NYC Mayor Adams defends involuntary removal of mentally ill people to hospitals
Mayor Adams on Monday defended involuntary removals of mentally ill people to hospitals and said his City Council critics need to get out of their 'sterilized environment' after a Council report slammed the practice as inefficient and detracting from other long-term strategies to meet severe mental health needs.
The report, released Monday, found that the data the mayor's office has released on the program is incomplete, that it disproportionately targets Black New Yorkers and that many of those who are transported don't get inpatient treatment or long-term care.
It also found that involuntary removals were more than five times as likely to happen in private homes than in public spaces like the subway system — which runs against much of the mayor's argument for the program as a way to get those in need of help out of public areas.
'The Administration has continuously relied on involuntary removals as a catch-all solution without providing funding for the necessary treatment measures for people in need of long-term services,' Councilmember Linda Lee, who chairs the mental health committee, said in a statement.
Adams, asked about the report at his weekly press briefing, said the administration was trying to be 'as transparent as possible' on the program and highlighted how 'challenging' the issue of severe mental illness is.
'They need to move out of the sterilized environment of the City Council chamber, and they need to go and do what we do: Go to the subway system, look at the population in need,' Adams said. 'We're going to respond to that need.'
The mayor has been a major proponent of the practice of transporting people, whether they are willing or not, to hospitals if they appear to be unable to care for themselves. The directive has received harsh backlash from advocates, but has picked up some traction from other elected officials and some mayoral challengers.
Data from the administration and the Council's report found that Black New Yorkers made up 54% of involuntary transports despite making up 23% of the city's population overall.
'Look at the ethnic demographics of who's homeless,' Adams said in response. 'Look at the ethnic demographics of those who are charged with some of these crimes of pushing people on the subway system, slashing, et cetera. We're going to go where the issue is, and we're not going to play race politics.'
The Council suggested funding mobile help programs, establishing transitional support programs and expanding community-based clubhouse centers.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
16 hours ago
- Forbes
Why Medicaid Needs A Text Message Exemption Now
Man standing outside, texting. (Photo by) A fierce debate rages over the Big, Beautiful Bill (BBB) and its impact on Medicaid beneficiaries. While House Speaker Mike Johnson recently claimed millions "will not lose their Medicaid unless they choose to do so," the reality is the bill's work requirements will create administrative barriers that will result in coverage losses due to poorly informed Medicaid beneficiaries. These communication barriers can be addressed by modifications to the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The TCPA, a decades-old law governed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), prohibits automated text messages without prior consent. The law has created a culture of confusion and risk aversion in healthcare administration. Healthcare administrators like lawyers and compliance officers view text messaging as a litigation minefield, while patients and families who need timely, accessible communication freely use digital messaging for everything else. This creates a glaring disconnect: people communicate through text messaging across all demographics, including Medicaid beneficiaries, yet Medicaid managed care organizations and state agencies continue relying on antiquated communication methods because they fear litigation from murky TCPA regulations. The FCC has already provided guidance permitting digital communication for Medicaid eligibility and enrollment. However, this guidance needs to extend further and establish an explicit, indisputable exemption for all Medicaid programs and Medicaid-related services. This clarity will provide authority that helps prevent unnecessary coverage losses due to communication failures. It will also lead to a welcome alignment between how health agencies communicate and how people want to communicate. As new work requirements loom, we can either continue prioritizing risk management gray areas over beneficiary communication needs, or we can adapt our approaches to align with the digital channels people use and prefer. We don't need to speculate about the impact of poor communication with beneficiaries because we witnessed it recently. During the 2023 Medicaid redetermination process, people were required to re-enroll to demonstrate their eligibility. The problem wasn't eligibility; it was communication. According to Kaiser, half of Medicaid enrollees were unaware of the process or knew little about it. Millions lost coverage not because they were ineligible, but because they didn't know about re-enrollment deadlines or couldn't navigate the bureaucratic documentation requirements. Many only discovered they'd lost coverage when they showed up for medical care. These coverage losses were avoidable with better, more efficient communication. After 25 years serving a patient population that is 90-95% Medicaid beneficiaries, I understand these are busy people juggling multiple responsibilities. The majority work in gig economy jobs, minimum wage positions, or jobs that don't provide affordable health insurance. Many work multiple jobs and communicate primarily via text message. When Medicaid agencies rely on outdated methods like snail mail and email, critical information gets lost. We have an excellent, accessible tool to address these communication inefficiencies. It is text messaging and we are afraid to use it. To address texting limitations and improve communication with the Medicaid population, Abner Mason, a digital health entrepreneur and longtime advocate for text messaging in healthcare, aims to establish the Medicaid Texting Coalition. The coalition will collaborate with and advise federal agencies to exempt Medicaid from TCPA restrictions. Mason says, "Texting is the primary and preferred mode of communication for all Americans, including Medicaid beneficiaries, and we must use it to improve health outcomes and, if the time comes, to allow efficient communication to verify work status." If we care about reducing the impact of the BBB on Medicaid enrollment, an obvious and politically feasible strategy is to exempt Medicaid programs from TCPA restrictions immediately. The technology exists and the solution is straightforward. Medicaid needs a TCPA exemption now because the freedom to text is among our best hopes for minimizing the unnecessary impacts of potential work requirements.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
NC's governor signs executive order establishing new advisory council on cannabis
The North Carolina Advisory Council on Cannabis will hold its first meeting in July. () Governor Josh Stein signed an executive order Wednesday establishing the new North Carolina Advisory Council on Cannabis. The Council will study and recommend options for a comprehensive statewide approach to cannabis that is grounded in public health and public safety considerations. Stein's order says the new council will learn from lessons in other states and experts and focus on the protection and safety of all North Carolinians, especially the state's youth. The council announced Wednesday includes 24 members and will be co-chaired by State Health Director Lawrence Greenblatt and Robeson County District attorney Matt Scott. Other who will serve on the board will be representatives from the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services, the Department of Public Safety, the state Department of Justice, local law enforcement officials, as well as North Carolina farmers. Notably, the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians would also have a seat at the table. The Eastern Band first approved the use of medicinal cannabis in 2021, launching recreational marijuana sales on its tribal land last year. In an interview with WRAL on Tuesday, Gov. Stein likened the current situation surrounding cannabis and THC products to the 'wild, wild West.' 'The idea that we have a system where this product, which is a drug that can get you high, is for sale out there without any restrictions on how it's sold to me is insane,' said Stein. Legislators have been grappling with whether to legalize medical marijuana for several sessions as well as how to address the growing number of vape stores that sell THC-infused products. Stein said he hopes the new council can bring Republicans and Democrats from both chambers together to work with health professionals and law enforcement to find common ground. What's clear, said the governor, is that the unregulated marketplace is not working. 'Just go into a vape shop, ask the clerk what product will get me the most high and they will give you something. And it would get you high if you were to take it. So that's not acceptable,' Stein said. 'So, if we don't accept the status quo, what do we want the reality to actually be?' According to the governor's office the rate of emergency department visits in North Carolina for intoxicating cannabis ingestion among children and youth ages 17 and under has increased more than 600 percent in recent years, and among older teens, the rate has increased more than 1,000 percent. Senator Bill Rabon, a cancer survivor and the primary sponsor of the Compassionate Care Act, has been a leading voice for medical marijuana legislation. He is one of four legislators asked to serve on the advisory council. Rabon (R-Brunswick) told his colleagues last year that there was very little difference between products like Delta 9 and marijuana and the state would be wise to craft its own regulatory framework. Legislation to regulate hemp-derive consumables and medicinal marijuana passed the NC Senate last June, only to languish in the House. The new Council will consider public health considerations, potential marijuana prescriptions for certain conditions, as well as what regulatory guardrails are needed regarding potency and purity standards. Another consideration would be the possibility of expunging past convictions that do not align with the recommendations of the Council, including for simple possession of marijuana. According to Pew Research, nearly six-in-ten Americans (57%) believe that marijuana should be legal for medical and recreational purposes. USA Today, citing the group DISA Global Solutions, reported in April that North Carolina is one of a tiny minority of just six states in which marijuana is fully illegal for both recreational and medicinal purposes. The North Carolina Advisory Council on Cannabis will hold its first meeting in July submitting preliminary recommendations for a comprehensive cannabis policy to the Stein by March 15, 2026. In the meantime, the governor said he would like the General Assembly to prohibit the sales of products that contain intoxicating THC to anyone under 21 by requiring photo ID age-verification, while requiring packaging that lets adults know what is actually in the cannabis products they may be buying. Read Stein's Executive Order below: EO16-Cannabis-Advisory-Council
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Marineland remains closed in Niagara Falls, Ont., says it hasn't decided if it will open this year
With the busy summer tourist season in Niagara Falls, Ont., weeks away, Marineland says it still hasn't decided if it will open this year. The beleaguered aquarium told CBC Hamilton in an email Tuesday "no final decision has been made." "As Marineland has repeatedly publicly stated, we continue to be actively engaged in a sale process and transition to new ownership," said the statement from the marketing department. "The long-term health and welfare of the animals remains Marineland's priority in the transition process." As of Tuesday, its main phone number wasn't working, its Facebook page was taken down and its website made no mention of its reopening date. This time last year, its reopening date of June 28 was already posted to its website, according to internet park has traditionally closed for the fall and winter, and reopened in the spring, but in recent years scaled back operations, said Janet Adams, an employment co-ordinator at the Niagara Employment Help Centre. At its height, Marineland would hire 500 to 700 seasonal employees, she said. But last year it hired only a few janitors and cashiers, and called back employees from the year before, Adams said. This year, they haven't posted any summer positions at all, impacting students looking for work, she said. 18 beluga whale deaths since 2019 Ontario's Animal Welfare Services has been investigating Marineland for five years, visiting the park more than 200 times since 2020. Eighteen beluga whales, one killer whale and one dolphin have died at Marineland since late 2019 — including one beluga earlier this year. The province declared in 2021 that all marine mammals at the park were in distress due to poor water, but told The Canadian Press last year the water issue had been brought up to standard. In 2024, Marineland was found guilty under Ontario's animal cruelty laws over its care of three young black bears. The bears lived in an enclosure that measured 48 square feet and their outside area was 360 square feet, and lacked water and climbing structures, a provincial court heard. However, the bears needed to be in an enclosure at least 10,000 square feet, animal welfare inspectors determined. Lobbyist working on animal export permits Last month, Marineland sold one of its properties that included an office building to a numbered corporation for over $2.7 million, according to land records. It's down the road from the sprawling main park. Earlier this year, it got permission from the City of Niagara Falls to sever the large park into four parcels to take out mortgages. Tom Richardson, a lawyer who represents Marineland, said at a public meeting in February that it needs the money to continue funding park operations and eventually move its animals, including more than two dozen beluga whales, as well as bears and deer. "It's to address the elephant in the room, and that is the moving of the whales and other creatures," he said. After the animals are moved, the park will merge the parcels back together, rather than sell them off individually, said Richardson. In March, a consultant for Marineland, Andrew Burns, registered as a lobbyist to "communicate with government officials" about obtaining permits to trade endangered species internationally and export cetaceans, a classification of aquatic mammals that includes whales and dolphins. Burns didn't respond to a request for comment.
