Vatsonga Machangani Forum condemns personal attacks on TUT Vice-Chancellor
Calls for unity as Vatsonga Forum addresses accusations against TUT Vice-Chancellor Professor Tinyiko Maluleke
Image: IOL/Independent Newspapers
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum has issued a strong condemnation of what it described as the recent 'personal attacks' directed at Professor Tinyiko Maluleke, Vice-Chancellor of Tshwane University of Technology (TUT), following a complaint lodged at the office of the Public Protector.
The organisation decried what it calls "the baseless allegations made by William Maphutha, who claims to represent an organisation in Sekhukhune," and emphasised the importance of respecting institutions and the individuals working toward educational development.
Unjust Attacks and Misinformation
Maphutha's claims stem from a report that the Bapedi Royal Kingdom in Sekhukhune has lodged a formal complaint with the South African Public Protector, Kholeka Gcaleka.
The complaint alleged that TUT has sabotaged efforts to establish a university in Sekhukhune—specifically a proposed University of Mining and Agriculture—despite a memorandum of understanding (MOU) signed in 2021 between the Bapedi Kingdom and TUT.
Maphutha, through his company Batsumi Pty Ltd, asserts that he pioneered the project and accuses TUT of hijacking it without proper consultation.
However, the Vatsonga Machangani Forum said that these claims are unfounded.
A statement released on Friday highlighted that Maphutha's recent communication does not address any legitimate concerns regarding project communication but instead targets Professor Maluleke, falsely alleging that he is from Giyani and implying misconduct.
The organisation condemned these tactics as attempts to incite tribal bigotry and undermine the integrity of the Vice-Chancellor.
"The recent personal attacks on Professor Tinyiko Maluleke are not only unfounded but also deliberately aimed at undermining the integrity of an esteemed academic and leader," said the Vatsonga Machangani Forum.
The Truth About the Giyani Campus
According to the forum, the campaign for a university in Giyani predates recent political promises.
'Since 2004, Vatsonga Machangani leaders, including Dr Ndhambi of the Khatsani Education Foundation, have advocated tirelessly for higher education in Giyani—long before President Cyril Ramaphosa's public commitment to establishing a mining university in the region.'
The forum said that the push for the Giyani TUT campus is rooted in decades of community-driven efforts to foster economic growth and development.
"Our community has been calling for a university in Giyani since 2004—long before political promises were made. This is a fight for our future, not personal gain," the Forum said.
'Despite opposition rooted in tribalism and fears of change, the economic potential of the Giyani campus is undeniable.'
The organisation argued that the hostility now expressed by some groups reflects a reluctance to embrace progress and the positive impact that higher education institutions can bring to impoverished regions.
"Both Giyani and Sekhukhune deserve their institutions of higher learning," the Forum asserts. "Our focus should be on collaboration, not conflict."
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
A Call for Fairness and Respect
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum underscored that Professor Maluleke is not alone in creating the Giyani campus.
'It is the culmination of long-standing advocacy by local communities and organisations committed to expanding access to higher education.'
They maintained that both Giyani and Sekhukhune deserve their own universities and that competition or rivalry should not be used to discredit efforts.
'South Africa faces a significant shortage of university spaces, with many matriculants unable to access tertiary education. Both regions should benefit from expansion, not be pitted against each other.
"There is enough room in South Africa for both Giyani and Sekhukhune to thrive through expanded access to higher education," read the statement.
Refuting Reckless Accusations
'Maphutha's accusations against Professor Maluleke go as far as calling him a "manipulator of truth" and a "thief"—claims that are reckless, unfounded, and damaging.
'The Vice-Chancellor's reputation, built on integrity and academic excellence, must not be tarnished by falsehoods.
"Claims that Professor Maluleke is a 'thief' or 'manipulator of truth' are reckless and baseless. He has dedicated his career to education and community upliftment," emphasised the Forum.
The Forum added that TUT has already taken steps toward establishing a Sekhukhune campus, including a letter dated April 12, 2025, confirming the appointment of a partner to conduct a market study.
It said any naming or branding issues, such as references to a "Sekhukhune University of Mining and Agriculture," should be addressed through proper channels and official processes, not inflammatory rhetoric.
"Claims that TUT hijacked the project are unfounded. The university is committed to serving all communities and is engaging in official processes to develop the Sekhukhune campus," the forum stated.
Ending the Cycle of Tribalism and Division
The Vatsonga Machangani Forum called on the Limpopo provincial government and relevant authorities to foster social cohesion and facilitate development efforts in Sekhukhune and Giyani.
They stressed that tribalism and divisive tactics only hinder progress and deepen divisions.
"We call on authorities to foster social cohesion and support our communities' development efforts instead of fuelling tribal divisions," urged the Forum.
The organisation said that community leaders and advocates remain committed to advancing educational opportunities in their regions. It urges all stakeholders to work together in good faith, putting aside personal and tribal conflicts in pursuit of shared development goals.
TUT did not respond to IOL by the time of the publication.
thabo.makwakwa@inl.co.za
IOL
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
7 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
A discussion about the coloured community and other conversation-stoppers
Against my better judgement, I stepped into a discussion on social media. It was one of those discussions that is marked by conversation-stoppers, deflections and presentations of innocence that is so de rigueur in South African society. It was a discussion about actual or perceived marginalisation of the coloured community in South Africa. This is a country built on decades of racism, but there are no racists. It is a country where citizens compare miseries, where individuals or groups of individuals attempt, constantly, to outmanoeuvre one another in the races to show who is or has been most persecuted, whose persecution matters most, and where the country's myriad problems are explained by monocausal simplicities and convenience. None of these is, of course, unique to South Africa. Conversation-stoppers are swung about like a rapier, slashing, and killing conversations, dead. You may say, for instance, that there may be a reason why people are opposed to your (Caligulan) brutality and cruelty, and the conversation-stopper is that you harbour an ancient hatred of the cruel brute and his people caught in flagrante delicto, so you cannot, possibly be intellectually honest. You may say that someone is wilfully marginalised through some biblical punishment where the sins of the fathers shall be visited upon the children. The deflection is slipped in; the children have been and will always be guilty, and exploit their intergenerational privileges, which, in some ways, may well be true. As a former colleague said after I admonished her for abusing a (white) child of about six or seven running through the newsroom: 'A snake gives birth to a snake.' This logic – hard to dispute the snake-gives-birth-to-a-snake, or kill them in infancy before they kill you – has been applied to present-day conflicts where innocent children are being killed almost daily. If I have not made it clear previously, I should do it again, here: I don't particularly care for identity politics or race-based politics, and I am not a specialist of coloured politics… there are people who, I am sure, are better placed for this purpose. All of this does not make me blind to the way privileges, powers and influences are handed down to successive generations, and how later generations will conspire to protect such privileges. It is an empirically verifiable fact that power and influence, privileges and benefits (the various forms of capital, political, financial, social or symbolic) accumulated over more than 300 years do not evaporate within 30 years… it is power and privilege that is vertically segmented. We speak, in this respect, about the 'development thesis' in terms of which powers, material and otherwise (ownership of property, development of technology and knowledge production, in general), tend to develop over time and become more powerful. When these powers are under threat, or even questioned rhetorically, those who wield the power feel 'uncomfortable', or 'fragile', and egads! they cry persecution, injustice and oppression, conveniently forgetting their (historical) roles and functions in getting us to where we are. Coloured community concerns and the deflection Let's leave all that as a backdrop, and return to my brief foray into the discussion of the coloured community I mentioned above. First, I should set out those nasty racial classifications, definitions and conceptions of purity and belonging. I refer hereafter to black people to exclude those South Africans who are classified coloured, and considered to be 'not black enough' or 'non-African'. Again, my personal identity affiliations or lack thereof (political, racial, ethnic or cultural) are set aside. The conversation I refer to went something like this: A coloured guy stands up and explains that the coloured community is marginalised, especially in the Western Cape. Also in Panayaza Lesufi's Gauteng, it should be said, and all of which makes a nonsense of the non-racialism that we fought for in South Africa. Before the topic of actual or perceived marginalisation is even considered, the host of the discussion deflects and asks why the coloured community persists with their coloured identity. Absent are the facts that the Afrikaner nationalists created the vile and contemptible racial classification system, and the African nationalists have simply adopted what has always been a vile and contemptible racial classification system. Those are just the facts. The Afrikaner nationalists may tell us that they meant well. I am absolutely sure that the African nationalists have only the best interests of South Africa in mind. That's the thing about oppressive or unjust regimes: Joseph Stalin or Pol Pot did not say they were going to kill millions of people. Kaiser Wilhelm II and Adolf Hitler did not say, up front, that they would be responsible for the death of more than 100 million people in Europe. (See this essay by my favourite 20th-century historian, Eric Hobsbawm) They meant well, no? The National Party (Afrikaner nationalist) and the ANC (African nationalists) would proclaim innocence, to be sure. Julius Malema's ethno-nationalism of a particular kind, where those people whom he considers to be non-African don't matter and don't belong. His staunchest of followers would tell you, I am sure, that he means well… Coloured community concerns and denials, and counter-accusations It's marvellous to behold. Frightening is probably a better word, but never mind. Criminal organisations or unjust regimes have at least one thing in common. Privileged people who are reminded of their ill-begotten status and the forms of capital mentioned above, have the same habit. Deny everything (we are not racist), admit nothing (we worked hard for our money) and make counter-accusations (you're racist/reverse racist). Before seriously considering the cries of the coloured community's leaders, the counter-accusation (a veritable conversation-stopper) is that coloured people are racist, and have always been racist towards black people. It does not help, of course, that very many coloured people have shimmied up to the party of white settlers, the DA, as they did to the National Party with the Tricameral Parliament. If we accept that more than one thing can be true at the same time – that the coloured community has been left behind in whatever resembles a peace and prosperity dividend of the democratic era, and that coloured people have shimmied up to the illiberal, undemocratic and unjust forces in the country – the least one can do is listen, and look at the evidence. Instead, when coloured groups raise issues of crime, disproportionate incarceration, unemployment, drug abuse (all social problems that stem from poverty and alienation), the black African response is: well, coloureds are racist, or they (themselves) reproduce myths about being coloured, when the African nationalists actually reinvoked and reapplied the vile and contemptible racial classification system – because the higher you are on the scale of racial superiority, the more money there is to be made. For instance, when the Dutch, then British, and then Settler Colonialists (during the Afrikaner nationalist era) placed and kept whites on the top rung, they reaped the benefits of everything; from the proceeds of gold and diamonds, to agriculture and education, which helps explain the development thesis referred to above. The main problem, the way I see it, is that in this great-tjank – everyone is in tears about being persecuted and we're in a state of national paralysis – claims of eternal innocence give one group a monopoly on persecution (they have been the most persecuted in history), and gives that group a free reign with meting out punishment (everyone else must suffer biblical punishment and, anyway, a snake gives birth to a snake), and nobody can be as innocent as the ones who claim eternal innocence, and nobody can be innocent enough. As a pessimist, I don't expect things to get any better for the coloured community. This is quite apart from declinism, although it is profoundly Panglossian to be positive. I will leave one example. Somewhere in the Northern Cape, somewhere between Springbok and Upington, there is a black man working on a farm. Once he got a job on the farm, he brought his family from Mpumalanga. Now, let me be clear. As much as South Africa belongs to everyone who lives in it, people are free to move around the country as they wish! Now, that man from Mpumalanga was employed after a coloured man from the area was replaced because black economic empowerment and affirmative action policies (according to the farmer) awards more points for employing a 'black African' as opposed to a coloured. The first problem with this is that the area has been predominantly coloured/Khoi/San for centuries. The ANC has had a policy of converting every corner of the country to reflect the demographics of South Africa; in other words, if, as Jimmy Manyi said when he was still in the ANC and a government spokesperson, coloureds are overconcentrated in any particular region, that had to be changed 'to reflect the demographics of South Africa'. This means that if there happens to be a street in which coloured people are in the majority, as in most of the Northern Cape, that has to change to the point where the street represents the approximately 80% of 'black Africans' in the country. It does not end on the streets of townships. I shan't complain, but I was told that I should forget about applying for an academic post at UCT as it would be futile, because the institution would rather employ a 'real African' from any of the 54 states on the continent than a coloured person. All told, the great-tjank has made us all wrestle over who has been most persecuted, who faces the most injustice and who has the right to mete out punishment, because, you know, a snake gives birth to a snake and at the extremes you must kill a baby before the baby grows up and kills you.
The South African
8 hours ago
- The South African
Mayibuye Mandela charges 'refugees', AfriForum with treason
Mayibuye Mandela, the great-grandson of Nelson Mandela's sister, has laid charges of treason against the group of Afrikaner 'refugees' who arrived in the US as 'persecuted' people. The outspoken politician also charged activist organisations AfriForum and Solidarity Movement for their comments about South Africa. On his X account, Mayibuye Mandela – who refers to himself as 'Nelson Mandela's great grandson' – revealed that he had officially taken action against the group of Afrikaner 'refugees'. Mayibuye posted official documents stating that he had laid a charge of treason against the group, as well as Afrikaner rights organisations, AfriForum, and Solidarity Movement. In the papers, Mayibuye accused the 'refugees' and the organisation of spreading 'fake news' and a 'false narrative' of a 'white genocide' in South Africa. The 30-year-old stated that the 'refugees' had violated numerous laws, including: Incitement to cause public harm or racial hatred over their 'propaganda'. Misinformation and Cyber Defamation for 'causing reputational harm to South Africa'. Immigration Act for 'knowingly submitting false claims of persecution'. Apart from being charged by Mayibuye Mandela, AfriForum is also facing a treason probe after four dockets of high treason were opened against it. The lobby group has been condemned for calling for the US to 'intervene' in domestic affairs. It has also been accused of spreading misinformation about the Expropriation Act. Afrikaner 'refugees' depart South Africa for the US. Image: X/ According to reports, the Haws are currently interviewing witnesses in their investigation. Hawks head, Godfrey Lebeya, said: 'These kinds of matters need to be approached carefully. We are dealing with a serious crime here.' AfriForum CEO Kallie Kriel has repeatedly claimed that he was 'not concerned' over the probe. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 . Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp , Facebook , X, and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
9 hours ago
- The South African
SANDF troops repatriated from DR Congo to arrive home on Friday
South African troops deployed in the conflict-plagued eastern Democratic Republic of Congo as part of a regional mission began withdrawing on Thursday and the first are due home on Friday, authorities said. The Southern African Development Community (SADC) said in March it would end its military mission in the mineral-rich area after 17 of its soldiers were killed in escalating conflict between government forces and the Rwanda-backed M23 armed group. The first phase that started in April 'focused on the equipment and other logistical assets', SADC said in a statement. The second phase that started on Thursday 'entails the repatriation of mission personnel along with their personal belongings, and the remaining operational equipment', it said. The South African National Defence Force separately announced that the first group of South African troops was due to arrive on Friday at an army base in Bloemfontein. The SADC Mission in the Democratic Republic of Congo (SAMIDRC) – made up of soldiers from Malawi, Tanzania and South Africa – was sent to the region in December 2023 to help the government of the DRC, also a SADC member, restore peace and security in the volatile region. The M23 has seized large swathes of DRC's North and South Kivu provinces, including capturing the key provincial capitals of Goma and Bukavu early this year. Stationed in Goma and Sake, the SAMIDRC troops 'will be transported to the United Republic of Tanzania where the Tanzanian contingent will continue to Dar es Salaam', the SADC statement said. 'South African and Malawian contingents will be airlifted to their respective countries,' it said. The size of the deployment was never made public, but analysts estimate it to number at least 1 300 soldiers, with South Africa contributing most of the troops. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
