French teacher suspended over minute's silence tribute to Palestinians in Gaza
A high school science teacher in France has been suspended since late March for holding a minute's silence for the victims of Israel's war on Gaza.
Le Parisien reported on Thursday, citing education authorities, that the physics and chemistry teacher at Janot Curie high school in Sens, Yonne, was suspended on 31 March.
Five days earlier, a minute's silence was held just at the end of her class to pay tribute to the victims of the war, just as Israeli forces unilaterally broke a ceasefire in Gaza and killed more than 700 Palestinians.
The Dijon education authority said: 'Respecting neutrality is a duty for civil servants, enshrined in their status, and any failure to comply with this obligation triggers disciplinary proceedings.'
It added that the minute's silence had been organised by the teacher. However, the educational branches of three trade unions said it was the students, aged between 15 and 16, who requested the tribute.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
'She herself was moved… and the teacher agreed, at the end of her class, to observe this moment of tribute with the students who wished to do so," the unions said in a joint statement.
'We demand that this teacher be reinstated immediately, that all charges be dropped, and that her dignity be officially restored in the eyes of the school, staff and parents.'
According to the unions, who called the measure "insane", the tribute "in no way constitutes a breach of the duty of neutrality".
They cited Education Minister Elisabeth Borne, who in February "recognised" the "role of teachers in addressing the plight of the victims of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and paying tribute to them", similar to "the actions in support of Ukraine", according to the press release.
The teacher is now the subject of disciplinary proceedings, which could result in a formal warning or reprimand. She does not know how long the suspension will last.
'Policy of denying Palestinian suffering'
The decision marks the latest episode of French authorities taking punitive action over protests and remarks related to Israel's war on Gaza.
Since 7 October 2023, there has been a marked rise in the use of the 'apology for terrorism' offence, with French authorities launching hundreds of investigations into comments made about the war in Gaza.
Jean-Paul Delescaut, leader of the General Confederation of Labour union, was handed a suspended one-year jail sentence for writing in response to the 7 October Hamas attacks: 'The horrors of illegal occupations… are receiving the responses they provoked.'
'Apology for terrorism' row in France shows silencing of debate about Palestine Read More »
Last month, three students from Sciences Po Paris were expelled for participating in pro-Palestine protests.
Leftist party France Unbowed (La France Insoumise) strongly condemned the decision to suspend the science teacher, calling it a "denial of the right to empathy".
'This moment of silence, held after a class as a gesture of humanity, led to a brutal and unjustified suspension by the education authority,' the party said in a statement.
'This is an incomprehensible and unspeakably violent decision against a teacher who simply wanted to impart the values of respect and solidarity to her students.
'This approach by the education authority is part of a comprehensive policy of denying the suffering of the Palestinian people.'
Earlier this week, the French government joined Canada and the UK in condemning Israel's "egregious actions" in Gaza and warned of joint action if it did not halt its current military offensive.
French President Emmanuel Macron accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of "unacceptable" behaviour in blocking the delivery of humanitarian aid to Palestinians.
In response, Netanyahu accused Macron of siding with a "murderous Islamist terrorist organisation".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gulf Today
2 hours ago
- Gulf Today
Granting Palestinians their full legitimate rights only way to stabilise region, Jordan King tells Macron
Jordan's King Abdullah II, during a meeting with France President Emmanuel Macron on Monday, stressed Amman's readiness to strengthen ties with France across various sectors, which will contribute to enhancing stability in the Middle East. The meeting, held on the sidelines of the third United Nations Ocean Conference. The two leaders highlighted the importance of maintaining coordination on regional issues, stepping up international efforts to reach comprehensive calm in the region, immediately reinstating the ceasefire in Gaza, and resuming the entry of humanitarian aid. King Abdullah warned of the serious consequences of continued escalations in the West Bank and Jerusalem, reiterating that granting Palestinians their full legitimate rights is the only way to stabilise the region. The King expressed appreciation for France's pivotal role in supporting efforts to achieve peace in the Middle East on the basis of the two-state solution, especially through its organisation of an international conference due to be held in New York 17-20 June, in partnership with Saudi Arabia. WAM
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Madleen: Social media users slam Israel's 'mocking' of Gaza flotilla activists
The Israeli military seized a charity vessel carrying international activists attempting to break the blockade of the Gaza Strip in the early hours of Monday. Israeli soldiers boarded the Madleen and ordered the 12 international activists - including Swedish climate compaigner Greta Thunberg and member of the European Parliament from France, Rima Hassan - to throw their phones into the sea before filming themselves handing out sandwiches and bottles of water in series of clips and posts shared on social media saying the "show was over". Social media users slammed Israel's move as a political stunt and used its labelling of the humanitarian vessel as a "selfie yacht' in a series of social media posts to highlight selfies taken by Israeli soldiers while committing abuses in the war-torn Palestinian enclave. Several people shared widely circulated selfies and photos taken by Israeli soldiers themselves, some of which depict potential war crimes. Others responded to the Israeli government's posts with the hashtag #selfiegenocide. 'Israel calls the Madleen a 'selfie yacht' while their soldiers snap selfies with war crimes. Hypocrites!' wrote one social media user. "Wild to go with the 'selfie' thing when your own cowardly soldiers have been uploading their war crimes to social media all through the genocide," another posted. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Several people criticised Israel for mocking a humanitarian mission and accused the government of staging the moment soldiers handed out sandwiches for propaganda purposes. Not sure 'selfie yacht' is the best talking point for a country whose soldiers routinely take photos of themselves with the underwear of dead/displaced Palestinian women. — Daniel Wickham (@DanielWickham93) June 9, 2025 "Israel is mocking a ship that is bringing humanitarian aid to a population that they are deliberately starving," posted one person. "Since the IOF (Israeli army) is putting out propaganda videos to show everyone 'hey look at how nice we are we gave them a sammie!' I'd like to remind everyone the reason the Madleen was going there in the first place was to break the siege on the Palestinians they've been STARVING FOR MONTHS!" another person added. Another said, 'This was a humanitarian mission. Stopping a civilian aid boat in international waters is both illegal and immoral. Posting a video saying 'we gave them sandwiches and water, the show is over' is not diplomacy—it's a PR stunt." I thought Israel doesn't occupy Gaza and here it is deciding who and what can enter the borders of Gaza 🤔 Also it's actually a violation of international law to kidnap unarmed civilians. I mean it's not as if you care about law since you're starving 2 million people you keep… — Isabelle (@Darkiora) June 9, 2025 Beyond social media, Madleen's seizure has drawn condemnation from legal experts, rights groups and international observers. Amnesty International's secretary general, Agnes Callamard, denounced Israel's interception of Madleen as a 'violation of international law'. #Madleen, launched by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC), was seeking to bring humanitarian aid in an attempt to breach Israel's illegal blockade of the occupied Gaza Strip. It was carrying unarmed civilians on a humanitarian mission. Israel interception of Madleen violates… — Agnes Callamard (@AgnesCallamard) June 9, 2025 Palestinian rights organisation Al-Haq condemned Israel's "unlawful interception" and demanded the immediate release of all detained activists, asserting: "Israel has no legal authority to restrict access to Palestine, since such is within the exclusive right of the Palestinian people." UK MP Zarah Sultana described the activists aboard the Madleen as 'heroes', calling Israel's actions a 'flagrant breach of international law' and urging the UK government to 'sanction Israel, end all arms and surveillance deals, and expel its ambassador'. Francesca Albanese, the UN special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the occupied Palestinian territory, said the UK government should take action to secure the British-flagged ship and called on "every Mediterranean port" to send boats with aid in an act of solidarity with Gaza. "They shall sail together—united, they will be unstoppable. #BreakingTheSiege is a legal duty for states, and a moral imperative for all of us," she said on X.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
North African 'resilience convoy' heads to Gaza, aiming to break Israel's siege
A grassroots land convoy is travelling thousands of kilometres from the Tunisian capital to Gaza on Monday, in the hopes of breaking Israel's debilitating 18-year siege on the war-battered Palestinian enclave. Thousands of volunteers from Algeria, Egypt, Libya, Morocco, and Tunisia left the Tunisian capital in a 100-vehicle convoy to raise international awareness of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and deliver life-saving aid, organisers said. The United Nations has described Gaza as the "hungriest place on Earth", with nearly half a million people in a catastrophic situation of hunger, acute malnutrition, starvation, illness and death. "The convoy will express solidarity with the Palestinian people under siege and deliver humanitarian aid to them," the coordination group said in a statement. "Participants in the convoy will head to the Ras Jedir crossing on the Tunisian-Libyan border, and travel along the Libyan coastal road to Cairo, then to the Rafah crossing on the Egyptian-Palestinian border, to deliver messages of solidarity and aid to the Palestinians in Gaza," it added. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters The "Soumoud" convoy, which means resilience and steadfastness in Arabic, is reported to include trade union and political figures, as well as human rights activists, athletes, lawyers, doctors, journalists, and members of youth organisations. It remains unclear, however, whether the convoy will actually reach the besieged Gaza Strip, as Egyptian officials have yet to authorise the convoy's entry into North Sinai. "This is a message to the people of Gaza: You are not alone," Sheikh Yahya Sari, a member of the Algerian Association of Muslim Scholars, said in a Facebook post. "We share your pain, and this is a form of public pressure against the occupier in the face of international failure to stop the massacres." Earlier on Monday, Israeli forces seized control of a charity vessel aiming to break the blockade of the Gaza Strip and detained its crew of 12, including activist Greta Thunberg. Gaza flotilla: The Madleen shows us the world as it could be Read More » The British-flagged yacht Madleen, operated by the pro-Palestinian Freedom Flotilla Coalition, was aiming to deliver a symbolic amount of humanitarian aid, including rice and baby formula, to Gaza later on Monday. However, the boat was intercepted in the early hours of Monday, hours after Israel's defence minister, Israel Katz, said that Israel's military would use "any means necessary" to stop it from breaching the naval blockade of Gaza. In recent years, several ships have attempted to break Israel's land, sea and naval blockade on the Gaza Strip, but have repeatedly been pushed back by Israeli forces. In 2010, the Mavi Marmara flotilla mission was attacked by Israeli forces who boarded the ship and killed ten activists. And last month, another vessel organised by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, the Conscience, failed to continue its journey to Gaza after being struck by two drones near Maltese waters. Since October 2023, over 54,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces, according to Palestinian health and government officials, including more than 28,000 women and girls. The figure also includes at least 1,400 health sector professionals, 280 UN aid workers - the highest staff death toll in UN history - and nearly 190 journalists, the highest number of media workers killed in conflict since the Committee to Protect Journalists began recording data in 1992.
