Man, 36, ‘slowly gassed to death' after car filled with deadly poison – as heartbroken sister fights for change in law
TRAGIC END
The driver was found slumped over the wheel by a dog walker
THE sister of a man who was "slowly killed" when his car filled up with a deadly gas is fighting for a change in the law.
Lucy Barnard, 25, lost her older brother Michael Barnard aged 36 after he inhaled a large amount of carbon monoxide exhaust over a period of weeks from his white Volkswagen Scirocco.
3
3
The colourless gas entered the vehicle through a fault heating system.
Following the tragedy, Coroner Robert Cohen told a court how a dog walker raised the alarm after she saw Michael slumped in the driver's seat at around 6:35 am.
A forensic toxicologist later concluded Michael's carboxyhaemoglobin levels were at 63% which were consistent with death.
Michael was described as "alive, well, and happy" when he was sitting in his car for two hours listening to music with the heating switched on.
He did not know the heating was pushing the gas inside the vehicle on the evening before he was found dead.
The coroner ruled that Michael's death was a tragic accident as he did not know the car's heating was pushing the gas inside the vehicle on the evening before he was found dead.
Now two years on from the tragedy, Lucy, of Barrow, in Cumbria, is hoping to make it a legal requirement for carbon monoxide detectors to be fitted inside vehicles in the UK.
Lucy said: "My brother was driving his car for weeks unbeknown to him that his body was slowly being poisoned - that fateful evening pushed him over the edge.
"It was a massive shock for us all when we found out he had died, a huge hole in the family has been left.
"It's so important that people are made aware of this as it's vital to raise awareness because this will help to prevent deaths in the future.
"I never want anyone else to have to endure what we have been through."
Lucy has revealed that on August 17 2023 Michael went out for a drive in his car at around 12am before parking up at his favourite spot on Walney Beach in North Scale, Cumbria.
She then told how her brother sent a text to his then partner at 1am saying "something felt wrong" and that "he didn't feel well".
She then replied at 3am asking if he was okay but revealed that she got "no response" from Michael.
The inquest into Michael's death was heard at Cockermouth Coroners ' Court on February 10 2024.
A court heard the vehicle had passed an MOT on April 3 despite having advisory warnings for a minor leak of gases from the front exhaust.
However, a forensic vehicle examiner found that there was no blame to be proportioned as he said the vehicle was considerably different to when it was presented in April having accumulated a further 9553 miles.
The court heard that Michael had also been in a 'turbulent relationship' with his then partner of three years and that he had been working at Windermere Aquatics and for Securitas at BAE Systems in order to save up money to put a deposit on a house.
Coroner Cohen said it was relevant to read into the record a sequence of text messages that Mike had sent to his partner on August 8, which he said implied Mr Barnard wanted to end the relationship and not his own life.
Coroner Cohen described his death as a 'tragic accident' which he recorded as carbon monoxide poisoning as a result of misadventure.
In the UK it is only a legal requirement for carbon monoxide alarms to be installed in rooms containing fixed combustion appliances, except gas cookers.
On April 25 Lucy started her petition calling on the government to take action in the wake of her brothers death.
She said: "Carbon monoxide is a very deadly silent killer because it has no smell.
"You have no idea you are being slowly brought to your death.
"You can buy sensors from local retailers such as Argos, B&Q and screw fix, as well as online at Amazon.
"I'm doing this in memory of him so no one else has to endure the pain that we had to go through."
Paying tribute to Michael, she said: "He was kind and would help anyone if they needed it.
"He loved being out in his car and enjoyed speed boating - he was a very family orientated man.
"I just want to make the best outcome of a bad situation."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Live
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Live
Orkney Assassin Michael Ross' lawyer describers convicted killer as 'gentle'
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Michael Ross' lawyer praised the convicted murderer as "well-mannered" and "gentle" upon their first meeting. Prime Video has just dropped its gripping new documentary, The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles, on Sunday, June 8, featuring interviews with former police officers, journalists, witnesses and Ross' own parents about the chilling murder of Shamsuddin Mahmood. Ross was convicted for killing the Indian restaurant waiter in 2008, 14 years after Mahmood's death, with the former Army sniper given a life sentence for the cirme. During the trial, Ross had Donald Findlay QC fighting his corner, but as the documentary reveals, with over 10 years left until he's up for parole, Ross hired a new lawyer. Scottish solicitor Aamer Anwar confessed to some initial doubts about taking on the infamous case in the documentary. (Image: PRIME VIDEO) He shared: "So when it came in, there was some healthy cynicism. "'Why me? You know my reputation. You know I fight injustice, human rights and on race' but they said that's exactly the reason why Michael wanted me to have a look at the case. "And when I met Michael, he was well mannered, considered, gentle." (Image: PRIME VIDEO) Despite years behind bars, Ross is remains insisted about his innocence and has tried to escape prison three times, with the most recent attempt in 2018 when he attempted to climb a fence. Anwar adds: "And the fact that in all these years, he's maintained his innocence. "That always strikes me when somebody refuses to take the easy option and go 'you know what, I'm guilty' to try and get out earlier. "But he's refused to do that, he says he cannot do that, he insists he's an innocent man. And it's never ended." The Orkney Assassin: Murder In The Isles is available to watch on Prime Video.
Edinburgh Live
12 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
F1 icon Michael Schumacher's three visitors as truth about his condition emerges
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info For over a decade, only a select group of Michael Schumacher's closest allies have been privy to the full extent of his medical condition. Despite rampant speculation, incessant media buzz, and even shocking extortion attempts, concrete information remains scarce. The public's enduring interest is largely driven by the mystery surrounding the Formula 1 legend's current state. Corinna Schumacher, his wife, has spearheaded efforts to fiercely protect the privacy of the now 56 year old since his tragic skiing accident in December 2013. Schumacher suffered serious brain injuries after striking his head on a rock while skiing with his then 14 year old son, Mick. He was put into a medically induced coma for over eight months and hasn't made a single public appearance since the incident. Corinna has since managed his care primarily at their Lake Geneva home. Only a handful of healthcare professionals and trusted individuals have been allowed to visit him. It's now suggested that the family also spends part of their time at a specially adapted estate in Mallorca, reports the Mirror. Corinna has largely refrained from discussing his health, speaking out only sporadically. She has not disclosed any significant medical updates and continues to request privacy. In the 2021 Netflix documentary, she stated: "We're trying to carry on as a family, the way Michael liked it and still does. And we are getting on with our lives. It's very important to me that he can continue to enjoy his private life as much as possible. Michael always protected us, and now we are protecting Michael." Eddie Jordan, a close family friend who passed away in March, reportedly said in 2023: "This was the most horrific situation. Corinna has not been able to go to a party, to lunch or this or that – she's like a prisoner, because everyone would want to talk to her about Michael when she doesn't need reminding of it every minute." False hope and misinformation have often clouded the issue of Schumacher's health. There have been several overly optimistic reports recently, including some German media claims from last year that Schumacher possibly attended his daughter Gina-Maria's wedding to Iain Bethke, where guests were told to hand over their mobile phones to prevent photos of Michael from being taken. These reports were subsequently debunked. Additional hopes were stoked when Schumacher's autograph appeared on a helmet for racing great Jackie Stewart during a charity auction. His former team mate Johnny Herbert is quoted by Wales Online as suggesting this might hint at positive developments, fuelling speculation that Schumacher might someday return to the F1 paddock. New details have emerged about the condition of Formula One legend Michael Schumacher, with confirmation that his wife Corinna was involved in signing a helmet. Sources close to the Schumacher family indicate that he remains largely confined to bed and speechless. Former Ferrari chief Flavio Briatore recently remarked in reflection: "If I close my eyes, I see him smiling after a victory. I prefer to remember him like that rather than him just lying on a bed. Corinna and I talk often, though." Elisabetta Gregoraci, Schumacher's ex-wife, has made poignant comments in the past, stating: "Michael doesn't speak, he communicates with his eyes. Only three people can visit him and I know who they are." Insiders believe these visitors include key Ferrari figures Jean Todt and Ross Brawn, as well as former racer Gerhard Berger. Jean Todt, a close friend of Schumacher's, regularly spends time with the family watching races but has acknowledged: "There's no longer the same communication as before. The family has decided not to answer the question [regarding Schumacher's condition], a choice that I respect. "I see him regularly and with affection, him and his family. Our bond goes beyond the past work. It is part of my life, which today is very far from Formula 1." Schumacher's condition was described as 'partly helpless' by German journalist Felix Gorner in March. He shared a sobering account, saying: "He is a person dependent on caregivers, who can no longer express himself through language. We're just clinging to hope, to a straw. But he's simply not well, so we won't see him again." Ahead of the 10-year anniversary of Schumacher's accident, it was reported that he is under 24-hour medical care with a team of approximately 15 staff. The family faced a blackmail attempt by a criminal group demanding £12 million for private photos and medical information. In Wuppertal, Germany, three individuals were charged over the extortion plot, including Markus Fritsche and Yilmaz Tozturkan, who issued the threats. Fritsche was handed a suspended two-year sentence, while IT worker Daniel Lins received a six-month suspended term. The Schumacher family has challenged the verdict, deeming the punishments too mild. Prosecutors disclosed that the purloined data depicted Schumacher as "partly helpless, in need of care and visibly marked" by his ordeal. Despite recent optimistic reports, the likelihood of Schumacher making a public appearance remains slim.
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Michael Schumacher's three visitors as truth about F1 icon's condition emerges
Michael Schumacher has not been seen in public since his skiing accident in 2013 and few people know the true extent of his condition - but some details have emerged from his inner circle For over a decade now, only a tight circle of Michael Schumacher's closest confidants have been aware of the full details of his medical condition. Despite a flurry of speculation, persistent media chatter, and even shocking attempts at extortion, solid information remains extremely limited. While much of the curiosity is rooted in widespread admiration for the Formula 1 legend, the public's persistent interest largely stems from how little is truly known about his current situation. Corinna Schumacher, his wife, has led efforts to strictly guard the now 56-year-old's privacy ever since his devastating ski accident in December 2013. Schumacher sustained severe brain trauma after hitting his head on a rock while skiing with his then 14-year-old son, Mick. He was placed in a medically induced coma for more than eight months and has not made a single public appearance since the accident. Since then, Corinna has overseen his care primarily at their Lake Geneva residence. Only selected healthcare workers and a few trusted individuals have been permitted to see him. Reports now suggest the family also lives part-time at a specially adapted estate in Mallorca. Corinna has remained largely silent regarding his health, speaking only occasionally in public. She has not revealed any significant medical updates and has continually asked for privacy. In the 2021 Netflix documentary, she said: "We're trying to carry on as a family, the way Michael liked it and still does. And we are getting on with our lives. It's very important to me that he can continue to enjoy his private life as much as possible. Michael always protected us, and now we are protecting Michael." Eddie Jordan, a close family friend who passed away in March, commented in 2023: "This was the most horrific situation. Corinna has not been able to go to a party, to lunch or this or that – she's like a prisoner, because everyone would want to talk to her about Michael when she doesn't need reminding of it every minute." False hope and misinformation Various optimistic stories have emerged in recent times, suggesting improvements in Schumacher's condition. Last year, German outlets reported that Schumacher might have attended his daughter Gina-Maria's wedding to Iain Bethke, where guests were allegedly asked to surrender their phones to ensure no images of Michael leaked. However, these reports were later dismissed. Further hope gained traction when Schumacher's signature appeared on a helmet for racing legend Jackie Stewart as part of a charity auction. Former team-mate Johnny Herbert speculated this indicated positive progress and promise that we could one day see Schumacher in the F1 paddock again, reports Wales Online. Nonetheless, it was later confirmed Corinna assisted in signing the helmet. More reliable sources close to the family maintain that Schumacher is still mostly bedridden and unable to speak. Former Ferrari boss Flavio Briatore this week shared: "If I close my eyes, I see him smiling after a victory. I prefer to remember him like that rather than him just lying on a bed. Corinna and I talk often, though." Speaking to the Telegraph, Elisabetta Gregoraci, his ex-wife, has now said: "Michael doesn't speak, he communicates with his eyes. Only three people can visit him and I know who they are." These individuals are believed to be Ferrari's Jean Todt and Ross Brawn, and ex-driver Gerhard Berger. Todt, one of Schumacher's closest allies, visits frequently and watches races with the family. He has stated: "There's no longer the same communication as before. The family has decided not to answer the question [regarding Schumacher's condition], a choice that I respect. "I see him regularly and with affection, him and his family. Our bond goes beyond the past work. It is part of my life, which today is very far from Formula 1." Schumacher 'partly helpless' In March, German journalist Felix Gorner provided a more candid picture of Schumacher's situation, saying: "He is a person dependent on caregivers, who can no longer express himself through language. We're just clinging to hope, to a straw. But he's simply not well, so we won't see him again." It was earlier reported ahead of the 10-year mark since the accident that Schumacher receives 24-hour medical supervision from a team of around 15 staff. Amid the tight veil of secrecy, the family was targeted by a criminal group attempting to extort £12million in exchange for private images and medical data. Three men were charged in Wuppertal, Germany, for the plot, including Markus Fritsche and Yilmaz Tozturkan, who made the threats. Fritsche received a suspended two-year sentence, and IT worker Daniel Lins avoided jail with a six-month suspended term. The family has appealed the decision, finding the penalties too lenient. Prosecutors revealed that the stolen material showed Schumacher "partly helpless, in need of care and visibly marked" by his injuries. At present, the prospect of a public return remains highly unlikely, despite the hope given to fans by recent reports.
