Natasha O'Brien reveals how she tracked down Cathal Crotty after vicious attack
Natasha O'Brien has revealed how she managed to track down Cathal Crotty after he viciously assaulted her.
Crotty, who was a member of the Defence Forces, was jailed for two years after beating Ms O'Brien unconscious in Limerick in 2022, when she challenged him for shouting homophobic abuse.
His initial sentence, which was fully suspended, caused public outcry, with the DPP saying that his sentence was unduly lenient. He was then re-sentenced to two years in prison.
Speaking ahead of a documentary about her ordeal, Ms O'Brien said that she was always determined to see Crotty brought to justice, and that a friend of hers who witnessed the attack recognised one of the men who were with Crotty at the time of the assault. Natasha O'Brien has revealed how she managed to track down Cathal Crotty after he viciously assaulted her. Pic: Fran Veale
'My friend that was with me recognised one of the males in that group,' Ms Crotty told Pat Kenny. 'That was the beginning.'
Ms O'Brien then spoke about how she and her friends tracked down who assaulted her after going through the man's photos, until eventually a photo with Crotty appeared — and they knew they had their man.
'We spent weeks, we went into this individual's profiles, we went into all his tagged photos,' she said. ' All his friends, all their friends, all their tagged photos. [We] kept going systematically for anyone that might have resembled my attacker and that's when we came across a group photo with my attacker in the middle smiling.' Cathal Crotty was sentenced to two years in prison after the Appeals Court ruled that his original, fully suspended sentence was too lenient. Pic: Collins
Crotty initially told Gardaí that he had been attacked first by Ms O'Brien, but admitted what he did when he was shown CCTV of the incident. He also bragged about assaulting Ms O'Brien on Snapchat, boasting 'two to put her down, two to put her out.'
Crotty was originally given a three year fully suspended sentence for assault causing harm, with judge Tom O'Donnell saying that if he were to receive a custodial sentence, his career with the army would have been 'over.' Crotty was later discharged by the army.
The DPP filed that Crotty had been given an unduly lenient sentence, and the Appeals Court later agreed, sentencing Crotty to three years, with the final year suspended. Ms O'Brien said that she tracked down who attacked her after a friend of her's who was with her on the night of the assault recognised one of the men Crotty was with. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/RollingNews.ie
Reflecting on what she had been put through, Ms O'Brien said that the original fully suspended sentence was the 'true injustice.'
'The sentencing judge explained that if I give this individual a custodial sentence then he will lose his job in the Defence Forces,' she said. 'I had read my victim impact statement, I explained about how I'd lost everything, I'd had to move back home to my mother's house at 23.
'I'm now on illness benefit because I'm too unwell to work… and this is all as a result of this individual's actions. Yet you [the judge] are trying to save his job? That's not justice.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Natasha O'Brien says her attacker is victim of Ireland's justice system
Campaigner Natasha O'Brien has said her attacker is a victim of Ireland's justice system. In 2022, the Limerick native was viciously attacked by Cathal Crotty, who was then a member of the Irish Defence Forces. He was given a three-year suspended sentence in June 2024. An appeal was lodged the following month, and the sentence was overturned by the Court of Appeal in January this year, and he was sentenced to two years in jail. But Natasha admitted Crotty was also a victim. "It's not his fault that the system is broken. If that judge last year had insured justice, my attacker would always have received justice. 'Like I am the primary victim but Crotty is the secondary victim now of the justice system because there was a media manhunt against him. That could all have been prevented by that judge and nobody would know his name if the judge hadn't made that decision and made that mistake. 'He has now been impacted by all of this as well. People can make really really serious mistakes and there should be accountability and punishment, but that doesn't mean that their entire life should be destroyed.' In her RTE One documentary, Natasha, which aired last Wednesday, she told viewers that the night she was attacked, she had been defended a passer by on the street who was being subjected to homophobic comments by Crotty and his pals. And despite the horrific assault that happened to her, Natasha said she would defend the person again. 'I would do it again to be honest. I don't see the point in not caring about other people. It's our job as human beings to support other human beings and if we can't do that, why are we even here? We are living our lives and if we can't stand up for others then what is the point.' Natasha said she feels like her own 'personal fight for justice' is now over and she hopes to make more documentaries. 'It has been an emotional rollercoaster but I'm slowly starting to heal now and I'm finally on a new chapter and journey. 'I feel like my own personal fights for justice are now over so now it's trying to go onto bigger things and trying to use this case as a great example of what shouldn't happen again. 'I'm really passionate about trying to continue along to make sure this doesn't happen again for others. I wanted to bare my soul. I'm really happy with how it turned out. 'There is massive potential to do more and work on another project exploring restorative justice and going down that route and how do we really achieve a sense of justice for anyone in the system. I'd love to potentially explore that too.' The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
The Irish Sun
10 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Shocking reality of kids mobile use revealed as teens bombarded with 100s of messages & spend 5 hours a day on phones
TEENS are bombarded with up to 360 phone messages a day – and could spend a total of 25 YEARS glued to their mobiles, a Sun on Sunday probe reveals. Concerned experts are warning that the shock usage poses a threat to kids' mental health. Advertisement 4 Teens are bombarded with up to 360 phone messages a day – and could spend a total of 25 YEARS glued to their mobiles Credit: Getty We tracked four One 16-year-old got almost 2,500 alerts — that is nearly 360 messages a day and one text every two-and-a-half minutes. Another was sent more than 1,600 messages, and one 15-year-old admitted she had messaged a friend back and forth for 967 consecutive days. Our shock findings come as a new report lays bare the amount of time kids spend on their devices — and experts fear youngsters' mental health is being hit by extreme usage. Advertisement Read More on UK News Labour MP Joani Reid, who is leading the call for a ban on smartphones in schools, said: 'Hundreds of messages a day isn't just about distractions in school — it's about safety. 'Every notification could expose our kids to serious dangers — grooming by predators, cyberbullying and graphic, harmful content. Apps like Snapchat and TikTok often shield these interactions from parents, leaving teenagers vulnerable and isolated. 'We need tougher regulations forcing tech companies to prioritise child safety over profit. Parents alone can't monitor every message or app — Government and schools must step up.' Addictive apps A new study has found that the average secondary school pupil is on their mobile for five-and-a-half hours each day. Advertisement Most read in The Sun If they keep that up, they could spend up to 25 years of their lives staring at a phone screen. And 68 per cent of youngsters polled by Fluid Focus said their academic performance was affected by their smartphone use, with 40 per cent admitting to constantly checking their mobile while studying. Snapchat streaks: How to get back a lost streak and how to report a problem Popular teenager Art McGrath, 16, from Leyton, East London, had the most smartphone traffic of all the youngsters we tracked — receiving a staggering 2,493 messages in seven days. His notifications comprised 2,320 Snapchat messages, 112 WhatsApp chats and 61 Instagram alerts. This averages out to 356 messages a day. Advertisement Art said: 'Snapchat is the main messaging app. I've been on it since I was around 12. Everyone is on it. 'I have groups with different friendship groups. I don't give myself phone breaks. If I get a message, I can end up stuck in a loop.' Snapchat is the biggest player in the world of youngsters' messaging apps and is used by 74 per cent of teens in the UK, according to Ofcom. It has been accused of exposing youngsters to Advertisement 'Zero tolerance' Its Streaks function, which tracks the consecutive days two users have messaged each other, has been criticised for being addictive. But bosses at the tech firm say it is just a 'fun thing'. Grace Dainty, 15, from Witney, Oxfordshire, maintains a Streak of 967 days with one pal. Advertisement Over seven days, she received 1,620 messages, with the vast majority — 1,594 — on Snapchat. She said: 'All of my friends, bar one, are on Snapchat. I have a Streak with my best friend of 967. I don't want to let this go. When I get an alert, I look at my phone and respond straight away if it's good. 'If a close friend didn't reply straight away, I would be concerned.' Mum Caroline, a 46-year-old social worker, said: 'I was surprised at the number of messages. This has opened my eyes to how Snapchat works.' Advertisement I was surprised at the number of messages. This has opened my eyes to how Snapchat works Caroline Dainty While Grace may feel as if constant messaging is key to her friendships, psychologist Dr Charlotte Armitage insists: 'As much as people feel like they're connected through phones, they're not — it's a pseudo-connection. 'We need a connection in real life to feel the benefits. Our relationships are crucial for health and life longevity, so we become more disconnected. 'It's snowballed in the last five years and it's getting worse with AI, because not only are people not talking to other people, in apps they are now talking to bots instead.' Dr Armitage, the author of Generation Zombie, also warned of the addictive nature of messaging apps. Advertisement She said: 'The brain becomes used to frequent stimulation and struggles to focus without it, as it starts to search for the next hit of dopamine. 'This has consequences for a child's attentiveness, interpersonal skills such as listening in conversation, ability to engage in academia or any other activity that doesn't provide a dopamine release at regular intervals.' A study from King's College London found that one in four children has 'problematic smartphone usage', meaning they use their devices in a way that is consistent with addiction. Banned in lessons But none of the teens we polled considered their phone use to be unusual or over the top. They all went to bed with their devices and checked them as soon as they woke. Advertisement Every one of them was allowed to take their handset to school, though the vast majority were banned from using devices in lessons. Some continued to text anyway, while others said teachers didn't enforce the rules. Lottie Taylor, 14, from Farsley, Leeds, received 1,243 messages over a week — 75 per cent of them via Snapchat. She said: 'I like Streaks and have 39 people I send to on a daily basis. Advertisement 'I wake up and the first thing I'll do is get on my phone. The longest streak I've got is 574 with my best friend. I like to keep them up. It's a symbol of friendship. I check my Streaks last thing at night as well.' I wake up and the first thing I'll do is get on my phone. The longest streak I've got is 574 with my best friend. I like to keep them up. It's a symbol of friendship. I check my Streaks last thing at night as well Lottie Taylor Lottie's mum Lydia, 43, a primary school teacher, said: 'It's hard to get Lottie moving on a morning because she won't get out of bed until she's done her Streaks.' In Snapchat messages shared with The Sun on Sunday, Lottie and her friend discuss meeting up in the park. Lottie says: 'Ikk [I know] we need to hang out… Bruh I just washed my hair.' Her pal replies: 'Aw bless. Anyway meet you at mine then we'll out.' Advertisement Meanwhile, Logan Hook, 15, from Pudsey, West Yorkshire, received 528 messages in a week on Snapchat and He said: 'I'm in a couple of WhatsApp groups for football mates, and one with school mates. 'I don't think I get a crazy amount of messages, but I will chat to arrange stuff or talk football.' In messages on a football team Advertisement Another pal adds: 'I didn't play bad but didn't play good either', before Logan replies: 'What do you think ur doing texting in class'. ART McGRATH, 16 - Leyton, East London 4 Art McGrath, 16, from Leyton, East London gets 2,493 messages a week Credit: Darren Fletcher Messages per week: 2,493 Average per day : 356 Advertisement Platforms : Snapchat, WhatsApp, Instagram Parent : Dad Nick, 54, a writer, gets around 160 messages in a day, mostly on WhatsApp. LOGAN HOOK, 15 - Pudsey, West Yorks 4 Logan Hook, 15, from Pudsey, West YorksLogan Hook, 15, gets 528 messages per week Credit: Glen Minikin Messages per week: 528 Advertisement Average per day: 75 Platforms : Snapchat and WhatsApp Parent's use: Mum Kirsty, 44, a doctor's receptionist, gets around 55 messages a day, mainly on WhatsApp. LOTTIE TAYLOR, 14 - Farsley, Leeds 4 Lottie Taylor, 14, from Farsley, Leeds receives 1,234 messages per week Credit: Glen Minikin Advertisement Messages per week: 1,234 Average per day: 178 Platforms : Snapchat, WhatsApp, TikTok Parent's use: Mum Lydia, 43, has around 186 messages a day on WhatsApp, texts and Instagram. Advertisement 'Getting more addictive' By Daisy Greenwell, Founder of the campaign group Smartphone Free Childhood THE amount of messages these kids receive is staggering. I was also struck by how long teens are maintaining their Snapchat Streaks for. These findings make me particularly angry because it's a design seemingly aimed at keeping kids on their phones for as long as possible. Children are being manipulated into staring at a rectangular screen when they could be out discovering the real world with real friends. The amount of time kids spend with friends has plummeted since 2010, when they started getting smartphones, while cases of teenage anxiety, depression and self-harm have skyrocketed. Seven in ten students believe phone use has harmed their academic performance. It's not surprising! Studies show it takes 20 minutes to refocus after your attention has been broken. If that's happening hundreds of times a day, that's a large portion of your day you're not focused on what you're doing or what's happening around you. Phones will not stop getting more addictive unless change happens. We are working with politicians to pressure the Government into stopping profit-driven companies from infiltrating our kids' minds.
Sunday World
a day ago
- Sunday World
Air passenger ‘helped woman and son illegally immigrate to Ireland', court told
Rita Marouani (53) initially denied that she knew the pair when she went to a different immigration booth at Dublin Airport, but their boarding passes and fake passports were found on her, a court heard. An air passenger who allegedly helped a woman and her son to illegally immigrate to Ireland, where they then sought asylum, is facing trial for people-smuggling. Rita Marouani (53) initially denied that she knew the pair when she went to a different immigration booth at Dublin Airport, but their boarding passes and fake passports were found on her, a court heard. Judge Monika Leech ruled the case was too serious to be dealt with at Dublin District Court and adjourned it for further DPP directions. Ms Marouani, a mother of one and carer with an address in Germany, is charged with assisting the illegal entry of people into the State and possession of false documents. Dublin Airport. News in 90 Seconds - June 28th Garda Sergeant Derek Spain said the DPP consented to the case remaining in the District Court. Outlining the prosecution's case, he said a woman and her son arrived on an Aer Lingus flight from Germany on March 30 and entered the immigration hall. They presented at a booth with no documentation and claimed asylum. This woman denied knowing Ms Marouani who came off the same flight, approached a different booth and presented a German passport. The accused also denied having travelled with the other two passengers. However, it was alleged, she had boarding passes in their names and when further questioned, she produced four passports. Two were genuine Georgian passports and two were false Czech passports, the court heard. In interview, she said she was only helping the woman and her son because they were afraid to fly alone and she knew the woman's mother from Georgia. According to the prosecution, she alleged that the woman had placed the passports into her handbag without her knowledge. The accused denied getting any payment from the woman to assist her arriving in Ireland. The woman said she and her son had travelled here on the false Czech passports and paid €2,500 each for them to 'an unknown entity'. She stated she had got the passports in Georgia before travelling to Germany and when they arrived there, she handed all four passports to Ms Marouani but did not pay her any money. It was the two other people who benefited from the alleged offence and Ms Marouani 'didn't understand the gravity of the situation' and made a 'terrible decision'. The two were released but as they were not detained, they left and 'continued their journey' out of Ireland and into the UK.
