent him signing a six-fight deal for McGregor to return to the UFC, starting with a bout against new lightweight champion Nurmagomedov in October that year. McGregor was defeated and a brawl broke out afterwards that led to both men receiving lengthy bans and heavy fines. After defeating Conor McGregor, Khabib Nurmagomedov jumped out of the octagon and a brawl ensued 🎥 @AndreasHale d — SB Nation (@SBNation) October 7, 2018 It was during his six-month suspension that McGregor allegedly raped Hand and was arrested over accusations he stamped on a fan's phone in another incident caught on camera. The alleged victim in that case stopped cooperating with police and charges were later dropped. On March 26, McGregor announced his second retirement from MMA, hours before news broke that he was being investigated over his alleged rape of Hand. On April 6 came the Dublin pub attack in which McGregor punched Desmond Keogh for refusing an offer to sample the fighter's 'Proper No. Twelve' brand of whiskey. McGregor pleaded guilty to the assault in November that year and was fined €1,000. He also issued a public apology. However, when it was reported in April 2021 that McGregor had bought the Marble Arch pub where the incident had taken place, he reposted a link to the article saying: 'Ye and your mans barred.' Keogh told the Irish Mirror: 'I wouldn't want to be spending money in his pub to be honest.' That same month, McGregor and his business partners sold Proper No. Twelve for $600 million. The rape investigation and a further – denied – sexual assault allegation failed to prevent McGregor making what was a winning UFC comeback in January 2020. He retired again and, later that year, was arrested on the French island of Corsica on suspicion of attempted sexual assault and indecent exposure. He was released without charge and a police investigation into the denied claims was eventually dropped. Hand filed her civil lawsuit against McGregor in January 2021, days before what proved to be the fighter's final UFC comeback. He lost that bout, to Dustin Poirier, and a rematch in July. By then, Forbes had ranked him as the world's highest-paid athlete on $180 million following the sale of his whiskey brand. In October that year, McGregor was publicly accused by Italian DJ Francesco Facchinetti of breaking his nose in a nightclub in Rome. Facchinetti filed a criminal complaint but, as of today, no known action has been taken over an alleged incident McGregor has yet to comment on. The following July, McGregor held a birthday party on his yacht in Ibiza, after which a woman filed a complaint that he had physically assaulted her and that she had broken her arm jumping off the boat to escape him. McGregor denied the allegation and the woman later withdrew a lawsuit she had lodged against him. After making the allegations, her car was torched outside her home and a brick thrown through her window. During last year's civil rape proceedings against McGregor, it emerged that a gang of masked men had broken into Hand's home, smashed the windows and stabbed her boyfriend in the months leading up to the court case. There is no suggestion McGregor had any involvement in or prior knowledge of these incidents but, with him having 47 million followers on Instagram in addition to 10 million on X, they could indicate his supporters are prepared to go to extreme lengths to silence his accusers. McGregor is now facing another sexual assault lawsuit, filed in Florida in January this year over allegations – which he denies – of attempted rape during the NBA Finals in June 2023. Following a police investigation into the claims, prosecutors confirmed in October that McGregor would face no criminal charges. His alleged victim's lawsuit claims McGregor 'attempted to forcefully place his unprotected penis' into her mouth and anus without her consent. The claim was filed days before Trump's inauguration, but, like the verdict in November's civil case against him, did not prevent him attending or being invited to the White House in March. It has certainly not stopped his relentless campaigning for the presidency of Ireland. So, when footage emerged last week of him punching someone to the floor of Pacha during his latest trip to Ibiza, it hardly came as a surprise that his victim was apparently ejected and he was allowed to carry on as if nothing had happened.
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Dublin grandfather (53) who died from stab wounds is named locally
A man who died from stab wounds in hospital after a late-night disturbance at his Dublin home has been named locally as James 'Jake' Berney, a father and grandfather in his 50s. A number of people in the Foxdene area of Balgaddy, Co Dublin, have told gardaí they heard shouting inside the house late on Wednesday night, with the alarm raised and the emergency services arriving at the property. Advertisement Mr Berney survived the initial aftermath of the attack and was treated at the scene by paramedics before being taken by ambulance to Tallaght University Hospital. However, efforts to save him were not successful and he was pronounced dead. According to The Irish Times, Mr Berney is believed to have been stabbed several times at his home on Foxdene Drive, which he shared with his father, who was in his 80s. The house was sealed off as a crime scene when gardaí arrived and remained secured overnight into Thursday morning. Ireland Man refusing to stop extracting peat has no trespa... Read More It underwent an extensive examination by members of the Garda Technical Bureau throughout Thursday in the hope forensic evidence from the scene would link the killer to the fatal stabbing. Advertisement 'This investigation is being led by a senior investigating officer at Lucan Garda station,' the Garda said in a statement. 'Gardaí are appealing to anyone who was in the vicinity of Foxdene Drive between 11pm and 12am and observed any activity which drew their attention to come forward.' Gardaí are also keen to speak to any motorists who were driving in the area, and had recording dashcam. Gardaí are urging them to contact Lucan Garda station and make the footage available. A postmortem on the remains of the victim was being carried by the State Pathologist's Office on Thursday.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘We just want to stop people being murdered': Kneecap on Palestine, protest and provocation
In April, the Irish-language rap trio Kneecap performed two sets at Coachella, the California music festival attended by 250,000 people. As is commonplace at the group's shows, Kneecap displayed a message stating: 'Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people,' and the words 'Fuck Israel. Free Palestine'. Mo Chara, one of the group's members, told the audience: 'The Palestinians have nowhere to go. It's their fucking home and they're bombing them from the skies. If you're not calling it a genocide, what the fuck are you calling it?' Within a week, Kneecap's US booking agent had dropped them, Fox News had likened the statements to 'Nazi Germany', a handful of summer shows had been cancelled, and two videos from 2023 and 2024 had resurfaced of the group on stage saying: 'The only good Tory is a dead Tory,' and 'Up Hezbollah, up Hamas'. The former statement attracted criticism from the families of murdered MPs Jo Cox and David Amess, leading the band to apologise – 'we never intended to cause you hurt' – and to reject 'any suggestion that we would seek to incite violence against any MP or individual'. While saying 'we do not, and have never, supported Hamas or Hezbollah', they also described the recirculation of the videos as a 'smear campaign' against them, with the footage 'deliberately taken out of all context'. British counter-terrorism police announced they were investigating the band over alleged pro-terrorist sentiment expressed in the video, and later charged Chara with terror offences for allegedly brandishing the flag of Hezbollah – which in the UK is a proscribed terrorist organisation – after someone from the crowd handed it to him during a November 2024 London show. In response, artists including Massive Attack, Paul Weller and Primal Scream signed a letter advocating for free speech and alleging that Kneecap were victims of a 'campaign of intimidation'. Two months after Coachella, and as they prepare for a Glastonbury festival appearance that has been criticised by among others, the prime minister, Keir Starmer, and the leader of the Commons, Lucy Powell, the band say they are unfazed by the uproar. 'Maybe visas get revoked, you're not allowed in America again, it's not ideal – but Jesus Christ, there's people being bombed from the fucking skies, and people being starved to death,' says Chara, AKA Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh. 'We're in the process [of applying for new visas], hopefully it works. But if it doesn't, I can go about my day without having to worry about my next meal or my family being bombed. Visa revoked, I can get over.' Do the band regret what's depicted in either of the widely circulated videos? 'It's a joke. I'm a character. Shit is thrown on stage all the time. If I'm supposed to know every fucking thing that's thrown on stage' – in this case a Hezbollah flag – 'I'd be in Mensa, Jesus Christ,' says Ó hAnnaidh. 'I don't know every proscribed organisation – I've got enough shit to worry about up there. I'm thinking about my next lyric, my next joke, the next drop of a beat.' And the 'dead Tory' comments? 'Why should I regret it? It was a joke – we're playing characters, it's satirical, it's a fucking joke. And that's not the point,' he says. 'The point is, that [video] wasn't an issue until we said 'Free Palestine' at Coachella. That stuff happened 18 months ago, and nobody batted an eyelid. Everybody agreed it was a fucking joke, even people that may have been in the room that didn't agree – it's a laugh, we're all having a bit of craic. The point is, and the context is, it all [resurfaced] because of Coachella. That's what we should be questioning, not whether I regret things.' Kneecap's opponents, he says, 'went and combed through eight years of a career … they're really scraping the bottom of the barrel'. He says that they then 'took those videos out of context. If you believe that what a satirical band who play characters on stage do is more outrageous than the murdering of innocent Palestinians, then you need to give your head a fucking wobble.' To suggest that parts of Kneecap's performance are satire and others aren't is a tricky and potentially confusing line to walk. But Ó hAnnaidh argues the band don't risk undermining their activism by blurring these lines. 'It's not our job to tell people what's a joke and what's not. Our job is: we make music as a band. We are going to have political messaging in our songs – it's not for us to dissect it for other people. Take what you want from it, but we're not going to change in that way.' Kneecap have granted only one interview prior to their Glastonbury performance, and over the course of an hour-long video call – Ó hAnnaidh, and DJ Próvai, AKA JJ Ó Dochartaigh, speaking from Lurgan, and Móglaí Bap, AKA Naoise Ó Cairealláin, from his home in Belfast – all stay staunchly on message. The controversy surrounding them, they reiterate, is not the story – Gaza is. 'We're a distraction, to take away [attention] from what's happening in Palestine, especially for our generation of people who are always on our phones,' says Ó Cairealláin. 'It's all being livestreamed – you can never say you didn't know what's happening in Palestine, and that's why they want to bog us down and go through old videos. Over 100 people were killed in the last four days – that's the real story.' He alleges that the US and the UK 'are complicit in this genocide' on the grounds that each country has sent military supplies to Israel, and that Israel's supporters are targeting the band because they want to move the news 'away from the arms support'. Kneecap say that resistance is in their blood. Ó hAnnaidh and Ó Cairealláin are from west Belfast, while Ó Dochartaigh is from Derry; rapping in Irish is a way, they say, to reclaim a sense of Irish identity that the British attempted to stamp out. While they satirically self-identify as 'Republican hoods' and 'Fenian cunts' in their cartoonish, lewd music, their message is less republican than it is anticolonial and anti-sectarian. Kneecap advocate for peace between unionists and republicans – 'the people on the 'other side' aren't our enemy … we're all working-class', Ó hAnnaidh told the Face last year – and train their fury towards the 800 years of British rule in Ireland. Because of this, as well as their frequent references to drugs, the group have been criticised by unionist and republican advocates alike, as well as by Kemi Badenoch last year, who, when serving as UK business secretary, tried to block Kneecap from receiving a government-funded Music Export Growth Scheme grant because they 'oppose the United Kingdom'. Kneecap won a subsequent discrimination lawsuit against the British government, and donated the grant money to Protestant and Catholic youth organisations in Northern Ireland. This week, the band released The Recap, a furious, gloating diss track aimed at Badenoch, in which they describe the grant money as reparations. It was around the time Kneecap sued the government that they caught the attention of Hasan Piker, a streamer and political commentator who the New York Times recently termed 'a Joe Rogan of the left' due to his enormous platform and influence (he is one of the most viewed streamers on Twitch). He describes Kneecap to me as 'uncompromising and unyielding in their commitment to anti-imperialism'. After it was announced that Kneecap's second Coachella set wouldn't be livestreamed, he offered to stream the show on his Twitch channel, which has more than 2.9m followers. 'I'm always impressed when I see anyone in the western world share this kind of sentiment,' he says. 'At no point did I feel like they were fearful or anything like that … their advocacy is about putting humanity first.' Kneecap's rise has been steady since they debuted in 2017, and was bolstered by last year's release of a self-titled Bafta-winning comedy film about their origins, starring Michael Fassbender and the group themselves. Politics aside, the music itself is a riot: bawdy and whip-smart, animated by ferocious beats, deftly slipping between trenchant political commentary and dazed odes to the joys of substance use. But it's their anticolonial stance that has secured them legions of fans in places such as Aotearoa (New Zealand) and Australia, where they played to 10,000 fans at a free gig in Melbourne earlier this year. That stance is also why the band advocate so fiercely for Palestine, which they say they have been doing since they began making music. 'Eight-hundred years of colonialism, it obviously does things to people up to the point where I don't think the Irish people are willing to stand on the sidelines any more. The Irish people aren't willing to let something like a genocide pass by without comment,' says Ó hAnnaidh, and in general, Irish artists – Kneecap, as well as peers such as Lankum, Fontaines DC and Sprints – have been more vocal about the Palestinian cause than British or American acts. 'If we lose a few quid, we lose a bit of clout in a certain space, we don't care – we know we're doing the right thing, we know we're on the right side of history.' Israel has been carrying out a full-scale military campaign on occupied Gaza for almost two years, an onslaught triggered by Hamas's 7 October 2023 attack on southern Israel, in which about 1,200 people were killed. The UN has found Israel's military actions to be consistent with genocide, while Amnesty International and others have claimed Israel has shown an 'intent to destroy' the Palestinian people. At least 56,000 Palestinians are now missing or dead, with studies at Yale and other universities suggesting the official tolls are being underestimated. (In July 2024, the Lancet medical journal estimated the true death toll at that point could be more than 186,000.) But away from Kneecap and other outspoken artists, across the creative industries as a whole relatively few have spoken about Gaza in such stark terms. 'The genocide in Palestine is a big reason we're getting such big crowds at our gigs, because we are willing to put that message out there,' says Ó hAnnaidh. 'Mainstream media has been trying to suppress that idea about the struggle in Palestine. People are looking at us as, I don't know, a beacon of hope in some way – that this message will not be suppressed. The music is one thing, but the message is a big part of why we're getting across.' As working-class, early-career musicians, Kneecap have a lot more to lose by speaking out than more prominent artists, but Ó Cairealláin says this is beside the point. 'You can get kind of bogged down talking about the people who aren't talking enough or doing enough, but for us, it's about talking about Palestine instead of pointing fingers,' he says. 'There's no doubt that there's a lot of bands out there who could do a lot more, but hopefully just spreading awareness and being vocal and being unafraid will encourage them.' Ó Dochartaigh adds: 'We just want to stop people being murdered. There's people starving to death, people being bombed every day. That's the stuff we need to talk about, not fucking artists.' There's no doubt that Kneecap's fearlessness when it comes to speaking about Palestine is a key part of their appeal for many: during a headline set at London's Wide Awake festival last month, days after Ó hAnnaidh was charged for support of a terror organisation, an estimated 22,000 people chanted along with their calls of 'free, free Palestine'. And thousands showed up to their Coachella sets – which the band allege is why so many pro-Israel groups were quick to push back on them, despite the fact that they had been displaying pro-Palestine messages for such a long time. 'We knew exactly that this was going to happen, maybe not to the extreme [level] that it has, but we knew that the Israeli lobbyists and the American government weren't going to stand by idly while we spoke to thousands of young Americans who agree with us,' says Ó hAnnaidh. 'They don't want us coming to the American festivals, because they don't want videos of young Americans chanting 'free Palestine' [even though] that is the actual belief in America. They just want to suppress it.' The support for the message, says Ó Dochartaigh is 'all genders, all religions, all colours, all creeds. Everybody knows what's happening is wrong. You can't even try to deny it now – Israel's government is just acting with impunity and getting away with it. Us speaking out is a small detail – it's the world's governments that need to do something about it.' Last week, Ó hAnnaidh made an appearance at Westminster magistrates court, during which he was unconditionally bailed with a hearing set for 20 August. Kneecap's defence team, which includes criminal defence lawyer Gareth Peirce, who represented the Birmingham Six and the Guildford Four, has argued that the charge against Ó hAnnaidh was made after the six-month period in which such a terrorism offence would fall under the court's jurisdiction. Hundreds of protesters – including Paul Weller – gathered at the entrance to the court, holding aloft Palestine flags and signs that said 'Free Mo Chara'; a van, emblazoned with the slogan 'More Blacks, More Dogs, More Irish, Mo Chara,' circled the block periodically. Rob and Kathleen, an older couple from Hayling Island, had shown up to 'defend free speech, to support people who protest about genocide in Gaza,' said Rob. 'We're also here to support young people,' Kathleen added. 'Old people have made a real mess of this world, and we are very sorry, and hopefully young people can get us out of this mess.' When asked by the BBC on Wednesday about Kneecap's appearance at Glastonbury, festival organiser Emily Eavis said 'we remain a platform for many, many artists … everyone is welcome here'. But there is still considerable opposition to their Saturday afternoon set. Earlier this week, Starmer said it wasn't 'appropriate' for the band to perform at the festival, while Badenoch said the BBC 'should not be rewarding extremism' by televising the band's set. (A BBC spokesperson told the Guardian that 'whilst the BBC doesn't ban artists, our plans will ensure that our programming will meet our editorial guidelines'.) And, earlier in the month, a leak exposed a letter sent to the organisers of Glastonbury in which a number of music industry heavyweights ask the festival to 'question the wisdom of continuing to have [Kneecap] on the lineup'. The letter was signed by top agents from major live music agencies. That the letter wasn't published publicly is a form of vindication for the trio, says Ó Cairealláin. 'The fact that the letter was leaked changes things,' adds Ó hAnnaidh. 'And I hope that these people regret it. I think they're already starting to.' Kneecap play Glastonbury's West Holts stage at 4pm on Saturday.
