MPs demand ‘root and branch reform' of Criminal Cases Review Commission
The justice committee has called for a 'root and branch' reform of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) and called for its chief executive to step down.
A report from the cross-party panel of MPs found CCRC's leadership 'has shown a remarkable inability to learn from its own mistakes' after serious failures in its handling of the wrongful conviction of Andrew Malkinson, who was wrongly jailed for 17 years for rape.
It comes after Peter Sullivan last week had his murder conviction overturned after 38 years in prison, in what is thought to be longest running miscarriage of justice in recent history.
Chairman Andy Slaughter said the position of the watchdog's chief executive, Karen Kneller, was 'untenable' after she gave 'unpersuasive evidence' over the handling of Mr Malkinson's case to the committee on 29 April.
A damning report found Mr Malkinson could have been exonerated a decade earlier (PA Wire)
Her account was later challenged by Chris Kenley KC, the author of a damning report which identified a 'catalogue of failures' in their handling of the case and found Mr Malkinson could have been exonerated a decade earlier.
Former chairwoman of the CCRC, Helen Pitcher, eventually resigned from the role in January following Mr Malkinson's case, but claimed she had been scapegoated.
Before her resignation, she had apologised to Mr Malkinson in April 2024, nine months after his conviction was quashed by the Court of Appeal in July 2023.
In a report published on Friday, committee chairman Andy Slaughter said: 'As a result of our concerns regarding the performance of the CCRC and the unpersuasive evidence Karen Kneller provided to the committee, we no longer feel that it is tenable for her to continue as chief executive of the CCRC.
'There is clear evidence in our report that the situation for the CCRC has deteriorated significantly and it now requires root and branch reform.'
The chairman also accused the leadership team of showing a 'remarkable inability' to learn from its own mistakes, and that the CCRC failed to respond adequately to Mr Malkinson's acquittal and to the publication of Mr Henley's independent review.
Mr Slaughter added that the committee received comments from Mr Henley and Chris Webb, who was employed by the CCRC as an independent communications consultant, 'to the effect that she had misled the committee' following the April meeting.
Peter Sullivan had his murder conviction overturned after 38 years in prison (Merseyside Police)
'Without making a finding on whether the committee had been misled and giving Ms Kneller an opportunity to comment on the allegations, the committee nonetheless found the manner in which she gave evidence a further indicator of her unsuitability to continue to lead the CCRC,' he said.
'The information provided since the session establishes that Karen Kneller omitted important information that would have provided a more accurate account of how the CCRC handled the Henley report.'
The committee's report concluded that Mr Henley's assessment on the work the CCRC had done was 'damning', and while it was focused on Mr Malkinson's case it should have been taken as evidence of systemic problems within the CCRC.
It also said the body had been without an interim chair since Ms Pitcher's resignation for four months, which is an 'unacceptably long period of time', particularly given the 'turbulent' period.
Mr Slaughter added that the Ministry of Justice should take a degree of responsibility for not putting a plan in place for a replacement.
Responding to the report, a CCRC spokesperson said: 'We note the recommendations in the Justice Select Committee report and the committee's view that its findings should 'inform the approach of the next chair of the CCRC' in reviewing how we operate.
'We look forward to an announcement on the appointment of an interim chair and to working with them in an organisation deeply committed to finding, investigating and referring potential miscarriages of justice.'
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: 'Miscarriages of justice can have a devastating impact. It is vital the public have confidence in the organisation dedicated to uncovering wrongful convictions.
'The lord chancellor will imminently announce the appointment to provide strong leadership to the CCRC and conduct a full and thorough review of how the organisation operates, including an assessment of its leadership.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
32 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Rachel Reeves in stand-off over policing and council budgets days before spending review
Rachel Reeves has been locked in a standoff over the policing and council budgets just days before this week's spending review, which is set to give billions to the NHS, defence and technology. Yvette Cooper's Home Office and Angela Rayner's housing and local government ministry were the two departments still at the negotiating table on Sunday fighting for more cash, after weeks of trying to reach a settlement. Whitehall sources said the policing budget would not face a real terms cut, but there was still disagreement over the level of investment needed for the Home Office to meet its commitments. Rayner's department is understood to have reached an agreement with the Treasury late on Sunday night after last-minute wrangling over housing, local councils and growth funds. However, any failure to strike a deal would raise the prospect of a budget being imposed on an unwilling department. The spending review, taking place on Wednesday, is a chance for Reeves to hold up billions of pounds of capital spending as a sign she is working to repair public services after years of Tory austerity. After tweaking her fiscal rules last autumn, she has an additional £113bn funded by borrowing for capital spending. Her plans will include £86bn for science and technology across four years and an extra £4.5bn for schools – taking funding per pupil to its highest level ever. However, day-to-day spending is more constrained in some areas, while the NHS and defence swallow up higher allocations. As well as policing, the Home Office budget covers the border force and spending on asylum costs, while the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government has been battling for funds for the affordable homes programme, councils, homelessness and regional growth. Labour has manifesto pledges to build 1.5m homes and deliver 13,000 new police officers. Pressed on the policing budget, the technology secretary, Peter Kyle, said Home Office and others would have to 'do their bit'. Funding for the police has the potential to become a politically difficult issue for Keir Starmer. Tory former shadow cabinet minister Robert Jenrick has been campaigning against transport fare dodging and Nigel Farage's Reform are also highlighting the issue. Asked about which public services will be prioritised, Kyle said 'every part of our society is struggling' and numerous sectors had asked Reeves for more money. 'On the fact that the police have been writing to the chancellor, they have,' he told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme. 'We also have letters from the universities, we have letters from doctors about the health service, we have letters from campaigners for child poverty writing to us, and other aspects of challenges in Britain at the moment. 'Every part of our society is struggling because of the inheritance that we had as a country and as a government.' He pointed to the £1.1bn extra funding already earmarked for police this year, as he defended Reeves's handling of the spending review process. 'We expect the police to start embracing the change they need to do, to do their bit for change as well. We are doing our bit,' Kyle said. 'You see a chancellor that is striving to get investment to the key parts of our country that needs it the most … You will see the priorities of this government reflected in the spending review, which sets the departmental spending into the long term. 'But this is a partnership. Yes, the Treasury needs to find more money for those key priorities, but the people delivering them need to do their bit as well.' While some areas of spending may be cut or receive only low increases, the NHS is set to receive a boost of up to £30bn by 2028, while defence spending is expected to rise to 2.5% of GDP by 2027. Kyle defended the chancellor's approach to public spending, saying she was like Apple founder Steve Jobs who turned the company around when it was 90 days from insolvency. He told Sky News's Trevor Phllips: 'Now Steve Jobs turned it around by inventing the iMac, moving to a series of products like the iPod. 'Now we're starting to invest in the vaccine processes of the future. Some of the hi-tech solutions that are going to be high growth. We're investing in our space sector. All these really high, highly innovative sectors. 'We are investing into those key innovations of the future. We know that we cannot break this vicious cycle of high tax and low growth by doing the same as we always have done. We have to innovate our way out of this and we are doing so by investing in those high-growth sectors.'
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE My neighbours have built an extension over my property by 15 INCHES... it has destroyed my home and left me facing £85k bill
A single mother has claimed a neighbour 'destroyed' her home after building a new wall that encroaches onto her property by 15 inches. Brenda Grant, from Uxbridge, west London, said Amarjit Singh Dhunna sliced her plastic conservatory roof to build his own extension wall, but left small gaps allowing water to run and leak into her property. After taking the case to court, Ms Grant owes £25k to her solicitor and fears she could lose her home of 22 years. The mother-of-one also faces a £60k bill to fix the water damage to her walls and floors. Ms Grant told MailOnline: 'Since he cut the roof, water has been coming into the conservatory; I have a report from a builder that it is destroyed. 'This has made me depressed. I have anxiety and panic attacks. I lock myself in the house and I am withdrawn, I don't come out. 'My son [is so depressed] he doesn't go to school. Basically he locks himself in his room.' Do YOU have a story? Email After the building work went ahead in March 2021, Ms Grant lodged a complaint claiming she had never been informed and businessman Mr Dhunna did not have planning permission to cut the roof and build over it. A small store room connects her property to Mr Dhunna's next door and the pair disagree about where the boundary lies. However, when Ms Grant got a land surveyor out to investigate, a report suggested Mr Dhunna's new wall hangs over the boundary line by 0.4metres - around 15 inches. She claims her neighbour had no right to cut the plastic roof and argued the new wall clearly hangs over onto her land. Ms Grant said: 'I sit in the house and I cry all day because I can't believe that someone's cut my roof. 'It's traumatising to point that I just want to kill myself, [...] even my son wanted to kill himself because of the amount of emotional stress, panic attacks, and he's lost out on five years of his life.' In October 2021, months after the work took place, Mr Dhunna - who does not live in the property but houses tenants there - received retrospective planning permission for the build by Hillingdon Council. 'It was given to him even though I tried to tell the council that he's on my land,' Ms Grant said. The red line shows the boundary between the two properties. The green line suggests Mr Dhunna's new roof line is hanging over onto Ms Grant's land 'When they cut the roof, because they didn't put any gutter in or any lead flashing, when it rains the water comes down into the property, so it's destroyed the conservatory. 'The floor is sunk and the walls have subsided inside. So the builder said it's £60,000 for that.' Ms Grant claims she has hired three land surveyors who have all stated encroachment onto her land. The court case is set to continue next week at Central London County Court. Ms Grant worked in customer service for British Airways but was let go as a result of poor mental health. She has now set up a GoFundMe in a desperate bid to raise the money for her legal costs.
The Sun
39 minutes ago
- The Sun
Three people arrested after teen boy dies near pub as cops launch urgent murder probe
THREE people have been arrested after a teenage boy died near a pub. Cops, paramedics, and the air ambulance were called to New Moston in north Manchester at around 5pm today, Greater Manchester Police said. 2 The force has not said how the teenager died but has launched a murder investigation and arrested three people in connection with the death. Superintendent Marcus Noden said: "This is a distressing and heart-breaking incident where a boy has lost his life. "We are still trying to establish the circumstances around the incident and have a number of scenes in place." Pictures from the scene show a police cordon on Nevin Road in New Moston as well as another at the nearby Fairway Inn pub. Detectives said the boy's family was currently being supported by specialist officers. Cops are currently appealing for information and are asking people who were in the Nevin Road area to come forward. You can report any information to the police through their website or by calling 101, quoting log 2250 of 8/6/25. If you wish to submit information anonymously, you can use the independent charity Crimestoppers to do so. More to follow... For the latest news on this story keep checking back at The Sun Online is your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video. Like us on Facebook at and follow us from our main Twitter account at @TheSun.
