Regional Covid-19 restrictions ‘did not change behaviour' during 2020
Regional restrictions did not change people's behaviour during the coronavirus pandemic despite rising numbers in Scotland, a study indicates.
Researchers from the University of Aberdeen examined adherence to restrictions including social distancing, mask-wearing, staying at home and handwashing, and found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other.
The study, published in the US journal Translational Behavioral Medicine, looked at behaviour during the Covid-19 pandemic in Scotland from March to November 2020, with 1724 people interviewed at random to get a representative sample.
People did not alter behaviour to follow enhanced local restrictions during the pandemic, the study found, and the restrictions may have been more effective if based around factors other than just coronavirus cases according to new research.
The study compared people's behaviours before and after local restrictions, and compared behaviours of those living in areas with increased restrictions to those living in areas without.
People did not change their behaviour when restrictions were tightened, including social distancing and mask wearing, defying scientists' expectations, research showed.
It also found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other, and examined 'intention and self-efficacy'.
Intention and self-efficacy related to keeping a 2.0 metre distance was assessed by asking: 'Do you intend to follow all the government instructions…' and 'How confident or not are you that you can follow the government instructions…' graded on a scale, according to the report.
The respondents answered questions about their behaviours from the past week, including if they had left home, had adhered to the social distancing rule, worn a mask in a shop or on public transport and if they washed their hands as soon as they got home.
Dr Chantal den Daas, senior lecturer in health psychology, in collaboration with the Covid Health and Adherence Research in Scotland (Charis) project, said the research 'can effectively influence public behaviour' in the future.
She said: 'When local restrictions were introduced in 2020 due to an increase in Covid-19 case numbers, we thought we would see a change in behaviour after they were implemented. But this was not what we found.
'It is really important to build an understanding of what could have been done differently and how we can effectively influence public behaviour in the future should we be faced with another public health crisis.
'This research provided insight on the type of information we should aim to collect in future pandemics, to see if we can find better measures to predict cases, examine the need for restrictions and the effect of any restrictions put in place.
'Future research in acute outbreaks should assess behaviour and beliefs about the virus, risk on an ongoing basis and identify the need for intervention even before cases rates start to go up.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Kate Garraway's secret health issue that made it 'dangerous' to be Derek's carer
Kate Garraway has opened up on the tough times she had while trying to care for her late husband Derek Draper while also dealing with her own health issues Kate Garraway has revealed the health issue that "worsened significantly" while she was caring for late husband Derek Draper. The political lobbyist died in January 2024 following a four year health battle after he contracted long Covid. Good Morning Britain host Kate, 58, was his primary carer, but she has candidly opened up on the health issues she also faced at the time. The presenter said at one point, her conditions made h er feel it was "not safe" for her or her family. She confessed that the stress of looking after her husband triggered her own health scares. And she admitted that it seemed as though surgery would be likely. Speaking to the Sun, Kate revealed: "The stress of fighting for Derek to get the support he needed along with the physical demands of being a primary carer 24 hours a day was such a strain that my body was feeling the effect. "And there were other signs too. Missed appointments. No time to rest. My autoimmune thyroid condition — neglected during Derek's illness — has now worsened significantly. Surgery now looks likely. It could have been avoided." She also explained how she had been so sleep deprived as the system tried to work out how to best look after Derek that she felt it was no longer safe. She claimed the situation wasn't safe for her, her kids or Derek. Kate went on to describe calling health services in desperation following three weeks of no support. She told them at the time she had refused to get off the phone until she was given an answer on how things were going to proceed. "In the end, the person on the other end of the phone, who was also clearly exhausted, told me, 'There is nothing I can do but — and this isn't official — you are not alone and what I always say to people is take him to A&E and leave him there, then they legally have to do something.' Exasperated, Kate wondered how it had come to this stage. "I didn't take him, I just couldn't, physically or morally," she said. Kate also admitted she knows she was lucky to have had family around her who were able to help. However, she knows some people were - and are - in worse situations. "Carers are the backbone of this country — but are being broken under the weight," she said. She then pleaded with Rachel Reeves not to forget the carers in her spending review. Last year, shortly after Derek's death, Kate praised their two children and the way the handled the heartbreaking situation. And she revealed the sweet message her daughter Darcey gave her dad during his struggles. Kate revealed how Darcey told Derek: "If, dad, you can't do this, it's okay. Don't worry about us." She confessed she too had had similar conversations with her husband.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Kate Garraway's 'tsunami of sadness' over heartbreaking habit that's stuck since husband Derek passed away
Kate Garraway, who looked after her husband Derek Draper during his battle with long COVID before his passing in January 2024, has opened up about her grief and urged Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves to support unpaid careers Kate Garraway has spoken about the overwhelming "tsunami of sadness" she feels, often waking in the middle of the night in a panic, fearing she may have forgotten to give her late husband Derek Draper his medicine. In a heartfelt article, the Good Morning Britain presenter reflected on the "joys and responsibilities" of being a career, following Derek's passing at the age of 56 in January 2024. Derek, a former political lobbyist, endured a lengthy battle with long COVID, during which Kate, now 58, took on the role of his primary carer. Kate, who has two children with Derek, previously stated in an interview that she held his hands until the very end. In her latest piece, the presenter shared that she is still mourning the loss of her husband, whom she married in 2005, the Mirror reports. She wrote: "Being a carer, its joys and its responsibilities, stays with you even after you have lost the person. I still wake up in the middle of the night panicking that I haven't given him his medicine, or that I have forgotten to move him every hour to prevent the painful contractions in his limbs. "The next second I realise he no longer needs that care. There is a moment of relief — that I did not let him down — before a tsunami of sadness hits." According to a recent report by the non-profit organisation Carers UK, nearly 60 percent of carers find it difficult to look after their own health. The study reveals that four in ten have cancelled medical appointments to prioritise the person they look after, and 1.2 million careers live in poverty - with 400,000 of them in deep poverty. Kate highlights these figures in her article for The Sun, noting that her own health suffered during Derek's battle with long COVID. In November 2022, she suffered a "heart event" on her way to work for Good Morning Britain and was rushed to hospital. She also revealed that she may need surgery for her autoimmune thyroid condition. Kate, who is originally from Oxfordshire, added: "My autoimmune thyroid condition - neglected during Derek's illness - has now worsened significantly. Surgery now looks likely. It could have been avoided. "During a three-week gap in care, while the system tried to work out which agency should give Derek the life-saving care he needed, I had no choice but to try to get through looking after Derek 24/7 completely alone." Katie pointed out that unpaid carers save the UK £184billion a year - more than the entire NHS budget. Despite this, the broadcaster argues that far more needs to be done to support them. She urged Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves to consider this when delivering today's spending review. In a direct message to the politician, Kate stated: "Put them at the heart of your plans. Invest in their health, give them real support and recognise the vital role they play."
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Doctor shares six symptoms of new Covid strain sweeping UK with key warning
A doctor has outlined the key signs we need to look out for in the new Covid variant known as 'Nimbus' as cases spike across the UK, with the strain also been found in 21 other countries worldwide A new strain of coronavirus is sweeping across the UK, and symptoms vary, but some are 'not typical' of former Covid cases. The new variant, known as NB.1.8.1, has been named 'Nimbus' and is causing a spike in cases across the nation. As of yesterday, 13 cases of the virus have been confirmed in the UK, prompting concern from health professionals. According to the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA), it is making up a "growing proportion" of Covid cases worldwide, as China and Hong Kong have seen a surge in cases, with the strain also identified in 21 other countries. The symptoms of 'Nimbus' can vary and are largely consistent with previous forms of the virus, but there are six key signs to look out for. Director & Superintendent Pharmacist, Prescription Doctor, Mohamed Imran Lakhi, exclusively tells the Mirror:"People commonly report a severe sore throat, persistent fatigue, mild cough, fever, muscle aches, and nasal congestion. "Some also experience digestive issues like nausea or diarrhoea, which isn't always typical with Covid variants." With a spike in cases of the 'Nimbus' strain across the UK, Dr Lakhi explains how we can best protect ourselves. He said: "While it seems to spread more easily, there's no strong evidence so far that it causes more severe illness than previous versions. Vaccines, especially those updated for Omicron strains, still offer good protection against serious disease. "It's important to stay up to date with your vaccinations and follow basic precautions like hand hygiene and wearing masks in crowded spaces, particularly as this variant circulates. "If you or someone you know develops these symptoms, especially the sore throat and fatigue, it's wise to get tested and isolate until you know more. Early detection helps protect you and those around you." The World Health Organisation (WHO) added the new Covid strain to its official watch list, amid fears it could be more contagious than earlier forms of the virus. However, there's currently no proof that it leads to more severe illness. According to WHO, the strain first appeared in January and by late April it was responsible for around 10.7% of global infections, up from just 2.5% a month earlier. Ireland has witnessed a sharp increase in cases linked to this variant in recent weeks. According to data from the Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HPSC), the proportion of sequenced Covid samples linked to NB.1.8.1 jumped from 3.7% to 27.3% in the last five weeks, reports Dublin Live.
