We will keep fighting, pledges MSP after assisted dying vote
Pam Duncan-Glancy – the Scottish Parliament's first MSP to use a wheelchair full time – voted against the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill at stage one on Tuesday and has campaigned fervently against it.
Proposed by Scottish Lib Dem MSP Liam McArthur, the legislation would allow terminally ill people to seek to end their lives and was passed by 70 votes to 56 with one abstention following a landmark debate.
But speaking to the PA news agency after the vote, Labour MSP Ms Duncan-Glancy pledged not to give up as she sought to persuade fellow members of the dangers posed by the proposals.
'We fight every day of our lives just to exist, and we never stop fighting,' she said.
'So we'll continue and we will keep fighting.
'And I fundamentally know that people will understand the serious concerns that we have.
'We will not be able to amend it out of this legislation.'
Ms Duncan-Glancy said she had hoped fellow MSPs would heed the concerns she and other campaigners have expressed, but she seemed heartened by some MSPs pushing for changes to the Bill at stages two and three.
The Bill was proposed by Lib Dem MSP Liam McArthur (Andrew Milligan/PA)
'I had hoped that colleagues would see the risk in this legislation and the message that it could send to people across Scotland about the value they place on people's lives,' she said.
'But I also heard in the chamber that many people have concerns and some people openly saying that they couldn't support the Bill as it stands if this was the final Bill at stage three.'
She added: 'I think that when they try to amend the legislation to get what they think are the safeguards, they will realise that there is no amendment that can provide the level of safeguard that they want, or indeed that we need as a nation in this legislation.
'So hopefully we will get to a point in stage three where colleagues feel that they are unable to continue to support that decision.'
During the near-five hour long debate on the issue, Ms Duncan-Glancy delivered an impassioned speech where she urged fellow MSPs to 'legislate to assist people to live' as opposed to assisting them to die.
She said: 'Today I've only scratched the surface of concerns, but for me it comes down to this: How can it be possible for people to make a free and equal choice to allow a system that oppresses them so much to also potentially assist them to take their own lives?'
The vote, the third such attempt to advance similar proposals at Holyrood, was described as a 'landmark moment' by Mr McArthur.
'This Bill has been a long time coming but, at long last, it can offer that compassionate choice for the small number of terminally ill Scots who need it,' he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
26 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
‘Think big' to save the ocean, William tells world leaders
William was speaking at the Blue Economy and Finance Forum (BEFF) on ocean preservation at the Grimaldi Forum in the principality on Sunday. The prince, whose opening and closing remarks were in French, said those attending the forum were 'united by our deep connection to the ocean and our concern for its safety'. Let us act together with urgency and optimism while we still have the chance The Prince of Wales William, wearing a navy suit with a recycled sustainable tie from Wilmok, said the 'clock is ticking' to meet the target agreed at the UN Biodiversity Summit in 2022 aiming to protect at least 30% of the world's land and sea by 2030. World leaders were greeted by a blue carpet as they arrived at the event, with William meeting French President Emmanuel Macron, Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, Prince Albert II of Monaco, and Costa Rica President Rodrigo Chaves Robles. Giving a speech at the heads of state and government session on the final day of the forum, William said: 'Rising sea temperatures, plastic pollution and overfishing are putting pressure on these fragile ecosystems and on the people and communities who depend most upon them. 'What once seemed an abundant resource is diminishing before our eyes. 'We all stand to be impacted. And we are all responsible for change – both negative and positive. But there remains time to turn this tide.' From left, Brazil's President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, France's President Emmanuel Macron, Prince Albert II of Monaco, Costa Rica's President Rodrigo Chaves Robles and The Prince of Wales (Manon Cruz/PA) Speaking to an auditorium of 1,800 people, the prince added: 'Watching human activity reduce beautiful sea forests to barren deserts at the base of our oceans is simply heartbreaking. 'For many, it is an urgent wake up call to just what is going on in our oceans. But it can no longer be a matter of 'out of sight, out of mind'. 'Halfway through this decisive decade, I call on all of you to think big in your actions. 'Let us act together with urgency and optimism while we still have the chance. 'For the future of our planet, for the future generations, we must listen to the words of Sir David Attenborough: 'If we save the sea, we save our world'.' William and Kate meeting Sir David Attenborough in 2021 (PA) William was recorded in conversation with Sir David at the Royal Festival Hall in May, with the veteran broadcaster saying he hopes his new film Ocean, released on Sunday, will galvanise society into action 'before we destroy this great treasure.' In their meeting, the future king chatted with his natural history hero about their shared optimism for future discoveries in the planet's seas, despite the threats they face. With a shared passion for protecting the natural world, the prince and the veteran broadcaster have supported each other in their missions to tackle some of the biggest environmental challenges the planet faces. In his Monaco speech, William said Sir David's film 'makes the most compelling argument for immediate action I have ever seen'. A Kensington Palace spokesman said: 'There should be no doubt that this speech is The Prince of Wales calling for action to save our oceans now. The world is watching. 'This is him using his platform to call for more to be done sooner rather than later.' As he arrived at the forum, a journalist shouted to the Prince asking whether he was excited to go to Brazil, to which William replied: 'Yes'. The Prince of Wales arriving at the Blue Economy and Finance Forum in Monaco (Manon Cruz/PA) William also met finalists, winners and partners of the Earthshot Prize – a global environmental award of which he is founder and president. Kensington Palace said the finalists and winners had showcased 'innovative solutions that have the potential to reverse the damage caused to the oceans and that can preserve it for future generations'. William met Sam Teicher from Coral Vita, a 2021 winner, which works to restore coral reefs by growing coral on land to replant in oceans and Jennifer Koepke from WildAid, a 2023 winner, which scales marine enforcement to end illegal fishing and strengthen ocean conservation. William also met 2022 finalist Nick Wilson, whose entry was the Great Bubble Barrier, which works to prevent plastic pollution by intercepting waste before it reaches the ocean, and 2024 finalist Nicholas Hill from Coast 4C, which connects investment in coastal agriculture with conservation through the farming of regenerative seaweed. Each year five winners are awarded the Earthshot Prize from a shortlist of 15. The BEFF is organised by the government of Monaco, the Prince Albert II of Monaco Foundation, and the Oceanographic Institute of Monaco, with support from France and Costa Rica. The forum is a UN Ocean Conference special event and aims to contribute to the implementation of sustainable development goal 14 to 'conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development'. France is hosting the UN Ocean Conference from June 9 to June 13 in nearby Nice. The King is due to host Mr Macron on a state visit by the French leader and his wife Brigitte Macron from July 8-10. The French president will stay at Windsor Castle and be hosted at a state banquet at the historic Berkshire royal residence during his stay.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Furious Anas Sarwar clashes with BBC journalist over Labour policies
The Scottish Labour leader dodged questions about his previous comments on GB Energy and a bespoke Scottish visa, instead taking aim at the journalist and accusing them of 'letting the SNP off scot-free'. First Minister John Swinney would answer questions on the BBC Scotland Sunday Show immediately after Sarwar's tense appearance. Sarwar made the appearance after his party won a shock by-election victory over the SNP in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse on Friday. BBC journalist Martin Geissler appeared to spark Sarwar's ire after pointing out that he had said prior to the General Election that GB Energy would create 69,000 jobs. READ MORE: Scottish independence 'already begun as UK political culture diverges' Asked how many it has created now, a year later, Sarwar responded: 'Martin, I think you have to live in the real world rather than in a fantasy world.' Geissler pointed out: 'It's in your manifesto…' 'No, one second to set up the legislation, set up a company, make the appointments in terms of who runs that company, to then start making the investments, and then see the fruits of those investments,' Sarwar said. 'Any sensible person in the country will know that will take longer than 10 months if you are to get to that final outcome…' Geissler kept trying to interject but a furious Sarwar continued to talk over him, adding: 'It's a crazy suggestion for you to make that somehow a Labour government comes in, after 10 months, we clean up all the mess left by the Tories after 14 years and we build a utopia across our country. (Image: BBC) 'People didn't buy it in the run up to the by-election so that's why the SNP and Reform lost…' Later in the interview, as Sarwar tried to turn the focus on Scotland's NHS, Geissler tried to make a point about immigration policy impacting the health service's ability to get staff. Sarwar fired back: 'It's down to mismanagement of the SNP…' Geissler tried to finish his point, even going so far as to say 'no no no, I'm talking' and asking Sarwar to 'please' let him finish. But the Scottish Labour leader continued his rant, adding: 'The NHS is completely in the control of the SNP and you're falling for the exact same narrative that commentators had going into the by-election…' READ MORE: SNP must turn support for independence into 'real political action' 'Commentators embarrassed, pollsters embarrassed, pundits embarrassed and frankly your questions are embarrassing too, Martin.' Geissler fired back: 'I think you should be slightly embarrassed that you're not listening to my questions.' 'Go for it,' Sarwar said. An exasperated Geissler could be heard saying 'right', before asking Sarwar about his previous claims he was speaking to the Home Office about a 'bespoke visa system' for Scotland's needs. He then asked if Scotland would get its own immigration system. Sarwar replied: 'No, why would we have our own immigration system? We would have an immigration system that's tailored for the needs of individual parts of the country. That's what we said.' 'I thought you said you'd had talks with the UK Government about a bespoke Scottish visa system?' Geissler asked. 'Again, Martin, you are misleading in your characterisation,' Sarwar said. (Image: BBC) 'We have always said a single UK Border Agency, a single UK Home Office, but [an] immigration system that reflects the needs of different parts of the country. 'But again you want to talk about a UK Labour Government and let the SNP off scot-free' Geissler pointed out that the First Minister was due to be interviewed next and he wanted to talk about Labour policy. Again, talking over the journalist, Sarwar said: 'But talk about what we're going to do here in Scotland, talk about how we're the only party that can remove the SNP from office, talk about how we're going to fix the NHS, talk about how we're going to fix our schools..' Geissler pointed out that he had been trying to, while Sarwar continued to talk over him.
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Swinney poised for cabinet reshuffle following by-election defeat
However, it follows his earlier remarks on the show where he expressed his 'obvious disappointment' at his party's results in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election on Thursday. Scottish Labour's Davy Russell won the seat over the SNP's Katy Loudon in a move which shocked pollsters, pundits and journalists. The SNP were seen as the frontrunners throughout the race with suggestions from some polling that Reform could even overtake Labour. However, Labour's Mr Russell received 8,559 votes on the night, a majority of 602 over the second-placed SNP. Reform UK finished third with 7,088 votes, knocking the Conservatives into fourth place who received only 1,621 votes. The vote followed the death of SNP MSP Christina McKelvie, who had represented the constituency since 2011. The Herald was previously told Ms McAllan was expected to return to her role as Cabinet Secretary for Net Zero and Energy in July this year. The SNP's Gillian Martin is currently the acting cabinet minister in this brief. Today, Mr Swinney revealed he would be looking at his cabinet shortly. Asked if he would be having an emergency reshuffle of his senior ministers, Mr Swinney said: 'Obviously, I've got a cabinet minister coming back from maternity leave so I have to look at the team. I'll be doing that in due course.' His comments come after Scottish Constitution Secretary Angus Robertson said the SNP would need to "look very closely" at the by-election result and "learn the lessons" for the Holyrood elections. Speaking earlier on the programme about their defeat, Mr Swinney said: 'Obviously, I'm disappointed that we didn't win the by-election on Thursday. We fought a very energetic campaign with an excellent candidate in Katy Loudon. The First Minister said his party was still in 'a process of recovery' and they must 'get stronger' in order to win support. READ MORE: How Labour beat the odds — and rocked the SNP All change after Hamilton – but not perhaps in the way you expect Ash Regan to Elon Musk: 'Forget Trump and bring SpaceX to Scotland' Mr Swinney said his party must focus on the NHS in order to win over voters. 'Improvements in performance in the National Health Service….We need to deliver on and that's exactly what I'm focused on in the course of my work as First Minister," he said. However, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar accused Mr Swinney of running a 'dishonest and shameful' campaign which he argued drove voters into the arms of Reform UK at the recent by-election. He also hit out at the 'commentariat' who he said are 'wanting to ignore a party that's been in power for 18 years.' Mr Sarwar told the programme: 'The best John Swinney had to offer after eighteen years was to vote SNP to stop Farage. "A dishonest, shameful campaign, lack of ambition, running down the clock and having no idea about what's affecting the daily lives of people in Scotland which is a disgrace.' He added that the SNP campaign 'attempted to push people into the arms of reform rather than confront the issues that he caused in people's communities across the country.' Mr Sarwar added: 'The people across Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse are tired of this SNP government that has failed them every single day, that has broken our NHS, that has seen a decline in our schools, has wasted billions of pounds and they reject them. 'They think they are out of steam, they think they are out of ideas and they want them out of office. I think that's clear and it's also clear that only Scottish Labour can do that. 'For all the noise of Reform and all the noise of Nigel Farage, people did reject Reform UK and Nigel Farage.' After conversations on the doorstep of the constituency they have just won, Mr Sarwar said: 'People do want a UK Labour Government to go much quicker in terms of them making a demonstrable difference in their lives. I think that was loud and clear too.' Mr Sarwar has said he would urge the Labour Government to 'do more' and pointed to specific policies such as the winter fuel payment creating 'frustration' amongst voters. 'We have to continue with economic stability, we have to get growth up that is going to improve jobs and conditions….Bringing people's interest rates down so that mortgages are reduced.' During his interview this morning, Mr Sarwar said it was important to distinguish the different powers both Westminster and Holyrood hold. He said more needs to be done to address the cost of living, energy bills and people's mortgages by the UK Government, however, he said Scots have been let down by the SNP through a 'broken NHS' and 'a decline' in education, transport and housing. Mr Sarwar said: 'The choice next year is not to remove a UK Labour government, it's not to change who the Prime Minister is. The choice next year is a third decade of the SNP with John Swinney as First Minister or a new direction for Scotland with me.'
