Federal appeals court agrees to keep Maine's 72-hour law on hold
Apr. 10—A federal appeals court in Boston ruled Thursday that Maine's 72-hour waiting period on gun purchases will remain on hold pending a larger appeal from the state attorney general's office.
State lawmakers passed the 72-hour bill last year along with several other gun safety reforms following the mass shooting in Lewiston in October 2023 that killed 18 people and wounded more than a dozen others. It required any gun seller who violated the waiting period to pay fines between $200 and $1,000, depending on the nature of the violation.
Gun rights advocates quickly sued the state in November after Gov. Janet Mills allowed it to become law without her signatures. Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker then granted their request in February to temporarily pause the law, siding with their arguments that the waiting period likely violated their constitutional right to bear arms.
The Office of the Maine Attorney General immediately appealed that decision to the U.S. 1st Circuit Court of Appeals in Boston. Chief Deputy Attorney General Christopher Taub has argued the law saves lives and that it doesn't infringe on Mainers' constitutional ability to bear arms.
Taub asked Walker if the law could be temporarily restored, pending the appeal, which Walker also denied in March. The appeals court is still weighing that aspect of the case.
View this document on Scribd
The 1st Circuit wrote in Thursday's ruling that the question at the center of Maine's case is so new, "in an emerging area of constitutional law involving a legal standard that is difficult to apply and subject to varying interpretations," that they are not persuaded the law should be restored at this point in the legal battle.
Copy the Story Link
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
9 minutes ago
- Politico
Direct line
Presented by U15 CANADA – Canada's Leading Research Universities Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Canada Playbook | Follow Politico Canada Thanks for reading Canada Playbook. In today's edition: → MARK CARNEY and DONALD TRUMP are on the horn. → A one-on-one with Northwest Territories Premier R.J. SIMPSON. → A look back at MARC GARNEAU's early advice on countering Trump 2.0. POLITICO PRO SPACE: Need an insider's guide to the politics behind the new space race? From battles over sending astronauts to Mars to the ways space companies are vying to influence regulators, this weekly newsletter decodes the personalities, policy and power shaping the final frontier. Try it for free for a limited time starting today. Find out more. Trade war PICK UP THE PHONE — One of DONALD TRUMP's allies in Congress has some advice for MARK CARNEY: Call up the president, call him again and then call him some more. Sen. KEVIN CRAMER (R-N.D.), who joined a recent peacemaking congressional delegation to Ottawa that scored face time with Carney, told POLITICO's JONATHAN MARTIN that Trump is keen on a cellphone relationship with world leaders. The president wants to receive constant intelligence from guys like Carney, Cramer said, adding he was aware of at least one informal leader-level conversation between the two following the prime minister's trip to the White House last month. — High-stakes negotiations: Carney appears to have taken the counsel. Trump's Ottawa envoy, PETE HOEKSTRA, revealed to The Globe and Mail that the PM and president are directly engaged in negotiations on a new economic and security relationship. 'The indications that they are talking and in communications regularly is a clear indicator to me that both sides recognize the importance and the urgency of moving this forward,' Hoekstra told the Globe, adding that a prospective deal could touch on autos, critical minerals, defense spending, energy, border security — and steel and aluminum. The ambassador added the talks also include Canada-U.S. Trade Minister DOMINIC LEBLANC, U.S. Commerce Secretary HOWARD LUTNICK and U.S. Trade Representative JAMIESON GREER. — Official lines: The Prime Minister's Office isn't commenting on the Globe report, but Industry Minister MÉLANIE JOLY confirmed to reporters the two leaders are in touch. 'We won't negotiate in public,' she said. 'We'll let the prime minister do his work.' — Elsewhere in trade: Ontario's premier lashed out at any notion that Trump would show warmth to Chinese President XI JINPING, who landed a lengthy morning call with Washington on Thursday. 'China is getting better treatment than their closest allies and friends,' Ontario Premier DOUG FORD. Ford didn't hide his impatience with the Americans during a Thursday spot on MSNBC: 'I'm in constant communication with the prime minister as of even [Wednesday] afternoon, and if it doesn't go too well, then we have to start matching tariff for tariff, dollar for dollar.' — Speaking of China: 'Carney agrees to high-level talks with Beijing on resolving Canada-China trade war,' the Globe's STEVE CHASE reports THE ROOMS THAT MATTER — At 10:15 a.m., federal officials will hold an embargoed background media technical briefing on the introduction of a bill to 'build One Canadian Economy.' — Carney will lead a 12:30 p.m. media availability in West Block alongside ministers DOMINIC LEBLANC, CHRYSTIA FREELAND and TIM HODGSON. — Industry Minister MÉLANIE JOLY is in Hamilton. Joly is scheduled to visit ArcelorMittal Dofasco alongside local MPs LISA HEPFNER, JOHN-PAUL DANKO and ASLAM RANA. The minister will speak to reporters at 12:45 p.m. LISTEN UP, OTTAWA HE THE NORTH — Canada's North is having a moment — and R.J. SIMPSON is here for it. The Northwest Territories premier just wrapped up a trip to Ottawa, where he sat down with Prime Minister MARK CARNEY armed with a wishlist of nation-building projects — one of which is likely to bear fruit in the coming months. The meeting was a refreshing change for Simpson, who says he went through pains to get Ottawa's attention when former Prime Minister JUSTIN TRUDEAU held office. Even landing a meeting used to be a challenge. 'I just met with Prime Minister Carney, and it hasn't been that long since he's been in office,' Simpson told Playbook. 'We've had a number of face-to-face First Ministers Meetings, which was not common in the last government either.' — Breaking the ice: The Liberal government took a renewed interest in the North in January, Simpson said, when President DONALD TRUMP returned to the White House. — Slap on the wrist: In a February trip to D.C. with other premiers, Simpson said U.S. lawmakers flagged Canada's lack of Arctic infrastructure compared to Russia and other Nordic countries. 'They view it as a missing component in their defense,' Simpson said. Some proposed infrastructure projects have languished for up to 70 years, Simpson said. — Elevator pitch: This isn't merely a list-checking exercise for Simpson. Infrastructure projects can feed national defense and economic strategies. They can help Canada meet NATO spending targets, keep China out of its backyard and unlock critical minerals, Simpson insists. The premier teased that some of his priority projects could gain traction 'in the next couple of months.' — Wishlist: That fast track could include an Arctic Security Corridor, Simpson said, which would run through the territory's Slave Geological Project — an untapped critical mineral zone. 'It is one of the most mineral resource-rich areas in the world. We know there's critical minerals. We know there's rare earth elements,' Simpson said. He's also pushing for a road to NORAD's forward operating location in Inuvik — to facilitate military infrastructure and transport goods to communities. — For sovereignty's sake: As past governments pursued different priorities, China has attempted to move in, Premier Simpson said — including by buying into N.W.T. mining firms. — Watch your back: 'We have not received a lot of investment in the North, ever. And when an area is not receiving any investment from their own government, they become more open to investment from elsewhere,' Simpson said. 'It would deter Chinese interference in the North if the North was getting what it needed from the government of Canada.' WHO'S UP, WHO'S DOWN Up: House of Commons confidence in the Liberal government, which watched its throne speech sail through the chamber Wednesday without a recorded vote. Shortly after the anticlimactic victory, Liberal MPs indulged at various Sparks Street watering holes. Down: Canada's merchandise exports, which Statistics Canada said dropped 10.8 percent in April compared to a month earlier. The agency called the country's global trade deficit in merchandise the 'largest … on record' at C$7.1 billion. IN MEMORIAM MARC GARNEAU — The trailblazing astronaut and former Cabinet minister offered what turned out to be his parting thoughts on the trade war with Trump in an April 24 interview with Playbook co-host MIKE BLANCHFIELD. — No illusions: Days before the federal vote, Garneau offered an unvarnished take on the cross-border state of play in Trump 2.0. 'We have to take a very aggressive approach with the full realization that, you know, never mind trying a charm offensive. That's a waste of time. The world order has changed, and at this point there should be no illusions about ever going back to what existed before. And in fact, I think it would be a mistake to try to go back to what existed before,' Garneau said over the phone. 'From Canada's point of view, we have to be resolute in dealing with the tariffs that he ends up imposing on us. There will be pain, there's no question about it.' Most recently, Garneau was the Canadian co-chair of the Canada-Korea Forum. He saw a good opportunity in the Indo-Pacific region to diversify Canada's trade portfolio. — Spreading our wings: 'They are a like-minded country to us, and so we should try to strengthen our trade ties to that part of the world, not only to Europe,' Garneau said. 'I'm also talking about the ASEAN countries, and I'm also talking about India, where we have had some challenges.' MORNING MUST-CLICKS — Top of POLITICO this morning: DONALD TRUMP, White House aides signal a possible détente with ELON MUSK — 'Insiders say Mark Carney could compromise on emissions cap,' reports the Toronto Star's ALEX BALLINGALL. — CP's ANJA KARADEGLIJA reports on Canada's years-long wait for a national disaster response agency. — The House of Commons unanimously voted Thursday for a government-proposed tax cut for middle-income earners. PLAYBOOKERS Birthdays: HBD to House Speaker FRANCIS SCARPALEGGIA and former diplomat HOWARD BALLOCH. Also celebrating today: Quebec Education Minister BERNARD DRAINVILLE, as well as former MPs RAMESH SANGHA and NICK WHALEN. Celebrating Saturday: Liberal MP ROB OLIPHANT, NDP politician JINNY SIMS, former Ottawa Centre provincial Liberal candidate THOMAS SIMPSON, and GUY GALLANT, chief of staff to Agriculture Minister HEATH MACDONALD (40!). On Sunday: Former Bank of Canada governor DAVID DODGE and McMillan Vantage founding partner MARK RESNICK. Spotted: Prime Minister MARK CARNEY, stopping in for lunch at Cocotte Bistro. Environmental activist DAVID SUZUKI, strolling past West Block Thursday afternoon: 'What I'm here to tell people is we have very little time to take big steps, and if we don't take them, guess what? Extinction in our grandchildren's lifetime is what faces us.' Noted: Parliament Hill's cutest dog award went to LOUIS, whose owner is Liberal MP KODY BLOIS … The Bloc Québécois' Bill C-202, a private member's bill that would shield supply management from future trade negotiations, cleared third reading in the House on Thursday by unanimous consent. Movers and shakers: The PM revealed his new parliamentary secretary team. Some standouts: — ALI EHSASSI and TIM LOUIS: Canada-U.S. Trade Minister DOMINIC LEBLANC — ROB OLIPHANT and MONA FORTIER: Foreign Affairs Minister ANITA ANAND — KARIM BARDEESY and CARLOS LEITíO: Industry Minister MÉLANIE JOLY — COREY HOGAN and CLAUDE GUAY: Energy Minister TIM HODGSON — RYAN TURNBULL: Finance Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE — LESLIE CHURCH: Jobs Minister PATTY HAJDU (with responsibility for persons with disabilities) — ÉLISABETH BRIÈRE is deputy chief government whip, and ARIELLE KAYABAGA is deputy government House leader. JEREMY NIXON, Hogan's Conservative opponent in Calgary Confederation and a former Cabinet minister in Alberta, is now a principal at Navigator in Calgary. Lobby watch: The Canadian Canola Growers Association posted a Wednesday meeting with Agriculture Minister HEATH MACDONALD, Deputy Minister LAWRENCE HANSON and senior political aides. Media mentions: Unionized employees at The Canadian Press are publicly calling out their employer's latest offer amid collective bargaining … La Presse won the 2024 Michener Award. Send Playbookers tips to canadaplaybook@ PROZONE For Pro subscribers, our latest policy newsletter from MIKE BLANCHFIELD: Trump tariffs pound Canada's exports In other Pro headlines: — What do Musk and Tesla want from the Republican megabill? — Army leaders warn US is losing drone race, tout big changes. — Senate bill would add $10B to NASA budget. — GAVIN NEWSOM met privately with Trump's Hollywood ambassador JON VOIGHT TRIVIA Thursday's answer: Six foreign ministers have served since the Liberals were elected in 2015: STÉPHANE DION, CHRYSTIA FREELAND, FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE, MARC GARNEAU, MÉLANIE JOLY and ANITA ANAND. Props to CHRIS LALANDE, MARCEL MARCOTTE, JOHN PEPPER, ANDREW BALFOUR, STEVE YANG, CHRISTINA DE TONI, SHAUGHN MCARTHUR, ELIZABETH BURN, MARC LEBLANC, DARREN MAJOR, CAMERON RYAN, JEFF VALOIS, JIM REILLY, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, MALCOLM MCKAY, BOB ERNEST, ALEX BALLINGALL, HEATHER CHIASSON, DUANE BRATT, WAYNE EASTER and GARY COLLINS. Props +1 to JEFF VALOIS, too. Friday's question: On this day in history, British and American forces have fought on both the same side and opposing sides. In 1944, they joined forces on the beaches of Normandy. During which war did they once engage in battle on June 6? Answer to canadaplaybook@ Writing Monday's Playbook: MICKEY DJURIC Canada Playbook would not happen without: Canada Editor Sue Allan, editor Willa Plank and POLITICO's Grace Maalouf.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Protections for farmworkers discussing work conditions headed to governor's desk
Workers pick tomatoes at a farm owned and operated by Pacific Tomato Growers on February 19, 2021 in Immokalee, Florida. (Photo by) In addition to the right to minimum wage, agricultural workers in Maine may soon be protected from retaliation for talking about work conditions. On Thursday, the Maine Senate cast a final enactment vote for LD 588, which would give agricultural employees the right to engage in certain concerted activity, which includes talking about wages, working conditions and other employment matters with other employees or the employer. The House of Representatives initially rejected the bill, but narrowly decided Wednesday to change course and join the upper chamber in passing the measure. It now goes to Gov. Janet Mills for final approval. Opponents argued the bill is unnecessary and opens the door to unionization, which they said would be difficult for the agricultural industry given the seasonal nature of the work and other nuances. Sen. Scott Cyrway (R-Kennebec) said the proposal 'just puts another layer of difficulty for farmers.' However, Rep. Amy Roeder (D-Bangor), who co-chairs the Labor Committee, said the bill only asks for 'this very baseline concerted activity because we know unionization poses a lot of challenges.' Earlier this week, the chambers also approved legislation that would give farmworkers the right to state minimum wage. SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Proposed tax increases spark clash in Maine Legislature
Jun. 5—AUGUSTA — Lawmakers and advocates clashed over proposed tax increases Thursday as the debate over the state budget heats up in the closing days of the session. Progressive activists and some Democrats gathered at the State House and urged lawmakers to increases taxes on the wealthiest Mainers to help close a budget gap. But Republicans reiterated at a separate press conference that they will oppose any budget that includes tax increases. And Gov. Janet Mills, who has proposed a series of targeted tax increases and program cuts in her budget, has said she would not support any broad-based tax increases. Lawmakers are facing a budget squeeze as they try to pay for programs and commitments created in previous budgets, as state revenues flatten. Senate Minority Leader Trey Stewart, R-Presque Isle, said Democrats are responsible for the budget deficit because they have repeatedly passed majority budgets without Republican support. "They own this," Stewart said. "They set up three majority budgets in a row. They have run out of your money, and now they want to raise taxes on Maine people. We're not going to vote for it. But if they want to jump over that cliff, that's on them." Historically, lawmakers have sought to pass two-year state budgets with a bipartisan supermajority, so the funding can become available at the start of the fiscal year on July 1. Budgets passed by a simple majority, which the Democrats have done in recent years, don't become effective until 90 days after adjournment. Most of the budget negotiations have been taking place behind the scenes among Democrats, who are balancing Mills' proposed budget with their own priorities. More than 100 bills passed by the Democratic majority await funding. Earlier this session, Democrats used their majorities to pass an $11.3 billion continuing services budget over Republican objections. It includes funding to cover 55% of public education costs and provides $122 million to help stabilize MaineCare. But that budget doesn't include at least $122 million in additional funding needed to support MaineCare — Maine's Medicaid program — in the second year of the budget. The continuing services budget does not include $285 million in additional spending originally proposed by Mills, who also has proposed $156 million in tax increases, including increasing taxes on cigarettes, online streaming service and other areas. Mills has also proposed cutbacks, which include eliminating state funded food assistance for noncitizens, cutting two crisis receiving centers planned for Aroostook and Kennebec counties and stopping planned increases in child care worker stipends and cost-of-living increases for direct care workers. Mills also proposed reforms to the state's General Assistance program aimed at reducing costs. The governors said the changes would return the program to its original mission as a last resort safety net, rather than an ongoing housing assistance program. Advocates argued that increasing taxes on wealthy residents and corporations could raise millions of dollars to avoid the cuts proposed by Mills and support other vital programs. Maura Pillsbury, tax policy analyst for the Maine Center for Economic Policy, urged lawmakers to pass LD 1089, which would increase taxes on incomes over $1 million to fund public kindergarten through 12th grade education, and LD 1879, which would increase the tax rate on large corporations to support agricultural businesses. "These are reasonable, responsible steps to balance our budget and protect critical services, like child care, health care and food assistance, and not balancing the budget on the backs of vulnerable Mainers through harmful cuts," Pillsbury said. Amended versions of each of those bills have been advanced by the Taxation Committee and face floor votes in the coming days. It's unclear what changes the committee recommended, since the amendments are not yet posted. Advocates also support bills to overhaul of the state tax code to shift the burden more to higher income earners, which passed last year but vetoed by Mills, and increasing taxes on real estate sales over $1 million. Rep. Cheryl Golek, D-Harpswell, said her proposal for a millionaire's tax is modest compared to a proposal approved by voters in 2016 to add a surcharge to incomes over $200,000 and would correct "massive injustice in the tax system." "Today, I am asking that our richest share a slice of bread to those who turned the dough and made the loaf for them to eat," Golek said. Our economy shouldn't be balanced on the backs of the working class. Hard-working Mainers are struggling to pay their bills, yet we continually ask more of the most vulnerable among us by cutting vital programs and services instead of making our tax code more fair." Copy the Story Link
