AI ‘could significantly increase unemployment' Oireachtas committee told
The rise of
artificial intelligence
(AI) may lead to job losses which could 'significantly increase unemployment' an Oireachtas committee was told on Tuesday, with experts warning that entry-level software engineering and legal roles are among the first sectors hit by AI job displacements.
The chair of the AI Advisory Council, Patricia Scanlon said in her opening remarks to the Join Committee on Artificial Intelligence that AI has begun to perform roles previously occupied by humans which she said could lead to job losses.
'Even moderate job losses across multiple sectors could significantly increase unemployment,' she said, 'but we can't predict the pace or scale of this, or if lost jobs will be replaced.'
Ms Scanlon called for plans to be developed for 'multiple eventualities' noting it is not possible to make long term predictions on the impact on the technology.
READ MORE
'We need to ensure our tax base can fund ... if there are displacements and there are not replacement jobs,' she said.
Asked which industries would see the first job losses as a result of AI, Sean Blanchfield, the chief executive of AI start up, Jentic and a member of the AI Advisory Council, warned that software roles are first in the firing line.
'Ironically enough, it will be the software engineers,' he said, noting that entry-level programming jobs are 'largely replaced by AI now, certainly among the leading companies.'
He said that some software engineering roles have evolved into software architecture roles, with a similar shift taking place in entry-level legal roles. Customer service and jobs in the creative sector were also pointed out as roles that would be likely to be replaced in the sector.
Trinity College Dublin professor in law, Deirdre Ahern, another member of the AI advisory council noted that human roles would still need to be present in the industries to 'interrogate the outputs' but that the number of roles would reduced and have a different focus.
Ms Scanlon said the Government needs to put in place an AI Observatory to monitor the real time impacts of AI on jobs and skills 'as they happen' noting the State 'cannot be reactive' to the impacts of the new technology.
'There is an uncertain future,' Ms Scanlon said under questioning from Sinead Gibney, TD, 'One of the issues could very well be around the quality of work, even if there are new jobs or people are transitioning [to them], is it much like the gig workers where there is a lower quality of employment?'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
34 minutes ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on housing provision: builders needed
Anyone who wants to undertake a refurbishment of their home will know that a key task is finding a builder. And if one can be found, it will soon become clear that the price has risen significantly from what it would have been a couple of years ago. In part this reflects general inflation and in part the shortage of tradespeople in all areas and the higher prices which they now charge. This problem also exists at a national level. The latest quarterly commentary from the Economic and Social Research Institute(ESRI) underlines the point, referring to earlier research it presented, which showed that 40,000 additional employees would be required to increase annual output by 20,000 homes. It had appeared that a fall-off in non-residential construction such as offices might help here, but this has picked up again in the first quarter of this year, while residential construction has fallen. This is part of the reason why the ESRI is cautious on the issue of housing completions this year, saying on current trends that around 33,000 might be delivered, followed by 37,000 next year. And it warns that even these relatively modest forecasts face some 'notable' downside risks. The ESRI says it makes this point in part to underline the difficulty of ramping up housing supply quickly. And it underlines some obvious policy directions in trying to boost training in the sector and also improve productivity through more modern construction methods. READ MORE However, it also points to one more immediate implication. The Government is working on an update of its National Development Programme, the State's long-term investment plan. The dilemma for the Coalition is that doing everything quickly will not be possible, with the economy at full capacity. Trying to progress on all fronts would only push up construction inflation – and anyway would not be achievable, due in part to the shortage of employees. Planning and prioritisation is thus essential. The State has the cash, for now at least, but delivery is complex.
Irish Times
35 minutes ago
- Irish Times
‘Up to 400 post offices could shut' unless state increases subsidy to keep them running, TDs told
There could be widespread closures of local post offices from January if the Government does not approve a 50 per cent rise in the level of subvention to support them, an Oireachtas committee has been told. About €23 million has been provided to postmasters across the country to help maintain the network since the scheme was introduced a little over two years ago, members of the Oireachtas Communications committee were told on Wednesday. But the annual amount needed to be increased from €10 million to €15 million if services were to be retained in hundreds of offices considered to be less viable. 'You're looking at in January of next year, without government funding being increased, unrestrained closures throughout the country, rural and urban,' said Seán Martin, president of the Irish Postmasters' Union, citing a recent poll of its members. READ MORE 'Up to 40 per cent, 400 post offices, may go because the Government decides that it doesn't believe the community should have them.' He said a Grant Thornton assessment commissioned by the union had suggested many local offices were struggling to stay open because payments for the provision of government services were so low. He cited the recent the handling of the recent €2,000 carer's support grant paid to those providing full-time care to an elderly person or someone with a disability, saying that for their time and effort and security concerns related to the handling of cash, postmasters received just 65 cent for each payment handled. 'That's the difficulty postmasters have ... they're doing business, but unfortunately the business they're doing for Government is in cents rather than euros.' Contracts for such services are negotiated centrally by An Post . The company's chief executive, David McRedmond, said its aim was, where possible, to achieve increases in the fees obtained that it could pass on to them. Mr Martin said his union wanted to see more services provided through local post offices and it believed its members could play a valuable role in areas such as updating the register of electors and identity verification. He suggested postmasters could be become peace commissioners, a move that could free up gardaí from having to sign or witness official forms. An Post and the Department of Communications support the proposed €5 million increase in annual Government support, the committee heard, with a decision expected in the budget to be announced later this year. Many committee members expressed support for the increase. Labour's Alan Kelly , who chairs the committee, said he believed the union was selling itself short with the scale of its request. Mr McRedmond said many of the more than 800 post offices run by contractors, which were said to be generally more efficient than the 41 directly managed ones, were doing well, but he accepted some were 'struggling'. Asked about the recent decision to sell the post office building in Rathmines, Dublin, one of a number being transferred to contractors, he said it had been offered to the Land Development Agency and to Dublin City Council before the decision had been taken to put it on the open market, but both had declined. Asked about the terms on which it was offered, he said the LDA had been offered it for 'almost no payment', but would have to check with regard to the discussion with the council, which had viewed the premises before deciding it did not want to take it over.
Irish Times
35 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Carl O'Brien: ‘Are grinds really worth it?
I was writing today on how white-hot competition in the grinds sector is leading, in some cases, to eye-watering salaries for the most sought-after teachers. One of the new arrivals to the private tuition scene is online provider Grinds360, which has poached teachers from established operators like the Institute of Education and the Dublin Academy of Education. The grind schools, which are heavily oversubscribed, insist students fare best in-person with real teachers. Most Leaving Cert students avail of grinds nowadays. Photograph: Cyril Byrne Either way, business is booming in a sector estimated by some to be worth as much as €60-€80 million. But maybe a more significant question is: why? What factors are at play in driving so many to secure whatever advantage they can get? READ MORE High stakes The high-stakes nature of the Leaving Cert and CAO points system is an obvious one. Some argue that competition for top college courses has intensified due to grade inflation and rising points requirements. Others point to increasing anxiety, with more students feeling pressure from their own expectations or those of their parents. What is clear is that grinds have become normalised and are now an accepted part of exam success for most students. The grinds culture in Ireland is well in excess of many other European countries. According to a 2022 ESRI study , about one in five final-year students (16-20 per cent) get private support in Germany compared to more than half (55 per cent) in Ireland. Yet, the study's authors, Prof Selina McCoy and Prof Delma Byrne , found that private tuition only appeared to pay off for students with lower levels of achievement, with 'little, if any' gain for their middle and higher achieving peers. Nonetheless, grinds remain a lucrative business in Ireland, with costs ranging from €80 per hour for private grinds to more than €11,000 for full-time grind schools. The popularity of grinds raises uncomfortable questions around the quality of teaching in regular schools. Teacher shortages in key subject areas mean many students have either reduced subject choice or may be taught by an unqualified or 'out of field' teacher. Shortages Parents often are unaware, given that principals fear reputational damage if they highlight these difficulties. Some schools, especially in the South Dublin area, have been losing significant numbers of students to grind schools as a result. It remains to be seen whether Leaving Cert reforms – with a greater emphasis on project work and continual assessment – will affect demand and, in turn, the business model of grinds. Or perhaps the growth in the number of alternative pathways into further and higher education will take some heat out of the CAO points race. Anything that eases some of the acute stress experienced by students must, surely, only be a positive. How were the exams for you? We'd love to hear your feedback on this year's Leaving Cert exams: what were the hardest ?; what kind of toll did it take on students?; what changes would you like to see?; are you concerned about grade 'deflation' and its impact on CAO points? Please take a few minutes to complete our survey, below, and we'll share the results soon: Later this week: In advance of the CAO deadline, we'll share a last-minute checklist, as well as updates on what course areas have additional places and our analysis of how the 'deflation' of grades this year may affect this year's CAO points.
