Owner challenges order to sell patch of land to St Andrews community group
A landowner is challenging a Scottish government decision to force it to sell a patch of overgrown ground to a community group.Forthtay Ltd does not want to sell the strip of land in St Andrews to Poet's Neuk, which plans to turn it in to a public garden dedicated to Mary Queen of Scots.But those behind the Isle of Man-based trust were compelled to do so by ministers under the terms of land reform laws, which came into force in 2020.It is the first time the legislation has been used to force a community buyout of land, and the Scottish government will defend its decision in a case starting at Dundee later.
And, if the appeal is denied, lawyers for the trust say it may have a "ground breaking" implications for land ownership in Scotland. Poet's Neuk said the land - at the corner of Greyfriars Garden and St Mary's Place - was gifted to the Fife town by Queen Mary prior to her abdication in 1567.The group said in recent years it has been the scene of anti-social behaviour and drug taking and also has an issue with vermin.
Poet's Neuk was granted planning permission from Fife Council to transform the land - which sits within St Andrews' conservation area - into a public garden, complete with a statue of Queen Mary.In 2018 it was awarded the right to buy the land under the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016.A provision added to the legislation in 2020 stated "abandoned, neglected or detrimental" land can be bought by a community organisation via compulsory purchase if it is judged to be in the "public interest" for it to do so.That was granted to the group in 2023.
'National implications'
But lawyers acting for Forthtay, which was previously known as Optimus Fiduciaries Ltd, said several of its previous planning applications for the site were rejected by Fife Council.The latest application was for a coffee kiosk on the land inside a converted horsebox.It was unanimously refused after attracting more than 40 objections.Lawyers also said previous plans to curb anti-social behaviour on the site were turned down by the council.MML Law, based in Dundee, warned the outcome of the case would have "national implications".A spokesman said: "The owners are now essentially being accused and found guilty of effectively neglecting the land and thus being required to forfeit ownership against their wishes."This is a groundbreaking case which could have far reaching consequences for many around Scotland."Any property owner in Scotland would be well advised to pay very close attention to the provisions of this act and how this case unfolds."The Scottish government said it could not comment on live cases.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Rangers don't need to cash-in on best players ahead of summer rebuild, insists new boss Martin
Russell Martin insists Rangers will be under no obligation to sell any of their star players during a major summer rebuild. Martin was appointed as the Ibrox club's new head coach on Thursday on a three-year deal and will be tasked with revamping the squad and playing style. With fresh investment of around £20million coming from the club's new American owners, chief executive Patrick Stewart has stated that 'a decent amount' of that will be made available to Martin. Nico Raskin and Mohamed Diomande have both been strongly linked with moves away from Rangers this summer. Midfield duo Raskin and Diomande are two of the club's top assets and have attracted interest from the English Premier League and across Europe. Any money raised from player sales will be reinvested in the squad, but new boss Martin insists the club are under no pressure whatsoever to sell. Asked about retaining top talent, he said: 'We have to try and keep our best players. I think we're all really aligned with that. 'So unless things come in that really help the club to build and move forward, I don't think it's a necessity to do that [sell] at all. That's my understanding of it. 'And we've all been really clear on it. So we'll just have to wait and see. But I'm looking forward to working with those guys. 'There are a few positions where we'll need to strengthen fairly quickly and fairly early on [with regards to Champions League qualifiers in July]. 'I'm pretty sure by then we'll have one or two in. I'm also willing to be surprised and I'm open to being surprised by some of the players we have here. 'I feel excited about the challenge of Europe, yeah. I think it's different in terms of obviously having a bit less awareness of the opposition, which is going to take a bit more working. 'But it's going to be about us. Whether we're playing in Europe, in the league, in the cup, whatever it is, it's going to be about us and trying to be the best we can be. 'But to experience that, the thought of having European nights here, it's hugely exciting and appealing. So we have to try and make that happen.' During his short loan stint at Rangers back in 2018, Martin played alongside club captain James Tavernier. The new head coach insists he is full of respect for the skipper, who has one year left on his deal. Despite Tavernier continuing to divide opinion among fans, Martin sees no immediate reason to change the captaincy. 'First and foremost, I'll speak to Tav, to explain things and have a discussion about the last two years, his thoughts on the team,' said the new Ibrox boss. 'I'll get his thoughts on what we're going to bring and how the players will feel about that. 'I think to play here for as long as he has, to be captain for as long as he has, takes a lot of energy. It's not easy. 'I've been at a club where sometimes you're the one that's been there the longest and you end up getting criticised a lot because you've been there the longest. You're an ageing player and all that stuff. 'I think he's been so important for this team and this club on and off the pitch and I'm looking forward to chatting in more detail with him and speaking to him about it all. 'Then how much he gets used on the pitch will be down to Tav and how he trains and how he plays, the same as every player. 'But he's going to be hugely important in the culture. I know what he's like a person behind the scenes and he's fantastic. 'He really was when I played with him and hopefully football hasn't beaten him up too much. It doesn't seem like it has. He still seems like he plays with a big smile and a lot of enthusiasm. 'It does carry a big weight to be captain of a club this size. I think he's done it incredibly well. 'How much he plays on the pitch, I can't sit here and tell you he's going to play 50 games, 20 games, whatever. It will be down to him in the way he performs and the way he buys into it, which I'm pretty sure he will. 'He's been the captain for a very long time. I don't see any reason to change that. And if he's not playing, it will be someone else.'
The Independent
8 hours ago
- The Independent
Warning airport staff strike could ‘ground planes and passengers'
Over 800 workers across five companies at Glasgow Airport may strike due to pay disputes, potentially disrupting summer travel. Unite the union will ballot staff at Glasgow Airport Ltd, ICTS Central Search, Swissport, Menzies Aviation, and Falck for industrial action if disputes aren't resolved in two weeks. Swissport workers are in dispute over rotas and work-life balance, while ICTS Central Search workers are protesting under-staffing, working conditions, and pay. Workers employed by Glasgow Airport Limited and Falck firefighters rejected a 3.6% pay increase, and Menzies Aviation workers turned down a 4.25% uplift. Unite general secretary Sharon Graham stated the companies can afford better pay and conditions, accusing them of prioritising profits over fair wages. Holidaymakers warned that airport strikes could disrupt summer getaways
Scottish Sun
9 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots holidaymakers warned of summer chaos as hundreds of airport staff plan walkout
Passengers and planes could be grounded FLIGHTMARE! Scots holidaymakers warned of summer chaos as hundreds of airport staff plan walkout Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HOLIDAYMAKERS have been warned of the potential for strike action at Glasgow Airport over the summer as more than 800 workers from five companies are involved in pay disputes. Unite the union said workers at Glasgow Airport Ltd, ICTS Central Search, Swissport, Menzies Aviation and Falck could be balloted for walkouts. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Staff at Glasgow Airport could strike later this year Credit: John Kirkby - The Sun Glasgow 3 Workers are caught up in a pay dispute with bosses Credit: John Kirkby - The Sun Glasgow The union said on Saturday that if there is no successful resolution to the disputes in the coming days, it will move towards holding votes on industrial action within two weeks. It warned strikes could "ground planes and passengers". Pat McIlvogue, Unite industrial officer, said walkouts could be held from the middle of July. More than 100 Swissport workers are locked in a dispute about rotas and work-life balance, according to Unite. It said the company "is demanding that workers at extreme short notice have to work shifts at various times and for various durations, which is directly impacting on their personal lives". Unite said some Swissport staff are "struggling with chronic fatigue". A further 250 ICTS Central Search workers, who deal with passengers directly in the security search area and process them for flights, are currently involved in a dispute over under-staffing, working conditions and pay. A total of 120 workers employed by Glasgow Airport Limited have rejected a basic 3.6% pay increase, with staff including airport ambassadors, airside support officers, engineers and managers involved. The same 3.6% pay increase was rejected by 50 Falck firefighters who perform fire safety functions at the airport. Meanwhile 300 Menzies Aviation workers, including dispatchers, allocators, airside agents and controllers, have rejected a basic uplift worth around 4.25%. The union recently announced a series of what it said were wage wins for 100 North Air workers across Scottish airports, and more than 140 staff based at Glasgow Airport employed by ABM and OCS. Shock moment brazen Manchester Airport worker WEES on driver's Range Rover in long-stay carpark Unite general secretary Sharon Graham said: "Hundreds of workers at Glasgow Airport are heading towards summer strike action which would ground planes and passengers. "The companies involved are all highly profitable and can easily afford to give our members better pay and working conditions. "The truth is that they are denying fair pay increases to cynically boost their profits." Mr McIlvogue said: "Unite is in dispute with companies at Glasgow Airport which could ultimately bring hundreds of workers out on strike. "The companies can resolve these disputes with Unite before that situation happens by addressing the legitimate concerns and pay aspirations of our members. "If the companies refuse to work with Unite to resolve these disputes, then we will have no option but to open strike ballots. This could mean strike action happening from the middle of July." A spokesperson for Swissport said: "We are in dialogue with Unite - the talks so far have been constructive and we remain focused on working together to address the issues being raised." Phil Lloyd, senior vice president UK, Menzies Aviation, said: "Following the rejection of recent pay award proposals, we remain committed to seeking a resolution, and have in fact met with Unite today to make an enhanced offer, with a follow-up session scheduled. "We hope to reach an agreement which is workable for both the business and our employees at Glasgow Airport. "We continue to work towards an agreeable solution to protect services for our airline and airport partners and their customers." Glasgow Airport Ltd, ICTS Central Search, and Falck have been contacted for comment.
