Senate parliamentarian's role under scrutiny over as Republicans call for her firing over the ‘Big, Beautiful Bill'
Republicans are calling for the removal of Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough after she ruled that some of the measures outlined in President Donald Trump 's signature 'Big, Beautiful Bill' could not be included on budgetary grounds.
MacDonough blocked several measures in the legislation that would have provided tens of billions of dollars in savings, including one that would have shut down state strategies for obtaining federal Medicaid funding and another that would have limited student loan repayment options.
MacDonough is the first woman to hold the office since its founding in 1935. The parliamentarian is primarily responsible for advising the upper chamber of Congress on adherence to the law, with the House having its own parliamentarian to perform the same function.
They are also charged with providing information to members of Congress and their staff on a strictly nonpartisan and confidential basis.
Her actions leave lawmakers scrambling to make cost-cutting compromises over the weekend ahead of their July 4 deadline.
Alabama Senator Tommy Tuberville raged on X on Thursday evening: 'President Trump's landslide victory was a MANDATE from 77 million Americans. The One Big Beautiful Bill delivers on that mandate. The Parliamentarian is trying to UNDERMINE the President's mandate and should be fired.'
Florida Rep. Greg Steube called MacDonough 'an unelected swamp bureaucrat,' complaining that she is not accountable to voters.
'It is time for our elected leaders to take back control,' he continued. ' JD Vance should overrule the Parliamentarian and let the will of the people, not some staffer hiding behind Senate procedure, determine the future of this country.'
Appearing on Newsmax's Chris Salcedo Show, Kentucky Senator Rand Paul fumed that MacDonough's authority to determine which provisions in the legislation are matters of policy or budget allowed her excessive discretion and would be best left up to lawmakers.
'I think most Americans would be perplexed to know why an unelected person is making these decisions,' he said. 'These are profound, big decisions.'
Summarizing his argument, Paul said: 'Essentially, it's this. When we have reconciliation, there's a question: Is the predominant effect of the portion of the legislation about the budget, or is it about policy? But a lot of things are a tough call, and they can be about both policy and budget, as I think this is.
'This person who has not been elected by anybody can't be unelected, can't be removed from office, and for which the public has no way of expressing displeasure is making these decisions.
'It's a terrible situation, and it's a bizarre sort of situation that we are all beholden. No one has voted for this person.'
Unlike Tuberville and Steube, Paul was careful to make clear he did not object to MacDonough personally.
MacDonough initially worked in the Senate library, left to earn a law degree from Vermont Law School, and then advanced through the Justice Department before being appointed to her present position by then-Speaker Harry Reid in 2012. She was retained by Republican Mitch McConnell when he became majority leader in 2015.
She steered the Senate through Trump's first and historic second impeachment trials during his first term and had her office ransacked by Capitol rioters on January 6 2021.
But she has also frustrated Democratic ambitions, notably blocking Joe Biden 's administration from including a minimum wage hike in his Covid-19 relief bill in the pandemic and dropping immigration provisions from the party's climate legislation.
The House and Senate parliamentarians make recommendations, but they can be overruled; the final decision lies with the presiding officer overseeing the proceedings.
Michael Thorning, director of structural democracy at the Bipartisan Policy Center, told the Associated Press he believed Republicans are unlikely to challenge MacDonough and that both sides regard her as 'very much an honest broker.'
'The Senate relies on her,' he said. 'Sometimes, those decisions cut your way, and sometimes, they don't. I also think members recognize that once you start treating the parliamentarian's advice as just something that could be easily dismissed, then the rules start to matter less.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Pope Leo XIV appeals for unity within the Catholic Church in Holy Year messages to priests
Pope Leo XIV doubled down on Friday on his appeal for unity in the polarized Catholic Church, urging priests to act in communion with their superiors and be models of reconciliation in a world driven by conflicts and divisions. Leo appealed for unity in a triptych of messages to priests who are celebrating a special Holy Year week in Rome dedicated to clergy. He hosted a special meeting on Thursday afternoon, celebrated an ordination Mass on Friday morning and also delivered a written message to priests around the world. During the Mass in St. Peter's Basilica, Leo ordained 32 new priests and recalled his appeal for unity during his installation Mass right after his May 8 election. 'Today, I share this desire once more with all of you,' he said. He quoted St. Augustine – the inspiration of his Augustinian religious order – in repeating the words he said on the night of his election: 'For you I am a bishop, with you I am a Christian.' During the meetings that preceded the conclave that elected the first American pope in history, cardinals made clear their hope that the next pontiff would heal some of the divisions within the church that deepened during the late Pope Francis' radical 12-year pontificate. Francis' progressive social justice priorities, his informal style, liturgical looseness and disdain for the capitalist economic system often alienated conservatives, particularly in Leo's native United States, who begged for a new pope who could pacify divisions. Leo's consistent reference to unity in the church suggests he has heard those appeals and is working to respond. In a message to priests around the world Friday, Leo offered encouragement in his appeal for unity, not a browbeating as Francis often gave priests. 'In a world marked by growing tensions, even within families and ecclesial communities, priests are called to promote reconciliation and foster communion,' Leo said. He added that priests should not be afraid of their own weaknesses. 'The Lord does not look for perfect priests, but for humble hearts that are open to conversion and prepared to love others as he himself loved us,' he said. He gave a similar message Thursday to thousands of priests who gathered in a Vatican-area auditorium for a Jubilee rally that ended with Leo giving English-language shoutouts to priests from various parts of the world, including his native Chicago. In the encounter, Leo acknowledged the 'crisis' in priestly vocations, which have been falling consistently in traditionally Christian parts of the world for years even as the overall global Catholic population grows. According to Vatican statistics, there were 407,730 priests globally at the end of 2022, down 142 from the previous year. Europe saw the greatest decline, losing 2,745 priests — a figure that was only compensated for globally by the addition of 1,676 priests in Africa and 1,160 in Asia. 'Thank you for who you are, and remind everyone that it's beautiful to be a priest,' he said. 'We aren't perfect, but we are friends of Christ … and that's enough.' ___ Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP's collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Moment Pope Leo is hit on the head with a flag thrown from worshipers who then charge towards him as he begs them to stay calm in the Vatican
This is the tense moment an object is thrown at Pope Leo XIV from a huge crowd that tries to charge him on World Drugs Day. Swarms of worshippers were pressed against the railing, desperately trying to reach out to the Catholic leader. One overly-enthusiastic faithful threw a red and yellow object - believed to be representing the football club AS Roma - and knocked the pontiff's skullcap. It is believed that the newly appointed pope is a fan of AS Roma, which many felt was confirmed last month after he allegedly responded 'Forza Roma' to a Giallorossi supporter. As he rearranges his skullcap, a huge swell from the crowd breaks the railings and they suddenly surge forward, trying to grab at Pope Leo's arms. The pope's security team immediately rushed towards the barrier and tried to restore order as the first US leader of the global Catholic Church tries to step back for his safety. He pleads with the crowd to calm down, gesturing with his hands to the group to step back. Once the eager crowd are behind the barriers again, Pope Leo goes forward to shake hands with worshippers once more, even blessing a baby. The pontiff spoke with the crowd yesterday about the ramifications of substance abuse at the International Day against Drug Abuse and Illicit Trafficking. Established by the United Nations, the day was intended to raise awareness of the impacts of substance abuse in society and to work towards an end of drug addiction through campaigns, educational events and community schemes. The gathering at San Damaso square was attended by Italian government officials, recovering drug addicts as well as people who help them. Pope Leo called on governments to not criminalise the poor and instead those those who make businesses out of addiction. He said: 'Our fight is against those who make their immense business out of drugs and every other addiction, think of alcohol or gambling. 'There are huge concentrations of interest and extensive criminal organizations that states have a duty to dismantle.' 'Too often, in the name of security, war is waged against the poor, filling prisons with those who are merely the final link in a chain of death. 'Those who hold the chain in their hands instead manage to gain influence and impunity. Pope Leo pleads with the crowd to calm down, gesturing with his hands to the group to step back The pontiff spoke with the crowd yesterday about the ramifications of substance abuse at the International Day against Drug Abuse and Illicit Trafficking 'Too often, in the name of security, war is waged against the poor, filling prisons with those who are merely the final link in a chain of death,' Pope Leo told crowds in San Damaso 'Our cities must not be freed of the marginalised, but of marginalisation. They must be cleared not of the desperate, but of desperation.' Pope Leo was elected as the latest pontiff of the Catholic Church last month after only two days of conclave. He had spent many years before as head of the Augustinian seminary in Trujillo, Peru, where he had moved to as a missionary in 1985 and was known as Robert Prevost. Seen as a man who has similar attitudes on reform to the late Pope Francis, many of Pope Leo's initial messages have been one of peace. However it has been widely reported that along side his religious duties, he is an avid sports fan. Father Joseph Farrell, the Vicar General of the Augustinians, has spoken about how Pope Leo play tennis frequently, while it has been said that the Chicago-native is fan of the White Sox baseball team in MLB. 'He's a regular tennis player. He would come up and play on our grounds once a week at least,' Father Farrell said. 'He is [AS] Roma all the way,' he added. The club have also shared a statement on X saying: 'AS Roma joins in rejoicing with Rome and the world following the election of Pope Leo XIV, and wishes him all the very best for his papacy.'
Daily Mail
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The '100% communist' set to become New York's new mayor: How hard left poster boy Zohran Mamdani, 33, plans to tax the rich and make bus rides free after shock NYC primary victory
When he announced his run for Mayor of New York City back in October, Zohran Mamdani was a state lawmaker unknown to most of the Big Apple's residents. On Tuesday evening, the 33-year-old marked his stunning political ascension when he declared victory in the Democratic primary from a Queens rooftop bar, beating former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo. While the race won't be decided until November, the former rapper and self-described socialist appears well on his way to becoming the city's first Muslim and Indian American mayor - and its youngest in generations. Mamdani's stunning primary victory truly put the cat among the pigeons on both sides of the aisle. Donald Trump branded him a '100 per cent Communist lunatic' - a comment to which Mamdani duly retorted. 'You know, this is not the first time that President Trump is going to comment on myself. 'We have won because New Yorkers have stood up for a city that they can afford... And it is where the mayor will use their power to reject Donald Trump's fascism.' Meanwhile, the Democrats must face up to Mamdani's popularity following his win over establishment-backed - and scandal-blighted - Cuomo. Critics have said the Big Apple would slide back into the type of permissive lawlessness that scarred the city during the COVID crisis under Mamdani's hard-left, inexperienced hand. But Mamdani has positioned himself as a man who understands and cares about solving the economic hardships many in New York face and says his relative political inexperience means he has not been mired in corruption or influenced by the rich. He also claims that, as a progressive, Muslim immigrant 'who actually fights for the things I believe in', he is a Republican's worst nightmare. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) attends the 2025 National Puerto Rican Day Parade in NYC with Zohran Mamdani Upbringing, background and family Mamdani was born in Kampala, Uganda, to Indian parents and became an American citizen in 2018, shortly after graduating from university. He lived briefly with his family in Cape Town, South Africa, before moving to New York City when he was seven. Mamdani's mother, Mira Nair, is an award-winning filmmaker whose credits include Monsoon Wedding, The Namesake and Mississippi Masala. His father, Mahmood Mamdani, is an anthropology professor at Columbia University. Mamdani attended the Bronx High School of Science, where he co-founded the public school's first cricket team, according to his legislative biography. He graduated in 2014 from Bowdoin College in Maine, where he earned a degree in Africana studies and co-founded his college's Students for Justice in Palestine chapter. After university, he worked as a foreclosure prevention counsellor in Queens, helping residents avoid eviction. He credits this job with inspiring him to run for public office. Mamdani also had a notable side hustle in the local hip-hop scene, rapping under the moniker Young Cardamom and later Mr Cardamom. During his first run for state lawmaker, Mamdani gave a nod to his brief foray into music, describing himself as a 'B-list rapper'. 'Nani', a song he made in 2019 to honour his grandmother, even found new life – and a vastly wider audience – as his mayoral campaign gained momentum. His critics, meanwhile, have seized on lyrics from 'Salaam', his 2017 ode to being Muslim in New York, to argue his views are too extreme for New Yorkers. Earlier this year, Mamdani married Rama Duwaji, a Syrian American artist, after meeting her on dating app Hinge. Duwaji is ethnically Syrian but was born and raised in Texas. She is a notable artist who primarily produces black and white artworks that explore cultural themes in the Arab world. 'Using drawn portraiture and movement, Rama examines the nuances of sisterhood and communal experiences,' her professional website reads. Like her husband, she is a staunch advocate for Palestinian statehood and has accused Israel of committing war crimes and genocide in Gaza - claims Israel refutes. Speaking to outlet YUNG earlier this year as her husband launched his mayoral campaign, Duwaji said: 'I'm not going to lie, things are dark right now in NYC. I worry for my friends and family, and things feel completely out of my hands. 'With so many people being pushed out and silenced by fear, all I can do is use my voice to speak out about what's happening in the US and Palestine and Syria as much as I can.' Move into politics, values Mamdani cut his teeth in local politics working on campaigns for Democratic candidates in Queens and Brooklyn. He was first elected to the New York Assembly in 2020, knocking off a longtime Democratic incumbent for a Queens district covering Astoria and surrounding neighbourhoods. He has handily won re-election twice. The Democratic Socialist's most notable legislative accomplishment has been pushing through a pilot programme that made a handful of city buses free for a year. He has also proposed legislation banning non-profits from 'engaging in unauthorised support of Israeli settlement activity'. Mamdani's opponents, particularly Cuomo, have dismissed him as woefully unprepared for managing the complexities of running America's largest city. But Mamdani has framed his relative inexperience as a potential asset, saying in a mayoral debate he's 'proud' he doesn't have Cuomo's 'experience of corruption, scandal and disgrace'. Mamdani's policy focus centres around addressing the cost of living and wealth inequality, stemming from his experiences working in Queen's as a foreclosure avoidance counsellor. He says he wants to raise taxes on the top one per cent of New York earners and make a number of city services free, including childcare and buses. To fund his vision, he hopes to procure $10 billion in new revenue through higher taxes on businesses and the wealthiest individuals. He also has plans to invest $70 billion in publicly subsidised housing and to open up public land for housing development. Mamdani's site says: 'We need significantly more affordable housing. But for decades, the City has relied almost entirely on changes to the zoning code to invite and shape private development. But other policies have invited harsh criticism, particularly from right-wing commentators, such as calls to defund the NYPD and the desire to spend $65 million in taxpayer funds for a transgender 'gender-affirming care' facility if elected. $57 million would be handed out to public hospitals, community clinics, federal health centres and nonprofits, $8 million would expand services. His campaign site says his administration would form its own Office of LGBTQIA+ Affairs. During his campaign, the Democratic candidate rolled back earlier vows to defund the police, saying instead that he would 'work with the police because I believe the police have a critical role to play in creating public safety'. Mamdani's pro-Palestinian stance has sparked outrage amongst the Jewish communities, which make up a large portion of the city and constitute the largest population of Jewish people outside of Israel. Mamdani has defended his use of the term 'genocide' to describe Israeli military actions in Gaza, while also saying that he would 'protect Jewish New Yorkers' from anti-Semitism. Mayoral campaign Mamdani has used buzzy campaign videos – many with winking references to Bollywood and his Indian heritage – to help make inroads with voters outside his slice of Queens. He also made a point of connecting with the voters in what his supporters said was a 'joyous' ground game - a move that separated him from Cuomo who rarely put out a public schedule, chafed at questions from reporters and skipped most candidate forums. On New Year's Day, Mamdani took part in the annual polar plunge into the chilly waters off Coney Island in a full dress suit to break down his plan to 'freeze' rents. As the race was entering the final stretch, Mamdani walked the length of Manhattan, documenting the roughly 13-mile (21-kilometre) trip by posting photos and videos of his interactions along the way. In TikTok videos, he's even appealed to voters of colour by speaking in Spanish, Bangla and other languages. Mamdani has offered a more optimistic vision, in contrast to candidates like Cuomo, who have largely focused on crime and law-and-order issues despite being beset by their own scandals. His campaign has been packed with big promises aimed at lowering the cost of living for everyday New Yorkers – from free childcare, free buses, a rent freeze for people living in rent-regulated apartments, and new affordable housing – much of it by raising taxes on the wealthy. The big promises have, unsurprisingly, endeared him to the Democratic Party's liberal wing. Mamdani secured endorsements from two of the country's foremost progressives: US Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, and Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont. But Mamdani's outspoken support for Palestinian causes was a point of tension in the mayor's race, as Cuomo and other opponents sought to label his defiant criticism of Israel as antisemitic. The Shia Muslim has called Israel's military campaign in Gaza a 'genocide' and said the country should exist as 'a state with equal rights', rather than a 'Jewish state'. That message has resonated among pro-Palestinian residents, including the city's roughly 800,000 adherents of Islam – the largest Muslim community in the country. During an interview on CBS's The Late Show on the eve of the election, host Stephen Colbert asked Mamdani if he believed the state of Israel had the right to exist. He responded: 'Yes, like all nations, I believe it has a right to exist – and a responsibility also to uphold international law.' Mamdani's refusal to condemn calls to 'globalise the intifada' on a podcast – a common chant at pro-Palestinian protests – drew recriminations from Jewish groups who accused him of supporting a call to kill the Jews. In his victory speech on Tuesday, he pledged to work closely with those who don't share his views on controversial issues. 'While I will not abandon my beliefs or my commitments, grounded in a demand for equality, for humanity, for all those who walk this earth, you have my word to reach further, to understand the perspectives of those with whom I disagree, and to wrestle deeply with those disagreements,' Mamdani said.
