WHO expert group fails to find a definitive answer for how COVID-19 began
LONDON (AP) — An expert group charged by the World Health Organization to investigate how the COVID-19 pandemic started released its final report Friday, reaching an unsatisfying conclusion: Scientists still aren't sure how the worst health emergency in a century began.
At a press briefing on Friday, Marietjie Venter, the group's chair, said that most scientific data supports the hypothesis that the new coronavirus jumped to humans from animals.
That was also the conclusion drawn by the first WHO expert group that investigated the pandemic's origins in 2021, when scientists concluded the virus likely spread from bats to humans, via another intermediary animal. At the time, WHO said a lab leak was 'extremely unlikely.'
Venter said that after more than three years of work, WHO's expert group was unable to get the necessary data to evaluate whether or not COVID-19 was the result of a lab accident, despite repeated requests for hundreds of genetic sequences and more detailed biosecurity information that were made to the Chinese government.
'Therefore, this hypothesis could not be investigated or excluded,' she said. 'It was deemed to be very speculative, based on political opinions and not backed up by science.' She said that the 27-member group did not reach a consensus; one member resigned earlier this week and three others asked for their names to be removed from the report.
Venter said there was no evidence to prove that COVID-19 had been manipulated in a lab, nor was there any indication that the virus had been spreading before December 2019 anywhere outside of China.
'Until more scientific data becomes available, the origins of how SARS-CoV-2 entered human populations will remain inconclusive,' Venter said, referring to the scientific name for the COVID-19 virus.
WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said it was a 'moral imperative' to determine how COVID began, noting that the virus killed at least 20 million people, wiped at least $10 trillion from the global economy and upended the lives of billions.
Last year, the AP found that the Chinese government froze meaningful domestic and international efforts to trace the virus' origins in the first weeks of the outbreak in 2020 and that WHO itself may have missed early opportunities to investigate how COVID-19 began.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
U.S. President Donald Trump has long blamed the emergence of the coronavirus on a laboratory accident in China, while a U.S. intelligence analysis found there was insufficient evidence to prove the theory.
Chinese officials have repeatedly dismissed the idea that the pandemic could have started in a lab, saying that the search for its origins should be conducted in other countries.
Last September, researchers zeroed in on a short list of animals they think might have spread COVID-19 to humans, including racoon dogs, civet cats and bamboo rats.
__
The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Chronicle of chronic pain not merely doom and gloom
Imagine making your living through writing and cartooning but enduring severe pain in your hands and arms every time you hit a letter on your keyboard or pick up a pencil. This is the personal dilemma faced by Gabrielle Drolet and described in her memoir, Look Ma, No Hands. A journalist, essayist and cartoonist based in Montreal, Drolet's written work has appeared in the New York Times, Globe and Mail, the Walrus, Vice and Teen Vogue. She also contributes cartoons to the Globe and Mail, among other publications. Drolet has won awards for her essays on disability, and holds a master of fine arts degree from the University of Guelph. An account of debilitating pain impacting someone else's life might sound like a depressing read, but much to her credit as a writer, Drolet manages to include a healthy dose of self-deprecating humour along with cute, engaging cartoons to lighten the tone of her memoir. Even when bravely sharing her darkest moments, when thoughts of suicide were looming, her honesty and strong spirit shine through. Look Ma No Hands Drolet's chronic pain began in 2021, when at age 23 she was living in Wolfville, N.S. with her girlfriend. The COVID pandemic dictated that Drolet work from home, and she admits she often sat in bed or on the couch hunched over her laptop. Her first symptom began with pain in her fingers when typing, then progressed to pain in her wrist after picking up a pencil. Then came an aching feeling in her neck and hands, sudden jolts in her elbows and a constant soreness in her forearms. Soon the pain was keeping her up at night, leaving her exhausted and in increasing discomfort. She believed physiotherapy might help; the first two she saw diagnosed her with bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome. Told to do a series of exercises and stretches and wear splints when sleeping, Drolet found no relief. After breaking up with her girlfriend and moving to Toronto, Drolet received a new diagnosis, thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) — a compression of the nerves in your chest. She blamed her prolonged sedentary lifestyle and bad ergonomics for triggering this condition. Having a name for her condition didn't help her daily pain management. Drolet started using voice-to-text technology to keep her freelance writing career afloat, but was frustrated by the lengthy process required to weed out mistakes, and how the tone of her writing seemed to change. However, she gradually became used to the writing tool. Her personal relationships suffered as well. When telling others about her chronic pain, she discovered they generally reacted in one of three ways: being overly sympathetic; doling out advice; or praising her for enduring her disability. Never sure of how to respond, Drolet found herself expressing her thanks and trying to downplay her situation. Settling into a new life in Montreal while balancing her freelance and university studies, Drolet describes how she had to reconfigure her personal outlook. She forced herself to leave her apartment and meet new people. This change helped her mentally and emotionally, and surprisingly eased her physical symptoms to some extent. She continued seeing a physiotherapist regularly to help with TOS, but a referral to a doctor and results of an MRI gave her a new diagnosis — a herniated cervical disc. When the specialist told her that he wouldn't recommend surgery for her condition, Drolet was able to accept this knowing she now has the skills she needs to live a satisfying life. Drolet's journey as told in Look Ma, No Hands is intensely personal, but resonates with anyone who has faced their own challenges — whether physical, mental or emotional. Andrea Geary is a freelance writer in Selkirk.
Global News
10 hours ago
- Global News
Alberta strikes deal to off-load remaining controversial children's pain medicine
Three years after Alberta's government paid $70 million for children's pain and fever medicine, its front-line health provider says it has worked out a deal to off-load what remains of the controversial stockpile. Alberta Health Services spokeswoman Kristi Bland, in a Friday statement, confirmed the medicine is being donated to the charity group Health Partners International of Canada to distribute to 'vulnerable communities worldwide.' 'Preliminary shipments of products have started to leave Alberta, and additional shipments will happen in the coming months,' she wrote. Jackie Cousins, president of Health Partners, said the group works with others to ship medicine where it is needed, and that donations of medicine could end up in more than one country. In an email, she said some of the Alberta medicine would be sent to war-torn Ukraine. Story continues below advertisement 1:46 Alberta government looks to recoup $80M from children's medicine shipment The medication has proven to be problematic for Premier Danielle Smith's government. It struck a deal for the medicine three years ago to fill a gap during the COVID-19 pandemic. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Alberta paid $70 million to MHCare Medical for the medication in 2022 during a countrywide shortage. The province only received about 30 per cent of the shipment, and it has sat on 1.4 million bottles since the spring of 2023 after front-line health staff reported problems, including that the medicine's thicker consistency risked clogging feeding tubes. View image in full screen The government of Alberta paid more than $70 million for 1.4 million bottles of children's pain medicine in 2022, during a countrywide shortage, but was forced to stop distributing the medicine when health care workers raised safety concerns. Government of Alberta At an unrelated news conference Friday, Opposition NDP finance critic Court Ellingson said the government 'refuses' to take responsibility for the medicine and has 'no plan' to recoup funds. Story continues below advertisement 'That somebody is able to make use of this Tylenol somewhere, I'm going to say that that is a good thing, but there are so many other challenges there,' he said. '(Smith's government members) need to acknowledge that they were the ones that made these inappropriate decisions, that we're still on the hook for (product) — that we did not get product, and we don't know if that money is coming back.' Smith hinted in March that her government was working on a deal to send scores of the medication elsewhere. At that time, then-health minister Adriana LaGrange called the medications 'good quality drugs' and said it bothered her that they were going unused. The government has said it's still looking to get its money's worth by working with MHCare to import other medications to fulfill the $70-million deal. 0:40 Alberta Health Minister confirms new procurement of children's medicine will be at average retail price MHCare has since became embroiled in a provincial contracting and conflict of interest scandal after the former head of Alberta Health Services filed a wrongful dismissal lawsuit against the province. Story continues below advertisement In the lawsuit, which hasn't been tested in court, Athana Mentzelopoulos alleges she was fired for looking into inflated government contracts awarded to private surgical companies. The lawsuit mentions MHCare multiple times, but the company is not named as a defendant. MHCare has said any allegations of wrongdoing on its part are 'unwarranted and unjustified.' The allegations have prompted numerous internal and external investigations, including by the RCMP.
Calgary Herald
11 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Training exercise at CFB Suffield faces down the invisible, lethal enemy
It can be a bit unnerving for a civilian to see military personnel in hazmat suits walking around, even if a person knows those involved are only running training exercises. Article content Over about three weeks this June, the Canadian Armed Forces led annual chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear training — Exercise Precise Response — at CFB Suffield near Medicine Hat. Article content Article content Article content The live agent training exercise was directed by Defence Research and Development Canada on behalf of NATO. Article content Article content The exercise involved about 475 participants, representing 12 NATO allies and partner countries. The flags of several NATO nations, including Canada, Great Britain and Germany, were seen flying at the Precise Response training ground as participants trained, tested and coordinated decontamination capabilities during realistic CBRN scenarios. Article content For those involved, hazmat suits are just part of the job, like steel-toed boots and a hard hat at a construction site, said Lt.-Col Trevor Waaga, the exercise director. 'It's just part of the equipment to keep the individual safe,' Waaga said during an interview Wednesday with Postmedia. Article content The origins of this chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear training on Canadian soil came out of the November 2022 NATO Prague Summit, which led to the establishment of the NATO CBRN Defence Battalion, a unit that forms part of the NATO Response Force. Article content Article content As part of its contribution, Canada offered to host three weeks of annual live agent training in support of the CBRN Battalion, which includes a wide variety of assets from several countries that run specific CBRN defence activities in support of NATO operations. Article content The Precise Response exercise began in 2004, and Canada has hosted the training each year since at Suffield, except for two years during the COVID-19 pandemic. Over the years, Precise Response has hosted approximately 4,000 chemical, biological, radiological and nuclear specialists from allied and partner countries. Article content This year's Canadian contingent included 40 members of the 5 Canadian Mechanized Brigade Group's Decontamination Platoon, along with reservists from across the country. The Decontamination Platoon provides chemical, biological and radiological decontamination for vehicles, equipment, and personnel, including those injured.
