Vietnam Jails 23 People Over Rare Earths Exploitation
A Vietnamese court on Wednesday jailed 23 officials and business people over the illegal exploitation and export of rare earths.
The trial comes after the US Geological Survey (USGS) this year significantly revised down its estimate of rare earth deposits in Vietnam, which it once considered the world's second largest.
The nine-day trial in Hanoi saw verdicts handed down to 27 defendants, including former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment Nguyen Linh Ngoc, who was given three years in jail for "violating state regulations causing wastefulness".
Others were given a range of prison sentences -- with 16 years being the highest -- for a number of offences, including violation of regulations on natural resources exploitation and causing environmental pollution.
Four people were given suspended sentences.
According to the court, the case concerning the exploitation, trade and export of mineral resources was "especially serious".
The court said that a firm called Thai Duong Company was unlawfully granted a mining licence for rare earth exploitation in Yen Phu mine in northern mountainous Yen Bai province between 2019 and 2023.
Defendants involved -- including environment officials as well as chief accountants and executives at various companies -- sold the rare earths and iron ore from the mine for close to $30 million, much of it to China.
USGS slashed this year its estimate of Vietnam's rare earth reserves from an estimated 22 million tons to 3.5 million, threatening its ambitions to compete with Beijing in a sector crucial to high-tech devices.
The revision meant the country dropped from the world's second largest reserve holder to the sixth, behind China, Brazil, India, Australia and Russia.
USGS describes mineral reserves data as "dynamic".
Reserves may be reduced as ore is mined or the feasibility of extraction diminishes, or they may continue to increase as additional deposits are developed, USGS says.
Rare earths are a group of 17 heavy metals that are abundant in the Earth's crust across the globe.
But mining the metals requires heavy chemical use that results in huge amounts of toxic waste and has caused several environmental disasters, making many countries wary of shouldering the heavy financial costs for production.
Each of the rare earths is used in industry and found in a variety of everyday and high-tech devices, from light bulbs to guided missiles.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
DW
28-05-2025
- DW
Is Vietnam courting Trump family with luxury golf course? – DW – 05/28/2025
A luxury golf resort owned by US President Donald Trump's family has swiftly received preferential treatment from Hanoi. The move comes as Vietnam faces high tariffs from the Trump administration. Ground was broken on May 21 for a $1.5 billion luxury golf resort in northern Vietnam owned by US President Donald Trump's family business. Vietnamese Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh and Eric Trump, executive vice president of the Trump Organization, presided over the ceremony. Days later, Eric Trump traveled to Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam's economic powerhouse, to finalize an agreement for a luxury hotel development in an upscale district of the rapidly expanding city. Reports indicate that the Vietnamese government expedited approvals and potentially violated domestic regulations to favor the Trump Organization. The deals come as Vietnam faces a 46% tariff threatened by the Trump administration on April 2. Although these punitive "reciprocal tariffs" have been postponed until July, Vietnam remains under pressure, especially considering its substantial $123 billion trade surplus with the United States. Vietnam ranks among the most trade-dependent countries globally, with exports to the US alone accounting for approximately 30% of its GDP, according to official data. "Hanoi understands that for the Trump Administration, what is public is private, and the best way to curry favor is to do deals with the Trump family," Zachary Abuza, a professor at the National War College in Washington, told DW. Relations with Vietnam were positive in the early years of Trump's first term. Former Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc was one of the first world leaders to meet Trump at the White House in 2017, and Hanoi was later chosen to host the high-profile but unsuccessful summit between Trump and North Korea's Kim Jong Un. However, Trump's stance shifted drastically in 2019 when he accused Vietnam of being the "worst abuser" in trade relations with the US, launching investigations into alleged unfair practices. These measures were only reversed after President Joe Biden took office. Eric Trump and Vietnamese officials attend the groundbreaking ceremony for the Trump International Hung Yen Image: dpa/picture alliance Vietnam fast-tracks Trump's luxury golf resort Although officially a private venture, the Vietnamese government significantly facilitated the Trump Organization's golf resort plans. In mid-March, Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh met Charles James Boyd Bowman, head of the Trump Organization's projects in Vietnam, and promised to "conduct a thorough review to fast-track the project." He called on the Trump Organisation to "position Vietnam as a business base and expand its investment footprint in the country," according to Vietnamese media reports. Vietnam has indeed delivered on its promise, achieving record-breaking speed for regulatory approval, Abuza noted. Typically, projects of this scale take years; this one reached groundbreaking within three months of initial filings. In March, Hanoi also gave permission for SpaceX, owned by Elon Musk, Trump's efficiency tsar, to launch its Starlink satellite internet service on a trial basis. Earlier this week, the New York Times newspaper revealed a letter from Vietnamese officials that explicitly stated that the project required support from senior members of the Vietnamese government because it was "receiving special attention from the Trump administration and President Donald Trump personally." According to the New York Times' report, the Vietnamese government has "ignored its own laws" by granting concessions to the Trump Organization that are "more generous than what even the most connected locals receive." Moreover, the entire project runs counter to the housing master plan of Hung Yen province, where it is located, and potentially the state's environmental and safety regulations. According to the aforementioned letter by Vietnamese government officials, the groundbreaking event was also brought forward to avoid "missing the window to capitalize on the support of the Donald Trump administration." Vietnam's strategic hedging The initial agreement for the golf course was signed last September, two months before Trump won the US presidential elections. "Although the specifics leading up to the deal are not known, one plausible theory is that a real estate project of this scale could not have proceeded without the backing of the Vietnamese government," Hoang Thi Ha, a senior fellow at the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore, wrote last month in an article for the institute's Fulcrum analysis website . She added that state backing "could have been a way for Vietnam to hedge its interests with Trump even before the US presidential election outcome was known." Moreover, the golf resort's location is significant. Hung Yen is just outside Hanoi and is the home province of To Lam, the communist party's general secretary. In early 2024, the incumbent and powerful general secretary of the Vietnamese Communist Party, Nguyen Phu Trong, passed away. In his place, To Lam, previously the public security minister and Trong's enforcer, quickly consolidated power. Lam became state president and then party chief, breaking the separation of powers norm of Vietnamese politics and leading some commentators to wonder whether he had dictatorial plans. He later relinquished the presidency. Since last year, To Lam has purged various ministries and appointed officials or personal friends from Hung Yen province in their place. Business and politics "There's little doubt that Hanoi has rolled out the red carpet for Trump-affiliated businesses in recent months," Khac Giang Nguyen, a visiting fellow at the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute, told DW. "It's a calculated, transactional move, with hopes that favourable treatment for Trump's business interests might buy some goodwill in Washington amid the ongoing trade negotiations," he added. The White House maintains that President Trump's trade discussions are entirely separate from his family's business dealings. Vietnam has actively sought to mitigate tariff threats, pledging earlier to reduce all duties on US imports and increase purchases of American goods. Khac Giang Nguyen said Hanoi's dealings with the Trump Organization reflect a strategic balancing act designed to navigate complex political and economic pressures. However, the analyst said this is not a "sustainable strategy," and that in the long run, "Vietnam's real test will be finding a stable way to balance the competing demands of Washington and Beijing, rather than relying on quick fixes." US-China tensions test ties between ASEAN members To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Edited by: Wesley Rahn
Int'l Business Times
26-05-2025
- Int'l Business Times
'Just Joking': Macron Denies Dispute With Wife, Blames Disinformation
French President Emmanuel Macron denied Monday having a domestic dispute with his wife Brigitte after a video appeared to show her shoving his face away when they touched down for a visit to Vietnam, blaming disinformation campaigns for trying to put false meaning on the footage. The Elysee had been hoping that the visit to Vietnam would showcase France's reach into the Indo-Pacific, but it has been shadowed by the incident which occurred as the doors of the presidential plane swung open after landing in Hanoi Sunday. This is the third time this month that Macron has been the subject of viral video footage at a time when France says it is being targeted by repeated disinformation attacks as Russia steps up attacks on Ukraine. It was falsely claimed Macron took cocaine on a trip to Kyiv alongside British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and images also emerged purporting to show Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan dominate the French leader in a handshake. Brigitte sticks out both her hands and gives her husband's face a shove, according to footage shot by the Associated Press news agency. The French president appears startled but quickly recovers and turns to wave through the open door. But with most of her body hidden by the aircraft, it is impossible to see his wife's facial expression or body language. "My wife and I were squabbling, we were rather joking, and I was taken by surprise," he said. Now it's "become a kind of planetary catastrophe, and some are even coming up with theories," Macron told reporters. Macron testily referred to the other incidents, including the images shot on a train to Kyiv where some accounts falsely claimed he shared cocaine with Merz and Starmer. But the object Macron removed from the table when the media entered was a tissue. Erdogan, meanwhile, was filmed holding the president's finger at a summit. "For three weeks... there are people who have watched videos and think I shared a bag of cocaine, that I had a fight with the Turkish president, and that now I'm having a domestic dispute with my wife," said Macron. "None of these are true," he said. "Everyone needs to calm down," he added. After the incident in Hanoi, the couple proceeded down the staircase for the official welcome by Vietnamese officials, though Brigitte Macron did not take her husband's arm when he offered it. The video circulated rapidly online, promoted particularly by accounts that are habitually hostile to the French leader. Macron's office initially denied the authenticity of the images, before they were confirmed as genuine. A close associate of the president later described the incident as a couple's harmless "squabble". Referring to the past incidents, Macron said: "In these three videos I took a tissue, shook someone's hand and just joked with my wife, as we do quite often. Nothing more." "We have loads of accounts, anonymous or not, whose frustrations are going to their heads, including news commentators who said this morning that I have the diplomacy of a beaten man," he added. He emphasised that all three videos were "completely authentic" but the meanings attached to them were not. Vietnam is the first stop on Macron's almost week-long tour of Southeast Asia where he will pitch France as a reliable alternative to the United States and China. He will also visit Indonesia and Singapore. The relationship between Macron, 47, and his 72-year-old wife has long been a subject of fascination at home and abroad. She was a drama teacher and he a pupil when they met at a private school in their hometown of Amiens in northeast France. A mother of three children, Brigitte divorced her husband and began a relationship with Macron while he was in his late teens. A high-profile first lady, she has taken legal action to counter false claims on social media about her gender. The incident took place just before the couple emerged from the plane AFP Macron had an air of exasperation AFP Grim day: France's President Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte Macron at a wreath-laying ceremony in Hanoi Monday AFP
Int'l Business Times
26-05-2025
- Int'l Business Times
France's Macron In Vietnam To Offer Third Way Between US, China
France's Emmanuel Macron will hold talks Monday in Vietnam at the start of his Southeast Asia tour, an opportunity to test his "Indo-Pacific strategy" in a region caught in the middle of the confrontation between the United States and China. The French president arrived in Hanoi late Sunday, the first stop of a six-day trip that will also take in Indonesia and Singapore. After paying tribute at a Hanoi war memorial to those who fought against French colonial occupation, Macron has a day of talks ahead. The president will meet his counterpart Luong Cuong before lunch with Communist Party General Secretary To Lam at the capital's star attraction, the Temple of Literature. Lam is considered the most powerful leader in Vietnam, a one-party state which tolerates no dissent and moves quickly to suppress any criticism. Ahead of Macron's first official visit to the country, Human Rights Watch pressed him to voice concerns about "the Vietnamese government's worsening rights record". Vietnam has more than 170 political prisoners who have been charged and convicted under "draconian laws" that criminalise free expression and peaceful activism for human rights and democracy, HRW said. A public appeal would be out of character for the French president, who regularly says he prefers to raise sensitive issues behind closed doors. Macron will focus attention on strengthening "cooperation in strategic sectors such as energy, transport and defence" while in Hanoi, according to an aide. The French president also hopes to sell to Hanoi his offer of a "third way" between Washington and Beijing. "Vietnam is really on the front line of all the tensions that are growing in the South China Sea," a senior French diplomatic official told AFP. Hanoi shares Washington's concerns about Beijing's increasing assertiveness in the contested South China Sea, but it also has close economic ties with China. Vietnam has also been threatened with a hefty 46 percent tariff by US President Donald Trump as part of his global trade blitz. Macron's "Indo-Pacific strategy" -- which proposes a third way to the countries of the region -- has regained relevance due to Trump's trade war, according to the aide. He said the president is "defending the idea of international trade rules, we don't want a jungle where the law of the strongest prevails". Vietnam has been careful to follow its own balancing act between China and the United States. It has adopted a "bamboo diplomacy" approach of seeking strength through flexibility, or looking to stay on good terms with the world's major powers. Hanoi is the first stop on Emmanuel Macron's six-day regional tour, which will also take in Indonesia and Singapore AFP
