Welsh politicians caught lying could lose seats in Senedd
Members of the Senedd who lie could lose their seats under new recommendations being made to the Welsh government.But the Senedd's Standards of Conduct Committee has stopped short of recommending that deliberate deception be made a criminal offence - to be investigated by the police and prosecuted in the courts.The committee said the existing standards regime should be strengthened, with the ultimate sanction of a referendum-style vote in an MS's constituency to decide whether they stay in office.Under the plans the Senedd's standards commissioner would also have the power to start their own investigation, rather than wait for a complaint, and could compel an MS to issue a correction.
If they do not make that correction then they would be considered to have broken the rules, or code of conduct, and face tougher sanctions.The report also called for lay members, from outside the Senedd, to join the standards committee.This has been the case in the House of Commons' equivalent committee since 2015, using people from outside the institution with relevant knowledge to bring an "independent and external perspective" to decision-making.If the Welsh government accepts the plans then MSs would be subject to a beefed-up code of conduct with a rule to act "truthfully" replaced with an explicit instruction to refrain from making deliberately inaccurate statements.Ministers are currently considering a previous committee report which recommended the Senedd introduce a "recall" procedure which would give voters the chance to remove MS's who had misbehaved.In their latest report the committee concluded that introducing a criminal offence risked unintended consequences which might outweigh any benefits.It had heard evidence that it might overwhelm police and the criminal justice system - which is already facing severe backlogs - and that any allegations of deliberate deception would have to reach the criminal standard.The committee also wanted one standards system, and not have lying treated separately and seen as more serious than other breaches.If the circumstances were deemed serious enough - subject to a recommendation from the committee and a vote in the Senedd - committee members felt that the ultimate decision should lie with the electorate to recall their Senedd member.
'Rebuild public trust'
Under the plans the disciplinary procedure would remain unchanged.The standards commissioner would investigate, the committee would consider the report and recommend a sanction before the Senedd would vote on it.Any MS falling foul of the new rules would have a note about the case on their biography on the Senedd website.The committee also called on the Welsh government to clearly define deliberate deception.Hannah Blythyn, the Labour MS who chairs of the Senedd's standards committee, said: "Toughening rules for Members of the Senedd and candidates standing for election is critical at a time when public trust in our institutions is low."By strengthening the law governing elections, toughening our code of conduct and giving more power and independence to those investigating complaints, we can start to rebuild public trust in our political institutions and support a parliament fit for the future."Committee members considered three options:To create a criminal offence of deception which would end up in the criminal courtsTo use an existing investigative body - the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales has been mentioned and gave evidence to the committee - and to bring in a civil sanction such as a fineStrengthen the MS code of conduct and beef up the available sanctions, meaning it would be dealt with through the Senedd's disciplinary proceduresFour members not on the standards committee, so called "observer members", also took part in the work.Three of them - Labour MS Lee Waters, Plaid Cymru's Adam Price and the Liberal Democrat leader Jane Dodds - favoured an independent process involving a criminal or civil offence.They supported improvements to the standards system but did not think it would go far enough to meet what the Welsh government had promised the public and the Senedd.
How did we get here?
Former counsel general Mick Antoniw, who is now a member of the standards committee, had made a commitment that the Welsh government would legislate in time for the 2026 Senedd election for the disqualification of members and candidates found guilty of deception through an independent judicial process.He made the concession after the government looked set to lose a vote on the issue, which could have led to the creation of a law that would have made lying a specific criminal offence.A separate set of rules would apply to candidates standing in a Senedd election.The committee recommended broadening the UK Representation of the People Act to include deliberate deception, which the Welsh government already has the power to do.At the moment it is a criminal offence to make a false statement about an opponent's conduct or character.A Welsh government spokesperson said: "The Standards of Conduct Committee has produced a detailed and thorough report into deliberate deception as part of its inquiry into member accountability. "We will now consider its findings and recommendations before responding formally."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
27 minutes ago
- Spectator
Nigel Farage's grand plan to reindustrialise Wales
'Our ambition is to reindustrialise Wales,' Reform's Nigel Farage announced to a small room lit up with turquoise lights at the back of Port Talbot's Plaza Café. The Reform leader had chosen the ideal place to launch his long campaign for the Senedd next May. The town's last traditional blast furnace closed in October; Farage wants to see them reopened. 'A Reform government based in Cardiff is going to be very different,' he smiled at the assembled press pack. 'It's going to be very, very different indeed.' Reform UK's campaign in Wales is targeted at working-class, non-graduate voters fed up with their failing public services and lack of opportunity. It's not just industry the party is focusing on here: Farage promised that under a Reform administration, Welsh people would be first in line for social housing. He wants to launch as many trades and skills colleges as possible so that young people from the age of 15 can begin to work in engineering and AI – a move which the Reform leader hopes will lead to further investment in the area.
Scotsman
43 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Winter fuel payment: Scottish pensioners could be worse off than those in England and Wales after U-turn
The U-turn was confirmed on Monday by Chancellor Rachel Reeves. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scottish pensioners could be worse off than those in England and Wales after the UK government confirmed its U-turn over the winter fuel payment. The Chancellor announced on Monday the payment, worth up to £300, will be restored to the vast majority of pensioners who previously received it as anyone with an income of under £35,000 a year will now get the payment automatically. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Chancellor Rachel Reeves has given more detail about the UK government's plans for the winter fuel allowance | PA/The Scotsman However, Scotland has already created a devolved benefit of £100 for all pensioner households, which is less generous than the UK government version, potentially leaving hundreds of thousands of Scots worse off than their English and Welsh counterparts. The decision will result in more money being sent to the devolved administration at Holyrood. Scottish Labour has now urged the Government to increase its payments. Rachel Reeves had announced the cut in the first first weeks of the Labour government last summer, prompting an immediate backlash and forcing the Scottish Government to delay the implementation of its own devolved benefit. John Swinney's administration later announced a similar payment for pensioners which would be tapered and see those on the highest incomes receiving £100, compared to £305.10 for those on the least. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scottish Labour MSP Paul O'Kane urged the SNP to support Scotland's pensioners. He said: 'The winter fuel payment is a devolved payment in Scotland and Scottish Labour has long been clear that we want to see it reinstated for the majority of pensioners up here. But despite their loud spin, the SNP voted against our attempts to do so. 'The SNP must not go ahead with plans that would rob poorer pensioners in order to fund payments for millionaires. 'The SNP must re-examine their own proposals in light of this game-changing announcement, ensure payments reach those most in need, and give a cast-iron guarantee that no struggling Scottish pensioners will be left out of pocket under their plans.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad However, Scotland's Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said the decision was 'a betrayal' of pensioners. She said: 'I welcome any extension of eligibility by the UK government, but this is a U-turn the Chancellor should have made a long time ago. But there is still no detail about how the Chancellor intends to go about that. Unfortunately, it still sounds as if many pensioners will miss out.' Ms Somerville said the Scottish Government had not been consulted on the decision and urged UK ministers to 'ensure the Scottish Government is fully appraised of the proposed changes as soon as possible'. Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville speaks to MSPs on the Scottish Government's response to the Supreme Court ruling on the definition of a woman under equalities law, in the Scottish Parliament at Holyrood. Picture: Jane Barlow/PA Wire 'The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government wrote to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury last week to urge the UK government to share its plans with us as quickly as possible, so that we can understand any implications for our own programmes and, crucially, our budget,' she said. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish Government's plans were initially to provide a universal payment to pensioners, but the proposals were scuppered by the Chancellor's announcement of the cut last summer, forcing ministers to create a different system for this winter. Ms Reeves said the UK government had 'listened to people's concerns' about the decision to limit the payment to the poorest pensioners last winter, and was now able to widen eligibility because Labour had restored 'stability' to the economy. Ministers have insisted no additional government borrowing will be needed to cover the costs of the reversal, prompting warnings of tax rises on the horizon. Those with an income above the £35,000 threshold will also receive the payment, but it will then be reclaimed from them in tax. To be eligible for the winter fuel allowance, a person will need to have reached state pension age by the week starting September 15 this year. Pensioners who do not want to receive the payment will be able to opt out, according to the Treasury. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Writing on social media site X, Paul Johnson of the Institute for Fiscal Studies said: 'The corollary of 'this will not lead to permanent additional borrowing' is that it will lead to permanent additional taxes (or just possibly permanent cuts to other bits of welfare).' No.10 insisted the UK government's manifesto commitment to not raise VAT, income tax or National Insurance remained in place. 'It will be for the Chancellor to set out how this is funded at the Budget', the Prime Minister's official spokesman added. Scottish Greens social security spokesperson Maggie Chapman said: 'There is no doubt that the damage has already been done. Families will have lost loved ones and illnesses will have been caused over the winter months because of the brutal decision by Rachel Reeves and the Labour government. "The reinstatement of the winter fuel payment for some is a welcome move, but we must go further. The Labour government must end the two-child benefit cap. which hits working-class families the hardest, and they must reverse their cruel austerity policies. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Poverty isn't inevitable; it's a political policy, a policy which Rachel Reeves has forced upon hundreds of thousands of people across the UK. If Keir Starmer has any shame, he would finally call an end to her disastrous time as Chancellor.' Kemi Badenoch, leader of the Opposition, claimed the Prime Minister had 'scrambled to clear up a mess of his own making'. The Conservative leader said: 'I repeatedly challenged him to reverse his callous decision to withdraw winter fuel payments, and every time Starmer arrogantly dismissed my criticisms. This humiliating U-turn will come as scant comfort to the pensioners forced to choose between heating and eating last winter. 'The Prime Minister should now apologise for his terrible judgment.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Liberal Democrat Leader Sir Ed Davey said: 'Finally the Chancellor has listened to the Liberal Democrats and the tireless campaigners in realising how disastrous this policy was, but the misery it has caused cannot be overstated. 'Countless pensioners were forced to choose between heating and eating all whilst the Government buried its head in the sand for months on end, ignoring those who were really suffering.
Wales Online
an hour ago
- Wales Online
The Nigel Farage interview: Why Reform hasn't got a Welsh leader, steel, coal and education
The Nigel Farage interview: Why Reform hasn't got a Welsh leader, steel, coal and education He faced tough questions on paying for the pledges he has made for Wales Reform UK's leader Nigel Farage has started his party's campaign ahead of next year's Senedd election, saying he believes his party will win enough votes to govern Wales. The Clacton MP spoke to WalesOnline after he gave a speech in Port Talbot in which he made pledges about reopening the blast furnaces at the steelworks in Port Talbot, restarting coal mining in Wales, and cutting the help available to asylum seekers. He made time for an interview after a private event for select party members and journalists at which he was asked about his plans for the party, who it would put forward to be First Minister, and for detail on the pledges he announced ahead of the visit - many in an opinion piece penned for WalesOnline. In that, he wrote: "We have said and say again that we think it's better to use British coal for British steel than imported coal. Which is why we would allow coal, if suitable, to be mined in Wales as part of Reform's long-term ambition to reopen the Port Talbot Steelworks but we know this will not be quick or easy." He also wrote: "We would end funding to the Wales Refugee Council". At the event he also announced two more councillors have joined the party, both were previously independent members at Merthyr Tydfil council. You can read about that here. Article continues below He claimed that fellow senior Reform member Richard Tice and he were to thank for the UK Government investing in British Steel in Scunthorpe, and said he was to thank for Labour today announcing a U-turn on its unpopular winter fuel payments policy. He claimed the timing of the UK Government for noon today was designed to clash with the planned start of his press conference. During our interview, we asked Mr Farage about the main points of his opinion piece - about reopening the blast furnaces in Port Talbot, resuming coal mining in Wales and cutting funding for the Welsh Refugee Council. We also asked about a leader being appointed in Wales. Currently, there is no Welsh figurehead, and no idea who it would put forward to be any prospective First Minister, something the party would have to do if, as he claims, it will govern Wales after the Senedd election in 2026. Mr Farage left the interview with WalesOnline early, refusing to take part in a quickfire series of questions. WalesOnline: "Right now you haven't got a leader yet in Wales. If you take seats you're going to need one. What are your plans?" Nigel Farage: "Right now, at the minute I'm the leader of the national party. I'm here in Wales, as I've just been in England in the local elections. Today we've opened up the candidates, for policy processes. "We're just getting going really, really just getting going in Wales. So please give me time. And that leadership figure in Wales will emerge." You were here a few months ago [November] and you asked for time. Then when what's your timeline? When when can we start asking that question and we'll get an answer? Have a look at what I've done since the last time I was here. Have a look at some of the victories we've secured in England and in Scotland last week in the Scottish Parliament by election, we came from nowhere to pushing up close to the SNP and Labour. We've got a lot going on, all right and it will happen. In terms of Port Talbot, one of the things you've announced today is that you want the blast furnaces to reopen, and it wasn't coal that shut them down, it was billions of under-investment, it was £1 million loss a day for a private company. What power has Reform got to make any pledge about that? We can state an ambition of what we think should happen. And I honestly believe, well, I know, we're going to be using more steel in the coming decades than we've ever used before. Even modern house constructions uses an awful lot of steel, out of town distribution centres use an awful lot of steel. We're talking about a military upgrade, a much needed military upgrade. We need steel and the idea we just import all of this from India and China... we have to find ways we can do it here. The barrier is the cost of energy and Cardiff on its own can't sort that out. We need a national government that understands it as well. But I think as an ambition, it's the right one. You've also spoken about coal mines and you'd like coal mining to resume here in Wales. No, no, no, specialist, specialist small scale. We still have certain uses for coal in this country. Certainly with the renewed steel industry, there'll be these bigger uses for coal. I just think this mindset that we as a country produce nothing and import everything leaves us very vulnerable in a dangerous world. You've also said that you want to end funding to the Welsh Refugee Council, and that isn't funded by the Welsh Government I didn't mention it in my speech. You mentioned it in an op-ed you sent Wales Online. Yeah, but I didn't mention it in my speech. Does that mean it's no longer a policy? We'll do what we can. But I mean the whole concept of a Nation of Sanctuary is just so far away from where most voters is, it's almost not true. Just yesterday your team gave us an opinion piece by you said that was a policy. Has that now disappeared? No. We will end all funding and if there isn't much of it, there won't be much to cut. There's been no real mention today of health or education policies, two huge devolved areas where I'm sure lots of people would agree that there's work to be done. Why haven't you picked areas that you can actually do something about? I talked a lot about education today. I talked a hell of a lot of education today. I talked about the fact that the worst GCSE results in the whole of the United Kingdom are in Wales. I talked about the fact there are lots of people leaving school at 18 who frankly, have been freewheeling for the last few years, not even not even wanting to be there. But setting up a technical college isn't going to improve standards, it was one thing, it won't improve standards across the board? It is actually to introduce vocational training and learning trades and skills through school, cooperating with colleges, cooperating with companies. There are one or two examples in England where this has happened, where a big say, a big local manufacturer has started to encourage people at 15 to do GCSEs, but also to learn some engineering as well, or whatever else it may be. And through engineering and AI, this actually for many, many young people gives them something they can focus on. Something that they actually want to do. And that way by the age of 18, we get to produce kids with an education far better than they've got. Article continues below Mr Farage then left the interview after being asked to do a quickfire quiz.
