Zarah Sultana: UK halting Israel trade talks is 'irrelevant'
Zarah Sultana, who remains suspended from Keir Starmer's party after voting to get rid of the two-child benefit cap, has said the decision to call off negotiations was part of Labour's 'mealy-mouthed, empty rhetoric' over Israel's assault on the enclave.
This week, Foreign Secretary David Lammy described Israel's actions as 'monstrous' and warned that a 'dark new phase in this conflict' had been reached.
He also described the Israeli government as 'extremists'.
READ MORE: Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu hits out at Keir Starmer and other allies
Lammy said the shift in the UK Government's position came in response to the blockade on aid to Gaza, Israel's devastating bombing of the territory and high-level leaders' public statements about ethnically cleansing the territory.
However, there has been no movement on arms sales, with the UK continuing to send parts for F-35 fighter jets to Israel, which have been used in Gaza.
One move Lammy did make was announcing the suspension of negotiations for a new free trade deal with Israel, while Israeli ambassador Tzipi Hotovely was summoned to the Foreign Office.
But Sultana (below) told the Sunday National the change in approach from Lammy is 'too late' as she ripped into a 'pathetic' response to the bombardment by the UK Government.
She said. 'These words [from Lammy] are 18 months too late and at the same time as delivering them at the despatch box, you are still continuing the supply of lethal fighter jets, you are still complicit in the destruction of Palestinian lives and you're still sending out spying surveillance flights.
(Image: PA) 'It's mealy-mouthed, empty rhetoric and it is not backed up by a single action.
'The halt in the 2030 trade deal is so far away in the future that it is irrelevant. People need the genocide to be stopped now. They need the starvation to end now, and we're being told about all these things in the future.
'He couldn't even expel the Israeli ambassador. It's pathetic.'
Just hours after Lammy said he condemned Israel's actions 'in the strongest possible terms', the UK Government sent a Shadow R1 spy plane from the Cyprus base RAF Akrotiri to monitor Gaza.
The RAF describes Shadow R1 planes as being capable of 'comprehensive intelligence gathering' that is 'particularly valuable to ground commanders'.
The UK Government said it will share information gathered from the flights with the Israeli military, but only if it was deemed relevant to securing the release of hostages held by Hamas within the Gaza Strip.
Despite Lammy announcing the suspension of around 30 arms sale licences to Israel back in September, analysis of Israeli import data has revealed UK firms have exported thousands of military items to Israel.
At a hearing in the High Court earlier this month, the UK Government defended its decision not to include parts for F-35 fighter jets in the suspension of licences.
Labour's lawyers have argued that the evidence does not support findings that a genocide has taken or is taking place in Gaza – despite the UK Government publicly insisting that any determination of genocide is for the courts and not them.
READ MORE: Kneecap's TRNSMT 2025 set would need major operation, police say
The UK Government is obliged to block export licences if there is a clear risk they will be used to breach international law.
The National also reported how Labour licensed exports of more military equipment to Israel in the final three months of 2024 than the Tories did for all of 2020 to 2023, according to figures from the UK Government and Campaign Against Arms Trade (CAAT).
Sultana raised this statistic in the House of Commons last week and asked Lammy how 'he sleeps at night', but the Foreign Secretary accused her of being 'keen on clickbait'.
Sultana told The National Lammy's response was an 'insult' to the more than 50,000 Palestinians who have been killed by Israel's assault on Gaza.
'These statistics are not social media headlines, they are official export data from the Government tied to weapons that are being directly sent from the UK being used in a genocide that is being investigated by the International Court of Justice,' she said.
'The Foreign Secretary brushing them off as clickbait isn't just dismissive and offensive, it is an insult to the tens of thousands of Palestinian lives that have been destroyed by the very weapons that this government is licensing.'
Sultana added: 'His response is incredibly beneath the office of Foreign Secretary. This is someone who is actively licensing arms exports who could stop a genocide and instead he tells a backbencher in his party who has had the whip suspended because she doesn't believe children should be in poverty that she is keen on clickbait.
'That says more about him than it says about me.'
The Coventry South MP also hit out at Health Secretary Wes Streeting who was heard to say her question to Lammy was 'cheap' in the Commons.
'I don't think calling out genocide is cheap. It is a duty,' she said.
The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
33 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Rachel Reeves to announce £86bn for science and technology in spending review
Regions will be handed up to £500 million with local leaders given powers to decide how investment is targeted in their communities, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) said. The overall package, which will be announced as Chancellor Rachel Reeves sets out departmental spending plans on June 11, is expected to be worth more than £22.5 billion-a-year by the end of the decade. DSIT said 'every corner of the country' would benefit as local leaders are given a say on how the money is spent on leveraging expertise specific to their communities. In Liverpool, which has a long history in biotech, funding will be used to speed up drug discovery and in South Wales, which has Britain's largest semiconductor cluster, on designing the microchips used to power mobile phones and electric cars. The Chancellor said: 'Britain is the home of science and technology. Through the Plan for Change, we are investing in Britain's renewal to create jobs, protect our security against foreign threats and make working families better off.' Science and Technology Secretary Peter Kyle said: 'Incredible and ambitious research goes on in every corner of our country, from Liverpool to Inverness, Swansea to Belfast, which is why empowering regions to harness local expertise and skills for all of our benefit is at the heart of this new funding – helping to deliver the economic growth at the centre of our Plan for Change.' Local leaders including North East Mayor Kim McGuiness and West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker welcomed the package, but research backers warned more is needed to secure Britain's reputation for Rottingen, chief executive of Wellcome, Britain's biggest non-governmental research funder, said: 'The Government rightly acknowledges that investing in science and technology is a key way to boost the economy. 'But while it's positive under the financial circumstances, a flat real-terms science budget, along with continuing barriers such as high visa costs for talented scientists and the university funding crisis, won't be enough for the UK to make the advances it needs to secure its reputation for science in an increasingly competitive world. 'The UK should be aiming to lead the G7 in research intensity, to bring about economic growth and the advances in health, science and technology that benefit us all. We look forward to seeing the full details at the spending review.' Meanwhile, the Institute of Physics called for a longer-term strategy for science, including a plan for teachers and other members of the skilled workforce needed to deliver advances. Tony McBride, director of policy and public affairs at the institute, said: 'It's good to see the Government recognise the power of science and innovation to transform lives and grow prosperity in every part of the UK. 'But to fully harness the transformational potential of research and innovation – wherever it takes place – we need a decade-long strategic plan for science. This must include a plan for the skilled workforce we need to deliver this vision, starting with teachers and addressing every educational stage, to underpin the industrial strategy. 'We hope that the Chancellor's statement on Wednesday will set out such a vision.' Universities UK said the Government had made a 'smart investment' and academia would put its 'shoulder to the wheel' behind the plans. Vivienne Stern, chief executive of the group representing 142 higher education providers in Britain, said: 'The UK has a real opportunity to sow the seeds of long-term growth, benefiting all parts of the UK – with universities spread right across the country working with industry and public sector bodies to turn discoveries into economic success. 'They stand ready to double down with government, building stronger links with sectors of the economy where we have real room to grow. 'This creates good jobs and attracts investment everywhere from Swansea to Aberdeen, from Barrow to Plymouth.'
South Wales Argus
33 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Rachel Reeves to announce £86bn for science and technology in spending review
Regions will be handed up to £500 million with local leaders given powers to decide how investment is targeted in their communities, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) said. The overall package, which will be announced as Chancellor Rachel Reeves sets out departmental spending plans on June 11, is expected to be worth more than £22.5 billion-a-year by the end of the decade. DSIT said 'every corner of the country' would benefit as local leaders are given a say on how the money is spent on leveraging expertise specific to their communities. In Liverpool, which has a long history in biotech, funding will be used to speed up drug discovery and in South Wales, which has Britain's largest semiconductor cluster, on designing the microchips used to power mobile phones and electric cars. The Chancellor said: 'Britain is the home of science and technology. Through the Plan for Change, we are investing in Britain's renewal to create jobs, protect our security against foreign threats and make working families better off.' Science and Technology Secretary Peter Kyle said: 'Incredible and ambitious research goes on in every corner of our country, from Liverpool to Inverness, Swansea to Belfast, which is why empowering regions to harness local expertise and skills for all of our benefit is at the heart of this new funding – helping to deliver the economic growth at the centre of our Plan for Change.' Local leaders including North East Mayor Kim McGuiness and West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker welcomed the package, but research backers warned more is needed to secure Britain's reputation for science. John-Arne Rottingen, chief executive of Wellcome, Britain's biggest non-governmental research funder, said: 'The Government rightly acknowledges that investing in science and technology is a key way to boost the economy. 'But while it's positive under the financial circumstances, a flat real-terms science budget, along with continuing barriers such as high visa costs for talented scientists and the university funding crisis, won't be enough for the UK to make the advances it needs to secure its reputation for science in an increasingly competitive world. 'The UK should be aiming to lead the G7 in research intensity, to bring about economic growth and the advances in health, science and technology that benefit us all. We look forward to seeing the full details at the spending review.' Meanwhile, the Institute of Physics called for a longer-term strategy for science, including a plan for teachers and other members of the skilled workforce needed to deliver advances. Tony McBride, director of policy and public affairs at the institute, said: 'It's good to see the Government recognise the power of science and innovation to transform lives and grow prosperity in every part of the UK. 'But to fully harness the transformational potential of research and innovation – wherever it takes place – we need a decade-long strategic plan for science. This must include a plan for the skilled workforce we need to deliver this vision, starting with teachers and addressing every educational stage, to underpin the industrial strategy. 'We hope that the Chancellor's statement on Wednesday will set out such a vision.' Universities UK said the Government had made a 'smart investment' and academia would put its 'shoulder to the wheel' behind the plans. Vivienne Stern, chief executive of the group representing 142 higher education providers in Britain, said: 'The UK has a real opportunity to sow the seeds of long-term growth, benefiting all parts of the UK – with universities spread right across the country working with industry and public sector bodies to turn discoveries into economic success. 'They stand ready to double down with government, building stronger links with sectors of the economy where we have real room to grow. 'This creates good jobs and attracts investment everywhere from Swansea to Aberdeen, from Barrow to Plymouth.'
South Wales Guardian
33 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Rachel Reeves to announce £86bn for science and technology in spending review
Regions will be handed up to £500 million with local leaders given powers to decide how investment is targeted in their communities, the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) said. The overall package, which will be announced as Chancellor Rachel Reeves sets out departmental spending plans on June 11, is expected to be worth more than £22.5 billion-a-year by the end of the decade. DSIT said 'every corner of the country' would benefit as local leaders are given a say on how the money is spent on leveraging expertise specific to their communities. In Liverpool, which has a long history in biotech, funding will be used to speed up drug discovery and in South Wales, which has Britain's largest semiconductor cluster, on designing the microchips used to power mobile phones and electric cars. The Chancellor said: 'Britain is the home of science and technology. Through the Plan for Change, we are investing in Britain's renewal to create jobs, protect our security against foreign threats and make working families better off.' Science and Technology Secretary Peter Kyle said: 'Incredible and ambitious research goes on in every corner of our country, from Liverpool to Inverness, Swansea to Belfast, which is why empowering regions to harness local expertise and skills for all of our benefit is at the heart of this new funding – helping to deliver the economic growth at the centre of our Plan for Change.' Local leaders including North East Mayor Kim McGuiness and West Midlands Mayor Richard Parker welcomed the package, but research backers warned more is needed to secure Britain's reputation for Rottingen, chief executive of Wellcome, Britain's biggest non-governmental research funder, said: 'The Government rightly acknowledges that investing in science and technology is a key way to boost the economy. 'But while it's positive under the financial circumstances, a flat real-terms science budget, along with continuing barriers such as high visa costs for talented scientists and the university funding crisis, won't be enough for the UK to make the advances it needs to secure its reputation for science in an increasingly competitive world. 'The UK should be aiming to lead the G7 in research intensity, to bring about economic growth and the advances in health, science and technology that benefit us all. We look forward to seeing the full details at the spending review.' Meanwhile, the Institute of Physics called for a longer-term strategy for science, including a plan for teachers and other members of the skilled workforce needed to deliver advances. Tony McBride, director of policy and public affairs at the institute, said: 'It's good to see the Government recognise the power of science and innovation to transform lives and grow prosperity in every part of the UK. 'But to fully harness the transformational potential of research and innovation – wherever it takes place – we need a decade-long strategic plan for science. This must include a plan for the skilled workforce we need to deliver this vision, starting with teachers and addressing every educational stage, to underpin the industrial strategy. 'We hope that the Chancellor's statement on Wednesday will set out such a vision.' Universities UK said the Government had made a 'smart investment' and academia would put its 'shoulder to the wheel' behind the plans. Vivienne Stern, chief executive of the group representing 142 higher education providers in Britain, said: 'The UK has a real opportunity to sow the seeds of long-term growth, benefiting all parts of the UK – with universities spread right across the country working with industry and public sector bodies to turn discoveries into economic success. 'They stand ready to double down with government, building stronger links with sectors of the economy where we have real room to grow. 'This creates good jobs and attracts investment everywhere from Swansea to Aberdeen, from Barrow to Plymouth.'
