Exclusive: UK considered Palestine recognition in 2014 if Israel built settlements now being planned
The UK privately decided in 2014 that it would consider recognising a Palestinian state if Israel advanced with the contentious E1 settlement project, Middle East Eye can reveal.
Israel is currently poised to move forward with the settlement plan, which would effectively split the occupied West Bank in two.
'This is how we effectively kill the Palestinian state,' Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who also oversees settlement activity and civilian affairs in the West Bank, said last Tuesday.
Although the construction plan dates back to the 1990s, its implementation has repeatedly been delayed due to strong international opposition.
Britain's Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government publicly criticised the plan in 2014.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
But multiple Foreign Office sources with knowledge of the matter told MEE that privately, the government went much further and decided it would consider recognising Palestine if the Israeli government moved forward with the project.
Responding to the revelation, Labour MP Kim Johnson said: "Even the last Tory government acknowledged the necessity of recognising the state of Palestine in the event of any further Israeli illegal annexation of Palestinian land and escalation of a threat to the viability of a Palestinian state."
She added: "Britain must unilaterally recognise the state of Palestine without any further delay."
Labour MP Uma Kumaran, a member of Britain's Foreign Affairs Select Committee, told MEE that "we are witnessing the total destruction of Gaza and the creeping annexation of the West Bank in real time.
"If there is further delay, the devastating reality is, there may soon be nothing or no one left to recognise."
In October 2014, the House of Commons voted 274 to 12 in favour of recognising a Palestinian state, but the government insisted it would do so when it was "appropriate for the peace process".
Asked for comment on the revelation on Tuesday, the Foreign Office referred MEE to the Labour government's position on the issue.
Earlier this year British Foreign Secretary David Lammy insisted that the UK would only recognise a Palestinian state "when we know it's going to happen and it's in sight".
Pakistani military says UK engines powered Israeli drones used by India Read More »
Now, however, there is speculation that Britain and France could recognise a Palestinian state at a conference on the two-state solution in June.
In late April, Lammy acknowledged for the first time that the UK is in discussion with France and Saudi Arabia on the topic.
Kumaran said: "This government was elected on a manifesto that promised to recognise Palestine as a step towards a just and lasting peace. I strongly support the recognition of a Palestinian State, and I have raised this repeatedly in parliament, on the Foreign Affairs Committee and with ministers."
Former senior British diplomat Sir William Patey, who chairs the Labour Middle East Council, told MEE: "Now is the time for the UK along with France to recognise a Palestinian state before it is too late to save a two state solution."
Alon Liel, who was formerly director general of Israel's foreign ministry and adviser to Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, told MEE he believes UK support would be vital in helping to secure Palestinian statehood.
"Britain's position on the two states issue and the recognition of the state of Palestine is critical mainly because of its historic responsibility," said Liel, a founding member of the Policy Working Group, an Israeli organisation which opposes Israel's occupation of Palestinian territory.
"British recognition of Palestine will save the two-states idea. The Labour Party has the recognition issue on its platform and should proceed and implement its commitment in order to avoid a further Middle Eastern deterioration that will endanger Europe too."
Former Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn, now an independent MP, told MEE: "It is disgraceful that the government has chosen to delay and delay the recognition of a Palestinian state.
"We should recognise it unconditionally and immediately. Not some time in the future. Not when the time is right. Now."
'Irreversible consequences'
Both the United States and the European Union have warned successive Israeli governments against advancing the E1 plan, citing its potentially devastating impact on prospects for a two-state solution.
The project would involve the construction of 3,412 housing units for Israeli settlers on occupied Palestinian land.
It aims to connect the settlements of Kfar Adumim and Maale Adumim with occupied East Jerusalem, cutting off Palestinian communities from one another and significantly disrupting territorial continuity.
'The UK should be recognising Palestine because it recognises Palestinian national rights'
- Chris Doyle, CAABU
Responding to MEE's revelation that the UK decided in 2014 it would consider recognising Palestine if Israel advanced the E1 project, independent MP Ayoub Khan said: "That moment has now arrived.
"The Israeli government is moving forward with E1 - an illegal project that would sever East Jerusalem from the West Bank and destroy the geographical viability of a future Palestinian state."
Khan added: "To prevent the E1 project and its irreversible consequences, the UK must immediately recognise the State of Palestine and defend this position across international diplomatic platforms.
Israel to advance E1 settlement project that would 'kill the Palestinian state' Read More »
"If necessary, the UK must table a motion at the UN to deploy international protection forces on the ground to uphold the territorial integrity of Palestine and safeguard its population."
Israeli Finance Minister Smotrich said at a settlement conference last Tuesday that the Israeli government had already approved 15,000 settlement units in 2024 and is investing 7bn shekels ($1.9bn) in new roads across the West Bank to facilitate further settlement growth.
Independent MP Adnan Hussain said: "The UK government must take immediate actions to recognise the Palestinian state before Israel advances its plans for the E1 settlement project, which if successful will split the West Bank in two and end any hope for a Palestinian state."
Chris Doyle, director of the Council for Arab-British Understanding (CAABU), added that the UK "should not recognise a state of Palestine as a punishment for illegal conduct.
"Israeli criminal behaviour, as with any state, should be met with sanctions," he told MEE.
"The UK should be recognising Palestine because it recognises Palestinian national rights and the right to self-determination."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gulf Today
3 hours ago
- Gulf Today
Netanyahu admits Israel supporting armed criminal gang against Hamas in Gaza
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu admitted that Israel is supporting an armed group in Gaza that opposes the Hamas group, following comments by a former minister that Israel had transferred weapons to it. Israeli and Palestinian media have reported that the group Israel has been working with is part of a local Bedouin tribe led by Yasser Abu Shabab. The European Council on Foreign Relations (EFCR) think tank describes Abu Shabab as the leader of a "criminal gang operating in the Rafah area that is widely accused of looting aid trucks." Knesset member and ex-defence minister Avigdor Liberman had told the Kan public broadcaster that the government, at Netanyahu's direction, was "giving weapons to a group of criminals and felons." "What did Liberman leak? That security sources activated a clan in Gaza that opposes Hamas? What is bad about that?" Netanyahu said in a video posted to social media on Thursday. "It is only good, it is saving lives of Israeli soldiers." Michael Milshtein, an expert on Palestinian affairs at the Moshe Dayan Center in Tel Aviv, told AFP that the Abu Shabab clan was part of a Bedouin tribe that spans across the border between Gaza and Egypt's Sinai peninsula. Some of the tribe's members, he said, were involved in "all kinds of criminal activities, drug smuggling, and things like that." Milshtein said that Abu Shabab had spent time in prison in Gaza and that his clan chiefs had recently denounced him as an Israeli "collaborator and a gangster." "It seems that actually the Shabak (Israeli security agency) or the (military) thought it was a wonderful idea to turn this militia, gang actually, into a proxy, to give them weapons and money and shelter" from army operations, Milshtein said. He added that Hamas killed four members of the gang days ago. The ECFR said Abu Shabab was "reported to have been previously jailed by Hamas for drug smuggling. His brother is said to have been killed by Hamas during a crackdown against the group's attacks on UN aid convoys." Israel regularly accuses Hamas, with which it has been at war for nearly 20 months, of looting aid convoys in Gaza. Hamas said the group had "chosen betrayal and theft as their path" and called on civilians to oppose them. Hamas, which has ruled Gaza for nearly two decades, said it had evidence of "clear coordination between these looting gangs, collaborators with the occupation (Israel), and the enemy army itself in the looting of aid and the fabrication of humanitarian crises that deepen the suffering of" Palestinians. The Popular Forces, as Abu Shabab's group calls itself, said on Facebook it had "never been, and will never be, a tool of the occupation". "Our weapons are simple, outdated, and came through the support of our own people," it added. Milshtein called Israel's decision to arm a group such as Abu Shabab "a fantasy, not something that you can really describe as a strategy". "I really hope it will not end with catastrophe," he said. Agence France-Presse
Middle East Eye
7 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Thousands march in Rome against Israel's war on Gaza
Tens of thousands took to the streets of Rome on Saturday to protest the ongoing Israeli war on Gaza, in a massive demonstration led by opposition groups accusing Italy's government of being complicit in Israel's assault. 'Stop the massacre, stop complicity!' read a banner at the front of the march, as a sea of Palestinian flags, rainbow peace banners, and 'Free Palestine' signs stretched down the capital's avenues. Organisers estimated the turnout at around 300,000. The peaceful protest moved from Piazza Vittorio to San Giovanni, where speakers condemned the violence in Gaza and criticised the silence of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni's far-right government. Protestors hold a banner reading "Free Palestine" as they join a demonstration called by Italian opposition parties in support of Palestinians in Gaza, in Rome on June 7, 2025 (AFP) A man holds a placard reading "Free Palestine" as he joins a demonstration called by Italian opposition parties in support of Palestinians in Gaza, in Rome on June 7, 2025 (AFP) Protesters holds puppets on the shape of human bodies covered with fake blood as they join a demonstration called by Italian opposition parties in support of Palestinians in Gaza, in Rome (AFP)
Gulf Today
8 hours ago
- Gulf Today
How Robert Jenrick skewered Kemi Badenoch's reboot
Kate Devlin, The Independent Robert Jenrick's attention-grabbing videos have angered other senior Tories as the party desperately tries to raise the profile of their beleaguered leader, Kemi Badenoch. The shadow justice secretary hit the headlines last week thanks to a stunt that saw him chase down and challenge fare dodgers on London trains. The clip, which follows others on a range of issues including bin collections in Birmingham and the government's deal to hand over the Chagos Islands to Mauritius, was watched more than 10 million times. But the move overshadowed Ms Badenoch's own video meeting grooming gang victims, and is far from the first time Jenrick has garnered publicity apparently at the expense of his party leader. A recent mishap, where hundreds of Westminster insiders were added to a WhatsApp group publicising his London marathon run, led to Badenoch being asked if Jenrick, who ran against her for the leadership of the party, posed a fresh threat to her. She laughed it off. But party insiders have told The Independent his interventions are leading to tensions with other members of the shadow cabinet. It comes as the Tories try to raise the profile of Badenoch, as even some of her closest political allies — including shadow chancellor Mel Stride — admit she needs to improve her performance. This week's tracker poll by Techne UK puts the Tories on just 17 per cent (up one per cent) — a full 14 points behind Reform on 31 per cent, with Labour also struggling on 23 per cent. The polling showed that well over a third, 37 per cent, of 2024 general election Tory voters have now deserted them for Reform. Recent focus groups, held by the pollsters More in Common (MIC), suggest one of the problems is that very few people know who Badenoch is. When groups of former Tory voters are shown clips of the Conservative leader speaking, they like her, but for most of them, it is the first time they have seen her, MIC found. In a bid to bolster her position, insiders plan to lean into Ms Badenoch's forthright personality, in what has been dubbed the 'Let Kemi be Kemi' strategy - a nod to the famous West Wing 'Let Bartlet Be Bartlet' quote. And, like Jenrick, there is a hope that her clips will go viral. There was surprise when a video of Ms Badenoch telling two incredulous BBC Breakfast hosts that she had not watched the Netflix hit Adolescence took off online. At one point, Badenoch told them she already understood the issues highlighted by the programme, adding 'I don't need to watch Casualty to know about the NHS'. Her supporters want her to double down on what is seen as her 'authenticity', at a time when voters appear to be turning away from career politicians to support people such as Donald Trump and the Reform leader Nigel Farage. In the background, there is also frustration about the amount of airtime Badenoch gets on the main broadcasters. The issue is one all opposition leaders struggle with, as the government is inevitably seen as more newsworthy. But it is seen particularly difficult at the moment, at a time of huge international news, with President Trump in the White House, war raging on the edge of Europe in Ukraine and the ongoing bombardment of Gaza. Insiders claim Badenoch is relaxed about Jenrick straying into briefs that are not his own, especially given huge demands on the time of the leader of the opposition. However, sources say there have been tensions with other members of her shadow cabinet. One senior figure told The Independent: 'Some have been very annoyed... That has caused tensions. Kemi has a challenge managing the competition in her team.' Another insider said: "There's no discipline. Basically, shadow cabinet members can do what they want with no central grid. It's causing complete chaos.' A supporter of Jenrick accused some frontbenchers of being 'jealous' that he was able to make headlines.
