Decision looming in murder trial of man charged with killing Lindy Lucena in Ballina
The NSW Supreme Court has been told a man accused of murdering his partner in Ballina in 2023 concocted multiple false stories when talking to police.
Robert Karl Huber is accused of killing 64-year-old Lindy Lucena, also known as "Kimmy", whose body was found in a laneway near a Salvation Army Centre more than two-and-a-half years ago.
Crown prosecutor Susan Oliver today told the court Ms Lucena may have been dead for at least three hours before Mr Huber walked into the Ballina Police Station.
Mr Huber has pleaded not guilty to the murder and manslaughter of Ms Lucena, and is facing a judge-alone trial in Coffs Harbour.
At the start of proceedings last Wednesday, Mr Huber pleaded guilty to assault occasioning actual bodily harm over an incident that occurred on Boxing Day 2022, eight days before Ms Lucena's death.
The court heard Mr Huber and Ms Lucena met in 2017, and that their relationship had become volatile from around 2019.
The pair became homeless following the Lismore floods in 2022 and had been staying in a Ballina caravan park.
On Boxing Day 2022, Mr Huber was charged with assaulting Ms Lucena in their motor home.
The court heard that following his release from custody on December 28, Mr Huber and Ms Lucena were kicked out of the caravan park.
The two had unsuccessfully tried to stay at a local motor inn before relocating with their possessions to a small courtyard on the side of the Ballina Salvation Army on the afternoon of January 3.
Ms Oliver told the court Mr Huber blamed Ms Lucena for their homelessness.
She said their relationship was one characterised by Mr Huber lashing out at Ms Lucena physically when things got bad.
The court had previously heard evidence that a passer-by called triple-0 at 7:03pm on January 3, 2023, telling the operator he had heard a man "bashing the hell out of his woman".
Body-worn camera footage was also played for the court earlier in the trial, showing Mr Huber allegedly leading the police to Ms Lucena's body around 12:30am on January 4.
In the footage, Mr Huber is seen gesturing to Ms Lucena's body and allegedly telling police, "She doesn't look too good, does she?"
When asked in court what they were arguing about earlier in the evening, Mr Huber said, "I don't recall. It's usually something minor."
The prosecution said the forensic pathologist who carried out the post-mortem on Ms Lucena determined that she suffered multiple blows and died of craniofacial injuries.
The court heard some of her injuries were consistent with being grasped and held firmly, and that facial lacerations caused her to lose a lot of blood.
Defence counsel Jason Watts is due to start his closing arguments later this afternoon.
Mr Watts previously told the court he would argue it could not be proven beyond reasonable doubt that any assault by the accused caused Ms Lucena's death.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Huge delays on Sydney's M4 after car, truck crash at Minchinbury
A four-vehicle crash has caused major delays on Sydney's M4, one of the main citybound routes from the city's western suburbs. Three cars and a truck collided on the M4 eastbound at Minchinbury - between Wallgrove Rd and the M7 offramp - at about 5.50am on Thursday, police say. Two of the three eastbound lanes have been closed approaching the M7, with motorists warned to expect delays. Live Traffic NSW's map showed significant traffic jams stretching as far as 10km. Traffic cameras near the scene show significant congestion as commuters begin their morning journey towards the city, with banked-up vehicles stretching for kilometres. Paramedics treated one of the car drivers – a 65-year-old woman – at the scene, before she was taken to Westmead Hospital in a stable condition. The other drivers - a 25-year-old man, a 38-year-old man, and the 42-year-old truck driver - were all uninjured in the collision. The incident is under investigation by officers from the Traffic and Highway Patrol Command. Anyone with information or footage of the crash has been urged to come forward and contact Crime Stoppers. Traffic appears to have begun easing as of 8am, though significant delays are still expected.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
David McBride lodges High Court application to challenge conviction
Former military lawyer David McBride has lodged a special leave application in the High Court in a bid to challenge his conviction for sharing classified material with journalists. The ACT Supreme Court jailed McBride for five years and eight months for theft and leaking the material to three journalists. He was to face a jury but pleaded guilty when it became evident the court would not allow his basic defence that it was his duty to share the documents in the public interest. His point was that soldiers in Afghanistan were being "over-investigated" for alleged war crimes and he wanted the public to know. McBride appealed against his sentence and conviction, but that was thrown out earlier this year. His High Court appeal canvasses the same issues, drawing a distinction between disciplinary duties and duties of office, and relying on the Oath of Allegiance to the Sovereign. The oath, which McBride made to Queen Elizabeth II, includes a promise to serve the sovereign according to law, and "… faithfully discharge my duty according to law". The appeal centres on the scope of that duty. His lawyers say in their submissions to the High Court, that the ACT Court of Appeal "… erroneously assumed that a duty of service requires unqualified obedience to orders". The appeal court remarked that if it accepted McBride's argument it would "… also extend to conduct of members in all spheres of a member's military service, including on the battlefield". McBride's lawyers say in their High Court application they are not encouraging general defiance of orders, but rather suggesting it should be recognised "duty cannot be reduced to blind obedience". "… the applicant sought to communicate to the public evidence of serious misconduct at the highest levels of military command." the submissions to the High Court say. "An insistence that duty is wholly defined by orders strips away the necessary safeguard against executive overreach and ignores the principle that duty is judged by law, not merely military command." The application even cites the Nuremberg War Crimes Tribunal after the Second World War "which recognised following orders is no defence to actions that violate fundamental principles of law, such as crimes against humanity". "There must be circumstances where a soldier can and indeed must, disobey orders — even if those orders are authorised pursuant to military law." Only the ABC used the material David McBride provided, in a series called the Afghan Files, which revealed allegations Australian soldiers were involved in illegal killings in Afghanistan. This was not, of course, what David McBride had hoped to achieve by handing over the documents. He had begun copying the material, printing it and taking it home in 2013. A search showed he had removed 235 documents, 207 of which had a secret classification. McBride knew for a long time he would face charges. During the investigation the ABC was raided by Australian Federal Police looking for evidence in the case. It was not until 2019 that he finally appeared in the ACT Magistrates Court, with even longer to wait for trial, after interruptions from the pandemic. He is now in Canberra's jail. It is not known when the High Court will consider the application.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Warnings to residents after huge blaze at factory in Hallam, Melbourne
An arson chemist has been called to investigate a suspicious fire at what is believed to be a school uniform shop in Melbourne's southeast. The building was engulfed in flames when firefighters arrived at the scene on the Princes Highway at Hallam just after midnight on Thursday. Crews from Fire Rescue Victoria (FRV) and the Country Fire Association (CFA) battled the blaze for hours until it was deemed under control just after 3am. A warning was issued to neighbouring communities as smoke plumed from the blaze. Residents were warned to stay informed and be aware that they may see or smell smoke. Ambulance Victoria and Victoria Police also responded to the fire and a building surveyor was also on the scene. A Victoria Police spokesman confirmed the fire was being treated as suspicious, and fire crews remain on the scene to fully extinguish the blaze. An arson chemist will visit the Princes Highway site later on Thursday to determine the cause. Anyone who has any information or footage of the fire has been asked to contact Crime Stoppers.
