Trump has shown up Britain's border weakness

Telegraph

2 days ago

Donald Trump's decision to ban travel for citizens of 12 countries and restrict travel from another seven will undoubtedly result in uproar and legal challenges.
The idea of restricting the travel of an individual based on their country of origin, rather than their personal characteristics, is anathema to the liberal world-view, and rhetorically uncomfortable for an individualist Right.
That does not mean it is without merit. A person's country of origin – the culture they were brought up in, and the economic opportunities available to them on return – can be highly informative about their propensity to overstay visas, the fiscal contribution of their household contingent on their income, and many other factors that a sensible immigration system should consider.
In several cases, it is hard to take significant dispute with the logic of Trump's decision. Indeed, there is much for Britain to learn from it.
It was reported earlier this year that the Home Office was examining plans to restrict visa applications from countries prone to overstaying and asylum claims. This project should be carried out and expanded.
The Government has access to a wealth of information on the outcomes of migrants in Britain. If it turns out that for a given visa route, migrants from one country routinely impose higher costs to the state than migrants from another – through lower spousal workforce participation, higher birth rates, or a lower attachment to employment – then this should be reflected in the salary and income thresholds set for their visa applications.
Equally, restrictions on applications from countries which sponsor terrorism or which lack a 'competent or cooperative central authority' to provide sufficiently reliable background information for citizens attempting to leave are entirely sensible. Britain should mimic this, and should consider too the merits of restricting visa access for countries which refuse to cooperate in enabling the return of their citizens.
It is a grim note that part of Mr Trump's explicit motivation is avoiding repeating in America 'what happened in Europe'. If our migration system is becoming a cautionary tale in other political systems, our politicians should be willing to change it.