Irish Examiner view: It's Catastrophicto be going backwards on climate targets
The figures from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) are grounds for concern for anyone worried by the climate crisis.
The agency says that Ireland has 'moved backwards' when it comes to our goal of reducing carbon emissions by 51% by 2030, as the latest statistics show the country is on course for a maximum reduction of 23%. That percentage makes a stark comparison with a predicted reduction of 29% made just 12 months ago.
This is a terrible indictment of our performance. It is bad enough not to reach targets, which were set to help us combat the greatest existential threat which faces humanity, but to go backwards — as stated by the EPA — is catastrophic.
The best that can be said about these figures is that they expose our lack of commitment and bring some reality to this situation. We may be making all the right noises and gestures, but clearly substantive progress is not being achieved: Going by these figures, the situation is getting worse.
If 'lack of commitment' sounds excessive, readers should consider the contribution of environment minister Darragh O'Brien. He said the EPA figures 'are a clear signal that, while we've made real progress, we need to move faster to meet our 2030 climate targets'.
It beggars belief that any politician would attempt to describe the EPA figures as a sign of progress, yet here we are.
The bad news does not end there: We are also set to miss EU-mandated carbon targets for 2030 by a massive margin.
That could result in fines of tens of billions of euro for failing to match the EU's Effort Sharing Regulation, which penalises member states not doing their fair share in terms of climate action.
It is long past time we treated this crisis with the urgency it deserves before it is too late. However, if missing our emissions targets and owing billions in fines doesn't motivate us to act, what will?
State bodies hid and deflected
Earlier this week, justice minister Jim O'Callaghan apologised to the O'Farrell family in the Dáil.
It was a long-awaited day of vindication for the O'Farrell family, who have spent almost 15 years fighting for justice for their son and brother Shane — who was knocked down and killed near Carrickmacross, Monaghan, in August 2011. Shane O'Farrell was struck in a hit-and-run incident by a car driven by Zigimantas Gridziuska.
Lithuanian Gridziuska was a repeat criminal who had committed a series of offences while on bail. A year before the hit-and-run incident, he was given a prison sentence which he did not serve. When the O'Farrells started investigating, they found that Gridziuska appeared to be committing crimes all over Ireland with apparent impunity.
In the 18 months before the hit-and-run incident, he committed approximately 30 offences, with Lucia O'Farrell, Shane's mother, saying: 'He seemed to be in every court walking in and out ... He seemed to get fines, get the benefit of the Probation Act, community service, and then he'd get full temporary release, and re-offend. He could do what he liked, bail had no legal meaning for him.'
The failure of the legal system to deal with this offender is a shocking indictment of that system, but there is a lesson here which goes beyond criminals ignoring the courts.
In their years fighting for Shane, the O'Farrell family were treated shamefully by the State. The family requested information from bodies as various as the Department of Justice, the Courts Service, the Prison Service, and the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission, but they described their treatment as 'abusive and disrespectful ... What followed was stonewalling by State agencies who adopted deflection, evasiveness, and most importantly, a deliberate lack of completeness and transparency. We learned of Gridziuska's criminal past from our own efforts, not from the State'.
It is disgraceful that State bodies would treat citizens in this manner. Those responsible for protecting their institutions rather than aiding fellow citizens should face disciplinary action for their treatment of the O'Farrell family.
Unfair play
It may be a week and a half away but the excitement is building for the Munster hurling final, one of the highlights of the Irish sporting summer.
This year, Cork take on Limerick in the Gaelic Grounds, a mouthwatering clash expected to sell out when tickets go on sale.
However, supporters are swallowing hard at the ticket prices — €50 for stand, €40 for terrace, and €10 for U16s, with €5 concession for students and OAPs.
That is a €5 increase on stand, terrace, and juvenile prices from last year's final. In 2023, stand admission was €40 and terrace €30 for that year's provincial final.
That means a 25% hike in ticket prices in just two years, a staggering leap in cost. Given the huge following both Cork and Limerick have, and the near-guarantee that the venue will sell out, those supporters are entitled to feel their loyalty is being penalised here. As a comparison, stand tickets for the Munster football final between Kerry and Clare this year were €20 cheaper than their hurling equivalents.
If the authorities were to reconsider and even freeze prices at the 2024 level, it would be a welcome gesture and an indication that the supporters' loyalty is something to be appreciated and not exploited.
Read More
Irish Examiner view: Our support for the people of Liverpool
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
41 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Almost one in four Irish earners is paying no income tax, says Revenue
While the number of taxpayer units earning enough to be liable for the standard rate will be just over 2.2 million, an estimated 1.06 million of these, or 30pc, will not pay anything because their liability is fully covered by their tax credits. Another 256,600 taxpayer units, or 7pc of the total, are exempt from income tax. The statistics, contained in an answer by Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe to a Dáil question, means 37pc of earners will pay no income tax this year. In an annual report on the Irish economy, published yesterday, the European Commission emphasised the need to reduce the risks created by the high concentration of tax revenue among a relatively small number of payers. Ireland should broaden its tax base, given the reliance on relatively few foreign-owned multinationals, and there is particular scope for expanding the local property charge, the commission says. 'Ireland's labour-tax system is highly progressive, but it relies on a narrow tax base,' according to the report, which says the top 10pc of taxpayers accounted for approximately 60pc of the tax yield in 2022. This concentration of revenue means the tax base is vulnerable to economic shifts. Ireland's labour-tax revenues are well below the EU average, and 'to cope with high projected budget expenses, diversification in Ireland's public revenue structure is warranted', the report says. Ireland's share of labour taxes as a proportion of GDP is not even half the EU average, and remains below the EU average when adjusted to GNI*, a measure of economic activity that takes out the distorting effect of multinationals. There is also scope to expand the local property charge, since the revenue collected – which was 1.8pc of GNI* in 2022 – is also below the EU average, which was 2.1pc that year. On the spending side, the European Commission calls on Ireland to 'reinforce' defence spending in line with decisions reached by the European Council in March. The report points out that spending on defence in Ireland remained stable at 0.2pc of GDP between 2021 and 2023. According to its forecast, it will remain at this level for both last year and this year. This means there has been no change in four years. ADVERTISEMENT As the healthcare system is overly reliant on costly hospital care, exacerbated by the lack of universal primary care coverage, there is scope for reform to alleviate the strain on hospitals The commission says there are still concerns about the impact that spending by the healthcare system is having on fiscal sustainability. The ageing of the population is going to mean an increase in health spending of 1.5pc of GDP by 2070, while across the EU the average increase is projected to be 0.4pc. 'As the healthcare system is overly reliant on costly hospital care, exacerbated by the lack of universal primary care coverage, there is scope for reform to alleviate the strain on hospitals,' the report says. Given the heightened political uncertainty, Ireland's dependence on foreign multinationals needs to be looked at, and the European Commission warns there is an 'urgent need' to build a more resilient, innovation-driven domestic economy. It points out that spending on research and development (R&D) in Ireland is at one of the lowest rates in the EU, accounting for just 0.4pc of GNI*. This has led to a noticeable technology innovation gap between Irish SMEs and their counterparts in comparable European countries. 'Boosting R&D expenditure and providing targeted Research and Innovation (R&I) support could help boost SME productivity,' it says.
Irish Independent
42 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Markets hover near all-time high despite latest tariffs drama
In Europe, shares in Germany's DAX index hit a record high after the new coalition government there approved a €46bn package of corporate tax breaks as part of a push to revive economic growth, and ahead of an expected interest rate cut on Thursday from the European Central Bank. The Stoxx Europe 600 Index of European shares closed up 0.5pc after it pared some earlier gains following weaker-than-expected US jobs data. European shares are increasingly outperforming the US, closing what had been a yawning valuations gap. US stocks are close to their own highs, having recouped the 20pc suffered in April during the initial phase of the reaction to Donal Trump's tariffs. While the White House has rowed back on its most extreme tariff policies, it did pull the trigger on Wednesday on a huge 50pc tariff on imports of steel and aluminium, double the size of a tariff first announced in February. The steel levy, imposed for supposed national security reasons, is outside the scope of a US court that last week ruled much of the Trump tariff regime was illegal. The decision to push ahead with the higher rate came after the White House was stung by the new insult that Trump always chickens out (TACO). Canada, the biggest exporter of steel to plants including in the US industrial belt close to the border, will be worst hit. The MSCI index made up of a basket of stocks from across the developed world – and therefore a good guide to confidence in the global economy – touched an all-time high on Monday and remained close to it on Wednesday. In Dublin, the Iseq 20 index of Irish shares hit a high on May 29, and remains close to it. The numbers point to investors increasingly looking through the tariff threat, despite the noisy policy shifts, at least until next month when a number of 90-day tariff 'pauses' are due to roll off. Talks – including between the EU and US, Canada and the US, and the US and China – all aimed at influencing the July deadlines are currently taking place. 'As the market continues to move higher, I think investors are simply saying look, the trend is your friend, and just like white-water rafting they will let the market take them where it wants to go,' said Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist of CFRA Research in New York. 'The markets are going through some sideways movement until we get into July because then we'll have a better read on what kind of an impact tariffs have had on Q2 economic growth and earnings, and give a better idea as to what might happen for the remainder of this year.'
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
EU alert at Russia's use of migration 'weapon'
The threat of Russia and Belarus intensifying hybrid tactics — including sending migrants over borders into the EU — is a 'serious concern', the EU border agency has said. Frontex said these countries had already used migrants as a 'geopolitical weapon' and warned Russia would continue to exploit this power to 'exert pressure' on the EU. 'The situation on the EU's eastern borders remains volatile due to Russia's ongoing war of aggression on Ukraine," the agency said. The flow of migrants across the Eastern borders is influenced by strategic decisions made by Moscow and Minsk to instrumentalise migration to put pressure on EU border management. 'As the situation in Ukraine evolves and as the EU takes greater responsibility in supporting Ukraine, Russia may be incentivised to extend hybrid operations against member states to influence internal politics and foreign policy decisions.' Frontex's Annual Risk Analysis 2025/2026 said Israel's war in Gaza, along with fragmented security in Lebanon and Syria 'could drive' further displacement and increase migration pressure on Europe. It said armed conflicts and worsening economic conditions in northern African and the Sahel were sources of migration, but added there was 'particular concern' at Russia's growing influence in the region, including a military base in Eastern Libya. 'This presence raises fears that migration flows across the Mediterranean could be instrumentalised to put further pressure on the EU,' it said. The analysis said changes to US migration policy could increase pressure on European air borders by 'directing migratory flows of Venezuelan, Colombian and Cuban nationals', as well as non-Latin American migrants towards the EU. The report highlights other related issues: As migration from conflict zones increases, the risk grows of criminals, terrorists, saboteurs and intelligence operatives 'infiltrating' migration routes; Organised crime poses a 'persistent threat' to the EU's external borders, including gangs trafficking drugs and firearms; Document fraud is a 'primary' enabler of irregular entry at EU airports and criminal gangs provide 'sophisticated forged documents' and countries need advanced technologies On this point, the report said: 'Fraudulently obtained visas, imposters — individuals using another person's migrants claim to be from conflict-affected regions to facilitate asylum claims, are persistent tactics.' The report added: 'A growing area of concern is the potential infiltration into irregular migrant flows of mercenaries or war veterans with advanced combat capabilities. These individuals pose an elevated security risk, particularly if integrated into organised crime networks.' Frontex said hybrid threats originating from Russia's proxies and Belarus would remain 'a consistent and evolving' challenge. 'These threats may escalate in response to geopolitical shifts, including a potential ceasefire agreement or changes in EU-Ukraine relations,' it said. 'Threat tactics are expected to include direct provocations against EU border personnel, sabotage of border infrastructure, cyberattacks and disinformation campaigns aimed at undermining EU cohesion and public confidence.'
