'End of an era': Shoppers mourn Smith & Caughey's closure after 145 years
The business announced it would be shutting down after 145 years.
Photo:
RNZ / Marika Khabazi
Shoppers in Auckland are mourning the closure of Smith & Caughey's department store on Queen Street.
On Wednesday, the
business announced it would be shutting down
after 145 years.
Heart of the City chief executive Viv Beck said the situation was devastating.
"It's very sad for the family, the staff, and a major loss for Queen Street."
She said once the City Rail Link opened, the building would be in a great location.
But as well as ongoing construction work, she said Auckland Council and Auckland Transport limiting vehicle access on the street was making it harder for businesses in the area to survive.
"We've already lost around 44 percent of the cars coming in during the morning peak since 2015 and yet there's a fine for people going into a stretch of Queen Street just by Smith & Caughey's.
"We know people for instance with disabilities can't get through that stretch to get to Smith & Caughey's.
"It's also our night time entertainment area. These decisions are not grounded in common sense or economic viability and we've been appealing to transport and council to do something. This has to be a wake-up call for them."
Waitematā and Gulf Ward councillor, Mike Lee, agreed AT and the council were partly to blame for Smith & Caughey's demise.
He said it was gutting to see the "commercial life being squeezed out" of the once thriving street.
"This [the store's closure] is a massive body blow for Queen Street and the viability of retail and the whole social ambience.
"Smith & Caughey's have bravely battled on for years now, but this forever construction, forever disruption, perceived lack of safety, the filthy streets, all of that is a turn-off for shoppers."
One shopper RNZ spoke to, Jane Etheridge, said she was devastated to see the end of the store's famous Christmas display and Santa's Grotto.
"It's unbelievably sad. It's been around for such a long time and is part of New Zealand's heritage. It's one of the few heritage brands we have.
"I grew up coming here every Christmas looking at the window displays and coming to the grotto. I bring my children here and there's not anything else like it."
Meredith Townsley Fenton said it was a shame given the store's long history.
"It's the end of an era. I was talking to one of the staff members and her mother brought her bridal lingerie there in the 1920s.
"All of Queen Street has really changed."
Some people including Allan Fitzgerald had noticed a declining number of people in the area.
"My wife and I, my mother, and grandmother all used to shop here.
"I look around and where are the cars? Where are the people? They're not carrying shopping bags.
"It's really disappointing. But I fully understand why they're having to close."
The future of the partially heritage-protected building owned by private shareholders is unknown.
Auckland Council said it did not want to speculate on what it would be used for.
Smith & Caughey's declined to comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
98 road cone reports on hotline's first day
Photo: Photo / 123RF WorkSafe received 98 reports on the first day of its road cone hotline. The 12-month pilot got underway on Tuesday, as part of the government's broader overhauls to health and safety. The workplace relations and safety minister Brooke van Velden has shifted WorkSafe's focus from enforcement to advice , telling the agency to work with businesses and individuals to manage risks. Her letter of expectation told WorkSafe to establish the hotline for businesses and individuals to report excessive road cone use traffic management requirements, with follow-up inspections where necessary. A WorkSafe spokesperson said as at 4:30pm on Tuesday, it had received 98 reports. Van Velden said the road cone policy would be the most "front-facing" that people would see, as most people were not going onto dangerous work sites. She said there were originally suggestions of a road cone phone line, but she went against it and suggested a digital system as it would need fewer resources and staffing. "I want people when they're out on the streets, taking their kids to school or heading to work, to know that if they see a roadcone... it's there for harm. Whereas at the moment, there are so many road cones that people are ignoring them." Transport minister Chris Bishop said the use of road cones was regulated in various ways, but NZTA had a role to play. "NZTA is not responsible for all the roads around the country. They're responsible for State Highways, but often people have road cone issues on local roads, which are the responsibility of the contractor, who's ultimately responsible to the local council, who sets the rules around that," he said. "There's temporary traffic management in place around particular events, which has been and can be quite overzealous." Bishop said there would continue to be cones on the road, as the government had made significant investments in road maintenance. Labour leader Chris Hipkins was not in favour of the hotline. "It's a total waste of time. Ultimately, WorkSafe should be focused on keeping people alive at work, making sure that all of our workplaces are safe, not worrying about road cones."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Thieves target Bay of Plenty orchards for scrap metal
Photo: RNZ/Carol Stiles Sheet metal from outbuildings and copperwires from frost fans are among some of the things being targeted by thieves for scrap metal amidst an increase on orchard thefts in Bay of Plenty. Te Puke police sergeant Mike Owens said since January they'd had close to 40 such burglaries, adding those were just the ones reported to police. "Items that get targeted are farm vehicles, equipment, tools, diesel from frost fans, other machinery, trailers, solar panels and of course the frost fans also have batteries attached to them as well." He said it was an unfortunately common experience for growers and farmers during the busy harvest season, when many might be travelling between sites or have additional people on-farm. Taking preventative measures was key to deterring these kind of thefts, he said. Things like storing equipment securely away or out of view. "Generally good locks, good security makes it more difficult. "Farmers and orchardists being lovely rural people will tend to leave keys in their vehicle or sheds and equipment unlocked." Owens said some frost fans had been rigged up with sensor lights and alarms which acted as a good deterrence. "I've seen footage where that has immediately deterred, obviously an alarms come one deterred the thief, and off they've gone again." Police recently executed search warrants and recovered a large number of items which they were in the process of returning to their owners. Owens said it was important for growers and farmers to report these kinds of incidents to police. He said it was also helpful to make note of any identifying features of items which might be targeted which might help with recovery efforts.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Trade Me sale will not alter commitment to news
Stuff CEO Sinead Boucher and Trade Me CEO Anders Skoe Photo: Supplied / TradeMe The owner of media company Stuff says it remains committed to news despite the sale of its digital arm. The company has agreed to sell 50 percent of Stuff Digital , which runs the Stuff website and ThreeNews, to online marketplace Trade Me. Under the agreement, Stuff's property section will become Trade Me Property branded, with listings, ads and some content shared across both platforms. Stuff Group chief executive Sinead Boucher told Morning Report the change was about expanding and diversifying the business. "We've done a very good job over the last five years of securing our own future. But we're in a industry and in a world where there is lots of change, lots of things still to be done and lots of opportunity," she said. "We want to make sure we're in the best position to harness that and keep growing." Since last July, Stuff has been providing an evening news bulletin, replacing the former Newshub news service, after the company announced an agreement with Warner Bros Discovery New Zealand. "There isn't going to be any changes as a result of this deal to any of our products or our staff of people," Boucher said. "Whatever happens to that, that's up to Warner Brothers, it's not up to Stuff." Boucher said she had no concerns about the future business moves of Trade Me's owners. Trade Me was bought by private equity company Apax Partners in 2019. Stuff's mastheads, The Post, the Press and the Waikato Times, its events business and Neighbourly were not included in the deal. Last year the media company was divided in two - Stuff Digital and Masthead Publishing which runs newspaper brands and its own websites. "[Masthead Publishing] is also a very digitally focused business," Boucher said. "It has spent the last couple of years building up very strong subscription audiences. We have re-positioned The Post for example as a national publication around politics, business, economics, etc. That's continuing to go really well for us." Boucher did not rule out a future sale of the mastheads but said she had no immediate plans to do so. "We're in media, nobody should ever say 'always' or 'nevers', but that's certainly not on my agenda at the moment." The property section of Stuff would be clearly delineated, Boucher said. Meanwhile, former editor of the New Zealand Herald and media commentator Gavin Ellis said the Herald had been drifting of late and there had been a clear signal that there needed to be more media experience on the board. He was commenting after media company NZME, which owns the New Zealand Herald and Newstalk ZB, revamped its board . Canadian businessman and activist shareholder Jim Grenon launched a bid to replace the board with himself and three associates. He ended up with a seat on the board and former National government minister Steven Joyce has taken over as chair. Ellis welcomed the appointment of Joyce who brought not only political expertise but also a lengthy association with the radio industry. He was a lot more "nuanced" than people realised and would be good for the board. However, he was less sure about the impact of Grenon and his attitude to editorial matters. "New Zealand media for as long as I can remember have been free of political interfence from their boards." Editorial independence was "a precious thing to preserve". "I think that anybody who crosses that editorial line does so at their peril. I think the paper would suffer and levels of trust would suffer." No assurances had been given so far, Ellis said, and the Herald's soon to be created Editorial Advisory Board should have a binding charter which should be made public.
