Regional Covid-19 restrictions ‘did not change behaviour' during 2020
Regional restrictions did not change people's behaviour during the coronavirus pandemic despite rising numbers in Scotland, a study indicates.
Researchers from the University of Aberdeen examined adherence to restrictions including social distancing, mask-wearing, staying at home and handwashing, and found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other.
The study, published in the US journal Translational Behavioral Medicine, looked at behaviour during the Covid-19 pandemic in Scotland from March to November 2020, with 1724 people interviewed at random to get a representative sample.
People did not alter behaviour to follow enhanced local restrictions during the pandemic, the study found, and the restrictions may have been more effective if based around factors other than just coronavirus cases according to new research.
The study compared people's behaviours before and after local restrictions, and compared behaviours of those living in areas with increased restrictions to those living in areas without.
People did not change their behaviour when restrictions were tightened, including social distancing and mask wearing, defying scientists' expectations, research showed.
It also found people in high or low restriction areas behaved no differently to each other, and examined 'intention and self-efficacy'.
Intention and self-efficacy related to keeping a 2.0 metre distance was assessed by asking: 'Do you intend to follow all the government instructions…' and 'How confident or not are you that you can follow the government instructions…' graded on a scale, according to the report.
The respondents answered questions about their behaviours from the past week, including if they had left home, had adhered to the social distancing rule, worn a mask in a shop or on public transport and if they washed their hands as soon as they got home.
Dr Chantal den Daas, senior lecturer in health psychology, in collaboration with the Covid Health and Adherence Research in Scotland (Charis) project, said the research 'can effectively influence public behaviour' in the future.
She said: 'When local restrictions were introduced in 2020 due to an increase in Covid-19 case numbers, we thought we would see a change in behaviour after they were implemented. But this was not what we found.
'It is really important to build an understanding of what could have been done differently and how we can effectively influence public behaviour in the future should we be faced with another public health crisis.
'This research provided insight on the type of information we should aim to collect in future pandemics, to see if we can find better measures to predict cases, examine the need for restrictions and the effect of any restrictions put in place.
'Future research in acute outbreaks should assess behaviour and beliefs about the virus, risk on an ongoing basis and identify the need for intervention even before cases rates start to go up.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
6 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
I still wake up in the night panicking I haven't given Derek his meds – stress of caring for him left me needing surgery
Kate tells us why it's vital Rachel Reeves puts carers at the heart of her plans, invests in their health, and gives them real support KATE GARRAWAY I still wake up in the night panicking I haven't given Derek his meds – stress of caring for him left me needing surgery CARING for someone you love is a tough, relentless and, very often, such a lonely task. But it is also a privilege that all carers embrace. 7 TV host turned carer Kate Garraway with husband Derek at their home in 2023 Credit: PA 7 Derek died in January 2024 aged 56 four years after contracting Covid Credit: ITV 7 Kate, above with her husband in 2008, says looking after him was one of the greatest honours of her life Credit: PA Looking after my husband Derek — who died in January 2024 aged 56, four years after being left seriously ill from Covid — was one of the greatest honours of my life and I wish I was still doing it today. The children and I were so grateful he had survived despite the terrible damage the virus had done to him, and that with the help of doctors, nurses and professional carers we had the chance to give him the best life possible. Being a carer, its joys and its responsibilities, stays with you even after you have lost the person. I still wake up in the middle of the night panicking that I haven't given him his medicine, or that I have forgotten to move him every hour to prevent the painful contractions in his limbs. The next second I realise he no longer needs that care. There is a moment of relief — that I did not let him down — before a tsunami of sadness hits. Caring takes over your whole life. You don't begrudge it, but you suffer because of it. A report by non-profit organisation Carers UK this week reveals that 58 per cent of carers struggle to look after their own health. Four in ten have cancelled medical appointments to prioritise the person they look after and 1.2million live in poverty, including 400,000 in deep poverty. Almost half of adults who have looked after a loved one have physical or mental problems as a result, with seven in ten living with long-term conditions afterwards. That works out as 10.7million people whose lives have been turned upside down and left with serious health problems. Emotional Kate Garraway opens up on spending first wedding anniversary without Derek Draper I was one of the lucky ones, with hugely caring family and friends and supportive employers, but the harsh reality is that my own health still suffered. One day in November 2022, I was heading to Good Morning Britain when I woke up with searing chest pain. I could barely move, but I forced myself into the car. On the way in, I threw up. By the time I arrived at the studio, something was clearly wrong. Dr Hilary told the producers to call an ambulance. Instead of going on air, I was in hospital, wired to machines, with doctors fearing a heart attack. Thankfully, it was not. It was what they described as a 'heart event'. The stress of fighting for Derek to get the support he needed along with the physical demands of being a primary carer 24 hours a day was such a strain that my body was feeling the effect. And there were other signs too. Missed appointments. No time to rest. My autoimmune thyroid condition — neglected during Derek's illness — has now worsened significantly. Surgery now looks likely. It could have been avoided. During a three-week gap in care, while the system tried to work out which agency should give Derek the life-saving care he needed, I had no choice but to try to get through looking after Derek 24/7 completely alone. How could the only answer be to abandon someone who couldn't move, couldn't safely be left alone — but was fully aware and trusted me — to God knows what, just to have a cry for help answered? By the end I was so sleep-deprived I was scared it was no longer safe — for me, for the children, let alone for Derek. In desperation I called health services again and this time refused to get off the phone until some answer was given. In the end, the person on the other end of the phone, who was also clearly exhausted, told me, 'There is nothing I can do but — and this isn't official — you are not alone and what I always say to people is take him to A&E and leave him there, then they legally have to do something.' I knew she meant well but how could we have come to this? How could the only answer be to abandon someone who couldn't move, couldn't safely be left alone — but was fully aware and trusted me — to God knows what, just to have a cry for help answered? 7 Kate sends a plea to Chancellor Rachel Reeves to not forget carers ahead of the spending review Credit: Rex 7 Carers are the backbone of this country — but are being broken under the weight, says Kate Credit: Shutterstock Editorial PLEASE HELP HELPERS By Grace Macaskill MILLIONS of people throughout the country are struggling under the weight of looking after loved ones. According to a new survey, almost half of carers have seen a decline in their own mental and physical health. Research by Carers UK also found that four in ten current or former carers – equivalent to 10.7million people – put the health of disabled, older or sick relatives before their own. This leads them to skip medical appointments, tests, scans or therapy because they are unable to get someone to look after the person they are caring for. Carers are also more likely to suffer health problems, with 70 per cent dealing with issues compared to 59 per cent of the general population, according to last year's GP Patient survey in England. Helen Walker, chief executive of Carers UK, said: 'Sadly, caring for someone often comes at a personal cost and carers still face significant inequalities. If you are caring for someone it's likely that you will experience poorer health, financial strain, challenges accessing employment and education opportunities and be at greater risk of loneliness and isolation. 'It can be a negative cycle for many carers who experience worsening physical or mental health and are unable to take a break to look after themselves. 'The impact of this can be long- lasting, but we know that change is possible – from the Government investing more in support for unpaid carers and the NHS having clear measures of help for carers, to rights at work and support within education.' I didn't take him, I just couldn't, physically or morally. Final straw I got through another day somehow until a family member took time off their work to come — and we got through. But others are not so lucky. And they are simply breaking and fearing even worse is to come. I have more friends than ever taking on caring roles. And my own mum is now caring full-time for my dad following a stroke, and they are both in their eighties. There are millions out there in far worse situations than I found myself in. Carers UK has raised serious concerns about the Government's proposed welfare changes, particularly reforms to Personal Independence Payment. If eligibility becomes stricter, many carers could lose vital financial support and their Carer's Allowance. These changes could affect up to 150,000 carers, with losses of more than £8,000 a year per household. For many, barely surviving, that would be the final straw. Carers are the backbone of this country — but are being broken under the weight. They are doing the work of a second NHS. Silently. Without pay. Without recognition. Every day, 12,000 more people become unpaid carers. And every day, 600 workers leave their jobs to care full-time. Britain depends on an army of unpaid carers who save the country £184billion a year — more than the entire NHS budget. But who is caring for them? This week is Carers Week and, just as the Chancellor prepares to give her spending review today, investment in the sector is at an all-time low. So my message to Rachel Reeves is: Please do not forget the carers. My message to Rachel Reeves is: Please do not forget the carers Put them at the heart of your plans. Invest in their health, give them real support and recognise the vital role they play. When you support carers, you take pressure off the NHS, you keep people out of hospital and you help get them home — where they want to be, where they belong. Carers are not asking for praise. They love what they do. They are just asking not to be forgotten. Not now, not again, and not when they are holding up the very fabric of our country with their bare hands. 7 Kate's autoimmune thyroid condition has now worsened significantly after being neglected during Derek's illness Credit: Refer to Caption 7 Kate and Derek pictured with their family Credit: Instagram
Daily Record
14 hours ago
- Daily Record
All you need to know about new Covid strain 'Nimbus' as doctors issue UK warning
The new variant, called NB.1.8.1, or 'Nimbus' spreads more easily than previous strains on the virus, spreading rapidly around the globe. Doctors have issued a warning for the UK over the new easily transmissible strain of Covid, called 'Nimubs', which has seen a surge of in the country. The new variant, also called NB.1.8.1, is making up a "growing proportion" of Covid cases worldwide, according to the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA). China and Hong Kong have seen a surge in cases as well as 21 other countries, and 13 cases have already been found in the UK, warned doctors. Symptoms of Nimbus are similar to previous variants, with a painful sore throat and even heartburn reported as key signs of the new strain. According to Dr Naveed Asif, GP at The London General Practice, the NB.1.8.1 variant has a distinctive symptom, a severe sore throat known as a "razor blade sensation". Common Covid symptoms like fever, muscle aches and congestion as well as redness in the back of the mouth and swollen neck glands are also listed symptoms of NB.1.8.1. "However, symptoms can vary widely so vigilance is key," Dr Asif told the Manchester Evening News. According to the NHS, Covid symptoms include a high temperature, a new continuous cough, a loss or change to sense of smell or taste, shortness of breath and feeling sick. Although classic Covid symptoms include a severe cough, sore throat and high fever, NB.1.8.1 has also been found to have gastrointestinal symptoms. Symptoms of the new variant include: Nausea Vomiting Diarrhoea Heartburn Bloating Constipation Abdominal pain The World Health Organization (WHO) has added the variant to its official watch list, suggesting that it is more transmissible than other strains of the virus. However, there isn't any evidence to indicate that it causes more serious illness than previous versions of Covid. Nimbus first appeared in January, and by late April it was responsible for around 10.7 per cent of global infections, up from just 2.5 per cent a month earlier. Recent weeks have also seen a spike of cases in Ireland. Data from the Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HPSC) shows that the proportion of sequenced Covid samples linked to NB.1.8.1 jumped from 3.7 per cent to 27.3 per cent in the last five weeks. The variant has been flagged in the UK, US and Australia, and has been linked to spikes in Covid cases in India, Hong Kong, Singapore, and Thailand. Dr Gayatri Amirthalingam, UKHSA Deputy Director, said: "NB.1.8.1 has been detected in small numbers in the UK to date, but international data suggests that it is growing as a proportion of all COVID-19 cases. "Based on the available information so far however, there is no evidence to suggest that this variant causes more severe disease than previous variants, or that the vaccines in current use will be less effective against it." 'Variants like this pop up when the virus mutates, which is normal for viruses, especially ones that spread widely,' explained Dr Chun Tang, GP at Pall Mall Medical. 'NB.1.8.1 was first picked up in early 2025 and has since been detected in several countries, including the UK, China and US. It's got some new mutations that scientists are keeping a close eye on.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Daily Record
15 hours ago
- Daily Record
What has caused the global spike in new Covid variant 'Nimbus' NB.1.8.1?
The new 'Nimbus' strain is the latest Covid variant, and cases have been confirmed in the UK. A new variant of Covid named NB.1.8.1 or 'Nimbus' is spreading like wildfire across the globe, with India the newest country to report a severe spike in cases. This new strain has also been found in Thailand, Indonesia and China, and the UK Health Security Agency recorded its first cases in the UK last week. NB.1.8.1 originated from the Omicron variant of the virus, and was first found back in January of this year. Cases have also been reported in states across the United States and Australia. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), the Nimbus variant made up around 10.7 per cent of global recorded sequences in April, a staggering increase from just 2.5 per cent in March. The new strain has been declared a "variant under monitoring" by WHO, meaning that it could change the behaviours of the virus. Nimbus has been found in 22 countries so far and presents some unusual new symptoms. Scientists have found that this new variant also spreads more easily than previous strains of Covid, which may explain the recent surge in cases. Dr Chun Tang, GP at UK private healthcare centre Pall Mall Medical, said: 'NB.1.8.1 isn't too different from the Omicron variant, but it does have some tweaks to its spike protein, which might make it spread a bit more easily or slip past some of our existing immunity. 'That said, early signs suggest it doesn't seem to cause more serious illness, but of course, we're still learning more about it.' Australian virologist Lara Herrero, of Griffith University, wrote in The Conversation last month: 'Using lab-based models, researchers found NB.1.8.1 had the strongest binding affinity to the human ACE2 receptor of several variants tested, suggesting it may infect cells more efficiently than earlier strains." WHO has stated that risk to the global public is low, and that existing Covid vaccines are considered effective in preventing severe cases of the virus. Most common symptoms of Nimbus are similar to that of previous Covid strains. They include a severe sore throat, fatigue, mild cough, fever, muscle aches and congestion. Some patients have also experienced gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea, diarrhoea, or even heartburn, reported The Independent. The full list of symptoms are; a high temperature or shivering (chills) – a high temperature means you feel hot to touch on your chest or back (you do not need to measure your temperature) a new, continuous cough – this means coughing a lot for more than an hour, or 3 or more coughing episodes in 24 hours a loss or change to your sense of smell or taste shortness of breath feeling tired or exhausted an aching body a headache a sore throat a blocked or runny nose loss of appetite diarrhoea feeling sick or being sick While Nimbus may be more easily transmissible between people, healthcare experts are stressing that there is no evidence that the new strain is more deadly or serious than previous variants. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
